October 19, 2006
Page 1 | Page 2 | Page 3 | Page 4
Not only was Jeffrey not booted from competition, he won the whole damn thing! He was at the Bravo offices again yesterday and I forced him to sit down at my desk for a face-to-face interview. What could be a better prize for winning Project Runway!?
SO, WHAT WAS IT LIKE AFTER YOU FOUND OUT YOU WON?
This is the worst question to ask. I mean, you were there that day! I was exhausted and in shock! So many thoughts went through my head and all I could think was, "What does this mean? Does this mean that I am the next great American designer?!" My experience tells me no, nothing is in the bag. It means I worked hard and did some smart things and won a contest. And now, hopefully because of the nature of the contest I can fuel my business with this. I don't take anything for granted. I am hoping for a higher standard of living for my family and a great career.
WHEN YOU WERE STANDING THERE WITH ULI, WHAT WERE YOU THINKING? DID YOU THINK YOU WERE GOING TO WIN?
Honestly, it was easier for me to grasp the idea of Uli winning because there was nothing attached to it for me. I am fine thinking, "Oh, this is going to be so great for Uli!" But I have a hard time stepping outside myself and thinking about what's great for me. My opinion of the finale shows was that it went how I thought. I sometimes don't get the judging, but to see Michael go first for the reasons he did made sense, and then Laura and then I thought from the moment I got there that it would be between Uli and I. I don't pretend to know what the judges are thinking. If you show up and be in the moment and not have expectations you're not prepared. The moment got big and exciting and i was like, "Wow, now what do I do?"
Comments
tj wilson wrote:
I was so disappointed with the finale - Jeffrey did not deserve to win. Not only are his clothes not mass marketable, I don't see how they fit into the INC and the judges completely contradicted themselves. What type of message is 'Project Runway' sending to aspiring designers? You can be obnoxious, treat cients poorly and design garbage and still win? I thought that the decision to choose Jay over Kara Saun was awful - this just continues the poor taste of Project Runway.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 10:55 AM
Nikki_Darling wrote:
Uli was robbed but that does not surprise me at all: Note to season 4 designers, if you are creative, love color, truly a trailblazer with impeccable who happen to make beautiful clothes that make women look sexy, stunning and sophisticated....something that women would love to be in and touch them: If you make it to the finals, become an insufferable a-hole and submit a collection of ugly unwearable clothes for the punk rock sect. That is all Nina & Michael recognize as "innovation". Personally I can't wait to buy Uli, Michael, Laura, Nick, Kara Saun designs, can't wait.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 11:17 AM
Wendy Miller wrote:
Why doesn't character matter? Jeffrey was abusive to the older woman he designed for, making her cry. He is a bully and thug. He should not be rewarded for bad behavior.
Also interesting that comments were made that women would love to wear Uli's clothes. So why isn't that a factor??!!!! Isn't it the whole idea to design what WOMEN love and not what these bizarro judges want to see?
Personally I wouldn't buy anything designed by this jerk and it would be totally based on his lack of character.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 11:17 AM
mad wrote:
Cheating...Spending too much... Just what were the rules again?? or where they just a guideling that well.. you really didn't have to abide by. What a let down... Couldn't find a receipt for the shorts... i wonder why? BECAUSE SOMEONE ELSE DID THEM and he tried to pass them off for his own! If it was college well he would have been sent home packing! but its not... it truely was a let down because RATINGS ran this competition!
True Crap... better off watching cartoons
posted on October 19, 2006 at 11:23 AM
M wrote:
Absolute crap that Jeffrey won. I really wanted Michael to win however his collection unfortunately didn't show that well. Uli and Laura would have been much better choices. I hate to see really unkind people win. It just sends a horrible message that you can behave and speak anything you like and there will never be consequences. Absolute crap.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 11:24 AM
Virginia wrote:
Have to say that Jeffrey sounds the most human ever in this interview. Nice job, Andy. I certainly hope he uses the money for his business and his family and takes this win as an opportunity not only for success but for one more chance at redemption--of his soul this time. I'm not usually prone to preachiness, but while his thoughts on Buddist philosophy are nice, I wonder if he can learn to apply them to his treatment of other people. I know, I know. Its trite to think that we can actually be talented and successful and respectful of others at the same time. But you learned the rules in Kindergarten, Jeff. Try to remember them on the way up.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 11:24 AM
Judy Edmonds wrote:
I was never so disgusted and disappointed as I was last night witnessing Jeffrey winning Project Runway. He had the most dis-jointed, ugly collection presented. How could you possibly choose his creations over the other three presenters?! I was a huge PR fan until last night. I watched every time it was on (all the re-runs) up to last night. I think you might have just lost a few viewers.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 11:27 AM
Essmac wrote:
Adding my voice to the chorus of disappointed viewers. Nina and Michael really let Bravo down; of Uli's collection, they kept saying "These are clothes women want to wear" as though it were a backhanded compliment at best. Boy, did Fern stand out over those two. Love her, except for the possibility that she may have voted for Jeff.
Why in the world should I watch Season 4 and risk the enormous letdown we saw last night? 15 of us together at a PR Party, in unison screamed "NO!!!!" when the winner was announced. Lots of regrets expressed all around that time was spent watching the show this season-- sour grapes? Sure, but like so many others, I acknowledged that Uli's collection was better than my personal favorite designer. I don't think it's just a case of people being mad that their own favorites did not win- it's more a feeling that the decison was just wrong.
I realize that drama sells the show, but not at the very end- for the finale, talent should count more.
Very sad, and very much something that I will be having no part of next season.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 11:34 AM
Fashionistababe wrote:
I am very disappointed that Jeffrey was chosen as the winner of the Project Runway competition last night!!!! What were the judges thinking?! I think this was done just to get audience reaction because Uli's and Laura's designs were so much better than Jeffrey's - and the judges even said so!!!!! Dumb ass show! Jeffrey is only "best" at being a JERK!!! I hated the way he talked to and about the other contestants. I'll watch the "reunion" show, but that's it - never again will I invest my valuable time in this show!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 11:37 AM
Charmaine wrote:
I have to say that all of my friends at work, my mom and aunts we were all very dissapointed. All of us said that we will not be watching the show again. This was a let down, Jeffery should have been kicked off the show when he spoke to angela's mother the way he did. He also should have been kicked off the show instead of bradley because both of their outfits were ugly but at least she liked her outfit that bradley made. Angela's mother hated it. I really think the bottom two should have been Michael and Uli. I really am a Michael fan but after seeing ULI's collection it was georgous. I liked Micheals as well so I would not have been disappointed if either of them won. Laura's was great as well but we know she can make evening wear what else can she design. This was a let down and I think they all will make it big I just hope they make it bigger then Jeffery.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 12:05 PM
T wrote:
I'm glad Jeffrey won. His collection was the most interesting, innovative, and showed range. Laura's was beautiful, no doubt, but everything looked the same. Uli's was beautiful as well, but same things I've seen before. I do love her style, but I can buy similar items at BCBG.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 12:06 PM
Kona wrote:
I've read a lot of comments that have expressed disappointment with the final outcome and I disagree; I think the judges got it absolutely right this time.
I am a huge Michael fan and thinks that he has an amazing amount of potential. However, what Tim said in his podcast is absolutely correct: he needs guidance. He flourished when he had Tim asking the right questions, but is not quite mature enough to be off on his own. He will do great things, but right now he really needs to work for a designer.
Uli and Jeffrey's lines were by far the strongest and I feel that either of them could have legitimately won. What's interesting about Uli's line is that her clothes are gorgeous and chic and look like something you could buy right now. I would love to wear an Uli dress.
Jeffrey, on the other hand, managed to have an entire line filled with clothes I would never want to wear, but could completely understand. Just living in New York and seeing what's going on in fashion right now, I can tell that he is on the cutting edge. One article I read (I think it was Entertainment Weekly) said that the skinny pant/striped blazer combination looked like something Misha Barton would wear. I absolutely agree. It's not my style, but I understand and respect the design asthetic.
With that said, I think the lack of a receipt was a blessing in disguise. Because LEATHER BUBBLE SHORTS? Are you KIDDING me? Jubillee Jumbles indeed.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 12:07 PM
gim00 wrote:
it has disheartening to see Jeffrey win. Who would wear his stuffs. At least Uli and micheal were wearable. He didn't deserve the victory.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 12:11 PM
Brenda wrote:
Sad season. I'm sorry you turned your "new type of reality show" into "another drama driven reality show"
Not much designing, lots of angst. No fun, lots of drama, over and over again.
Lighten up, it's just fashion and we want it back!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 12:15 PM
mel wrote:
What a disappointment! Jeffrey was by far the nasiest, most self-obsessed designer on the show this season. I wouldn't dress my dog in one of his designs. Could he look anymore like he just crawled out from under a rock? $100,000 to start his own line? HA! I bet six months from now we'll be hearing how he spent it all on booze, drugs and hookers!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 12:18 PM
C.C. wrote:
Really disappointed in the whole show. This was my favorite show but I doubt if I'll be watching again and not because my favorite didn't win.
It was so phony and fixed. I really don't think Nina should be a judge. She clearly picks designers based on what will look good in her magazine and it's hardly fair. Given that Elle awards the big prize we know her vote has the most pull.
Sorry Nina but Elle isn't Vogue. She should sit back and listen to people who actually have taste. Take up skydiving if she's so bored. I have a hint for her tacky doesn't equal not boring.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 12:20 PM
leslie wrote:
What the hell??? I ABSOLUTELY agree that Jeffrey should
not have won last nite...were those judges smoking crack!!
Micheal was my favorite, but truthfully I was disappointed
seeing his collection. However, Uli or Laura should
have won. This outcome is so unjust and was all about the
ratings.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 12:30 PM
Kathy wrote:
What runway show were the judges watching. Not only was Jeffery's clothes ugly and not something anyone is gonna want except to wear for Haloween. Uli was the clear winner and with her talent and the guidance that she would have gotten if she had won she would have be fantastic. What makes you think that Jeffrey is every gonna learn a thing from anyone he will continue to put out the tacky stuff like he showed us last night. I loved the show but I stop watching things when you know the fix was in for the ratings. You lost me! What a waste of my time and your Money.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 12:41 PM
Sue wrote:
i am so THRILLED that Jeffrey won the competition! compare to other competitors i thought he was the most honest, creative, innovate designer~ other designer made clothes w/ pratical view point follwoing what the norm of fashion but Jeffrey in the other hand, he wasn't afraid show his new designs that we haven't seen before! very very talented designer who work to the perfection. i don't feel sorry for that women who cried on the show, she was hella annoying person so senstive just like that girl, what was her name??
only the artistic sense of people will appreciate what Jeffrey has accomplished! go Jeffrey!!!!! woohoo~~~~~~~~~~~~
posted on October 19, 2006 at 12:41 PM
Disappointed & Mad wrote:
They are no words to express how my group of friends and I are so disappointed and mad for the decision of the judges to have picked Jeff's Collection as the winner. Even though my favorite, Michael Knight, was not as surprising as Laura and Uli's collections... I still cannot understand how it did not affected the matter of not submitting receipts, when requested, and going over budget ($800 in wigs) was not a factor at the moment of the decision. In addition that Jeff's collection is something that I DEFINITELY, as a women, would not wear...
Do not count with our participation for Season 4....
posted on October 19, 2006 at 12:45 PM
ellen wrote:
It is horrible to think that this season's winner was the only designer unable to work well with a client and lacked the skill to place the client's need before his (as portrayed with Angela's mom). Jeffrey could certainly work on developing some social skills. Uli was robbed!!!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 12:47 PM
Ed wrote:
Could not be more pleased that Jeffery won. Not only proving he had what it takes to survive a gauntlet of challenges, he managed to grow as a designer. He seems like an outstanding guy who has a knack for upsetting the balance of normal which is exactly what this show was looking for. This is a success story everyone needs to admire.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 12:52 PM
danielo wrote:
Well I have to get this off my chest but Michael Kors should GO..giving Jeffrey the win may make him think that he is hip but his collections are just rehashes of other designers ideas
posted on October 19, 2006 at 12:54 PM
Diane wrote:
Wanted Uli to win we are so disappoint in you judges what where you thinking ???? or drinking it was a fun season to watch but sad to see that someone who was so arrogant to win ……and with no style to boot…..
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:04 PM
Caitlin wrote:
I am very disappointed.. i thought project runway was not fueled by ratings and shock value but clearly the "integrity" that Tim Gunn always talks about should be substituted with"ratings ploy." Jeffrey was not innovative.. you can go into any mall in America and find that entire line in a Wet Seal or Hot Topic. Micheal was my overall favorite of the season, but Uli CLEARLY put out the best collection. I mean do the rules not mean anyhing? I am very disappointed and also will not be tuning in next season.. and that is the resounding response that I am getting from everyone I know.. Bad choice producers to pick shock over talent..it is very disappointing
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:05 PM
LilBit wrote:
This is the first season I watched PR I was fascinated at first. (and do not plan to watch future shows.)Disliked Jeffrey from the get-go. His design for the mature woman was horrible and looked so badly made(something a 5 yr old might have made) He embarrassed his model and put her down. His treatment of her is unforgiveable. I think he forgot she wasn't a professional model but felt she was some one beneath himself. I think he could have made a wonderful design for her and still used her colors.(very unflattering) I liked all the other three finalist designs. Uli's designs were consistent and had her subtle and personal touch but not so bold like Angela's.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:08 PM
jrr wrote:
Andy, I thought you said the finale was very emotional ?? so much so, it made you cry? I guess you had to be one of the insiders to get it. this show so much reminded me that success in life is not measured by the amount of money you make .. or win .. nor can talent be measured by how much you win ... or make.
Jeffrey ... congrats on your victory, but I think you'd be better served to try and see the rationality behind Laura AND Michael's suspicions. (don't forget Michaels concurred with Laura). Let's face it, if one egotistical, mean-spirited, "I'll say whatever I want when I want because I'm wonderfully talented", pompous designer(Keith) can cheat, why not 2 ? I think they wanted just what you did .. a level playing field. I sincerely do wish you the best of luck to you and your family. The kid really is cute.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:09 PM
Beverly wrote:
What a disappointment. Uli should have won. Next time please concentrate on showing us the runway models and outfits -- not constantly showing us people in the audience while the girls are walking. This is a fantastic show and great website. Bravo to BRAVO!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:12 PM
donna howard wrote:
Jeffrey should not have won. The clear winner was Uli.
You guys messed up big time. Even Laura was better than him.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:17 PM
Pablo wrote:
Uli comes in second... again. Uli's Bryant Park line was breathtaking. In my opinion Uli should have won more of the challenges during the season. At best the judges gave her second place or in many cases scored her much lower. I'm assuming that there was more going on than what made the edits for TV or that the judges just didn't like her easy-to-get-along-with personality, that it didn't make for "good TV". I'm greatly disappointed in Mrs. Klum, Michael Kors and Nina Garcia and have been throughout most of this season. But no worries. I'm sure we'll see Uli's clothes on the store shelves sometime in the near future.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:21 PM
Alex wrote:
Bye PR...I am done watching this show....
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:26 PM
Delvia Logan wrote:
Jeffrey's win is a sad day for fashion and the true twelve-step people.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:28 PM
christa wrote:
CONGRATULATIONS JEFFERY! I'm so happy for you and wish you all the best in the future. Your clothes were beautiful and I GET IT! Nice job and you have a very adorable son and lovely girlfriend.....my best to you all.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:28 PM
cdlr wrote:
Uli's and Laura's designs were so much better than Jeffrey's - and the judges even said so. What happened? Why the winner was jeff
Jeff was a bad choice.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:30 PM
Carol Ann V. wrote:
I'M SO PLEASED that Jeffrey won!!!
Jeffrey I really like the way you make clothing to show off a girl's good figure and legs!
Your stuff was: exciting, shocking, bright/colorful, determined. (like you.)
I only just started watching this show for Season 3, and it's the only TV show I watch. My teenage daughters got me in to it, and now it's our new religion - Wednesdays 10pm - Project Runway. A very fun hour! We were all adamantly for Jeff, with Uli a strong runner-up.
Jeffrey, best of luck to you and your family. Your life story has been really significant to me, and really moving.
Uli, you are beautiful and kind and inspiring, and your clothing is gorgeous. Will definitely buy it if ever I get the chance!!!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:34 PM
Lily wrote:
I couldn't be happier. The best guy clearly won.
Reading over the comments, I think it's clear that many people are letting the drama interfere with their judgement. I am active on two big PR boards; members of both boards agreed that the drama was out of control this season.
This show was good - no, it was great - when it focused on the work and the talent of the designers. If we could go back to that....
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:37 PM
Juliayes wrote:
I hate Jeffrey's attitude! I hate his style and worse, I hate his clothes! Translation; I hate Project Runway! You don't even play by your own rules, every year, it's the same thing, you keep some no-talent on the show until the end to boost ratings. This year you went too far, you had the no-talent win! Snotty attitude, cheating and poor taste, maybe you should have kept Keith in, he was a cheater, too, but at least he had taste. This was my last season. Good luck getting anybody to watch next season.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:38 PM
Ann wrote:
I am so disappointed that Jeffrey won last night. I, like every other person I know watching the show, thought his was the worst collection. Who wears that stuff? Uli should have won, Jeffrey should have been out when he "designed" that hideous frock for Angela's mother, not for his rudeness but because it was horrible and his client absolutely hated it! I have watched every season and look forward to my Wed nights but I don't think I can watch anymore. To pick Jeffrey’s line over the other 3 was too much of a disappointment!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:41 PM
eileen wrote:
I must of been watching a different show then the judges!! Jeffrey's line was horrible and very disjointed!! That long print thing and the short navy pleated thing were terrible and looked like he threw them in at the end because he needed two more outfits!! Not only that he was dishonest, he went over budget, and most of all he was downright obnoxious the entire run of the show!! Everyone thought Michael was going to win because he was consistently innovative...but last night his line was disappointing. Lara's line was beautiful and classic(Ralph Laurenish) and Uli line was great(sorta Diane Von Firstenburg)both lines women would buy! They were robbed! The entire run of the show Jeffrey things were punk and ugly and would only appeal to Nichole Richie and Lindsay Lohan!! I guess that's the demographic you want to appeal to...so you've just lost alot of viewers!!!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:43 PM
GKelly wrote:
I'm sorry--are the rules spend $8000 for the final collection or just turn in $8000 worth of receipts???
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:44 PM
Carol wrote:
To disagree with all the naysayers below: I absolutely think the judges picked the right designer this time. I liked Uli's collection very much and would wear her pieces myself. However, what people seem to forget is that high fashion is not about creating clothes that everyone is able to readily accept with open arms. Fashion at its best challenges us with something alien and new. An innovative work is often dogged by hostility and jeers (Van Gogh, Da Vinci, etc) because it requires us to grapple with it and see it on its own terms. Better just to go with something familiar that doesn't require too much effort to understand it, right? Wrong. Keep up the good work, judges.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:45 PM
judie wrote:
I cannot believe that a person who had nothing nice to say about anyone, who designs clothing for aging rockers (excuse me), SKINNY aging rockers, won this competition. Innovative? I think not. Jeffrey cheated by going over budget for his runway collection and would not have told anyone. How is it possible that the judges just turned all of this aside and rewarded this behavior? I loved watching the whole season but the finale was such a disappointment that I don't think I will watch again unless you get better judges. Michael Kors, I love your designs! How could you not see through Jeffrey? And how will he fit in at INC?
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:47 PM
Jasmine wrote:
Uli's designs are enthralling, i just hope i can afford one of her dresses. They are chic, loose fitting, flattering and stunning as awell as ageless. Jeffrey's designs are innovative and fresh, without a doubt. His attitude, however, is less than stellar. And I found myself less than thrilled when the winner was announced.
Michael and Laura have careers as well. I recommend Michael stick with Sportwear. He amazing at it and his dresses are borderline Cheezy!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:48 PM
Yulia D. wrote:
I believe that none of the designers did their best for this season's runway show, but I was never so disgusted and disappointed as I was last night witnessing Jeffrey winning the final prize. He had the most ugly, unrealistic collection of all. And how could you possibly choose him over the other three designers? I was a huge Project Runway fan from it's conception and have turned lots of people onto it. I think you have just lost a few viewers, but myself - definitely!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:48 PM
evelyn wrote:
I am so dissapointed that Jeffrey won I am a Michael FAN all the way HOWEVER Uli should've won, she really surprised me with her collection it was very beautiful and I would wear everything! Michael was good but Uli was better this time, Jeffrey's collection is not unique nor innovative I see it in all the teenage stores and it's not practical clothes to wear. My whole Family and my friends said NOOOOO When they said Jeffrey is the winner I vow to never watch the next season I think this time they lost lots of viewers, the Judges and Heidi got it WRONG! I don't know what world they live in!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:52 PM
Lara wrote:
I think what people forget is that this is not a personality contest. The judges judge on the creations put in front of them, not what so and so said to someone else. And remember, we only see what the producers choose to show us. They have the job of creating a story that is compelling and will draw in viewers. I don't believe for one second that any of the designers is an one-dimensional as portrayed. They are all complex individuals who have good days and bad and we all have times when we are under stress, open our mouths and say things we wouldn't under normal circumstances.
About the fashion, I loved Jeff's collection. It was like walking art and was unlike anything I had seen before. Also the range he showed was great, the construction was immaculate and the collection was cohesive. Uli's was beautiful as well, but the range was limited and the 3-4 brightly colored pieces didn't fit in with the rest of the collection. Laura's was absolutely lovely and perfect for what she does. She definitely will have a niche in the market. Michael, I think, just needs more time. He created wonderfully, refined pieces within the parameters of the show, but when left to his own devices, returned to his niche market. It was unfortunate, but there is a market for that type of clothing.
Great interview Andy and Congrats Jeff!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:54 PM
Ako wrote:
The truth is, Laura and Uli sent the same stuff down the runway that they had all season. They are beautiful clothes, but we've seen it all before. Those who are bashing Jeffrey because he's 'mean' or whatever your reason, get over yourselves. He was deemed the winner by people who know a lot more about fashion than any of you.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 1:59 PM
Chrissy wrote:
I was so upset the Jeffery won he is the one person I didn't want to win this show realy upseted me I will not be watching season 4.. Sorry you just lost a viewer. I think jeff is a fake. he did not make the clothes. I am sorry project runway but you picked the wrong person to win. and this blog shows that.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 2:00 PM
michelle wrote:
I am so disappointed at Jeffery winning last night. I thought any one of the other 3 deserved to win and would have been so happy if they would have. But i was in total shock when he won. Not only did i not care for his designs but i thought that his behavior the whole season was so unprofessional. And his
comments made to Angela and her mother should not have been tolerated by the producers. I was extremely disappointed at how they let him get away with being such an ass. oh and he was caught breaking the rules and going over budget but all they did was tell him to get rid of something. I just didnt agree at all with the results and the handling of most situations this season.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 2:10 PM
jdtango wrote:
I am glad Jeffrey won and especially after his work ethic was questioned by Laura. All of the fashions were beautiful and showed how talented they all were.
We also so another side of Jeffrey the father, boyfriend and son....and I liked what I saw.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 2:12 PM
A fan in Chicago wrote:
I love how people seem to hold double standards...
On the one hand, they complain when during the competition they think the Bravo TV gods KEEP someone on just b/c of they have a good-for-ratings personality despite poor designs....Now, they're complaining that the judges didn't take personality into account when awarding Jeffrey the win.
I didn't like Jeffrey's (edited) attitude in some of the eps, but I think the guy does have talent even if some fans can't appreciate his aesthetics. I also think he had the most cohesive final collection. Uli's outfits were well-made, but I agreed w/ Michael Kors, even before he said it, that her collection as a whole looked disjointed. Half of it was monochromatic beige and silver then a few colorful prints thrown in with nothing really tying them together. While I do think she's talented, I don't think she showed the range and versatility that Jeffrey did throughout the competition.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 2:13 PM
Sherri Brault wrote:
I agree Uli was robbed. I was also a huge fan of PR (noticed I said was). I will not watch anymore seasons as this has shown me that TV does not care if the person is abusive, cheats, and has no taste in fashion. The punk rock fashion is over!!!!
I will no longer wathc this show and Ione one day to see Ulis fashions everywhere and I will walk out of any store that carries Jeffery's line.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 2:16 PM
Amy wrote:
I, too, am disappointed at the outcome. Michael's collection wasn't up to what I had hoped for. Laura's was beautiful, but too much alike. Uli really broke out of her shell and had some unique designs. She's a likeable, amenable person who seems to get along with everyone. I wouldn't have minded if she won.
The judges made comments about every woman would want to wear her collection and said that someone asked how to reach her before they even left the tent at Bryant Park. Uli had a great Every Women outfit.
Hope Jeffrey listens to his clients and doesn't tell them to go away and leave him alone. Maybe he can spend some of his winnings on a session or 2 with Miss Manners.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 2:16 PM
Sharon Brault wrote:
The show last night was a farce. You booted one candidate for breaking the rules and then reward a second for breaking rules - even your judges stated last night that his evening gown was a nightmare. Jeffrey did not turn in his receipts for all of the effort and even went over budget - two rules broken but no punishment handed out. Is this not as bad as having a pattern book in the room? I think so as it shows he had outside help and then tried to hide the factor. He should have been botted as well for breaking the rules.
We have spent every Wed. watching your show, including reruns, but never again. The judges were quoted saying the Ule had made designs that every woman would wear while Jeffrey made designs that no woman would want to wear. There will be no season four in our household.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 2:18 PM
West Miller wrote:
W O W W O W W O W
F--G WOW !
I c a n n o t believe the amount of people here moaning about Jeffrey's win.
Congrats Man.
Ignore it.
You won it, you deserve it, enjoy the ride ..
WM
posted on October 19, 2006 at 2:19 PM
avis wrote:
Jeffrey winning was a big disappointment for us die hard fans, uli's clothes were beautiful and wearable. laura had some very classic pieces in her line that any fashionista would have in her closet. The judges seem to pick 'innovators' that clearly they are impressed with but the rest of us find ugly, tacky and un-wearable. this show is beginning to show clear signs of being 'rigged' from the start.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 2:19 PM
dee wrote:
I believe that the best designer won, and I do not think that Jeffrey insulted anyone on the show. I DO belive that some of the drama was created by selective editing of footage that was shown on television.
Congratulations, Jeffrey, I thought you deserved the win from the first episode!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 2:27 PM
jam wrote:
YOU HAVE GOT TO BE FRICKING KIDDING ME! JEFFERY, GIVE ME A BREAK..HE COULD NOT SELL ME ANYTHING FROM THE CLEARANCE RACK OUT OF TARGET!
THIS SEASON WAS THE WORST AS FAR AS THE JUDING GOES. BRING VERA WANG BACK!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 2:35 PM
Sally Sue wrote:
Uli had the best all-round collection and the most marketable fashions for a nation that sucks up leisure time like a fine wine! Alas, for Season 4, the Wednesday Night Project Runway Party can now revert to "the Wednesday Night Girl's Poker Night"! We're all in agreement--Season 4 will proceed without us! Good luck to Jeffrey--with his unwillingness to be anything but a vulgar little toad, sly cheating, and his attitude of feigned superiority toward others, it is predictable that he shall be rendered his just rewards in the future! Project Runway "You are OUT!"
posted on October 19, 2006 at 2:36 PM
Sean wrote:
The response to Jeffery just shows what the world would be like if people stooped to the lowest common denominator. This show is about innovation and talent; not who is nice. Uli rocks. Her collection rocked. But step back from your feelings about him as a person and look at the ideas Jeffery has in his clothes. Uli makes beautiful stuff. But the ideas aren't as expansive as Jeffery's. She might wow you, but she didn't make you pause or think. That Jeffery can make you think and produce something beautiful is serious talent. Of the three winners of Project Runway so far, I think this is the best outcome.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 2:36 PM
mm wrote:
The best person won, Go Jeffery!! His show was the best. Michael was dissapointing, after the build up on the show and Laura was average, I believe I have seen this kind of stuff before. The best innovative designs won.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 2:44 PM
mony wrote:
My sister and I were very dissapointed with the finale. My kids were rooting for Michael, but after seeing his collection, we knew he had lost. Laura's was boring,but nice. Uli 's line was gorgeous.Where can I buy?! And Jeffrey? I can't believe he won. I'm done with the show. Goodbye Project Runway. Seeing hin win was a waste of time. I didn't like most of his pieces during the show, much less his final collection. Some were ok, but that's no reason to reward him with a win. I just don't understand.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 2:46 PM
Jenny wrote:
It is so obvious Jeffrey should never have won. His lack of manners, integrity and his overall style is poor. He looks like a reject from a Green Day concert! Michael was a dissappointment as well, it should have gone to Laura or Uli. Does anyone think Nina Garcia has great/any style? Get some new judges in there who have consistency when making there decisions. Attention Bravo your viewers are NOT happy and will likely NOT watch next season.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:01 PM
Phil wrote:
I love Michael's line, but understand why he didn't win. Laura's construction was good, as always, but I understand why she didn't win. Jeff's line had some nice garments, but was consistent at all. And don't confuse innovation and creativity with inconsistency and bad designs. Additionally, he was the only designer who had a garment that was pointed out for being terrible (at least on the edited version that they showed on TV, which, I assume, was the one that we all are basing our opinions off of). That leaves Uli, which, I am sure, will be far more successful and popular than Jeff.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:03 PM
De Wigger wrote:
JEFFREY with 2 FF's Jeffrey. YOU DID IT! You rock. You are the most talented, self respecting individual on the show. People can say what they want about a mean streak and cheating, but it just aint so. Jealousy is a double edge sword, Laura, so sorry your insecurity got the best of you. Worry about yourself and pleasing Albert Einstein and the brood, maybe your accusations are merely manifestations of guilt. Did your mommy help you with all those beads? Loved the "LIFTER" song on the runway show, fans of Jeffrey's passion for clothes should delve into his previous musical markings on the universe. Enjoy the ride Jeffrey.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:05 PM
CJ wrote:
Add me to the chorus -- I am SHOCKED and extremely disappointed that Jeffrey won. In fact, I don't know if I will continue to watch this show.
I disagree with others who say that character counts, and that's why Jeffrey shouldn't have won. After all, it's a DESIGN contest, not a personality contest.
HOWEVER, red + cream polka dots, and wide green + cream vertical stripes -- like something you'd see at the circus or on Ronald McDonald -- since when is that "innovative"? Polka dots, and ugly long silk or satin evening dresses, and then big green stripes -- exactly how does that translate into a cohesive collection and one distinctive, forceful point of view? Exactly what kind of woman would put on such ridiculous, costumey designs, on a day OTHER than Halloween? I thought these were the criteria upon which all 4 finalists were to be judged.
Yes, poor Michael's designs were too hootchie-mama, and Laura's were a big yawn -- how many times do we have to be subjected to an empire waist, beading and feathers? But ULI's creations clearly stood out. Elegantly and perfectly tailored, with a consistent safari look and theme, that all blended together in one cohesive collection. The kind of clothes that SO many woman would kill to wear.
Michael Kors knows this. His clothes are not out there, and not costumey. Did Nina take him along for a ride?
At the end of the episode, I felt so cheated to have invested so much time watching this show this season. Shame on you people!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:08 PM
West Miller wrote:
W O W again.
This season couldn't have been l e s s rigged.
At the end of the day do you really think Uli loses a n y t h i n g ? Her PR exposure alone will reveal itself in more commissions than she will be able to handle.
This show is based on finding 'the next great american designer' ..
Uli and Laura consistently showed a single aspect of women's wear .. dresses.
The judges practically begged them to expand their vision and they didn't, wouldn't, or couldn't.
Personally, and all things being equal, I would've been happier with an Alison/Keith/Bradley/Jeffrey finale.
But broken rules & reality television didn't play it that way.
And so we had Jeffrey. Who at every turn pumped out creative, unusual, unexpected, well crafted, and broad-spectrum work.
We got pants, jackets, coats, dresses, gowns, shirts, skirts, accessories, and we got attitude.
And on top of it we got the American dream. A man pulling himself up from the bottom and finding success in his own integrity.
We got a winner.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:12 PM
Joanne Robertson wrote:
I have been a fan of PR since the first season. It has insprired me and my friends to be creative, thoughtful and fashion forward. We look forward to gathering weekly to watch the show together, and we have appreciated the careful consideration shown when weaving together fashion and the beings that create that fashion. After watching as episode of PR, we feel satisfied. That was not the case last night. Jeffrey's victory was utterly unsatisfying and a huge disappointment on so many levels. I cannot say that I won't watch the show anymore, but I am not looking forward to the next season. Again, U am unsatisfied and disappointed. The end.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:17 PM
Kate Capps wrote:
Jeffrey,
Congratulations and I hope only the best for your future (both personally and professionally). I loved your collection -- and that was because my daughters (16 and 18) really helped me see it through their eyes. Both of them would love to wear your designs and they would look fabulous in them (I wouldn't).
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:19 PM
Silvana wrote:
Will never watch Runway again neither will all my family, friends both Florida and Boston, what a JOKE. Jeffery was rude, crude, and volgure. He should have been asked to leave the show when he was soooo rude to a Mother. Where was His??? $8,000. iisn't that a rule. He should have been disqualified just for that. The JUDGES were way off. Uli or Laura should have won. Anyone that wears Designer Clothes would not have picked Jeffrey, his collection was geared for who, him. NO, after watching 3 seasons of Runway this was the worst, will never watch it again. Tim Gunn I am really disappointed. Everyone of those Women Judges said they would wear Uli or Laura's collections. What happened to FAIRNESS, what a MESS. Goodbye RUNWAY......NO 4TH SEASON FOR A LOT OF PEOPLE.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:20 PM
Toddi in TX wrote:
Wow, how disappointing. I have been an avid PR viewer this season but was very disappointed with Jeffrey’s win. His designs are not innovative. Walk into any clothing store on Melrose in LA and you’ll see the same crap. Nina and Michael Kors don’t shop in those dumps so they think they’re seeing something new – ha. Based on her collection, Uli is the hands-down winner. Too bad that PR is not really about finding terrific, up and coming designers. PR is just another program chasing ratings by focusing on the immature, unkind behavior of the participants. Too bad, you’ve lost a viewer.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:22 PM
Kat Merrick wrote:
This is ridiculous?! This is not a contest to find the nicest, sweetest designer of today's safe fashions! And how is Jeffrey's behaviour any worse than Laura's constant nagging and narsasistic need to say EVERY SINGLE THING on her tiny mind?! And Angela's mom? Passive aggressive women often cry when their incredibly "innocent" and MANIPULATIVE behaviour blows up in their face. Jeffrey is not the easiest guy on the block to get along with but I think he is a straight shooter and you always know where you stand with Jeffrey. Can he take it down a knotch? Sure, and probably will with age and length of time sober - but get real, addicts are often very angry people. Congratulations Jeffrey - keep on keepin on.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:30 PM
queenmeg wrote:
Project Runway lost me and many other committed fans last night with Jeffrey's win. Laura and Michael were right! He never displayed that level of skill in any other design. He cheated! At the last minute (did you catch it) he decided not to use the "extra" denim skirt, "Oh, I forgot I had this other pair of white leather pants!" The other designers were working on their lines and knew exactly what they had. Jeffrey is a fraud. Didn't you see his eyelids blinking? Didn't you take notice of his lack of denial and tantrum? Uli's line was beautiful, Laura was impeccable. Michael was a favorite, but with reservation. Now what will I do with my Wednesday nights???
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:30 PM
Sandra wrote:
I have to say that I concur with the majority of what has already been said. I will NEVER watch Project Runway again! Overbudget, questions about integrity and not a marketable clothing show and still winning is absurd! First of all Jeffery said that he had some outside pleating done, but there were no receipts for that work...do you really think he was going to turn in any outside receipts? You could tell by his reaction he was scared that the producers were going to catch him. I don't think there was a thorough enough investigation performed.
Look at the scores from rate the runway and you tell me who should have won? It was not Jeffery!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:33 PM
Diana H Muldrow wrote:
Boo--
My first and last season to watch PR. Worst choice. Ulee's was beautiful and probably should have won. Michael's collection was nice but not his best work. However, he can sew as can Laura. Jeffrey only has the means to get it done by others. So much for teaching integrity to other.
Disappointed
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:36 PM
Disillusioned In New Orleans wrote:
To Bravo TV & The Judges Of Project Runway Season 3:
I am speechless!! When the Project Runway Season 3 Finale winner was announced - I literally sat there in shock! My husband asked me "Are you alright?" My immediate response and gut reaction was and is "I am never watching Project Runway again. Ever... Period.."
I had faith that the judges would stick with the rules and criteria of the competition and they didn't. Shame on them!! I put aside my personal dislike for Jeffrey as a human being (especially since I don't even know the man) and can honestly say I gave his finale collection a fair shake. I know I am not a professional designer, but I judged this competition based on the rules and criteria requirements.
Uli went above and beyond what was expected of her by the judges and quite frankly me. I kept hearing myself oooing and awwing as outfit after outfit came down the runway. Laura's collection was so beautiful, but I do agree with the judges that she could have reached further inside of herself and took more chances from a design standpoint. I was disappointed with Michael's but have such high expectations of him and expect to see more of him in the future. Jeffrey's collection however, was such a disappointment overall! I did like the design but not the fabric on the green striped dress). I expected more from him as a designer, just as I expected more from the judges!!
I am not watching Project Runway ever again... Not because of Jeffrey, but because of the judging of the finale of the collections of Season 3. While I have been typing this, I have been thinking of how the judges can justify their voting on this finale season.
My phone has been ringing off the hook and everyone's reaction is the same - Uli won hands down! They are in shock!
I am saddened that I won't share future designers dreams coming true. This show really has a great concept, but this fan and lots of others I have spoken with are saying "Auf Wiedersehen Project Runway".
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:41 PM
Virginia Russo wrote:
Posting to Andy's blog because I adore Rucker and Tim.
Forget not watching Project Runway because they yanked us around and ultimately disappointed us. I'll happily continue to watch Runway forever. However, I'll also be watching who sponsors the show.
My Saturn is paid for, tell Tresseme I'm switching back to Suave, and L'Oreal isn't worthy of me. Maybe that will get the producers' attention so they'll listen when we say we want a fashion competiton, not Survivor/Runway Island. Show more sewing. And how about putting a camera next to Heidi so we can see what she sees, because that surely is not what's happening now.
And don't call me Shirley.
Annasmom
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:45 PM
Joanne Smith wrote:
Project Runway = Project Runaway or the best wanna be designer, with the most absurd persona (short of being psychotic) of clothes that won't be worn and off. Jay and now Jeffery what is the message being sent out. El magazine and the fashion word want bizarre not real designs. Case in point, the pieces that Jeffery designed that might be perceived as marketable beyond the sci-fi or ‘who wants to be seen as the most peculiarly dressed’ event here a failure, like his attempt at a long evening dress and the judges themselves substantiated those comments. Well then, there has been a lot of contradicting statements made by the Nina & what's his name, so no surprises there. Why does the show have a guest judge if you're not going to value their candid and unbiased opinion? Jeffery didn't beak the rules???? Oh, I guess going over budget and not being able to produce receipts is just stretching the rules. Wasn't he just so smart to have an extra pair of leather pants handy just in case. In case of what --- that he got caught? I wonder if, in the producers comprehensive and through review of his accounting, if they asked to see the other papers Jeffery, with that panicky look on face, was cumbersomely shuffling papers around when he had to present them to Tim. Gosh forbid that a designer win that one of the countries top models would wear every one of their dresses. Enough, this is just as much a waste of time as watching this show. No more of that for me
Oh by the way, how are Jay's sales doing?
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:54 PM
selat wrote:
I just want to say how impressed I was with the quality of the designs of the collections at the Olympus Fashion Show. By far this was the strongest show with 4 qualified contestants. I am also so happy to see that the best collection won.
Jeffery is super talented, and his collection was the most beautiful and inovative. While many may not personally like him based on his comments and behavior, all must acknowledge he is very talented.
As Tim often said, it was a matter of taste, and frankly anyone except Michael could have walked away with the win in my opinion.
I also loved the emotion shown by Tim in the episode, I got choked up with seeing him getting choked up. It is clear how much he cares about the designers and that they succeed. He is clearly the heart of Project Runway!!!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:54 PM
Tim wrote:
Seems I have the same opinion as most people. I do not think Jeffrey should not have won. However I do give him credit for breaking out from the usual, and creating some crazy clothes. But in my opinion, he never grew.. he was like laura in that sense. Her clothes were incredible, but never really broke out or grew as the season went on. Uli I thought showed the most growth.. her finale was interesting if a little conservative. Michael i think got robbed to some extent because the crowd really luved his stuff. I will say, I'm not as anxious for the next season this time around. For 3 seaons now the ones with creativity and SKILL seem to lose out I agree with one writer, its starting to smell rigged
posted on October 19, 2006 at 3:55 PM
Molly wrote:
I wonder how many people that are bemoaning Jeff's win actually know anything about fashion? I certainly don't, but I have faith the judges certainly know what they're talking about!
I adored Jeff's collection. I thought is was marketable, just not to a traditional high fashion market. I can't say I've particularly cared for his attitude all season, but the work was the criteria, not his personality. It was cohesive, and everyone should know that cohesion is a huge factor--it's what killed Dan's chances last season.
Jeffery didn't break the rules. He lost a receipt. -gasp- I'm sure you've never lost a receipt. And yes, he went over budget. He subsequently removed items from his show, bringing his total back under budget. It doesn't matter if he went over, because the judges saw only the 8000 dollars worth.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 4:05 PM
mary wrote:
For the fans that claim they speak for everyone in finding Jeffrey's clothes unwearable and are soooo disappointed that they may never watch the show again... Get a grip, or a cocktail dress, or a mumuu, or a little whoretastic short set -- and let me have all the Jeffrey designs! I am ecstatic. And somehow I really doubt that the next PR will slip on the runway Or in the ratings. I have maybe three shows I watch regularly. This is one of them. Bravo Bravo.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 4:12 PM
Mimi wrote:
Unbelievable...Jeffery won? There was not one single thing in that collection that I liked. I agree ugly, tacky and cheap were the words the judges should have used to describe his work. Laura and Uli were Head and Shoulders above Jeffery in terms of talent and class. Good luck to them, as I am sure they will be much more economically successful than Jeffery. That is because no one will actually buy and wear his clothes!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 4:16 PM
Julieanna Rice wrote:
I loved the end. Jeffery was the best. what is wrong with you guys? Uli made wonderful clothes but Jeff made great clothes. He should have won and he did. Thank god for Judges with brains. I love this show and miss it all ready i can't wait till next season. I am going to LA to find jefferys clothes Julieanna in Oregon
posted on October 19, 2006 at 4:29 PM
traceknows wrote:
Laura and Michael should team up and drop a serious line! Her maturity and meticulous eye for fashion and his youth and flair...will make a FAB line
posted on October 19, 2006 at 4:34 PM
SMiddy wrote:
I have to agree with the popular sentiment that last night's win was a bad decision by the judges. I felt like nobody hit a home run with their collections, so given the fairly equal footing they were all on, why reward the person who cheated twice (no receipts and over budget) and was such an a@#hole the whole season. Yeah, yeah, he has a cute kid and came back from a rough patch, that doesn't mean he can be so rude and abrasive. And the fact that he did it all in such a calculating fashion makes him even LESS sympathetic than he already was. C'mon Bravo, is this the type of behaivor we want to reward?
posted on October 19, 2006 at 4:40 PM
Nancy wrote:
I, like others responding on this blog, have been very disappointed in the judging this season. Last night cemented my frustration. When bad character and fashion that no woman wants to wear is rewarded - that's when I call it quits.
No other season seemed to have such lopsided judging. Here's my suggestion for next year. The judges for the Olympus Fashion Show should NOT be the same ones judging in previous weeks. I felt that Nina and Michael were way too influenced by their expectations. I'd be interested in a fresh take now that the final designers are showing their best.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 4:47 PM
Mary B wrote:
The Project Runway finale was a huge letdown. So many friends hoped to see Michael win. Amazing craftsmanship by Laura and Uli's clothes would get a second look haning on the rack in the store. I can't imagine anyone wearing Jeffrey's stuff -- too out-there for your average woman consumer. And, to reward him with the win after he went over budget . . . that was just wrong. I don't know if I'll have the passion for Project Runway on a go-forward basis after the complete letdown from last evening.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 4:48 PM
pattie wrote:
Nomatterhowmuch I wantedMichaelto win because I truly elt he understood a woman's body more than any other designed, I have got to say Uli's collection blew me away. The sad truth is...the designer who won - Mean Jeffrey- deserved to win. Why? Because those designer judges do not care about what looks good on us normal people...they want to show a collection for Paris Hilton, Lyndsay Lohan yada yada yada. And, if you look at it from that standpoint...the decision was very clear as to who would win. Fashion favors money and where there is money to burn...there is trash to wear!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 4:55 PM
Andrew B. wrote:
I'm not upset that Jeffrey won because he's a mean person. I'm upset that he won because his clothes were just plain UGLY! My favorite all season was Laura, but I do admit that Uli had the better collection going down the runway. Uli was robbed. Jeffrey could be a big jerk, but if his clothes were nice I wouldnt have cared...but they werent. What a waste of my time. If being upset that Jeffrey won means that I'm "clueless about fashion" then so be it. I'll be spending my "clueless time" watching other tv programs and my "clueless money" on the runner-ups.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 4:58 PM
Lacey Dean wrote:
Please let me know when Uli's collections hits stores, she is by far the most practical designer of the four. Uli was robbed last night! I honestly would have loved to see any of them when except for Jeffrey. I do not understand how he was able to get away with cheating, Laura and Michael were right to questions his work since they were the first decent made garments all season! Very disappointed.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 5:07 PM
Kathryn wrote:
Yes I was horrified Jeff won - I hated his line. BUT what I really don't get is how he could be a contestant at all....Didn't he have his own fashion business already? How is it fair for him to compete against people like Laura and Michael who are just starting out? Look at the manufacturing facilities that Jeff had, and see how much harder the others had to work in their tiny corners. I am not surprised his craftsmenship was better - he has commercial grade supplies to make garmets with. Out of all the lines - I preferred Uli's.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 5:15 PM
Kristi wrote:
Do you all live in a cave. Jeffery's collection was incredible cohesive and well rounded. Evrey designer designs for a certain demographic/target audience. Jeffrey's collection is young, hip, and yes people dare I say it wearable. Not to mention incredible refreshing.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 5:18 PM
Sharon wrote:
ARRRGGGGH! What a huge letdown! To think that I watched every single show this season to see a mean spirited, nasty, trash designer like Jeffrey win ... I am in total shock. One of my friends told me she thought this was going to happen ... Bravo had been setting the audience up for this conclusion for several weeks now ... painting Jeffrey in the "victim's image" and Laura as the witchy villan. I just didn't believe it could be true. How foolish of me, I thought this was all about chosing someone who could design beautiful women's clothing and not grungry punk clothing that only very, very young women might wear. Although I was not an Uli fan throughout the show ... I truly thought her collection embodied everything that the judges and women everywhere could ask for. She was also obviously the audience's choice ... too bad the judges sold out to sensationalism!
Don't know that I care to invest my time in this show next year if this is the direction they are going.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 5:32 PM
Susan wrote:
Yes, I too was shocked by the outcome but in a positive, "thank God!" way. The judges actually judged on what was in front of them and didnt make this a popularity contest (as it was for so many people as evidenced by so many of the blogs above). Jeffrey's an artist and his line was fashion forward, innovative and outstanding. Just in terms of the intricacies of his designs and constructions, none of the other 3 designers came close. Uli needs more experience and she could do well in resort wear; Laura's one note but sews beads and baubles on well and Michael, well, he seems a nice fellow but oh geez; the judges were kind when they merely questioned his taste. Congratulations, Jeffrey! And praise be to the judges, at last!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 5:34 PM
Sophi wrote:
Jeffrey was a clear choice for the winner.
Smug-yes, arrogant-yes, best of thebunch-yes, diplomat-no, likable-no. He is what you seeon real runways.
All the other designers may have lines in Macy's and Norstrom, ( well, maybe not Michael) but Jeffrey is real runway stuff. And fashion. Not a line for the average. You will see his stuff in the future on the Events/Happenings pages with celebs wearing them.
Bergdorf has probably bought the rights to Laura's line already, to be seen on Lauren Bacall or other matrons. Uli will be worn by Christy Turlington and Goldie Hawn. But Jeffery will be seen by Pink, and Gwen Stefani and people that actually spend 10K to by seen.
Uli should move to New York for a few yearsand observe flowery prints vs. black.
Michael Kors is so so slick. Probably a lousey boss, but great cheesey judge.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 5:35 PM
Diane wrote:
I was dissappointed as well. The best collections were from Uli and Laura. They were both robbed. Nina turned out to be a bit of a b_____ . The way she attacked Laura, Was she jealous. And Michael Kors criticizing Uli - her designs were beautiful. There was no reason for Jeffrey to win. His clothes were actually distasteful - I want to see Nina in one of them or Heidi!!! Can you imagine!!!
I actually had thought Michael would steal the show but unfortunately this was not his best work.
It should have been Uli or Laura!!!!!!! I don't think I even heard anyone clap when Jeffrey's models strolled down the cat walk.
Uli & Lauras got plenty of applause.
Bravo should consider interviewing new judges for next season.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 5:40 PM
Rhonda wrote:
Who in the hell left the gate open!!! Jeffrey is a losser and so are the judges. Heidi needs to get all new judges with taste and fashions sense. Everybody knows that Uli should have won. If there is a season 4 PR DON'T GET IT TWISTED!!!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 5:41 PM
Mike Burns wrote:
People here seem to be editing the show and making up rules in their minds. Jeff couldn't produce receipts for 1 item. That item was removed from his collection. He was over budget and had to cut further things from his collection. People are allowed to have some outsourced help, if the help is paid for out of their original budget. S1 Kara Saun had no real receipts for her "free" shoes, so she just made up numbers to try to get by. Her shoes were not allowed to be judged as part of her overall look. Jay outsourced some of his collection, Michael outsourced some of his. The only difference is they kept receipts. People's irrational hatred of Jeffrey is definitely messing with their minds. Makes them forget he paid Angela's mom a compliment in the midst of all the drama surrounding the Everyday Woman ep. where he also gave her the colors she asked for only to have her tell Tim later she hated them. In the midst of a heated competition and a few hours befor the runway, wouldn't that look shady to you?
posted on October 19, 2006 at 5:42 PM
Shel wrote:
I am disappointed with the choice the judges made for the winning collection. Uli clearly had the winning collection. It was exciting, beautiful and wearable. Even during the coarse of the entire competition, Michael, Laura and Uli's garments were far superior in style, execution and presentation. I don't understand why all of the discrepencies concerning Jeffrey's collection were dismissed. The producers have lost credibility for the show. They need to take a serious look at their policies to make sure that the competition is FAIR for everyone. It did not happen in this instance. But certainly a change is needed among the judges. I am a Michael Kors customer and admirer of his fashions. But should he be regularly judging designers who could potentially become a competitor? Elle Magazine and Nina Garcia, no doubt have enormous influence over the choice of designers because they are an awarding sponsor? Should the narrow focus of that magazine carry the balance of the decision that will affect talented designers not in their sights? Individuals chosen to judge should be impartial. Without some changes I won't be tuning in for Season Four.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 5:44 PM
kathy wrote:
If I want creative, great sportswear, I'll choose Michael. If I want a gorgeous sundress or afternoon party frock, I select Uli. If I needed a drop-dead evening gown, I hire Laura. But if I wanted a Salvation Army special or felt a need to go dumpster diving, then I go straight to Jeffrey. Nuff said.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 5:54 PM
Rookie wrote:
Jeffrey did an absolutely great job - he deserved to win on that alone but it is simply icing on the cake after he was so rudely accused by the cry baby pregnant constantly whining "I'm tired" Mom - if she could raise 5 kids and put her collection together so well just think what he was able to do with only 1 child in the house. How unfair - Jeffrey earned the win and she "earned and whined" her way to losing.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 5:57 PM
Jennifer wrote:
Yihaa, yahoo, yay!!! Jeffrey won! I just love his collection, very sexy, young, stylish, cute, innovative, etc!! He DESERVES it!!! Those of you who think his collection sucked is because you guys are older people – no modern sense of style, that’s why you like Laura’s.
I like Uli a lot too but she didn’t win because her style is similar to what she has done in the past. Laura, she is just a fake, there are only one or two gowns that is nice in her collection, the rest sucked! Michael didn’t prove himself; his collection is the worst of them all. He is young; bet he can do better in the future. Overall, Jeffrey is the BEST! My friends and I were screaming at the top of our throat at 11 pm because he won!!! Unexpected!!! Love you Jeff! Well done!!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 5:58 PM
Sharon wrote:
ARRRGGGGH! What a huge letdown! To think that I watched every single show this season to see a mean spirited, nasty, trash designer like Jeffrey win ... I am in total shock. One of my friends told me she thought this was going to happen ... Bravo had been setting the audience up for this conclusion for several weeks now ... painting Jeffrey in the "victim's image" and Laura as the witchy villan. I just didn't believe it could be true. How foolish of me, I thought this was all about chosing someone who could design beautiful women's clothing and not grungry punk clothing that only very, very young women might wear. Although I was not an Uli fan throughout the show ... I truly thought her collection embodied everything that the judges and women everywhere could ask for. She was also obviously the audience's choice ... too bad the judges sold out to sensationalism!
Don't know that I care to invest my time in this show next year if this is the direction they are going.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 6:02 PM
Gari Collis wrote:
Uli was robbed! After the comments the judges made about her collection and then giving it to Jeffrey - I was aghast. Did they throw all their criteria out the window? Even if you like Jeffrey's designs, they appeal to such a limited audience which is what they always accused Laura of. As a Wardrobe Consultant I know what women of all ages and body types want and it's not what won last night.
Hopefully someone will come along to represent both Uli and Laura. Michael has the right stuff - it's just a matter of time for him. I hope the three of them read all these comments and take heart.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 6:02 PM
staciemckenzie wrote:
Andy,
Thank you for this insightful interview. It was really illuminating. I appreciate hearing from Jeffrey directly about a lot of the issues you brought up. I find his answers very thoughtful and articulate. Jeffrye is a very complex guy, and I wish all the best for him and Melanie and Harrison.
The finale was an emotional rollercoaster. Wow. So much drama. A myriad of emotions.
I admit that I cried at the end. I knew after viewing the collections that it would come down to Jeffrey or Uli, but it was still quite suspenseful.
Great job! I'm looking forward to the next season. Keep up the good work.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 6:05 PM
kH wrote:
Congratzz Jeff! You've done an amazing collection. My girlfriend was almost crying when you won! she loved you since the show first aired!!!
Great Jobe
posted on October 19, 2006 at 6:06 PM
RicaHgurl wrote:
Jeffry Won!!! I'm speechless, surprised but damn Happy!!! I would want to have his collection; it just looks so great!! people who complained that Jeff collection was sucked; please read hollywoods magazine and see what kind of clothing these actresses are wearing now!!! Jeff has that cutting edge, young celebrities will love his design!!
GO Jeffry!!!!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 6:10 PM
Seline Carlson wrote:
I was stunned...shocked....and disgusted when Jeffrey won. He is the last of the four to be considered for the win, in my opinion. He had flops repeadedly, he is outrageous in his style, and he is obnoxious in personality. Uli had the best collection last night, but it was supposed to be the whole season taken into consideration - or so I thought. I have decided never to watch Project Runway again, because with such an unfair decision, I believe the show is rigged. I now believe the goal of the producers and judges is for DRAMA and they pick winners based on who will be the most colorful and controversial. I'm so disappointed in the integrity of the show, and it's not worth watching a rigged show. Have you noticed the fans voting of the collections and designers? I believe we are much more capable of picking the most talented designers, thus the worthy winner, than those phoney judges. Shame on them. Perhaps you should implement the system where the fans votes count, so the judges can't be bought off. All three of the other designers deserved to win before Jeffrey should have been considered. This is not to say that he doesn't occasionally come up with good pieces.....it just is not consistent. Plus so many of his designs are as obnoxious as he is. The others were much more consistent, talented and their designs delightful over the season.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 6:11 PM
jengkol wrote:
Jeffrey, I just knew that you are going to win!!! Don't listen to others' complaints and bad words; keep designing because there are also people that loves you!! Great Job!!!!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 6:12 PM
Tressie wrote:
Horrifying...Jeffrey is the winner. I can't believe he survived week after week no less won. I agree with all my friends...the judges are short sighted and out of touch with the real world and have no vision for what real "Macy's" customers would purchase.
Uli, Laura and Michael all had pieces that would be in our closets. Don't be surprised PR that your ratings fall to the bottom, alot of us are signing off. We are not going to put up with the crap you want to shove down our throats. Jeffrey belongs back on the streets of LA. Just because he is a recovering addict doesn't mean he can design clothes. His lifestyle is as bad as his clothing line. His attitude and behavior is disgusting.
I think the biggest line of BS was Tim saying the producers have investigated the matter and find missing receipts and overspending. That should have been the end of Jeffrey. You are really making a mockery of design, as well as rules of fair play. Oh poor Jeffrey we will bend the rules cause he was a druggy. He still has an attitude that doesn't deserve adoration or acceptance. In the real world he won't make it. Do you think Michael Kors would hire him. He better not or his overpriced designs will be on the no buy list too. How bout going back to Jeffrey's design studio where he outsources his designs and checking out the illegal workers who really did the sewing. How is it that three of the designers come in with work to do and numbnuts Jeffrey sits on his but for days and then just happens to pull out an extra pair of leather pants for his collection. You judges better put down the lines and get real. We as of now over 50 girls at the office have decided no more Elle magazines will be purchased and no more PR will grace out PVR's. Smarten up advertisers. And get rid of the german model.PR you're out.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 6:21 PM
Jackie wrote:
I would like the producers to tell me why Keith was booted off the show for having pattern books when its obvious that Jeffrey went over the $8,000 limit & also did not produce a few of his clothes (which I believe is alot more than he admitted to). So why do rules applied to one designer & not to another designer? Why does one person get booted & the other gets the $100,000 etc.
Jeffrey has proven to be obnoxious & rude to clients, designs clothes for punk pre-teens & nothing a normal women would wear & has proved he will lie to win.
There is an old saying that applies here "What comes around Jeffrey, goes around" & you will get your just rewards in the future.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 6:26 PM
susan wrote:
The judges definitely got this one right! As for Laura, she should never presume to give another woman advice on how to improve their lives by virtue of her style or esthetics -- her behavior of pettiness and jeolousy set the woman's movement back 50 years. Grow up, Laura, or get off the stage!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 6:27 PM
Carol B. wrote:
It’s very strange that Jeffrey Sebelia was ever allowed to enter the competition, not to mention win it. First, he’s an established designer. (His Cosa Nostra line is already being sold through retail shops in the U.S., Canada, Europe and Japan. And check out his website—I don’t know of any other “fledgling” designer with such a high-class site featuring such stunningly complex designs.) Second, he went over budget and couldn’t produce receipts, infractions that should have sent him home just like the guy caught with design books in his room. (Shame on you, PR, for unevenly applying the rules. And Tim, YOUR integrity is in question on this one.) Third, the presence of a seasoned designer like Jeffrey detracts from deserving up-and-comers such as Michael who REALLY could use a hundred grand and a car to launch his career.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 6:32 PM
Lisa wrote:
Am I surprised that the judges picked Jeffery as the winner, NO!! Not because I agree with their decision, but because in their world, he represents what THEY think is fresh, innovative, chic, art.....whatever. The overwhelming majority of people on this blog and I suspect everywhere else DON'T see through the narrow eyes of their specs. It's a small window in which they orbit, they will NEVER get the masses to accept those fashions or thoses clothes. Yeah it's nice for the size 2 rock star wannabe guys & gals in LA. Or Nina Garcia who tuts at anything an average person might like....but they'll ALWAYS only get less than 20% of that demos money, while the rest of us hunt through the horrific racks of crap in stores right now ..... waiting for the designs of people like Uli, Laura & Michael.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 6:38 PM
Dead Bullet, V wrote:
I don’t get the big hate for Jeffery. His clothes fit into the genre that he deigns for and they were stunning. I get the idea for watching these shows that the people on them were trying to show case who they are as a designer and show what they can do to the world. I don’t think making Angelina’s mom cry has anything to do with anything, she should have help Jeffery not hide behind his back and tell everyone else she didn’t like it. The client should be all over the designers ass and make them cry but she decided to keep her mouth shut and play the martyr. I don’t think that people’s decisions on who won should be based on their personal feeling, so their character flaws shouldn’t come into play. He designed some drop dead shit and I would be proud to wear them if I was a size half zero. His personality fits the people he designed for got a problem with that get over it and buy someone else’s clothes.
And this is a comment for a comment above, Most fans have no idea what to look for when designing and outfit, do you honestly think just by watching the show you can actually judge the crap they have sent out on the runway. Fans are judging by what they can see on a television screen therefore they miss things that can be see when someone who see the clothes in person. Fans also judge on who they like and don’t like and this is very obvious especially while viewing these comments. I have high doubts that all the people her have experience is designing. DO you not realize that all reality TV is rigged now, contestants go on there knowing the more shit they cause the more air time they get that is how it works, keep the masses watching. Now, doesn’t it. Anyone remember Satanio from season two?
It was refreshing to see someone who can think outside the box for once and not try to impress the sheep of this world!!!! Rock on Jeffery!!
And all those finalists have a good place in the fashion world so what the hell did they really lose compared to what they will gain …
posted on October 19, 2006 at 6:47 PM
Elizabeth wrote:
I rewatched the finale and not only did I not like Jeffrey's clothes the first time, it was even worse the 2nd time! I don't understand the judge's thinking and who cares about "the story" . THe blue dress and long dress were horrendous and what was special about any of the others? Who would they market his clothing to? The LA young rock crowd? Uli's were beautiful and I would love to have one of everything of her's as were Laura's. Michael's were disappointing but over the show's season he did some great stuff! I guess the one who is the most obnoxious ass will win this every year because it makes for good television??? So very disappointed in the outcome as I have been with past shows....
posted on October 19, 2006 at 6:54 PM
carol lisenby wrote:
I'm outraged that jeffrey won for his designs were totally off the wall. I also think it was unfair for him to even be in the top four, as he has an established fashion house with employees who turn out his designs for him. Uli's designs were beautiful as was Laura's and Michael's and I think it was really unfair to them for Jeffery to even be competing. I'm sure the producers checked out Laura's complaint against Jeffrey, and I applaud her for bringing it to tim's attention. I am just sorry the producers couldn't prove any of the allegations against him. Jeffrey should have been long gone.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 7:29 PM
Beth Collins wrote:
Well, one good thing came out of this show, my need to EVER watch it again. Sorry, I've had enough bad taste.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 7:43 PM
kryanox wrote:
i do not know alot about fashion, but i have never seen and most likely will never see a girl wearing that Green-white Stripped dress w/o thinking WHAT THE HECK WAS SHE THINKING!
i might add that this could be the beggining of the end for this show!
this is a simple example of how the sart loosing interest from the audience!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 7:51 PM
Brooke wrote:
To me Uli's collection stood out the best, esp the dress-turned-bikini design. I love her colors, her designs, and her craftmanship. I was rooting for both Uli and Jeffrey. Uli is my favorite because she is a genuinely nice person. Jerffrey is blunt and could be misunderstood as being rude. Laura is a nit-picker and at her age she should have learned that while her accusations might turn out to be true (which they didn't), she looked like a bull-dog for going after another person by attacking his integrity. Michael is a nice guy, but his final collection was a disappointment.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 7:52 PM
Bud wrote:
Wow
I just read a shirtload of negative comments about the finale.
Seems there's been a can of woop ass opened?
I guess alot folks just don't get it.
This year the finale four were all so talented. I think it's all about demographics and the wide age group the Show Appeals to.
If your approaching 50 you probably Loved Laura and her classic High end perfection. She took us back to the glamor of Black and White Hollywood. Michael fell in love with Pam Greer halfway thru and his youth showed in the end. Yuli showed us all how a woman can look great and be comfortable.
She just gets better and better.
Jeffery, well,the cutting edge straight shooter. I totally understood his attitude with Angela's Mom.
She would have turned on him during the judgement I'll bet you a nickle she would have. If you surveyed the World Public that watches BRAVO, I think Jeffery would be the overall winner.
I'm not saying I would have picked him. I was shocked when Allison left so early on. I loved Her.
I will watch next season.
I never agree with the Judges,
Peace !
posted on October 19, 2006 at 7:53 PM
Claire wrote:
Add me to the list of former viewers of PR. Are the rules of the competition only enforced for some? Jeffrey's behavior toward others was reprehensible. Talent and class do not have to be mutually exclusive. Will Jeffrey only be polite to customers who are 6 foot models who weigh 100 pounds? Uli was robbed. I do believe, because the show has become a ratings cow for Bravo, the best designer was not chosen. They chose the one who would cause the most controversy!!!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 7:53 PM
Sophi wrote:
Jeffrey was a clear choice for the winner.
Smug-yes, arrogant-yes, best of thebunch-yes, diplomat-no, likable-no. He is what you seeon real runways.
All the other designers may have lines in Macy's and Norstrom, ( well, maybe not Michael) but Jeffrey is real runway stuff. And fashion. Not a line for the average. You will see his stuff in the future on the Events/Happenings pages with celebs wearing them.
Bergdorf has probably bought the rights to Laura's line already, to be seen on Lauren Bacall or other matrons. Uli will be worn by Christy Turlington and Goldie Hawn. But Jeffery will be seen by Pink, and Gwen Stefani and people that actually spend 10K to by seen.
Uli should move to New York for a few yearsand observe flowery prints vs. black.
Michael Kors is so so slick. Probably a lousey boss, but great cheesey judge.
All the other noise is just good drama and people tune in to see that.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 7:55 PM
viviana santiago wrote:
I was also disappointed with last nights decision. I do feel Uli was robbed, but this is no shock to me, I've been disappointed by PR before ( Season 1) . Uli's collection was beautiful, and I would buy her clothes in a heartbeat. Jeffrey's collection as a whole, was as twisted as he is..on top of that, he's an arrogant jerk. I'm sure all his so-called fans would love to have him treat their mothers, the same way he treated Angela's right?. What I found funny was Heidi telling Uli she would wear everything in her collection, but she sure didn't say that to Jeffrey, did she?..lol. With the exception of Heidi (being the host), I really feel the show should have different judges every season, and not limited to the same bias opinions of the judges currently on. There are many others with a better and more modern sense of fashion and style, than Michael Kors and NIna Garcia. I was and still am a fan of Michael Knight. Although I wasn't "wowed" by his final collection, I did think he was the best designer on the show. I feel that the judges should give consideration to a designer's overall performance on the show, other than just the final runway collection. If this were the case, then Jeffrey wouldn't have won, and the majority of PR fans would not be so disappointed right now. MIchael, Uli, and Laura, congratulations on a job well done...You're all winners!!!....Jeffrey....learn some manners and respect, but most all .."TAKE A BATH".
posted on October 19, 2006 at 8:11 PM
Valarie Rehm wrote:
I'm soooooooo mad! I can't believe that jerk Jeffrey won. I really don't care about his pitty-pot story over having had a hard childhood and being a drug addict. Been there and done that and so have many others. Yet the majority come out better people, if they come out at all. Is his sad little story the reason he won? I've got some sob stories too, will that get my talents noticed? Jeffrey is a narrow minded, obnoxious freak who acts like noone else matters. His clothes stink like his attitude does. His back alley 80's CBGB's look is tired punk rock, that needs to be left back in the 80's instead of updated. Teenage rockers and young starlets are the only people that will wear them. I have loved INC clothing for some time now and search them out, but I'm afraid that will end. Laura, Uli and Michael are all better designers. His clothes aren't even figure flattering. I thought he was supposed to be designing WOMEN'S clothing. I like edgy, not little girl. Angela had a better look for INC than he does. What a dissappointment. Forget about bothering to watch Project Runway next season. And oh, by the way ... his ideas aren't outside the box...just go to any NYC grunge/punk backroom bar/nightclub. His clothes are there right next to the guy wearing Boy George. Now let's all grow UP!!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 8:13 PM
Molly wrote:
Sad, very sad. I never like to see mean people win.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 8:52 PM
Shannon wrote:
I'm sick to my stomach! PR needs to leave voting to the fans just like the other talent shows. We are the ones who will be buying these clothes. It's just like the guest judge said, no one buys the extra extravagant stuff rolling off of runways, they buy the much more toned down version that they can wear once a week and get away with it!
Who is going to wear a green and white striped dress with zippers on the outside??
posted on October 19, 2006 at 8:52 PM
Janet Coulson wrote:
What were you thinking? Why wasn't Jeff kicked off for cheating? Why was Jeff voted best designer for his ugly collection? Why would you damage your reputations by voting him the best designer? Why don't you care about your viewers? What ever happened to fairness? Why, why, why?
posted on October 19, 2006 at 8:55 PM
Vanessa wrote:
Add me to the list of viewers who won't be watching the show next season. I grew weary weeks ago with the constant drama which the producers tried to keep at fever pitch. I wonder if the viewers of this show were shown any footage at all which would enable us to draw any reasonable conclusions about who the designers or judges are. This year was anti-reality TV at its worst. I will miss the show.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 8:58 PM
Eric wrote:
I think it is just amazing that Jeffrey won. I did not find his fashions as amazing as Uli's or Laura's. He consistently was rewarded for being an amazing ass he how he presented himself to others. In the last season, that wasn't tolerated. I believe the rose colored glasses need to be taken off, and chose a professional who actually acts like a professional. Jeffrey certainly wasn't.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 9:02 PM
Janice T. wrote:
The rules were broken when Jeffrey was allowed to go onto the Olympus Fashion Show with Uli, Laura, and Michael. His dress was frumpy, clearly the worst of that episode. He should have been eliminated there and then. Clearly the show was rigged, unfair to each of the other 14 contestants.
I hope another network will rework, rename, and air a similar show, one with rules that will be strictly adhered to.
Auf.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 9:05 PM
Emily Houston wrote:
I was so excited that Jeffrey won. I think he is a great designer and I think the Judges were fair. He did go over budget, but he fixed it just fine and in the end he was under 400 dollars. He wasn't allowed to use the shorts that he had pleated because he didn't have a reciept which was totally fair, (I don't think he did anything illegal). I think that everyone looks at Jeffrey the wrong way because he speaks his mind, but he just says what everyone else is thinking, it is just that most people are raised to be fake and backstabbing, take for instance Laura. Besides the point of this show is not who has the best personaility, but who has the best design, and I think by far Jeffrey deserved to win the prize, although I must say I was very impressed with Uli, I think what she did was very unexpected and awesome. One last thing, I think Micheal did a much better job than Laura, and I can't even believe that Laura made it to the final, her designs and clothing are for middle aged women.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 9:20 PM
Evelyn Kale wrote:
I was surprised and disappointed that the prize would go to someone who did not hesitate to break the rules. Speaks volumes about the show and pretty much trumps all the talk about integrity.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 9:26 PM
Jennifer wrote:
That's it - I'm DONE with this show. The first season was so wonderful, the second - meh, but this was too much! I'm so glad that the judges found the re-hashed Westwood and Hot Topic designs presented by Jeffery to be so "innovative". Good God - it looked like cheap mall knock-offs circa 1984! Where is THEIR taste level?!? But I must admit, the matching his and her faux-hawks (+ some mullet in there too) sported by Jeffrey and the Mrs. were a scream!
posted on October 19, 2006 at 9:27 PM
G wrote:
What the HELL was that voting last night? Michael and Uli were robbed. I have been a loyal fan since season 1 and this was by far my favorite season, however the judges must have been high. Jeffery won what a joke. Michael was my favorite the entire season but Uli's runway stole the show. The judges continuously praised Michael about knowing a woman's body and being able to get his point of view across so what the hell happened. The comments from the judges were contradictory and bias. No more PR for me for sure. If this is about talent, then definitely the judges missed their mark. Women want to wear clothes that make them feel good, not to look like they are going to costume party.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 9:37 PM
janew wrote:
Jeffery is SO undeserving. There was not one design of his in the entire series that I would be caught dead in...much less wear alive. "Judges", you should be ashamed.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 9:56 PM
Mitsaoua wrote:
Jeffrey you are the best! See you around! Everyone else is just sour grapes.posted on October 19, 2006 at 10:03 PM
Caroline Bonney wrote:
Laura's collection was exquisite. classic and timeless, but I believe Uli's should have won. Her clothes were wearable and fun. They would appeal to women of various ages and body types. Jeffrey's collection was geared toward a vary narrow audience and very young. Michael's was disappointing . He is capable of much stronger work.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 10:06 PM
pinay wrote:
congratulations jeffrey. although i thought uli and michael would win, its no doubt that u deserved it. to laura, its true. "Your a bad mommy!!!!!!!!" She's probably just afraid of jeffrey's ability to beat her. Feel bad for you mom. that u have to grag somebody down for your own good. yes he used extra money for his works but he already decided to take out all the wigs from his collection w/c i think made the competition fair enough for others. Tim already said that there had been investigations of what had happened and what jeffrey did was all legal. so what else??? we all know that what we see in reality shows are also being edited. On their reunion, jeffrey already explained that what really happend between him and angela's mom we're not shown on tv and that it has been edited. jeffrey seems to be a good person. he managed to transform himself from being drunk, sober or alcoholic before to being a good father and good bf (hope u guys get married soon), and to being imaginative and versatile designer. i admire u jeff... keep it up... looking forward to your own shop...
posted on October 19, 2006 at 10:45 PM
Bravotvfan wrote:
Cann't believe Jeffrey won. The judges admitted that one dress of his was hideous. As far as critizing Laura for being one note, they rewarded Chloe last year for the same thing! Besides, her clothes were elegant. I figured Michael would win, because throughout the competition his designs were quite appealing. Unfortunately, his runway probably was a little let down, but admittedly he tried to grow a little. And Uli did grow and try to change, and her stuff was excellent! Beautiful clothes! She proved she could step up and be a little more than "the same dress." Between her and Jeffrey, Uli should have won. Was she robbed? Hard to say. I just have to believe that since Chloe already had a busines (her own boutique), and Jeffrey already has a business, they awarded people who are already somewhat established rather than going with someone who was not established with a no business. Jeffrey's stuff was not to anyone's taste I know of, and bordering, well, what did Laura say? Serious ugly. So much for taste. It's frightening, truly frightening.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 10:48 PM
m wrote:
Well Project Runway had 2 successful years and the 3rd what a total disaster. Please tell me who would wear the crap that Jeffrey designs? Innovative?!? Forgetting his obnoxious behavior, his style and designs are not worth the material. I really question his budget as well. At one point he states that he just happens to have another pair of leather pants. Did he provide the receipt for those pants as well? Totally off the mark with this one. Not sure if I want to continue watching after this season.
posted on October 19, 2006 at 10:52 PM
Dulcinea wrote:
Congratulations to Jeffrey and the prod