gary.e wrote:

Hi Gail: Does anyone on that show ever tell the Chefs to wear head covers. I,m not sure who Howie is sleeping with,but he sure seems to hang on. the thought of him and Hung being the last two standing , makes me sick.

posted on August 8, 2007 at 11:29 PM

Colin wrote:

Poor Sara N (so nice, so cute, so talented), but at least she's got the best parting shot so far about Howie being an a**hole. And here's a surprise, Howie cooked pork! I was amazed he didn't serve it up in his ice-cream dish. You are what you eat I guess.

posted on August 8, 2007 at 11:49 PM

NANCY SP. wrote:

I do think this challenge was a bit unfair to the women. Tre took off his shirt and worked in a t-shirt, but Sara and Casey had to work in high heels! And wearing low-cut tops is a problem, because you are constantly aware of it, and pulling things up, etc..

But it was still a fun show, and I think the judges had no choice but to send Sara or Howie home. I hoped it would be Howie. I don't think Sara is enough of a leader to win it all, but Howie does not play well with others, and cannot get along with anyone. He also cannot express himself to his teammates. Even Hung did better on teamwork this week.

I enjoy these blogs very much. Thank you.

posted on August 8, 2007 at 11:54 PM

Edwin wrote:

I'm wondering how hard it was for the judges not to throw both Sara N and Howie out the door; Howie seems to be totally incapable of anything vaguely resembling "teamwork," and he was at least as responsible for the poor showing of his team in the Aug 8 episode as was Sara.

I wonder how high the turnover is among the culinary staff at the restaurant where he's executive chef, and how that compares with the turnover of his competition. He seems like he would be an incredibly difficult person for whom to work, and a champion in the field of recrimination.

While all the chefs have proven themselves to be quite competent at finger-pointing, Howie actually seems to take more pleasure in it than anybody else.

I'm not going to spend all my time beating up Howie. I just wonder who would have gone had Sara been swapped with one of the men on the other team.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 12:04 AM

Charles Mudd wrote:

Gail - where were you during this episode? We missed you.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 12:05 AM

AnneM wrote:

I found the late night challenge to be particularly mean spirited.
It may have been fair to dismiss Sara N. but it was not fair to expect anyone to cook and work in high heels. The twist of showing up and then having to compete reminded me of a bad episode of Punked or Candid Camera. Come on, now.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 12:06 AM

AnneM wrote:

I found the late night challenge to be particularly mean spirited.
It may have been fair to dismiss Sara N. but it was not fair to expect anyone to cook and work in high heels. The twist of showing up and then having to compete reminded me of a bad episode of Punked or Candid Camera. Come on, now.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 12:07 AM

anne wrote:

Dear Daughter and I wondered if CJ could even
fit inside one of the food trailers!

posted on August 9, 2007 at 12:17 AM

Dominique wrote:

Haha...Tre does always get the BIGGEST cheese on his face after he wins!! I too was very satisfied with the outcome!! Good blog, and enjoy watching you on the show!!!

posted on August 9, 2007 at 12:24 AM

Mark wrote:

Gail, I wouldn't argue with what you said about Brian's dish: I wouldn't want to eat "slimy" food after an evening of partying. But having said that, I must say that I agree with his underlying logic: under the circumstances, it made sense to have a "cold bar" outside the trailer. If you agree with that, then what types of cold foods would you recommend for a latenight party menu?

posted on August 9, 2007 at 1:31 AM

paul wrote:

It looked as if they had judged on the food, Howie would have been eliminated because his cuban sandwiches were worse than Sarah's sliders. But because Howie made for better tv, he was not elimanated.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 2:21 AM

Sara wrote:

When I first got done with watching this week's episode, I couldn't help but be bitter about the judges' decision to send Sara N. home, rather than Howie. The reason for that was the fact that you judges have talked endlessly about not basing your decisions for each elimination challenge on any previous ones. This seemed pretty hypocritical to me, since before Sara N. was sent home, Tom stated that one of them (meaning Howie) was more cut out for the competition than the other, and it seemed to me that the reason Howie stayed was because he had proved his talents in previous challenges.
Reading your blog, a bit of my bitterness has subsided, because I do realize that Sara N.'s performance was lacking because she wasn't able to bounce back and get to work. However, it was still EXTREMELY disappointing because it's clear that the whole thing with "we don't take previous challenges into account for our decisions at judges' table," seems like a load of crap, because it's obvious that you only stand by that statement with certain people.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 2:24 AM

Saturn V wrote:

The show isn't as good when you're not on it, Gail and your blogs are my favorite. I enjoy the way you describe food, you really are an aficionado and I've learned a lot from what you've written in the last 3 seasons. You've made me stop and think about food in a new way and that's a lot of fun.

I loved this elimination challenge, it was creative and at first I thought the Orange Team had the advantage because their food actually sounded better to me. Too bad they didn't quite pull it off, but then, Howie is always a detriment.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 2:55 AM

Steve.R. wrote:

Gail, the producers pulled yet another disingenuous stunt tonight. Why on earth, except to make life more difficult for the contestants, would Padma deliberately LIE to them about having the night off, and setting them up for a fall. As people say, it's not about the food, it's about a reality show. I am getting sick of these stunts. The producers have done it no fewer than three times this season to date with mean-spirited "gotcha's":
1. The quickfire challenge at the welcome party. That was just tackly.
2. The cynical, "Oh, my, there's only going to be half the time we told you to cook for the telenovela." Tom's smirk was clear and the whole thing was obvious.
3. The outright lie in this episode about being off for the night, then being forced to run around in inappropriate clothing, etc. Don't tell me that "they should have been able to handle that." It may be true, but it's not clean.

Now, of course, the audience smells blood in the water and wants more heads. This is barbaric.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 3:16 AM

jake wrote:

Gail you always were one of my fave judges you see tom and padma seem to have gotten a bit high and mighty to do blogs it seems (or there really busy but you still seem increablely level headed)

In contestent terms Howie needs to leave however one of the teaser clips at the begining of the season (howie with a italia (think i spelt that right) shirt screaming at the poor cameraman) shows that untill that clip pops he's here to stay much to my chagrin

anyways good luck judgeing in the finale if you havn't shot it yet

posted on August 9, 2007 at 3:26 AM

glenn wrote:

Too bad for Sara. I can understand her being frustrated at working a roach coach instead of partying in Miami, and working with Howie probably doesn't help. I think his personality is part of his strategy, but it makes him look like a jerk. I liked seeing Tre pull out grits and shrimp for the win (with bacon) but isn't that South Carolina cooking, and not Texas?

posted on August 9, 2007 at 4:02 AM

Gopal Krishna wrote:

The elimination challenge was such BS. I felt nauseous and prepared to swear off Top Chef for life upon the realization that the contestants had been misled about their "night out". Top Chef is becoming My Big Fat Obnoxious Boss (Fox), or more accurately, a parody of itself. I don't watch the show to see people miserable and crying.

Unrelated, though also irritating, is how the reruns of Top Chef episodes are being re-edited. What's gone? Anthony Bourdain's invitation to Tre for late night yakitori and to get him "savage drunk", Clay's mentioning of his father's passing, Joey's tirade about one female contestant during a shopping scene, and probably more. Is this just to create more time for commercials or is something sinister going on? I am especially annoyed about the Bourdain cut, because it revealed a very charming aspect of his personality that made me want to find out more about him. Now I am a fan and watch his show on the Travel Channel religiously. Perhaps if I had not heard those words, I might not have taken an interest and would have been deprived of his cultural and culinary critiques.

What's going on Bravo? You also need to address judging mistakes that are made and aired on TV, not just on the web site. For instance, the whole lobster/cholesterol issue that was grossly blown out of proportion. Oh, and what about Micah's supposed South African roots? Born and raised in the US? (Source: Amuse-Biatch) Where's the due diligence?

posted on August 9, 2007 at 4:09 AM

Bonny wrote:

I wish you were always at the Judge's Table. Ted's OK but you have such a great depth of knowledge and you never seem to be trying to steal the limelight from the food or the chefs with corny, boring, far less than witty remarks. Thanks!

posted on August 9, 2007 at 4:23 AM

Jeff wrote:

Gail, before you make light of Sarah's difficulty with the challenge, you should at least watch her exit interview first. She talked about how, in the first 3 minutes of the challenge, she and Casey were verbally attacked by a clubgoer. This 'challenge' tipped the scales against her and Casey far more than it did for the other contestants. Again, you need to watch her interview to understand her forgivable anger and why she was demoralized. Perhaps if you were present at the challenge you might have been less dismissive of her feelings (maybe) but Padma was there, so she has no excuse. This challenge would have been just as interesting if they were not fooled and manipulated by the 'trick'. I for one did not feel entertained by that trick - I felt just as disgusted as they must have felt.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 8:05 AM

Corrine Puntel wrote:

For the record...See ya Sara! Well now that we can get past all of her whining and find out who the next Top Chef is going to be . I can not wait for next weds.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 8:20 AM

Aline wrote:

Frankly, I'm shocked that none of the chefs or judges or Top Chef staff realized the biggest problem with the women's clothes - SAFETY. There's a reason chefs where those silly jackets and closed-toe, sturdy, un-heeled shoes in the kitchen. Falling knives, splattering hot liquids, the non-slip mats with holes in them, and even just the regular rushing around in a tight space is inherently dangerous. Maybe if one of the ladies had lost a toe, burnt their breasts, or twisted an ankle, you wouldn't think they were being so silly complaining about their attire. Or perhaps you think that nothing says "whiny" like a trip to the hospital.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 8:34 AM

Pam Eldana wrote:

Last night's elimination challenge came down to Sara N. and Howie. Based on this challenge alone, I would think that Howie would have been the one to pack his knifes, not Sara. But with a couple of wins under his belt, Howie has a better track record. It seems that perhaps the judges take all things into account when letting a contestant go. In my opinion, Howie IS a bulldog and a jerk. I would not eat anything he has prepared for fear that he has accidentally added an 'extra' ingredient - the sweat off his forehead! Ah-Ha! Maybe that's the secret to his two wins (and near wins).

posted on August 9, 2007 at 9:18 AM

rbovaboy wrote:

Hey Gail, missed you last night. There was so much going on in this episode. The judges have all said in the past that judging can go very late. Do you know if the judging in this episode happened right after the late night snacks were all handed out? Everyone looked a little tired so I was wondering if it happened at like 5am.

I know the women should have sucked it up and not complained about what they were wearing, but wouldn't running around in high heels create a hazard for them? And taking them off to work in bare feet wouldn't help either. I just kept thinking how rough that must have been.

And the foods I would have avoided after a night drinking were items at the raw bar, CJ's ceviche tacos and I don't think the milkshakes would have been good at that time of day.

Send love to Ted and hope to see you next week!

posted on August 9, 2007 at 10:17 AM

Jennifer wrote:

My partner and I were stunned that Howie was still in the running last night. Not only does his attitude suck but can he make anything besides PORK!?

Pork n' slaw, pork n' applesauce, pork sandwiches...

One other thing, Casey and Sara... "Oh please..." is all I have to say. Even watching from home I knew they were not going out and that were going to be cooking. Give me a break. Like we are really going to have an episode of Top Chef with all the chefs partying and getting down. What is this? The Real World?
Have the chefs ever been allowed to relax and go out on the other seasons? NO! It was so obvious that they were messing with them. Please... duh!

posted on August 9, 2007 at 10:53 AM

Justin White wrote:

I would just like to say with Howies attitude the past few "Team Challenges" I was totally disappointed he wasn't going home. Just look at the cubans he provided even the customers were not happy let alone the judges. I hope after the decision to send Sara home that he realizes he needs to be a better "team" sport. Other than that I totally love this show. Keep up the good work!!!!

posted on August 9, 2007 at 10:56 AM

Jan wrote:

I was upset with last night's outcome. Who does Howie think he is? He should have been the one to go not Sara. I think you are keeping him on just because of his nastiness. He has not shown me that he is worth keeping. You could clearly see that he wanted to take charge of the team and then he failed, failed, failed. He wouldn't even listen to Sara, he just wants to have his own way all the time. He was also the downfall last week, I don't know why you are keeping him. I hope that he is eliminated soon.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 11:10 AM

Joanie wrote:

Gail:
You hit the nail on the head. Your comments echoed verbatum those I made to my husband at the beginning of the elimination challenge. After a night of drinking, all most people want is "salty, greasy, fatty foods to coat our stomachs and sop up the alcohol." Ditto on your comments about slimy foods, GAG!

I, once again, am surprised that the contestants were caught off guard by the changeup in plans. As has been said before, any contestant desirous of being on TC would be insane not to have watched every episode of previous shows. I found Sara's and Casey's remarks about their clothes lame. I've done dinner parties for a hundred in 4 inch heals and an evening gown. While in the kitchen you kick off the heals and throw on an apron. The whole argument about the emotional problems these women suffered over their dissappointment in the change of plans and their inability to handle cooking dressed up, well, let's just say I was embarrassed for them.

Brian's "barker" routine was brilliant and certainly contributed to the desirability of eating at their station (keep the party going), the food aside.

Sending Sara home was the correct decision. As for Howie, his days on numbered.

I always love your comments. Thanks.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 11:12 AM

Mistica wrote:

This elimination round was a dirty, rotten trick. It would have been a good one if the contestants had not been misled and abused (i.e. forced to work in high heels). This show is not Survivor or Amazing Race...it's about professionals competing with other professionals. The producers or judges or whomever made the decision did not behave professionally last night. The guys were able to bounce back easier because they hadn't spent hours on hair and make-up and weren't wearing high heels. Casey was right to say that it was demoralizing. I don't care if chef's are supposed to "rise to the occasion" no matter the occasion, this was not fair! Sara did not perform well and it probably was her time to go, but Howie is an ass and I'm ready to see him go. I am also sick (literally) of watching his sweat drip into the food. Get this guy a headband!!!

posted on August 9, 2007 at 11:20 AM

kyle wrote:

Gail, how come u alternate episodes this season?

posted on August 9, 2007 at 11:47 AM

gary.e wrote:

Gail: what a bad joke to pull on the chefs, but they should have known that there was a trap door waiting for them. the black team did very well due to Brian leading them into a party like mood and it showed in there performance, sorry Sara N. had to go I thought Sweat Hog Howie should have gone, I was surprised that Hung was a team player doing as good as he did.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 12:47 PM

FanFare wrote:

Hi Gail,

I am surprised by your revelation, that after taping a show where you have consumed copious amounts of the cheftestants' dishes, that you (judges) are still hungry. That is an interesting tidbit.

I agee with your assessment that the black team rose to the occasion, by getting over their disappointment and going with the groove. They looked as though they had fun (especially Tre who was laughing while preparing his dish).

Although the orange team ladies were uncomfortable wearing their low cut tops (I would be while cooking over a grease splattering surface), once again - it was Howie who could not play nice with the other kids in his neighborhood. He should have been given the gate in addition to Sara N. His overbearing manner and wrongly prepared Cuban sammy was a large part of the loss.
BTW: can't that guy cook anything else besides pork?

posted on August 9, 2007 at 2:40 PM

ollie wrote:

Gail, thank you for blogging on time. I hope you are absent less in future TCs, because I appreciate your comments about the food. I agree that the women should have put aside their distress about their attire and gotten down to business -- putting out great food. Sara N seems to have decided from the get go that she wasn't going to play in this game. She deserved to go. I don't think howie deserves the grief he gets. Casey didn't take Sara to task -- nor did cj. Why should howie get all the blame? Ithink his big personality makes him a target -- often not warrented.
Hope to see more of you, gail -- note to the editors: more gail and other judges' comments and less of the host padma's comments. The producers have given her so much time -- time that detracts from bona fide chef comments and discussions about how the food was prepared -- stuff we foodies are hungry to hear more of. And get her off the judges' table.
Love you

posted on August 9, 2007 at 2:49 PM

denise wrote:

I am not one of those women who choose to wear uncomfortable shoes or go all out in my outfits when I dress up for a night of partying, however the majority of women do. I cannot help but think that this lie that was told to the contestants put the women in a compromising situation, and the men were not affected in the same way. If the playing field is to be leveled and contestants are to be judged on their abilities in the kitchen, the way this particular elimination challenge was presented was unfair to the women and most anyone should have been able to tell in advance that the women were "targeted" because of their mind-set regarding going out and preparing for going out, as opposed to working.

I was not surprised to see a woman leave in the end, and as Ted mentions in his blog, the kitchen and cheffing industry is still mostly male...and so is Hollywood for that matter. I think this was done on purpose to target the women and see how THEY would handle themselves, and the woman who performed the worst would go.

I'm quite surprised that the women involved on the show, like Padma, Gail, LeeAnn and some of the producers didn't see this lie as passive-aggressive sexism...which is what it was.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 3:54 PM

Barbara wrote:

I love Gail and her blog rocks!!!! This episode is one of my favorites so far this season and it is interesting to hear what the judges think.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 4:46 PM

bets wrote:

I kept thinking of Project Runway's Jeffrey, who hung back and said "It's a trick. It's not going to be a wonderful cocktail party," when everyone was getting ready to go out. Heck, the first challenge was at their welcoming reception! What were they thinking??

Howie's 'hole-ishness is starting to get a little old. Let's see, crabs about Casey, Sara, Sara, and had rough spots with everyone else. He might make good TV, but he's not THAT interesting.

It does surprise me that no one on Team Orange was a good huckster. If you can make people laugh, a wait is tolerable!

posted on August 9, 2007 at 5:07 PM

Philip wrote:

this was a great challenge, the ultimate surprised. I loved seeing the looks on their faces when they realized what was happening, it was priceless. Overall, I was impressed with the way that the chefs handled the situation.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 5:40 PM

Addison DeWitt wrote:

Easy for you to talk: how would you like to be frying up hamburgers in stilletto heels with Howie sweating and cussing in a tiny portable and hot kitchen?
That was a dirty trick to pull on those chefs, in particular, the female chefs.
Howie, as a partner, seems to be the grim reaper for those forced to work with him.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 5:42 PM

Pelham wrote:

Gail,

You are the reason I watch this show. Could you be any more cute. I love the fact you are truelly a foodie at heart. I think your talent for letting the viewer learn more about food and inform us with your insight is a great asset to the show. If you are ever in DC let me know.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 6:22 PM

Daphne L. Easter wrote:

You people are all silly? I cook in high heels, make up, hair done, nice outfit all the time, be it if I have just gotten in from work and start dinner or if I am entertaining and get dressed before I cook and guests arrive. And I love the fact that I can! As a matter of fact, my family and friends are always amazed that I always have my heels on in the kitchen!!!! I can take the heat and the heels!!!!!

posted on August 9, 2007 at 7:40 PM

Kevin wrote:

From what we saw, Casey and CJ didn't think Sara's participation was bad enough that it need mentioning. I'm sure if you asked them about Howie's. Too dry and big doughy mess on the wrong bread versus too little salt, thin shakes and too few burgers? I'd put them equal on that footing.

However, let's not forget that Miami is Howie's turf, so how is it possible that they didn't do better? You can tell when he goes through the menu that he's dismissive of the ideas of others. He's not particularly versatile in what he makes. I'm surprised he didn't put pork with pasta last time. If someone shouldn't stick just to seafood as Tom noted (seafood is much more versatile than pork given that seafood includes many things... pork, not so much).

Sara WAS whiny after she was attacked by Howie, evidence that Howie doesn't know what a team is. He doesn't know how to effectively manage or work with others. TC is about more than cooking. If you're TC, you'll have people under you that need to respect you and feel like you represent them. Howie doesn't do that.

Take away past challenges and judge based on this one: Howie was more at fault than Sara. Look at this challenge along with others: Howie is ineffective as a team member.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 9:00 PM

Kathi wrote:

Gail,

I have the highest respect for your assessments. It's too bad you weren't a judge last night. Perhaps the dynamic would have been much different at the judge's table. I absolutely knew ahead of time that the show would find an excuse to send a woman home instead of whatever man deserved it more but I was still stunned when it actually happened. I'm sorry to say that I am now convinced that this show is biased against women. The producers should know that there are many long-time viewers who really don't watch this show for the "personalities." We watch it to learn about top-notch cooking and to see how different chefs respond to different challenges in terms of their culinary choices. If being a top chef really is all about macho display, that would explain why so many expensive meals I've had in high end restaurants have been incredibly mediocre.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 9:41 PM

kls wrote:

i am disappointed (not season two disappointed, but disappointed nonetheless) that the top chef production would design a challenge so overtly sexist. for that reason alone howie - whom i loved until last night - should have been the one to go home. or at least, it could have been a double elimination. sarah was no more to blame for the failure of their team, and she had the added discomfort of having to perform her task in very uncomfortable attire. we all know that the kitchen is a sexist place and that any woman has to work far harder than any man for credibility and respect.

i'm very sad that top chef doesn't have a problem promoting such sexism.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 9:48 PM

Jill wrote:

How can they serve the food Howie cooks on Top Chef to the unsuspecting public? He sweats profusely into the plates. It's horrible. I hope to see him with a sweat band in the next episode. He can get one at Nike or any athletic store. He has a real sweaty head. Can they fix it?

posted on August 9, 2007 at 10:26 PM

BigJohn wrote:

Gail, it has already been said, but you are easy on the eyes! We see too much of Padma and too little of you and your articulate commentary. This Elimination round aired on 8/8/07 was terrible. Whoever set up the Chefs with this "bait and switch" theme is a jerk. Who do we blame here, Bravo, the producers, Padma and Tom??? How would the judges feel if we told them to go to sleep, and then wake them up at 2am and ask them to cook in their pajamas or underwear? Oh, and whoever's food sucks, they're going home. Top Chef season one had alot of episodes that showed "front of the house" situations and how Chefs work to achieve marketed results. I see that next week we will get something like that, but Top Chef needs to stick to challenges that stretch the mind, and show what it is like for people who want to further themselves as professionals in the food industry.

posted on August 9, 2007 at 11:18 PM

Henry Barrera wrote:

Gail,
You are my favorite judge on Top Chef because you are a true foodie and you speak from the heart. You aren't afraid to tell the truth and you give good feedback to the contestants. I really liked this episode I think everyone has to realize sometimes life hands you a curve ball and you will be remembered for how you deal with it. I think Sara was a great person but I agree with her comments in the end she wasn't competitive enough for Top Chef.

posted on August 10, 2007 at 12:29 AM

CN wrote:

Sara is "spot on," as the show might say:

"... the fact that you judges have talked endlessly about not basing your decisions for each elimination challenge on any previous ones. This seemed pretty hypocritical to me, since before Sara N. was sent home, Tom stated that one of them (meaning Howie) was more cut out for the competition than the other, and it seemed to me that the reason Howie stayed was because he had proved his talents in previous challenges. "

the way the episode was cut, it seemed the clientele gave sara n's dish superlative remarks (understanding we were given a small sampling). i actually don't doubt that in the end, "her spirit wasn't in it," as they say, but by what was shown on TV, her food was *better* (as judged NOT by me, or the audience, neither of whom ate the food, but the people WHO WERE THERE and ATE THE FOOD) than howie's on this night of the competition. this isn't to say she is a better cook (indeed, it's strange how so many ppl think this show is about who is the better cook)--but on that night, it seemed like she cooked the better food, hence it was somewhat surprising that howie did not go home. the way the episode was cut... it made it appear as if the judges were giving him a second chance b/c they saw potential in him that they don't in sara.

posted on August 10, 2007 at 12:43 AM

CoCo wrote:

I totally agree! Can the chef's please chip in and buy Howie a headband. The thought of one sweaty droplet being served to anyone expecting fine dining is repulsive! And the camera man always catches that one ball of sweat hanging of his nose! Then it drops, where??? Our imaginations are left to wonder. The only people that wouldn't care are the same people he served in the last challenge, drunken party-goers who could care less what the food taste like, all they heard was... free food! And I liked Sara, she was so sweet. But I guess Top Chef's can't be sweet. They have to be jerks (and that's being nice) like Howie and Joey! Howie, if anyone heard you speak to a woman like that in L.A. straight or gay, they'd kick your... you get the picture! If it were up to my panel of judges, he would have been sent packin' with his cousin Joey! I have no doubt he can cook, but he just makes me want to hurl! I know who the top two should be! They have the best attitude (thus far) and score card... an no its not you Hung... Ho... whatever! Granted, you may know a thing or two about cooking... cauliflower in ice cream??? Dude!!! And can someone give you- know-who a steak! You're on a cooking show for Pete's sake! Not America's Top Model! A little junk in your trunk is a good thing now!
Ok, said enough, I love the show, keep up the good work! CoCo

posted on August 10, 2007 at 12:59 AM

austingal wrote:

Howie gets another pass? Sara N.’s sliders seemed to be more liked than his Cuban sandwiches (by both the judges and the customers), so why does he get through yet again? Although he has had two elimination wins, he has been at the bottom almost every time otherwise. How many times does this guy have to be at the bottom before the judges realize that he can’t get along with others, is inconsistent, and cracks under pressure? Hello, what are the characteristics of a Top Chef supposed to be? Howie exemplifies the antithesis of all of them. And can he do anything besides pork? Sheesh.

I am so glad Tre won another challenge. He is so cool, calm and collected, and obviously so talented as well. I'd like to see Howie and Hung ousted soon, neither of them are capable of the leadership the title of Top Chef denotes. Tre, Brian and CJ, and possibly Dale, seem to have the culinary talent blended with the right qualities a true Top Chef should have.

posted on August 10, 2007 at 1:29 AM

jimmy wrote:

Greetings,

Okay people this is a contest. If you can't roll with the punches then you go home. Things happen in life and you don't get to have things your way most of the time. All the contestants should have known that things are not always what they seem to be.
To all those people who are complaining about Howie's sweating into the food, there is nothing that can be done about it now because the shows are already taped and edited. I'm sure Howie has been told about by now , so enough. Please
jimmy

posted on August 10, 2007 at 2:46 AM

Kathy wrote:

Had to respond to someone comment that Padma lied to the contestants, listen carefully, she never said they weren't going to have the elimination challenge or the night off. She said they were off the hook FOR NOW and that they were going to participate in the night life. They should have known better. There is a long list of what is and isn't allowed and going out partying is definately NOT ALLOWED. They should have taken her comments with a grain of salt....I knew they were going to have to do something just wasn't sure what It was. Sara needed to let go her disappointment and do her job. She wasn't able to and that is why she was sent home. And I believe what Tom C meant when he said one was more cut out for the competition than the other. Pig though he may be, Howie did his job and he did tell Sara not to add ice to a milkshake, HELLO, I am not a chef but I know a milkshake is icecream and milk, maybe a little vanilla flavoring if you have it. Come on.

Sara needed to go and I bet Howie will be gone soon if he doesn't learn how to work with others. Next weeks restaurant challenge may just be his downfall..we'll see.

posted on August 10, 2007 at 12:08 PM

Lesley wrote:

Dear Gail,

As much as I understand the difficulty of maintaining individual blogs in light of every day responsibilities, the main reason I enjoyed reading the judges' blogs was to get a better insight into their thinking while they are involved in the judging process. Reading the blogs of guest judges who merely watch the program on television is just not the same.

I am so happy that Tre won! His recipe for cheesy grits with shrimp wrapped in bacon sounds so amzing I am willing to break my diet to give it a try! LOL! As for Sara N's and Casey's complaining about having to cook and run around the store in heels and low cut blouses (and the bloggers who feel their pain and wish to make this a gender issue), may I remind people that there are THREE women in this competition and Sara Mair was the only woman on the Black team? She too was wearing heels and a low cut blouse (and she showed more cleavage than Sara N. and Casey by the way) and managed to do her job.

Also, may I remind folks that before they were blind-sided with the elimination challenge, everyone thought they were going to spend a night on the town DANCING and club hopping, including Casey and Sara N, which means they were going to be spending the majority of their time on their feet! So let me get this straight: Sara N. and Casey had no problem wearing high heels to go dancing and/or club hopping (and were willing to deal with the possibility that they may have to stand in line, possibly not get a table, and maybe get their feet stepped on while moving through the club's crowd) but had problems standing on their feet cooking and/or running around the supermarket??? Come on!!

posted on August 10, 2007 at 12:09 PM

shan72 wrote:

I like most people responding to this past wensdays show, fear that Howie or Hung will be one of the last two standing if not both of them. It seems that every season the biggest jerk is left till the end to make for good T.V, and while dram may equal ratings, the competition between two comrades can be just as vicious when a BIG WIN is on the line. I hope the executive producers will keep this in mind this season. Also, I lOVE Tom and I hope he stays grounded and not become high and mighty in his role on the show, he, Gail and Padma are a great formula that should not be changed.

posted on August 10, 2007 at 12:23 PM

chris wrote:

I understand that this is a show that continues based on ratings, but I thought it was a little degrading for Casey and Sara. They should have been allowed to to feel a little more comfortable in what they were wearing. The guys didn't have this problem. As for the drunk who made a pass at Sara, I hope he was handled apporopritely by the show. That is "Sexual Harassment"! I felt bad for Sara when I heard what she said. No person deserves to be treated that way. CJ should have been more of a leader in this team challenge! He was not! Casey was playing it safe! Howie was being himself and trying to be a leader to this team.

posted on August 10, 2007 at 12:25 PM

KAREN wrote:

Someone made a comment about CJ height.
How tall is he? 6'8"? 6'9"? Just curious.

posted on August 10, 2007 at 1:13 PM

Irena wrote:

Definetely, twist is a "must" for the reality show, but why wouldn't do it the other way around? Promise some hardship, some boring night and then surprise the contestants with either night out or some other kind of fun? What do you think, Gail? I just don't like to see people being upset...

posted on August 10, 2007 at 4:03 PM

Edwin wrote:

To add something to Aline's comments: my wife's cousin was badly burned, and permanently scarred due to an accident in a restaurant. She slipped on a wet floor while carrying a kettle full of boiling-hot food. She got third-degree burns on her thighs.

My father, about 30 years ago, was teaching women machine shop skills. In one session, some of the women wore low-cut blouses (it was summer, and machine shops were not air conditioned). The machines scattered hot, very sharp, metal chips into their cleavages. Next class, they all came in with long pants, closed-toe shoes, and no cleavage.

The women had a justified complaint. The show should have provided a change of clothes.

posted on August 10, 2007 at 5:08 PM

Jade wrote:

I agree with many people on this blog that this show is very unfair to these chefs. Don't lie to them, to have their expectation set up for the fun then it turned them to the hell kitchen. Men don't understand us women. I would rather to have Tom or another male judge (his name???) wear high heels and low cut and walk 1 mile in the super market to feel the pain. In addition, these chefs' mind set weren't on cooking. I gave them a lot of credit to come up with such wonderful snack food. The show needs to pay attention to these chefs' psychological needs. Play fair, play a nice surprise can win a lot of views and as well as make the chefs happy. This suprise was really not very well planned. Our viewers felt the pain for all of them. It's a mess. Many of us do not care too much of Padma, now she looks like a perfect lier and she makes the show looks cheap.

posted on August 10, 2007 at 5:08 PM

Jade wrote:

I don't agree with one poster who said this show targeted on eliminating women. I think this show was poorly planned. It made every one frustrated and felt the pain for the chefs. It was very unfortunate that women were affected because the way they dressed and the working condition was very poor. Remember these folks are professional chefs. If the show's goal is to trick them, that was really unfair to put them on the spot. I'd rather see more quality prepared food with plenty of time given.

posted on August 10, 2007 at 5:36 PM

Avid fan wrote:

I also thought it was mean-spirited to get the contestants hopes up about a night off and then throw a challenge at them. Shame on your producers! How cheesy! It was unfair to the women to make them cook in heels—and it was mean to make everyone ruin their nice clothes in the roach coach. I expect better from Top Chef.

posted on August 10, 2007 at 5:57 PM

Chris wrote:

Howie is playing the judges and the other contestants. It's more a game of elimination with him then a cooking contest. This last contest really showed it, his pork sandwich seemed the least favorite food but he was able to bully Sara into silence so he was able to eliminate one more potential competitor. This strategy can't go on forever. Also I think the challenge was unfair to the women, I guess they shouldn't try dressing up feminine just in case you guys pull a fast one. I agreed with Sara's comments.

posted on August 10, 2007 at 8:36 PM

Ann wrote:

Will someone PLEASE give Howie a bandana for his head!!! If I have to watch one more drop of sweat fall in his food, I think I will vomit! I cannot believe that his sweating is ok with the people who have to taste his food! I would decline if I were a judge. Please get him something!

posted on August 10, 2007 at 10:50 PM

Kirsten wrote:

Gail,
From the editted program, it appears Tom C. makes his descisions (or at the very least is completely influenced) long before he has tasted the food.
From his kitchen walk-throughs- canned artichokes come up as a red flag in the kitchen and bite them in the end, Hung's comments on the frozen dinner come in to play in the final descisions... yadda yadda.
It seems wildly unfair to me. He does not seem to be adding any mentoring or value to his kitchen visits, and I think they should stop. They make his look malicious and desperate for a point of view.
Thanks.

posted on August 11, 2007 at 1:57 AM

T wrote:

Hi Gail. I'm wondering why the chefs were so suprised by the elimination challenge. It has been consistently reported that they have no outside contact; no papers, phones, visitors, etc. So why would the producers suddenly allow them to go clubbing where all sorts of leaks would occur? Did they miss this observation because they are so desperate for interaction with the outside world?

posted on August 11, 2007 at 4:32 AM

Amy Palmer wrote:

This may not be PC, but I am so grossed out watching Howie perspire into his dishes every week to the point that I ready to support another Board of Health reg to control that for all chefs!

I remember the day when everyone (especially the waitresses) had to wear hairnets. A hair in my food is difficult to ingest and nearly impossible to digest, but who wants to metabolize your chef's bodily fluids?!!

All of you, if you are dripping, put on a sweat band --or two!!

posted on August 11, 2007 at 1:27 PM

Barb wrote:

Okay folks...If you couldn't see this coming, you are not paying attention. The Latin Lunch episode you could see they were going to shorten the time to cook. Here, it was obvious they were going to get there and cook. The chefs should realize they are not allowed contact with the outside and now all of a sudden they are going to be let out to a nightclub. A little common sense would come about and say, I may have to cook there. The ladies choose to wear revealing clothes out. Maybe they should rethink their attire. Just because they were going to a club did not mean that they had to be showing so much skin. I like the show and the twists they put in. I was sorry to see Sara go, but she has not been shown much on tv. Howie makes for good tv and they will keep him around for that reason. We cannot forget the producers have input on who stays and who goes home. Keep watching and see what the next twist will be!

posted on August 11, 2007 at 3:25 PM

Amy Elaine wrote:

I don't mind the stunt Bravo pulled this evening, but the fact that it was a stunt that disadvantaged one group at the expense of the other and, even more to the point, that none of the judges had a problem with it really disappointed me and at the same time made me realize why women have such a hard time in this business even when they diplomatically point out the unfairness of something. I am surprised about how dismissive you are toward these concerns in your post. It was unfair and sexist to make the women cook in low cut blouses (esp while cameras were around) and it was unsafe to make them cook sleeveless (when they have not chosen to do so in other episodes when allowed to dress as they would to protect themselves) and unsafe to make them cook in high heels. It was especially sexist that no one tooks these complaints seriously. Kitchens are dangerous places and the women who cook in them are entitled to be safe and they are entitled to be treated as professionals and at least wear what makes them feel safe and comfortable in the kitchen. Fine surprise them, but then give them the clothes and shoes to work. Sheeesh!

posted on August 11, 2007 at 5:41 PM

IRIS wrote:

gail... i agree with your comment on the show. the contestants should not be surprised that they would be put on the spot. its a competition!

so... i too agree with sara being the one to go. take off your shoes for comfot and put your apron on to cover your boobs... which could have been used to attract the customers like brian used his hottiness.

i was also very pleased with tre winning. his dish is something i would have wanted after a night of dancing and drinking. besides looking delicious ... it looked like it was prepared by a high end restaurant and not a lunch truck.

now howie... gail... please...hygene... doesnt it count for anything?

considering howie is from miami... he doesnt know what a media noche consists of. i am cuban... i know and what he made was NOT a media noche. but... for the most part... he seems to be a pretty talented chef.

the sweating though... should be addressed if you guys are going to keep him. he should be required to wear a terrycloth headband. a chef's hat i dont think will do the job with all his waterworks.

considering his being an a**hole... and all the controversy over him... it would not be a good move to be rid of him. the more the controversy ... the more viewers... the more comments... PRICELESS!!!

btw... is brian available??? handsome and he can cook... OMG!

posted on August 11, 2007 at 7:33 PM

bjwells wrote:

We all need to understand that this show is taped and asking that Howie wear a bandana is useless. Now, as far as the episodes go, I think everyone is right, Howie is a butt-head and I think that they keep him on because of what they think is good television. What I wish, since I do like watching TC, is that they (judges and producers) would not accept unacceptable behavior and not always allow persons who are rude and ungly to continue on the show. Howie was just as bad as Sara. Sara has the sweetest personality. I do believe that she should have snapped out of her mood and cook to her best abilities but it is difficult working with people who are just plain ungly. As per the comments that we were allowed to watch, Sara's dish was well received and his wasn't. But who knows, maybe the comments that we didn't were more against Sara. Howie gets into with everyone. How can he think that he is leading anyone to the promised land as he said. In every team challenge, he has taken control and been bullheaded, not listened and been on the bottom. So, how in the world does he think that he is such a good leader? I am so glad that Tre has won 3 challenges so far. His meek demeanor is really nice. It shows that you don't have to be a bully in order to succeed. Harold also had a good attitude and was respectful of everyone. I really hope that Howie was eliminated during the next challenge.

posted on August 11, 2007 at 7:58 PM

Tokyoite wrote:

Gail, love your comments and insights. Keep up the great job.

I am surprised that everyone bought into the idea that they would have the night off. If it is too good to be true, it just can't be. Unless of course you are Dale and you do actually get the evening off. (Go Dale, Go Dale!)

Can not wait for Howie to get voted off the show - we are all waiting for it. Sending him home earlier than Sara would have really made this a competition. Or, perhaps you could have sent both Sara and Howie home. Now THAT would have made for real drama, and put everyone on top of their game for the future eliminations.

posted on August 11, 2007 at 10:17 PM

michael wrote:

Hi Gail!! :)

It would've been great to see what you and Tom got to try out at the guest judge's place.

We definitely need more of you on the show!

Michael

posted on August 11, 2007 at 11:02 PM

Lei T wrote:

Sara seems really sweet, but I was a little surprised that she totally blamed Howie. I know that he first brought up that she was a little slow in the kitchen, but we all remember in the first episode Howie was criticized by Joey for the exact same thing. Joey did to Howie what Howie was doing to Sara. Howie was criticized for not being fast enough by Joey and the judges so he improved and picked up his speed. I think because his team members do not like him that they might be using him as a scapegoat. When the whole team was discussing the menu, Sara turned to CJ and Casey when she suggested falafels. She was not looking at Howie. It was CJ (and Casey) who did not listen to Sara (if you watch the rerun). Sara looked to them and they did not listen. CJ said something about fries being too common. She was not even looking at Howie when she suggested falafels. But when Howie mentioned she was slow, she got so upset, the same as when Howie got so upset at Joey when he mentioned to the judges that Howie should go for not putting the frog legs on the plate. Howie does need to calm down a little with his dictator type of appoach. Perhaps allow the other team members to talk. But in this particular episode, CJ and Casey chose to listen to Howie (Casey probably was tired of fighting with him last time she was on his team and learned to talk a little more aggressively...I noticed). Poor Sara was the only one who did not know how to deal with his aggressive way of talking and was left with no one listening to her. She does seem like a really nice person and should just focus on her strong points and not let Howie get to her. Howie was right about the milkshakes though. Sara was probably thinking about smoothies. Smoothies have Ice, but milkshakes are not smoothies. Milkshakes are pure Ice cream and milk, the more cream, the better...can't put ice in milkshakes because it will thin out the shake and make it Ice Milk instead of creamy. She must have been thinking smoothies, not milkshakes. She probably should have just done her own thing if she did not feel comfortable making his food. She should just put this whole thing behind her and focus on cooking what makes her happy. Afterall, her personality is too pleasant for this mean competition (no one should have to ever run around cooking in heels...kind of abusive don't ya think?)

posted on August 12, 2007 at 4:22 AM

dave wrote:

gail, this episode would've been so much better if you were in it! please clear your schedule 'cause you are an integral part to the show, it's success, and my enjoyment of it and every episode you haven't been on has simply been ok tv, not great tv. missed ya babe... oh well... there's always next week!!

posted on August 12, 2007 at 10:42 AM

kim wrote:

does no one from the show actually read these ever? i've seen literally dozens of comments that Howie's sweating is disgusting to people watching including a few comments that folks can no longer eat out comfortably since watching him. I think that there is a sufficient number of the same comments to take them to the producers and let them know how people feel

posted on August 12, 2007 at 3:13 PM

Kas wrote:

Gail, I wish you were there more often, the judging seems a bit more competent when your on the panel.

I totaly disagree with Sara going home, if you like her or not it wasnt how the judging was supposed to go and I will quote chef Tom in an interview he gave on MSNBC, he said in response to a question about Sam Talbot going home early.

Question:
Last season, some viewers were disappointed that Sam Talbot, who emerged as a fan favorite, didn't make it to the finals. How much of the decision to cut him was based on cooking alone, versus a desire to play up the seasonlong rivalry between the two finalists, winner Ilan Hall and runner-up Marcel Vigneron?

ANSWER:
None at all. When I signed up for this show, it was very important to me that the producers stay out of that process. They are not involved in who wins and who loses at all. They're there, there's a little disclaimer we put up at the end of each show to keep from getting sued. They give us freedom to choose whoever we want to choose. Look, Sam screwed up. His food wasn't as good as Marcel's or Ilan's that day. This isn't a cumulative event.

Howie had the worst food there and it was HIS SANBOX they were playing in. This shoulda been a gimme for him, he should have been yawning while cranking it out instead of sweating!

For those of you who dissmissed Casey and Sarah's comments about thier attire you are missing the point. Casey said it plainly when she told the judges that this was inappropriate, she didnt even let her staff see her in that way. She is a professional chef and if you read the message board the 'sophisticated' bravo audiance has reduced itself to juvinle comments about Sarah's anatomy. The comments that they should've gone barefoot, sucked it up, used thier sexy selves to shill food are all just... so out there. Donald Trump hasnt sunk that low. Barefoot in a kitchen? Right, maybe Betty Crocker waltzing around her kitchen singing aria's and banging out the perfect dinner for a hundred can do that but in real kitchens things get dropped, you know like knives, glasswear. Oddly enough the floor is where the grease ends up from the stove. Skating anyone? Oh and here girls, just take these aprons and sling up those puppies so they dont get burnt...and dont mind the melting makup or the hairspray, or the hose and the heals... dont be such a girlie girl. Oh and that little bit of sexual harrasement, you know the part about the male customers going into the roach coach for a go with ya, dont mind that, we like to see how much you can actually take.

Every woman who watched this show should have been outraged both for those women and the not so subtle message that it was sending.

This competition was sexist, biased and specificaly designed to put the female chefs in just such a situation to titilate the viewers and so far its certainly brought out the junior high crowd. It was a blatent message that girls dont belong in the kitchen. (unless thier barefooted).

posted on August 13, 2007 at 5:02 PM

Jade wrote:

Gail, this show has a strong emphasize on team work, leadership, decision making and quick fire. I am wondering when the producers selected the chefs, did they screen these criteria? It seems when the judges evaluate them, team work played some importance. To me, all of them are nice people, but when they are put into a team, you could tell their true color. I understand it could add some drama and spice to the show, but soon enough, person like Howie could make the show look a mess. It truly affects chefs cooking and emotions. In turn, it creates a lot of variables for a fair judgment. Especially it's so unfair to those women who teamed up with Howie. Teamwork for Howie means, "Every one team up and shut up, do what I say"... It would be interesting to see Howie teams up with Tre. Please ask Howie to take care of his sweat.

In addition, Tom needs to get some culture clues when he asked Hung to be more assertive. Asian American children are taught to keep harmony when conflicts occur. A typical cultural example is Hung "gave up" on his idea when he knew "exactly what to do with their frozen food" and Joey did not agree with him. So he deferred to Joey. I could see the same thing happened with Sara H. I can also see Sara M deferring to Howie. Sara H's exit comment mentioned about being an A**H***. To me, she may mean to be assertive enough to stand up for your own idea (I hope I could read her mind, I might be wrong). This is not what Asian culture teaches them when these young people grew up.

I'd rather see some individual work which brings each chef's finest culinary skills. I still believe Tre, Dale, Casey, and CJ can stand out from the rest of the chefs.

posted on August 13, 2007 at 8:43 PM

Amanda wrote:

I don't understand Tom sometimes. To me he makes a decisicion in the first couple of weeks of who he does and does not like. Therefore the ones he doesn't like, don't have a chance. I totally disagreed how he treated Sara during the frozen food episode. Although, she's not my favorite chef, I seen that she put as much effort in the challenge as Howie allowed. As far as Howie goes, I wish someone would put him in his place, and kindly let him know that the world does not revolve around him. Also I think it's disgusting to watch sweat fall off his face and land straight in the food. I've seen that happen several times and he doesn't even try to avoid it. Gross! But all in all I love the show!!

posted on August 14, 2007 at 2:56 AM

charlie johnson wrote:

hey gail you are beautiful if your ever in lake tahoe, let me show you the exquisite dining and a great time

posted on August 14, 2007 at 12:31 PM

David P. Rodriguez wrote:

Hi Gail,
A couple of things that have been bothering me in Season 3. The fact that Howie is still there, (pork, anyone?) as is Brian (fish?) does not give me a clear picture of what a Top Chef really is. You, as a judge, should know that versatility, creativity, and spontaneity, are all factoring ingredients in addition to spices and sauces. And why is Ted Allen on the show? He brings little to nothing to the show in terms of constructive criticism, is he still trying to hang on to his Queer Eye 15 minutes of fame? Love your matter of fact, love it or hate it attitude on the show, you tell it like it is. I agree on 99.9 percent of your comments. Tom seems to be very high on himself as the head judge, almost demeaning to the chefs, I am almost tempted to go and taste the cuisine in his restaurants and critique his output of food! Hopefully Howie's and Casey's luck runs out soon! TRE is my pick to win, but I am not counting out CJ! He is the darkhorse! Thanks for taking the time to read this, have a great day!

posted on August 14, 2007 at 1:42 PM

Hailee wrote:

I have to say i disagree with your comment about Brian's cold bar. I remember one of my vacations at the beach where all of my friends went to the local bar and they had a free oyster buffet (you had to shuck them yourselves) and it was awesome. There wasnt anything better after downing a bunch of beer. I also think that the girls needed to get overthemselves... They obviously didn't have a problem wearing low cut shirts when they thought they were gonna be clubbing. They would have had to pull their shirts up while they were dancing too. I thought it was a poor excuse

posted on August 14, 2007 at 7:11 PM

Francesco wrote:

Can't believe none of the judges have worked in a kitchen abroad. Bravo, put some real chefs as judges, bring some people from Piemonte, San Sebastian, for Christ's sake. People who really understand what food is about. Can't believe there is not a single foreigner chef judging those people. THis show is only 10% about cooking. 90% is about childish rude americans fighting. Why in every Bravo reality show there is so much hate, conflicts, rudeness? Is it an american problem?

posted on August 14, 2007 at 10:42 PM

Sheila wrote:

I was also disappointed at the producers for tricking the contestants into thinking they were going for a night on the town. The female contestants instantly had the disadvantage unless some of the male contestants were wearing HEALS!

posted on August 15, 2007 at 1:04 PM

tracy kirkey wrote:

Howie is SOO gross. He turns my stomach when he sweats into the food! How can you guys eat that sweat-drenced crap??

posted on August 15, 2007 at 3:20 PM

Gabriela Cohen wrote:

This is one of the very very few "reality" shows I watch...and as before I am starting to question just how much this is for show or are you (judges) taking this seriously ? 9 contestants to go and HOWIE is still there ? If I had to work for a chef like that I would personally smash his face in one of his dishes...I thought that this show is about TOP CHEFS - which I might add should include how well cook and how good a leader they are...and btw - last weeks episode has been a dissaster as far as I can say...WHat chef/cook will be in his finest outfit and just pop in the kitchen for cooking session? Please come up with something original but acceptable and believable.....one final thought SaraN should not have been eliminated , at least not yet...just because you guys did not like her audacity to tell you that cooking in high heels was stupid...at least she had the grace to be a little more "PC" about how she put it...I sure would not have been...For next season - please do better, so I don't have to give up yet another reality show...thank you

posted on August 15, 2007 at 8:18 PM

Mike H. wrote:

I just want to say that Gail is Hot! and she is so much better looking than Padma. Love ya, Gail

posted on August 16, 2007 at 11:15 PM

Mas_Tequila wrote:

Say - one last thing. Why didn't the girls simply take their shoes off?? I would have!

posted on August 18, 2007 at 11:38 PM

Charleene wrote:

Knock of CJthe, longer the show goes the Stupid and Jerk,comes out .He should have got dumped with his Grass Cassarole! Jerk!

posted on August 20, 2007 at 12:05 PM

Sevenmack wrote:

To those complaining that the elimination put the women at a disadvantage: Please. How come Sara M., who was on the winning team, was able to cook without a problem?

The reality is that Sara N had both the best meal from the orange team (the sliders) and the worst (the shake). She also was responsible for most of the food and moved too slowly. And she whined about how she couldn't cook in her jeans and blouse. Remember, she wasn't wearing a low-cut skirt and a bra, but jeans and a blouse. Hell, my mother cooked in a ball gown and in a house dress. If she could cook in that, then Sara N. could cook in jeans and a blouse. And by the way: She could kick off the heels.

So cut it out with the sexist crap. Sara N lost because she didn't do a good job with the food and the service. And she lost because she's been, overall, the most mediocre cook. She hasn't been talented-but-wildly inconsistent like Howie, Trey or Hung have been. Nor has she stood out for interesting dishes. She's better than most of us mere mortals in the cooking department, but when it comes to the competition, she sucks. Period.

posted on August 21, 2007 at 1:48 PM

Deano wrote:

Would someone PLEASE tell the servers, whomever they may be, that you serve from the left and remove from the right?

posted on September 27, 2007 at 9:38 AM