January 31, 2007
Page 1 | Page 2 | Page 3 | Page 4 | Page 5
This has been a lot of fun, what can I say?
This episode, I really thought the food looked great. They did a really nice job incorporating a lot of flavors.
The one thing I felt a little cheated on was the fact that they got to bring their own ingredients. First season, we went out there, and they said, "This is what you have to work with, this is what we have in the hotel, make it happen." I would have loved to have spent the better parts of two months, during that break, to shop out ingredients. That would have been outstanding.
Comments
Sharon wrote:
You were 10 times better than Ilan ever will be. He did Spanish over and over. Not that Marcel was the calliber of a Top Chef, but Ilan definitely wasn't either. It was a disappointing season--if not for stupid mistakes, it would EASILY have been Sam and Cliff in the Finale
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:05 PM
Juliet wrote:
I must say that I had you picked as the Top Chef from the first episode last season. Needless to say, I will stick by Sam the same way, since he was my pick this year. Is your restaurant opening in New York? Tough crowd. Don't forget to let your fans know where to get fed! You will be missed.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:13 PM
Mary wrote:
I wonder how Ilan feels, since 99% of the viewers wanted Sam to win. Harold, you are still the top chef, since Ilan is not professional.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:15 PM
Gale Webber wrote:
Line cook Elan Hall instigated over and over the negative vibes about fellow contestant Marcel. When Cliff attacked Marcel, it was Elan in the background yelling, instigating it, and compounding his usual vile slurs. It was sickening to watch this one immature man promote as much hatred as he did. It influenced the background scenes and treated the other chef, Marcel, horribly, disgracefully. It influenced the other contestants as Elan never let up. Marcel was far more creative, more talented, but he never really got a chance. If this were the real world, Marcel's sous chefs would have been fired; there was not responsibility when tasks were delegated. The immaturity and spiteful behavior was rewarded by awarding Elan the title of "Top Chef." It should have been Top Asshole. Congratulations to Chef Marcel Vigneron for being a CLASS ACT!
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:21 PM
Clio wrote:
Harold, what a great final entry for this season. I hope they bring you back for future Top Chef's! Your blog was my favorite every week, because it was so straight forward and fair, yet you didn't pull any punches. You're a good writer, and you should keep a hand in when you can.
Your fans in New York are much looking forward to your restaurant! (Um, no pressure!)
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:22 PM
missgentry wrote:
My dear Harold:
One chef inspires you. The other ripped off the Casa Mono menu (I know it well, having worked there) ridiculously: bay leaves on sorbet? please. The signature dessert dish there. I understand how tactful you are, but I will continue to pretend that you are as secretly appalled by this decision as I am.
I think Marcel could run a kitchen beautifully, if it wasn't filled with refugees from the Lord of the Flies Cookoff.
I am done with this show. I enjoyed your cooking very much, and Iook forward to eating at your restaurant.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:25 PM
jazmine wrote:
Right ON!! Two flippin' months and they come with spheric salad dressing and canned eel? Lets keep it hard and on the dirty that's what makes it difficult and fun for us at home to watch...tee hee hee
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:25 PM
Dana wrote:
How is Ilan going to be a great chef if he doesn't take chances. All of the immaturity he repeated displayed aside, I still don't think he should have won. Marcel, while not perfect (who is at that age?!), shows the creativity to become a ground-breaking chef. As he said, he never prepared any of those dishes before. His menu wasn't even created until he got back with the ingredients he selected. I didn't see any indication that Ilan has any vision. I don't expect him to be anything other than what he is -- a great line cook! I still can't believe he even made it to the finale, let alone won. A very disappointing outcome.
Marcel, don't worry, it's your name we will hear in the future! And I hope we will see you with a different hairstyle. ;)
Harold, it's been fun! Lotsa luck with the restaurant. I live in NJ, so I totally intend to ride up to check it out. I'm sure you will kick ass! And I'm sure you won't serve canned eels.
xo
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:26 PM
Leonda wrote:
Best of luck, Harold! You're still the Top Chef.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:26 PM
ceejay wrote:
Don't pass that torch, Harold. This season was a disaster from start to finish, with a bunch of drama queens, sociopaths (yes, I know the definition, and I really mean it!), and BABIES! Enough, already. Can't compare with Season One as far as food and SKILLS! C'mon. Like her or not, that Tiffani had SKILLS. Stephen had SKILLS. LuAnn had SKILLS. Hang on to that torch, Harold. You are the only one so far who really has deserved it.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:27 PM
Peach wrote:
Harold,
I have really appreciated your insights this season, and agree on principle with everything you have said.
(Just between you and me, I believe that you have revealed the most balanced perspective of any of the professionals from Top Chef that blog on this website.)
I am one more fan who wishes you the very best.
Sincerely,
Nancy Collins
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:27 PM
Dennis Witz wrote:
Harold, you are still the TOP CHEF!! I don't think this year was worth it. No one was in the same category as you or the other chefs from last year. They were much too childish. Thank you for your professionalism!!
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:28 PM
whitedaisy wrote:
I believe that the majority of the chefs this season need to mature and build character.
I was bored by Ilan's spanish cooking, again.
And thought that Marcel was a much more inventive and exciting candidate to win.
thank you, Harold for your wise insights. All the best with your restaurant...
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:30 PM
James S wrote:
Hi Harold: I'm glad you're progressing with your own restaurant. It's very disappointing to me that the one who kept bashing his opponent actually won the title (and where the food was so anticipated). My definition is obviously quite different than that of the judges. This in turn says a lot about the judges themselves. This show no longer has my interest.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:30 PM
Ashley Nicole wrote:
Harold, no Top Chef will ever be as great as you! I enjoy reading your blog and hope to be able to eat at your restaurant some day soon.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:31 PM
Jane wrote:
Harold, Ilan is not half the man that you are and will never come close to you in the culinary world. Thanks for being an example that good guys can finish first. It didn't happen this season, whith that thug Ilan winning, but at least there's you- holding the bar so hi with your integrity that Ilan will never measure up.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:33 PM
Tim Kau wrote:
you rock. can't wait to check out your new restaurant, and I hope that you will continue to write your thoughts on your blog. congrats to Ilan.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:34 PM
Brie wrote:
Harold, you're awesome! I think you should have won TC2, too, because of your awesome blogs.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:39 PM
GOD'sGirl wrote:
ilan is no harold. Marcel may lact maturity but he makes up for it in class.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:43 PM
Justin wrote:
Harold, I completely agree that there were significant differences in the limitations between the Season 1 Top Chef Finale and the Season 2 Top Chef Finale. What I would like to see is a 1 on 1 challenge between you and Ilan because I just saw him trashing you on Bravo for being boring. You don't have to have a keen eye in the culinary arts to see that he can only cook well when he is cooking Spanish food. I'm sure you would mop the floor with that guy, which is why I'm interested in a possible cookoff.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:46 PM
Pam wrote:
Ilan is no Harold. The torch has not passed as Ilan is no Top Chef in my book. Marcel hasn't yet matured, but the potential is there to be a Top Chef. Ilan just gives the title a bad name.
Harold, you will always be my Top Chef.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:47 PM
Susan Abato wrote:
Harold, I have missed you this year. I agree that the contest this year was very different than the one you had to go through. I think if you had to go up against this group you would certainly win. Thanks for blogging. Although I did enjoy the cooking the drama, and the language were not so great and frankly I wanted Sam to be the last guy standing. It says a lot about him when he did not step in when they got back to the loft after the last challenge before HI. Good luck When I get back to New York would love to drop by your restraurant.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:51 PM
Jennifer wrote:
Harold -- in my opinion, you're being too generous to Ilan. The torch is still yours.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:52 PM
karen wrote:
good grief, does everyone have to give the ending away? what kind of web site is this that no one is monitoring it, and where is the integrity of the judges and commentors? Why should I even watch the show tonite..I already know the outcome! what a letdown.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:52 PM
Cindy wrote:
First, I have to say that the end of TC season two was as dissappointing as the the season itself. I do love the show and enjoy learning about new culinary techniques, but this season lacked class. Ilan, while talented, lacks maturity and integrity. WOW, Spanish cuisine AGAIN!? I guess safe wins over creative. Elia proved her LACK of class right to the end, I was dissappointed with her personality change. I thought she was a better person than she turned out to be. I REALLY enjoyed TC season one, over all the skills, the maturity, the class, the Chefs were leaps and bounds over this season. I hope you base season three's selections on season one's Chefs.
I will say you had amazing Chefs judging on season two! Of course we all love Gail and Tom, I hope they will remain as judges!
Ok, second I have to say that Ilan has a lot of nerve to make fun of Harold and how he reacted to his TC win. Harold.. I hope you realize that Ilan is not worthy to mop the floor in your kitchen! Your skills make him look like a child playing pretend cook. You should invite him to your new restaurant and show him how it should be done!
I'm looking forward to a new season of TC, til then please run reruns of season one!!
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:53 PM
Teri wrote:
How do you feel about the final 3 contestants in Season Two vs Season One? I really think Season 1 finalists were more mature and really ready to be Top Chef. I'm not so sure that the choice of Top Chef for Season 2 was really a "Top Chef" decision vs. the best of the final two. I enjoyed Season 1 much more. One other observation, by the final episode, it seemed that Stephen has taken corrective action to reduce his weaknesses whereas Marcel just seemed way too defensive. He just doesn't seem to get it that he would learn more by the mutual sharing experiences by his fellow competitors than demonstrating his opinion he is better than them.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:56 PM
jasmine wrote:
I just wanted to say that I enjoyed your blogs, I read them from time to time. The way you write, is unique in that it shows your humility and honesty. Few writers are able to really put themselves out there in their writing, you have been able to do that to connect with people somehow because you seem genuine. It seems rather likely "the winner" will be writing next season's blogs, I think this is why more than a few people would rather have you continue writing the blogs than "the winner." Having said that, I do not need to wish you all the best, because I am sure you will continue to prosper in your life but yet I wanted to write a few words. You will be missed.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:58 PM
Noodle wrote:
You are great Harold, good luck with your place.
posted on January 31, 2007 at 11:59 PM
gregg benac wrote:
Hey Harold. Ijust watched the 1st season finale again and i appreciated why you won. You were always respectful to everyone and honest about your food. (I.E. the restaurant ep. "it was just another day at the office for me.") When i watch the show i always say to myself "I would cook with that person anytime" Its the highest compliment i can pay. I would cook with you anytime.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:03 AM
Dawn wrote:
Harold, you are so generous in your assessment of Ilan, especially given his catty comments about you in the "Disneyworld" Bravo commercial. I think Anthony Bourdain's description of him as a weasel (and worse) is more apropo. You haven't really passed the torch; not to him anyway.
All of us grownups out here know that $100,000 is not really all that much money; cetainly not enough to start a fine restaurant or quit work for more than a few months. If Ilan travels well on that money, it will soon be spent. Then, he will have traded the exposition of his lack of character for nothing really. I think you will be hard pressed to find any level of culinary respect approaching what we felt (and feel) for you Harold, among "foodies". Winning top chef will not accomplish much of anything for Ilan... but not winning may give marcel and impetus to prove that he can run the long and real race of culinary life. To both contestants, I would say emphatically- grow up.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:04 AM
terfen wrote:
Harold,
When are you going to open your restaurant?
I need a really good excuse to ride up to Manhattan.
Peace & best of luck
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:05 AM
Danielle wrote:
Hi Harold,
It's been great reading your posts - insightful and honest. Only wish this year's finalist could be half the MAN you are! You say he's a good kid, but have you seen him making fun of your reaction when you won? I think he's a twirp who lacks character and originality - he's going to need a lot more than 100 grand and "the title of top chef" to get through this life.
That said, let's hope the producers bring back some authenticity next season...and continue with your blog!
Best of luck with your endeavors - can't wait until you open a restaurant in NYC!
Danielle
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:06 AM
Rhonda Barket wrote:
Dear Harold,
Marcel was robbed of a title that belonged to him. He is the first contestant to stay true to his vision of cooking, without consideing who's bottom to kiss to win. Everyone is talking about his salad, when the reality is.. he was a soft shell crab in a bucket full of losers..they just pulled him down! Marcel, if you read this..go to Food Network, we want to see more of your ideas. Obviously, so does Sam, because he wasn't there to help you win! Bad choice on Mike the idiot, and yes Betty was a B##ch!
RhondaB
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:06 AM
Me wrote:
Thanks for the blogs, Harold. You are the man. I still think Marcel seems like the better chef, but mostly I wanted to see Betty cry. Good luck, sir.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:08 AM
nan546 wrote:
How do you feel about the new top chef trashing you already?
He has no respect for anyone. He is not a top chef.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:08 AM
e. wrote:
Harold,
Thank you for bringing up the fact that Ilan has been biting Casa Mono's style. I have seen him do it throughout the show, and as they have been playing reruns, I looked for it even more closely and was annoyed to find not only ingredients but dishes replicated on the show. Top Chefs innovate, they do not imitate. I am not a big fan of Marcel, but I am even less of a fan of imitation. I hope Chef Andy Nusser of Casa Mono and Ilan are still on good terms, because he got ripped off.
ps. Harold, when are you opening your restaurant? I want to make my reservations early!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:09 AM
Monica wrote:
Not so dedicated a fan after this sham of a finale--no season 3 for me.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:11 AM
Kim wrote:
You will always be the Top Chef. You show grace, style and talent. Things that were not always seen with this season's contestants. Thank you Harold.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:13 AM
Mia wrote:
Hi Harold,
Ilan is dissing you in his post-show confessional.
He will probably try to pass it off as good-natured ribbing, but I think it's representative of the character he's shown on the show, that of a jealous, pathetic weasel.
Take care, good luck on your new place. I'm done with this show.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:13 AM
maryd wrote:
Harold,
Thanks so much for your insight into Season 2. You've become a "celebrity" in your own right, and I suppose you're anxious to move on the next phase of your career. I don't live in New York, so I hope we'll be able to hear how you're doing from time to time. Good luck with your restaurant!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:15 AM
Liz wrote:
Harold, I really hope they keep allowing you to blog next season. I really have enjoyed your comments and I have agreed with them. I hope that we do not lose your spark in passing on the torch to someone who can only cook one type of cuisine.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:15 AM
rebecca wrote:
good luck and God's blessings to you Harold on your next endeavor. great insights on the finale of top chef season 2. you were right on about Ilan's dishes, it has no imaginations nor arstistry, I just wished you were part of the panel of judges.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:22 AM
Dave King wrote:
Ilan is a good kid? The guy who kept shouting for everyone to come assault Marcel as Cliff pinned him to the ground? The guy who dissed Marcel's dish in front of the CUSTOMERS??? Etc. etc. etc.
My question is: Everyone from you, Harold, to Bourdain has said that Ilan has stolen the dishes from Casa Mono.
WHY is this not considered cheating??
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:30 AM
Pamela W wrote:
Glad to read your blog.
Man did Ilan not deserve to win IMHO.
He knows Spanish food. Very well. It's like if one worked for
Mario Batali for years and then went on Top Chef and cooked
Mario's food. So what. You were a great decision.
The first TC was so good. You're a very level headed and interesting chef.
Ilan..................nowhere. I wouldn't go out of my way to eat at a restaurant he would open, unless it was in the East Village,
was cheap and I wouldn't have to pick up the check.
He made the most boring plates. Really. In the Hawaiian show,
the plates themselves were ugly. Yick squid and whatever in a Hawaiian inspired theme. These judges were crazy this time.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:31 AM
Chloe wrote:
Ahh, Harold. I've enjoyed reading your blog, you seem like a really interesting, down to earth guy. I am really excited for you, opening your own restaurant, how cool :)
I've really appreciated your opinions and take on this season. It was unique to hear what the winner of the first season had to say. I think you are great, and you have a great fan base. Keep on rockin!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:32 AM
Brian M Doyle wrote:
Marsel got SHAFTED.He should have WON.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:35 AM
Alvardan wrote:
So Ilan feels that he's glad to take over you because you're "boring". Do you know Ilan at all in real life? Because that seems a little too familiar.
Harold...as far as I'm concerned you'll always be Top Chef. Sequels are always inferior
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:38 AM
AOK! wrote:
Thank you Harold for your comments and class that you continue to demonstrate through this blog. I know you will have great success due to your character and commitment to your food and your kitchen staff. My family and friends can't wait to venture to NYC from Arizona just to eat at your new restuarant, Perilla. Many blessings to your future endeavors.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:43 AM
Brian Keith wrote:
you felt a felt a little cheated ? haha....
sould be a lot cheated! TC1 you guys had it TUFF.... this seasion was more like TOP CHEF light...
take care Herold and best of luck with Perilla's, Looking foward to dinning there on my next vist.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:54 AM
Blake Kirby wrote:
Harold,
You may have "passed the torch," but this new winner still can't hold a candle to the integrity and maturity you consistently demonstrated during last year's Top Chef episodes -- you're obviously far ahead of him in those departments . . . his continuel whining about, and attacking Marcel, became tiring, showcasing a definite lack of maturity. . . he's got a long way to go before he can catch up with you, my friend.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:55 AM
Tim Asbill wrote:
Harold...I agree with you on all the above but Ithink that you and many of the other contestants from season one could cook circles around the chefs in this season....thanks for all your comments and look foward to hearing, reading and maybe someday tasting your own food as the head chef of your own resturant.
tim
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:01 AM
Shokaste wrote:
IM FIRST!
And I am genuinely happy Ilan made it, even if I didn't watch the ep. I am doing so out of disgust for the Bravo peoples and Tom Coldickios two facedness about kitchen vs. personality. Sam should have done based on sheer talent, Elia would have been my next pick, Ilan would have been the next and Marcel would grade much lower. So, given the limitations of Sam and Elia being eliminated, I think Ilan was the best candidate to win this. This season was bogus, I guess commerce won over art huh Bravo?
You're great btw. Loved ya. K. yea. AHEM. K, good luck and will come to Perilla definitely. K.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:04 AM
Trent wrote:
All of these comments are coming from someone who should have been runner up at best, so him passing the torch to another loser is no big deal. He is so boring and it comes across in his cooking style too......... BORING!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:06 AM
AGamma627 wrote:
I was disappointed. Last season I happened on the first episode and was hooked! (and I HATE reality TV, this is the only one I have ever watched, no Survivor, American Idol etc ever..)
The first season I loved the dishes. I wanted to make your Thai snapper in the first episode and I wanted to try every dish. This season I thought food was a distant third between clashes between people crying cheating (while there may have been some I wasn't there to judge) and personality clashes. A very disapointing season. Too much reality too little food.
On the plus side, I can't wait to fly to NYC and try yours and Dave's places when they are both open
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:10 AM
Jennifer wrote:
I loved the first season of TC but I'm kind of glad this season is over. I continued to watch, but I was disappointed week after week. The food isn't nearly as good as first season - and I've made several of the dishes (minus teeny amounts of ingredients I'd have to go to another state to obtain). I say this time and time again, but TC2 chefs had no concept of good healthy food. Harold, last season I was yelling "thank you" at the television when you said you don't like to cook with a lot of dairy. Not only do I not eat much meat, but I have dairy allergies. You at least made a few vegetarian dishes last season (and several that taste quite good with substitutes) and I haven't found a single dish this season that doesn't contain meat or dairy. Don't even get me started on all the frying Ilan does. Bleh.
And quite honestly, this cast wasn't as fun to watch. I know a lot of people say they keep this person or that person for the drama or whatever, but it's not The Real World and I prefer to see people my age or my parents age act like adults. This cast was not only full of nasty drama, but none of them had the camaraderie that season 1 did. I found the junk food guessing game challenge more entertaining than everyone holding Marcel down to shave his head. I think the only people I was really rooting for to win were Sam and Betty, which obviously didn't work out.
That comment Ilan made about you was just wrong. He thinks you're boring? He should take a look in the mirror.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:11 AM
jenc wrote:
Harold, love you and you are still top chef to me. Ilan though? That is a joke. How boring a chef is he? How predictable and those eelings on soggy toast? His food is totally one-note and unappealing and unimaginative.
Marcel is an artist and his dishes were creative and well-enjoyed.
THe wrong decision was made.
Ilan? I bet we never hear from him again.
Marcel? Oh yeah. He is brilliant.
I cannot believe Ilan could be called a top chef. That is so funny I am still laughing.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:13 AM
April wrote:
Ilan definitely hasn't earned the title, in my opinion. You'll always be THE Top Chef -- no 'passing of the torch' should be involved! This season really just made me appreciate S1 and last year's cheftestants more. Good luck on getting through all of that paperwork to get your place up and going, and thanks for the great blog this season. Best Wishes!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:14 AM
John wrote:
Harold, you are an all-star Top Chef. Not only do you have the title, you have the character as well. Ilan, has no character. He was a instigator and a drama queen. I hate to see him win, it cheapens the title. It's unfortunate that the torch will be passed to such a scumbag. They should bring Tiffany back and have her co-host with Ilan, so we can see the worst top chef has to offer.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:15 AM
Jen wrote:
Harold, you are still top chef! Ilan can't hold a candle to you. The judges should have sent you in to settle things after the assault on Marcel.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:17 AM
Amy Cornett wrote:
I'm so glad that Ilan won, he shows a lot of what incorporates being a TOP CHEF. I am in Culinary school right now, and he definetly gives me inspiration to stive and be who I really am.
Thank You, for all the motivation that makes me a better chef and person.
Amy Cornett
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:18 AM
sandra wrote:
I totally agree with the way you put that.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:19 AM
sandra wrote:
I absolutely agree - don't need to add a thing. However, I do think you should be a judge on that show. Sam reminded me of you, and though I liked him, Marcel's food reminded me more of your creativity and flavors. Funny. But you have really made some very good comments on the episodes and I appreciate it. It calms me down from my anger over the WOWed judges on the last show - Marcel over Ilan it sounded on all counts. Then NOT! (except for that salade and bad people decisions, I know he didn't have much choice, but Mickey? I seem to remember every "team" effort he was on, he really went lame and messy if I recall. ....thanks.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:23 AM
maria wrote:
hey hey ilan rocks!!!!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:23 AM
staci cusimano wrote:
I am interested in what Harold is doing as far as opening his own place. I'm sure it has been stated somewhere in the past... but, I am new to the web part of TV. I'd love to know how he is doing since his win. If he has opened a place yet, etc. And as far as Passing the torch??? Not really!!! Harold owns the torch.... Ilan is just keeping it warm for a while!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:25 AM
Dalna Rodgers wrote:
Harold,
Good luck on your opening. You were my pick from the start
in season one and I picked Ilan for season 2 (need to pull
that off at the track) I have enjoyed keeping up with you
and will always remember not only are you a great chef,
but seem to be a great person also--you were ALWAYS
fair and honest with the other chef's-keep that quality.
DR
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:26 AM
SUSAN wrote:
GAIL,
I so agree with your comments about Ilan playing it safe. But I would go even further to say he wasnt just playing it safe by choice. He HAD to do Spanish because that's ALL HE KNOWS!!
Too bad you didn't have Ilan's boss Mario Batali as a guest judge in the finale. Maybe then he wouldnt been able to so shamelessly take credit for these rip-offs.
I feel really cheated by Illans win. Let me guess he's going to take his 100,000 and open up a.....Spanish concept.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:26 AM
Roy wrote:
Harold: I have really enjoyed your sincere comments. All the best - can't wait until you open a restaurant in California.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:30 AM
bluesmouse wrote:
Harold - You're still the man! I remember that when the judges jumped all over you for having grit in your mushrooms all you said was "that's not good"...it was perfect. You had your own Marcel to deal with in the form of Stephen and his silly egotism. Season One was a class act. Best of luck and I look forward to visiting your restaurant....any updates on timing?
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:33 AM
DBRVNH wrote:
Best to you on your restaurant! It will be great! You will really be missed. Thanks for your comments, here, very keen.
I agree with Gale Webber and missgentry, I just realized when reading them...., Ilan DID instigate, always in the background all that - hatred never letting up and the others were never given a chance. So correct. Also, I agree totally with their deliverance of the reasons that Marcel is really the Top Chef (lol). Casa Mono really won, and Marcel could have picked anyone better than Mickey (he messes up on team stuff).
And last Sharon (and others), I agree, Harold was 10 times better than Ilan and I'll add that Marcel was 3% better. Doesn't better=win anymore?
So, I preferred the first season, though I really liked you, Harold being a judge on an episode! Rock on!....and I do enjoy the addition of Padma. I thought most of the episodes this year were judged well - just this last one is a tragedy in my opinion. After listening to the judges EVEN, on the show at least - Marcel wowed them, and Ilan was "casual", and had many more "issues" as Tom calls those failings.
Well, I think Harold should be a judge MORE OFTEN, do you think you can squeeze "recurring judge" in next season, at least 4 times? Sure would be appreciated!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:35 AM
karen wrote:
Ilan is no Top Chef and nothing will make me watch this show again, Marcel you won alot of fans for putting up with bullies and back stabbers, you will go far, Ilan I hope no where! You suck as a nice person and I think you won unfairly so long top chep you lost another person!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:43 AM
Robin wrote:
Go Harold! Ilan is NO Harold, and never will be.
You and Marcel are awesome, and I can't wait to hear more from both of you in the future.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:48 AM
Karyne wrote:
Ilan does not deserve the tittle of Top Chef. First of all his lack of creativity is apalling. He is imature, and not a leader at all. Elia cooked must of his food, she or Sam showed real leadership and must important of all, they both have skills. Harald you were missed this season. I am looking foward to visitng your restaurant. Good luck.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:52 AM
middlechef wrote:
Harold-
Yes, I agree with you how sweet was it to be able to bring your own stash from home to shop for for 2 months prior to the finale....But - here's the kicker - make it to the final 2 and then just give away the prize as your teammates who hate you come back into the picture. That's what Marcel got to work with. Totally assinine challenge with Betty and Mike. What is Mike going to do with molecular gastronomy? He can't even make a steak sandwich!
Oh - and didja catch when Ilan made fun of you winning the last season? He said how boring you were. What a PRO huh. This kid has no business in the professional world, culinary or otherwise. I see such passion and gift/craft in Marcel and I believe he will go far. I hope he is already taking advantage of the exposure that has come as a result of the show. He made a couple of mistakes, but then again he didn't back up the sausage and eel truck to the tiki hut like Ilan did, either. Neat to make half your meal at home prior to coming. Oh, well. I disagree with the judges selection. I really think the dining table that night was totally turned the other way. Maybe it was a fear of lynching by the Marcel-haters. Whatever, great show - inspires me to pursue my own culinary skils and we'll be watching next time. Let's all learn from our misses this season!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:53 AM
Deborah wrote:
Wow, this is the best blog on Top Chef! So insightful and mature. You were my pick the first episode, and my favorite all along - for good reason.
I agree this season was a disappointment, but I can't say it better than your bloggers, Harold. Such good true insight here. I'd love to see that cook-off between you and Ilan someone mentioned!
All the bloggers here seem to be mature, and this season, Marcel did consistently show the most risk and talent. Some of these posts are awesome, and it's weird that I agree with them all!
So, too bad for Marcel, but I hope he gets to know how really mature, true fans feel. Just read this blog. We all saw it all. And we have Harold to hold up for integrity and Class Act. By the way, I'll repeat one: Congratulations to Chef Marcel Vigneron for being a CLASS ACT!, and no need to pass the torch, with Ilan being crowned, that is pretty much saying - Harold is still top chef.
I'll be in New York and will be at your restaurant! Can't wait. It totally rock!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:53 AM
Sandra wrote:
Hi Harold, just want to say how much I've enjoyed reading your blog throughout this season, I love your straigtforwardness and honesty. I agree there were a lot of differences between S1 and S2, the lack of decent, likeable contestants for one. Personally I wanted Marcel to win, his treatment by Elia, Sam, Betty, Ciff and the ever puerile Ilan was outrageous, and his ability to rise above it and get on with the job was admirable. As far as I'm concerned you are the original and best. As well as being a great chef, you showed a level of decency and fairness that Ilan doesn't even know exists. I can accept that Ilan may have been the better chef tonight, but if he doesn't learn to be a decent human being the title is irrelevant. Marcel may have a little maturing to do himself, but I have no doubt that he will go on to bigger and better things. Hope you'll be blogging again next year, best of luck with your restaurant!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 2:02 AM
Chuck Simon wrote:
I did not watch top 1, but season 2 was interesting. I think for the most part all
the chefs did a pretty good job. I really
thought the winner was going to be either Sam,Cliff, or the girl who shaved her head, her name escapes me at the moment. :-)
Marcel is a good chef, but to me it seemed
he cared more about the technique and style
of cooking and not so much the taste. I have
tasted many a meal that looked good and tasted like crap. Never underestimate great
flavor. Congrats Ilan!! :-)
posted on February 1, 2007 at 2:02 AM
Cece wrote:
I agree that llan is an unworthly top chef. On many other reality tv shows he would have been kicked off the show for his conduct and contribution to the scene of Cliff assaulting Marcel. What Illan did was criminal. It is really sad that the impression given on the show was that everyone, including the viewers, would see that Marcel was a jerk. How far from the truth. I would love for all of the contestants to know that the viewer can not be so easily fooled by their competive tactics. The average viewer could see each of the losers for what they were......losers, who for an hour allowed us to see what competition does to peoples perceptions and personalities. Marcel was the only worthy winner and I think that if Harold and Marcel openned a restaurant together it would be the best.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 2:11 AM
Michael S wrote:
Harold, I agree with most of the posters here. You are being much too generous with Ilan. You are still Top Chef. The title is yours, not Ilan's. His food showed no originality, at any stage in the competition. He has a lot of chutzpah (he knows what that means) criticizing your deference when you were awarded the title. In fact, except for Marcel, none of the cooks this season (notice I don't use the word "chef") compare with the final six from last season. I think if any of them had had the opportunity to compete again they would have walked away with the title. Betty, Ilan, Sam, Mike, and Cliff were truly pathetic little people. Only Marcel was a mensch. (Again, Ilan will know what that means).
posted on February 1, 2007 at 2:19 AM
Tim wrote:
I feel kinda robbed knowing that the title of Top Chef goes to Ilan when the previous owner was so much more deserving of it. You're A-OK in my book Harold. If I ever make it to NYC, I'll be visiting your restaurant long before I make a stop to Ilan's (unless, of course, I'm in the mood for lots and lots and lots of saffron).
posted on February 1, 2007 at 2:21 AM
Ron Castillo wrote:
Aloha Harold,
I agree with your comments. I do see Ilan running a kitchen and top restaurant on his own. All the food looked amazing from both chefs. Who will be the next great restaurants?
Day to day operations of any business needs a strong team behind it. Food will not come out of the kitchen without cooperation, regardless of the vision and skill. If he goal was to help the next top chef get a head start , then Ilan is the winner. Mahalo for your blogs and good luck, I hope enjoy your resturant when I'm in New York. Aloha
posted on February 1, 2007 at 2:22 AM
amy wrote:
I have to say that Season 1 contestants were far more talented and PROFESSIONAL than those of Season 2. And, although Season 1 contestants had their beefs with each other, they appeared to be more mature about their differences. I really could have cared less who was Top Chef in Season 2 (because of their bad behavior), although I was rooting for marcel to win because he had to take alot of abuse. Thanks for your blog. Interesting stuff. Good luck to you
posted on February 1, 2007 at 2:24 AM
Bety Degrauwe wrote:
Harold, you are the true Top Chef...but for this season, Marcel really should have won it over Ilan..who is really just a male Betty Clone and an immature jerk and despicable pr*ck as well. I just wonder how much of that $100,000 did each judge get a slice of?
posted on February 1, 2007 at 2:27 AM
freD wrote:
Marcel obviously has more technical ability and maturity than Ilan, but no top anything chooses a couple of enemies over people who want to work for them. He may have screwed himself with that final "nice guy" act.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 2:28 AM
Matt wrote:
HAROLD! You're still top chef! Forget this season's babies, you're still the man. Don't pass your torch to that hack Ilan, who by the way, bashed you on TV by calling you boring. Challenge him and take back what is yours! Show him how to make an array of food rather just spanish flavors. You have to get together with Bravo to hold a competition, your new restaurant would get so much more press. Your leadership and professionalism still make you in my and many other people's eyes as the true top chef!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 2:32 AM
Krystal wrote:
I agree with the other bloggers, Ilan can't touch you in terms of leadership, professionalism and skill. Besides, that whiner had the gull to diss you out of nowhere. Another sign that he can't hold a candle to you. Good luck with your restaurant.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 2:33 AM
Maria Calkins wrote:
What a disappointing finale!!! How on earth could you pick Ilan over Marcel as Top Chef??
Ilan is cooking same old, same old over and over, besides being immature and nasty in the competition.
Marcel is much more of a Chef in fine cuisine. And really I never could understand, why everybody was picking him as a villain. As far as personalities go other contestants like Betty and Frank weren't exactly pleasant. And they are 20 years his senior! Shame on them. I was glad to see both of them go.
I must say, I am thouroughly disgusted with your choice. I am sad to see it being a popularity contest after all.
Marcel - you rock!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 2:35 AM
Maria Calkins wrote:
What a disappointing finale!!! How on earth could you pick Ilan over Marcel as Top Chef??
Ilan is cooking same old, same old over and over, besides being immature and nasty in the competition.
Marcel is much more of a Chef in fine cuisine. And really I never could understand, why everybody was picking him as a villain. As far as personalities go other contestants like Betty and Frank weren't exactly pleasant. And they are 20 years his senior! Shame on them. I was glad to see both of them go.
I must say, I am thouroughly disgusted with your choice. I am sad to see it being a popularity contest after all.
Marcel - you rock!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 2:39 AM
Denise wrote:
Harold, it was a joy watching you get stronger and stronger in season 1 until you won hands down. This season, all centered abound Ilan, Betty and Clif's inane hatred of Marcel. I thought the name of the show was 'TOP CHEF', not 'Top Line Cook'! Marcel showed his class by not allowing himself to be goaded by the others' sniping. Ilan doesn't have any original thoughts, springboard ideas or creative edits in his dishes, at least, none that were shown on the show. I think salad and vegetables are the hardest to make into a fabulous dish while spotlighting the key ingredients. Sure, if you put enough butter and heavy cream on a veggie dish, you can disguise it. But how many salads wow you? I can only think of a very few chefs who do so with salads and veggies on a consistant basis.
Hey! Next season, let's have only people with the title of 'executive chef' or 'executive sous chef' as contestants. They could actually cook food for which people would be willing to shell out dinero. I dunno---it's just an idea.
Best of luck with your restaurant. Your blogs were interesting and you had a real keen insight as to the goings on. And as Chef Tom simply stated, "I don't care what goes on in the kitchen, it's about the food!'
posted on February 1, 2007 at 2:57 AM
Wendy wrote:
Harold - I agree, hands down, that you are still the reigning Top Chef.
I think next year Bravo should bring back you, LeeAnne and Tifffani and pit the three of you against Ilan, Marcel and Sam, or mix it up.
Whatever happened, by the way, to what's-his-name (the wine steward)?
Wow. The aftermath of "15 minutes of fame" must have hit him hard in his double-Winsor knotted tie but I hope he's doing well keeping the affluent sloshed on over-priced wine.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 3:03 AM
Liz Lakomsky wrote:
Harold,
You are a true gentleman, and Ilan will never be able to measure up. I think that Sam should have been in the finale, instead of Ilan. He only does Spanish food, and while there;s nothing wron with that, being a Top Chef involves versatility. I would love to know more details about your restaurant, as I will definitely be there!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 3:11 AM
TopChefFan wrote:
Harold, you exemplify everything a Top Chef should be, as did your worthy opponents.
How do you feel about the way Ilan has trash-talked you?
And, how to you feel about the fact that Ilan stole recipes for his finale dinner from Mario Batali?
posted on February 1, 2007 at 3:21 AM
canela wrote:
This season of Top Chef STUNK and Ilan winning in the end was the miserable cherry on top. Although he was a fine cook, he did the same thing that was expected and safe or in another word, BORING. Marcel does need to communicate better but the Marcel bashing especially by Betty who is disgusting was just uncalled for. I clearly felt Marcel should have won, especially hearing from the judges how innovative and delicious his food was. Ultimately they picked Ilan because of Marcel's 'lack' of people skills? Didn't Tom C. say it was about cooking?? In the end a complete contradiction, not to mention Ilan bashing Harold calling him one effing boring dude during Top Design was stupid. No respect. Lame
posted on February 1, 2007 at 3:23 AM
canela wrote:
This season of Top Chef STUNK and Ilan winning in the end was the miserable cherry on top. Although he was a fine cook, he did the same thing that was expected and safe or in another word, BORING. Marcel does need to communicate better but the Marcel bashing especially by Betty who is disgusting was just uncalled for. I clearly felt Marcel should have won, especially hearing from the judges how innovative and delicious his food was. Ultimately they picked Ilan because of Marcel's 'lack' of people skills? Didn't Tom C. say it was about cooking?? In the end a complete contradiction, not to mention Ilan bashing Harold calling him one effing boring dude during Top Design was stupid. No respect. Lame
posted on February 1, 2007 at 3:26 AM
JavaJunkie wrote:
Harold,
You are the best. We've loved reading your blogs, and have enjoyed chatting with you. Ilan should feel honored to share the title of Top Chef with you!!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 4:01 AM
R. Christian Anderson wrote:
Harold.. YOU are a professional... you were polished, intelligent, articulate, intense, serious, thoughtful and kind. I can't say that for season 2. Marcel was at least inventive and original. It was a sad choice and I hope they will get another professional line up of cast members for season 3 like they had in season 1.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 4:03 AM
Mike C. wrote:
Top Chef is one of my few must watch shows, but I must address a few issues with this season. First, I think the overall quality of the chefs was down this year. Second, It seemed like the editing was geared more toward a MTV reality show than a serious competition. Third, the final two chefs were not the best chefs in the competition. Marcel is a little weasel - we all have known people like him. He is an instigator and lacks people skills, he was treated the way he was for a reason. Ilan is in over his head and was not in the same ballpark as Marcel as a cook. I would have picked Sam as top chef because of his overall cooking and leadership skills - not that they were overly impressive. I am looking forward to season three, but if it plays out like this one it will be my last as a viewer.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 4:03 AM
alise nilsen wrote:
I was not a huge fan of Marcel throughout this season. However, this was not because of his food. I always knew he was amazingly talented, and I hated it! He deserved the title of Top Chef, and I think that over time, this will be evident. Ilan's food seemed to taste good, I just don't think it was very imaginative. It's too bad so much of the competition is based on chance. If it were a little different, we would have saw Sam and Marcel in the finale. Their food looked amazing 99% of the time. I also thought Cliff was very talented. He got drunk and made a poor choice. It was weak that he was asked to leave. It wasn't that serious, and it just made Marcel look like a victim. I'm sure Marcel doesn't appreciate that.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 4:06 AM
Alexandra P. wrote:
I'm copying what I posted on someone's blog about you:
"Harold is the epitome of talent, professionalism, camaraderie, respect.....not mentioning that he's so cool and so very hott at the same time...
Oh, Harold...you set that bar so damn high...
Btw, I heard Ilan made fun of you on the live show.... As we say in Brazil, he still have to eat LOTS of rice and beans to try to fill your shoes... What a disapointing season.
And between the winner and the runner-up, I do believe Marcel has a better shot of making a name in the future.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 4:19 AM
Mary wrote:
Harold, you're such an amazing chef! I truly enjoyed reading your blog. I'm sure you have no clue about this, but I hope that you'll still stick around and make an appearence or two on the show. I think you're such an integral part of the show. Good luck witn your restaurant. I'm sure it'll be great.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 4:24 AM
Lonny wrote:
Good luck Harold...
posted on February 1, 2007 at 4:33 AM
Julia Hailton wrote:
Your choice of Chef won Harold. You said he was in the same position of winning the first "Quick Fire Challenge" as you had. Would you hire him too? If I were you, I wouldn't because he might hate you and have the other workers in the kitchen scheme against you. Just merely "FOOD for THOUGHT!"
posted on February 1, 2007 at 4:34 AM
elle wrote:
harold,
heard you on "watch what happens" saying something about passing on the groupies to ilan. yuck do u really hate us that much ;)
posted on February 1, 2007 at 4:35 AM
jean wrote:
Harold your still #1 for this show!! They had 2 choose between 2 evils, no clear winner, not at all like last year. There were many chefs on your show that had goodness & integrity along with the cooking. This year they may have cooked well, but failed F- as human beings.
If Ilan gets the next Top Chef blog, I won't read it, as I don't care what he has to say, he was so obviously a child throughout the competition, and a whiny one at that, I am too old to care about a childs thoughts about others, I heard enough on this season from him.
And he cooked what he normally did in the kitchen he worked for, for his final meal??? Not creative, just stealing but that seems to go along with the rest of his immaturity shown all season.
I hope your blog continues here, although I am sure you are ready to get on with your life, you may have passed the torch, Illan will surely douse it out.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 4:48 AM
Jean Ortuso wrote:
THANK GOD THIS HORRIBLE SEASON IS OVER!!!!!! I really could have cared less who one - the whole cast was a nightmare. Ilan ripped into you in a commercial later - calling you "boring". He is not good enough to shine your shoes. Ilan is what the nuns in school used to call a "Casper Milquetoast" always trying to get others to fight his battles for him (Elia in the finale). The title better for him is "Top Snake". I hope they get chefs with class like youfor next seasons show - and ones that look like they wash their hair and bathe.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 5:23 AM
peg aucoin wrote:
Harold,
You are still number 1, you are the top chef. Ilan 'SUCKS', I am cajun, we are all good cooks here in south Louisiana and Ilan should have never been in the final four much less final two. Marcel was the risk taker in creating new food ideas, presentation, etc...But my favorite above all was SAM----this was the top chef. His integrity, leadership and he can cook too please, chef tom and those other 2 fancy broads (gail & ?????) whoever need to rethink how this just went wrong. Don't show the audience behind the scenes action if it's not going to count for anything. Betty was a trouble maker who was a diner cook.
There was a lot going on that could have been nip in the bud. Anyway, SAM to me was the man, just like I picked you, Harold
from the beginning. This show has really upset my values
posted on February 1, 2007 at 5:46 AM
Becky wrote:
Ilan is a good kid? Well, he's a kid. I didn't see the good part.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 5:51 AM
meliblu wrote:
Disappointed in the Top Chef finale this time. Ilan's food seemed uninspired and boring to me and nothing new from him. Did enjoy seeing Marcel's dishes except for his salad, but he certainly wasn't rewarded for his creativity. Hope that next season is better and hope that Marcel exceeds and surpasses the evil vile Ilan as a chef. Didn't like Ilan the bully and just despised him after he told Marcel that from Day one he wanted to punch his face in. Not overly impressed with Ilan's food either.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 6:36 AM
James Katzenstein wrote:
Harold, you were outstanding as last years Top Chef. Being a fourth generation owner is a food business I know one of the main reasons for being on top is team work and being fair. You are a team player as was Ilan, Marcel was not.
Maybe everyone else was bored by Ilan's Spanish cooking but I love Iberian cuisine. No doubt Marcel is talented and thinks "out of the box" but, if he is not a team player in the kitchen, he will have high turnover of staff...and that is the worst thing for any industry!
Jim K
posted on February 1, 2007 at 7:15 AM
Scorpla wrote:
Harold, I'm forming a party tonight and we're heading over to Ilan's to ambush him while he's sleeping. Don't worry, it's nothing serious..just a joke really! See he has this torch, and it's freaking yours!
Everything about you is Top Chef Harold, and I hope your planning to blog next season as well. Your blog is by far the most interesting to read and I enjoy your insight.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 8:06 AM
BD wrote:
I still cant belive Iian made it to the final. Marcel is at a whole other level in the final and still lost - HOW? Sam should have been cooking against Marcel in the final. What was that thing tom said about Iian at the end last night - you may not be the top chef in a few years but you are now- come on, he is a talented line cook thats it.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 8:11 AM
Oliver wrote:
You may think you have passed the torch, but it is still firmly in your hand. Ilan is the Spanish Top Chef. You were a professional throughout. Never conspiring or stooping to dirty tactics. Honestly, you know that and so do we.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 8:15 AM
jayne wrote:
Marcel was the definite winner. I can't believe that they picked Ilan. Who many Mexican dishes can you make. llan rarely tried anything new and when he did, it was a disaster. I really cannot believe that the judges could not see the truth. Ilan will not get far because he is not mature and is not a CHEF!!!!!!!!!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 8:17 AM
Cleta wrote:
How is it possible that Ilan won?! The only contestant with some dignity left was Marcel. And I love how Sam in every episode sabotages others by instigating their tiffs and then pretends like he's above all of the drama. I would never eat Sam or Ilan's food. Bad vibes all over.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 8:18 AM
Rita wrote:
Harold you're their only Top Chef.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 8:32 AM
puchi wrote:
The best chef of Season II is Sam and it was disappointing that he was not selected for the FINALE. Both Ilan and Marcel are still young and not as experienced as Sam.
I would have enjoyed having Harold be one of the final judges because he has such constructive feedback and suggestions. Perhaps Bravo should consider having the top 2 chefs of each Top Chef season compete in an "IRON CHEF" style competition...my picks:
Harold, LeAnn, Sam and Cliff
posted on February 1, 2007 at 8:43 AM
Bob wrote:
Harold, i that to agree with the crowd here, you were ( are) a much more deserving Top Chef than perhaps anyone on season 2, for all the reasons i loved the first season--team work-leadership- food flair. I thought the only person close to you was Sam, despite his attitude towards Marcel a few times, he had flair and leadership.
Best of luck to you in your endeavors.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 8:45 AM
Jack Sprat wrote:
Harold,
If you think Ilan is a "good kid", you haven't been watching the show. Or your morals are really screwed up. Plus, he's a hack (sorry, I don't know how to say it in Spanish). Marcel has more creativity in one finger (perhaps the one he peed on), than Ilan has in all ten of his fingers. Marcel will refine his technique with experience, but his creation of dishes will have no limitations, unlike Ilan who can only cook Spanish.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 8:47 AM
faith canali wrote:
Hi Harold,
You are Top Chef! You are a true gentleman also. Ilan is always putting people down, and that turned me off completely. This season was so disapointing. Everyone was backstabbing everyone else, and they did it openly. I hope next season will be more enjoyable. Please continue to be kind, gracious and humble, that is the qualities that made you Top Chef and my favorite.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 8:50 AM
Irma wrote:
Dear Harold,
3 Cheers to You! Always the gentleman, humble and real.. Thank you for a season of sanity and fairness in your commentaries.
You are being verrry kind with your thoughts on Ilan. He was not one bit as versatile as you. His Spanish themed food actually put me off it. (I always adored Spanish cuisine before he overworked it ad nauseum). In addition, his character was just plain despicable. (He stated that he really wanted to pee on Marcel. What an "A.W." -- ass wipe.) I have little respect or patience for his attitude.
I thought Marcel was genuinely unique in his approach and deserved more respect for his efforts. Unfortunately, season 2 was reduced to kindergarten, playground politics within the children who came to play the game you mastered in S-1.
Harold - Best of luck to you & your new restaurant. I can't wait to try it out. Hopefully, you will keep in touch with your many, many fans that you have deservedly attained.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 8:51 AM
Joan K. wrote:
Hi Harold,
I did enjoy the season you were on Top Chef so much more then this one. I couldn't bleive how rude some of these so called chefs were to each other. I think Marcel could have been Top Chef this season if not for all of the back stabbing.
I wish you all the best on your new restaurant.
J. Kohls
posted on February 1, 2007 at 9:06 AM
chief cook wrote:
I think the two performed equally. Marcel's salad was equivalent to Ilan's 1st eel course--canned eels? Come on. I wanted Marcel to win for a few reasons. He finally bagged his foams and everything he put together was original. I understand that Elan's dishes progressed, but the Spanish Spanish Spanish, I mean, break out, guy!
I think it was extremely clever for the producers to permit former contestants to help. Clearly, Marcels difficulties (whether they were brought on my himself or childish behavior on the part of the other players) came home to roost in choosing helpers.
But it came down to who could pull the whole thing off that night without problems and I guess Elan did that the best. I think Elan is probably close to peaking and Marcel will have a long way to go. With regard to behavior, I still never saw what drove everyone mad about Marcel, unless it was his confidence. I think Elan's outbursts towards Marcel were really beyond rude. For Elan to refer to himself as easy going is silly. Even in his initial submission video he notes he has a real temper... Cant wait til next season.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 9:06 AM
Suzie wrote:
Marcel, Marcel, Marcel... Pleeeease. You people that support him do so only because you feel inadequate yourself. You should expect more in yourself and the people you want to make a mark on this world. What kind of example are you setting to want and allow such disastrous people to succeed. It would be better for all of us to promote and support good behavior and strong, positive leadership.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 9:13 AM
BABI WALZ wrote:
Harold, You've heard it before but I too from your first show last season saw you as the TOP CHEF.
I loved the way you handled yourself and reveiwed this season's first show. And as usually not only are you a TOP CHEF but a gentleman and must do the right thing in passing the torch; it's just too bad it was the wrong kid. Leader's dont go behind people's back and beliitle them in public and try to undermine them to a judges table during a challenge. These are things we did in 3rd grade.
All the judges at the table immediately loved MARCEL'S FOOD. MARCEL was given elans FANS as his helpers. Marcel held his head high, IS THE ONLY PERSON THAT NEVER LIED on the SHOW, always made it about the food, never backstabbed and as much as I keep asking for all this footage of MARCEL doing all the awful things they never show it.
Sam was definetely an excellent Chef and maybe all 3 should have been in the finale w/MARCEL allowed to use his helpers, HIS FANS, not their SPIES. And the 4 helpers should never have been asked about Leadership. When in all 16 weeks I watched as most were rude, crude, backstabbers, liars, cheaters, bi-polar, did not take responsibility, pointed fingers, threatened to punch MARCEL'S face (THAT ALONE SHOULD HAVE BEEN GROUNDS FOR DISMISSAL.) i DIDN'T taste the food but believe my background has been worldwide gourmet and Mom was a cordon bleu. I LOVE MARCEL AS I was so happy YOU TOOK THE TITLE DUE.
Prior to final judge decisions the days footage should be reviewed and not necessarily dismiss you but give you negative points and when you reach 3 YOU ARE OUT!
MY HEADLINE READS: "FIRST & SECOND SEASON TOP CHEFS----
HAROLD and MARCEL!
Come back next year more often to judge!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 9:20 AM
BABI WALZ wrote:
Harold, You've heard it before but I too from your first show last season saw you as the TOP CHEF.
I loved the way you handled yourself and reveiwed this season's first show. And as usually not only are you a TOP CHEF but a gentleman and must do the right thing in passing the torch; it's just too bad it was the wrong kid. Leader's dont go behind people's back and beliitle them in public and try to undermine them to a judges table during a challenge. These are things we did in 3rd grade.
All the judges at the table immediately loved MARCEL'S FOOD. MARCEL was given elans FANS as his helpers. Marcel held his head high, IS THE ONLY PERSON THAT NEVER LIED on the SHOW, always made it about the food, never backstabbed and as much as I keep asking for all this footage of MARCEL doing all the awful things they never show it.
Sam was definetely an excellent Chef and maybe all 3 should have been in the finale w/MARCEL allowed to use his helpers, HIS FANS, not their SPIES. And the 4 helpers should never have been asked about Leadership. When in all 16 weeks I watched as most were rude, crude, backstabbers, liars, cheaters, bi-polar, did not take responsibility, pointed fingers, threatened to punch MARCEL'S face (THAT ALONE SHOULD HAVE BEEN GROUNDS FOR DISMISSAL.) i DIDN'T taste the food but believe my background has been worldwide gourmet and Mom was a cordon bleu. I LOVE MARCEL AS I was so happy YOU TOOK THE TITLE DUE.
Prior to final judge decisions the days footage should be reviewed and not necessarily dismiss you but give you negative points and when you reach 3 YOU ARE OUT!
MY HEADLINE READS: "FIRST & SECOND SEASON TOP CHEFS----
HAROLD and MARCEL!
Come back next year more often to judge!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 9:22 AM
GoddessLu wrote:
Hey Harold, you'll always be my first...Top Chef.
That said, while I agree with the judges (and you as well, however subtlely written) that Ilan's cooking perhaps does not all spring from his head, I believe that he is most ready to begin a career as a Top Chef. I say this with the utmost respect and admiration for Marcel's innovative ways and courage. He still needs to simmer a bit longer. That said, even though he displayed some appalling immaturity in the Marcel-bashing, Ilan was my pick from the beginning to go to the end with Sam (sniff), particularly as I have a thing for a cute guy in glasses. Ilan, still seeing Carolina? Call me.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 9:23 AM
Addie Appelbaum wrote:
Dear Harold;
I truly missed you this season...you are a gentleman and consummate chef! Your comments about the contestants this past season were spot-on.
I would love to visit your restaurant when it opens! Keep us fans informed!
Best wishes,
Addie
posted on February 1, 2007 at 9:25 AM
kathy wrote:
Dear harold, like many top chef fans last season was mush better exept for tiffany beating out leann, but in the end she was an asset in las vegas. I really liked dave as well, this year i really felt sam should have been in the finale and i hope next years chef pose more maturity
posted on February 1, 2007 at 9:27 AM
fa wrote:
I'd rather watch a reran of season 1 than that joke they showed last night. what's the title again?top ....chef????
posted on February 1, 2007 at 9:32 AM
Barry Johnson wrote:
Marcel was set up by having to use sworn enemies as assistants. Sam sabotoged, then took total credit when he shouldn't. Impartial Hawiian cooks should have helped.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 9:36 AM
Lisa wrote:
I'm sorry, but I kept saying during the episode last night that both of them were 'no Harold.' Aside from outside the kitchen antics, Sam was the closest thing and even that's all relative. Good luck in the new restaurant! I know tons of people are just waiting for it...
posted on February 1, 2007 at 9:37 AM
Johnboy wrote:
Harold, get over yourself with your Ilan bashing. In many ways, Ilan was a far more interesting and innovative cook than you demonstrated yourself to be on your season. Stop bashing. Start accepting. Ilan is the New Top Chef. Now go get some more financing for your new restaurant.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 9:41 AM
Von wrote:
Dear harold:
Your blog was the best. I truly feel you were the best top chef choice in season one. I think everyone should give Illan a chance. Sure, he has some maturing to do, but given the choices between the 2 chefs, I think illan was my choice. Marcel has his faults as well. He is not so supreme as he seems to think. Good luck to you Harold. Hope to hear more great things from you. You are a great person.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 9:44 AM
marsha wrote:
ilan showed his immaturity and mean spirit during the short blurb about passing the torch between commercials of Top Design last night. i will not repeat here, but, grow up kiddo, you aren't that great a chef.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 10:02 AM
Katy D wrote:
That guy who won is no TC. He has neither the talent or the class of Harold. We will always remember Harold as Top Chef, if we remember this guy at all it will be for his meanness and his infatuation for
Marcell.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 10:05 AM
Linda Nelson wrote:
Harold,
You remain THE Top Chef and the model for all future contestants...season 2 was, in my opinon, a total failure as evidenced by the lack of a real Top Chef contender in the finale. Thanks for letting us viewers see and read the work of a real Top Chef...and, no offense to Sam, but I think you're cuter, too!! Best of luck with your new restuarant...let us all know where it is and when it opens. Thanks. Linda
posted on February 1, 2007 at 10:21 AM
carol wrote:
Good luck, Harold. I think Ilan is a good choice. He might not have the maturity that you have, hope it'll come with time.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 10:28 AM
Dan wrote:
Too bad, i actually wanted Marcel to win. It's funny because i started out from the beginning rooting for IIlan, Elia, and Sam. But after seeing all the BS Marcel had to go through...
Think about it:
Betty psychotically blasted him several times and began the whole idea of ganging up on him.
Frank threatened him physically.
Cliff assualted him physically.
A fan assaultty him physically.
Illan said he wanted to assault him physically.
They all ganged up on him to shave his head.
Elia accused him of CHEATING without ANY evidence.
All this for the infractions of: being a somewhat cocky and sometimes socially inconsiderate.
Total social heard mentality.
I don't exactly feel the punishment remotely fits the crime. In fact, throughout all these insane instances Marcel conducted himself with a strong measure of forgiveness and class. I don't think ANY of those people would have raeacted the same under the circumstances. Perception is everything.
You want a cocky, poppous jerk? Try the pretensious hipster Iilan. His little dances when he think s he's acting tough. Egging Cliff to assult Marcel. Egging Elia to accuse Marcel of cheating. His childish culinary trash talking to Marcel. His proclamation, "I'm gonna be famous." Best, his childing Betty twice in the finale. Once for plating the shrimp wrong yelling, "Stop! Stop!" and my personal favorite, chiding Betty for not addressing him as "Chef". Last blasting the classy Harold for being "boring".
If MARCEL did that..
Oh wait, he didn't.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 10:29 AM
landy wrote:
Harold, you were a top chef that deserved it. I think Marcel should have won and would have much enjoyed a Sam/Marcel match-up. Ilan? Well I agree with the reading between the lines that you put up. Sam and Marcel would hav ebeen about the food and healthier competition...even though Sam was a quieter dissenter of Marcels. I totally believe that Sam and Ilan were in cahoots and Sam sabotaged Marcel. Oh well. you have your integrity and well earned title and Marcel has his integrity.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 10:37 AM
kj douglass wrote:
Dear Chef Harold, You are in your blog, just as you appeared on TV, reserved, professional, and a good judge and chef. Ilan does not seem to have the imagination to create his own, so he plagerized the dishes from where he worked. I don't care for that, but i was a Marcel fan. I believe Marcel will excell in the future, Ilan will not have a penny left in 3 months and no restaurant. Ilan could not touch your style and should beg for you to teach him. I loved your quiet professionalism in season 1. Compare last season to this, and this season looked sortof trashy. Thank you for your insights and I am as always a BIG Chef Harold fan. kjdouglass
posted on February 1, 2007 at 10:38 AM
Nora wrote:
Harold,
You are by far the best Chef so far! Ilan so immature it makes me sick! Saying he wanted to pee on Marcel's hand after the incident at the beach...immaturity at it's finest. Marcel was so much more mature and the best damn Chef on the show. He took risks... he was robbed and I think that Sam and Mike set him up to fail, he should have picked Mia and Frank to assist him. I hope you get inspired and open a restuarant here in Texas or maybe I will get to visit your place upstate one day!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 10:41 AM
Elizabeth wrote:
I think it is awful that Ilan won. The last thing we all need is another freaking Spainsh inspired resturant in this country. Anyway, I thought it was awful the way Ilan was trash talking you after the show on the extra interview. Your food looked ten times better then anyone esle this season. You should kept your damn torch.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 10:47 AM
KD wrote:
I for one did not watch the last episode due to both contestants that were chosen. Ilan was very immature and so was marcel( imean come on turning the heat on the stove down and moving others pots and pans come on. My seven year old behaves better than both of them. this was a bad season and i hope Top Chef gets involved more with how contestants act. Anyways Harold you are the one and only TOP CHEF i was for you all last season and enjoyed you this season and i love the blog.good luck on your future endevors, can't wait to eat at your restraunt.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 10:53 AM
JT wrote:
HAROLD vs. SAM!
or
Sam, Ilan, Marcel
vs
Harold, Leigh Anne, Tif
posted on February 1, 2007 at 10:57 AM
Jolie wrote:
Harold...let's be real. You are TEN TIMES the chef that Ilan is, and if I were you, I would be absolutely appalled at having to pass the torch to this recipe-stealing instigating, immature so-called chef. Keep your torch, because to me, you are still the TOP CHEF!!!!! And I am DYING to eat at your restaurant, by the way.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 11:00 AM
Karen-Lee wrote:
Harold,
I am a cook trying to be a chef. Can I come and show you my work at your restaurant? I think you have a lot to show others.
Where is you restaurant??? I would like to come a taste your food.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 11:05 AM
Chef Mommy wrote:
Harold-- You still reign as TOP CHEF.
This season was a JOKE and to award a smug adolesant whose behavior was that of a two year old, with a win, is rediculous. Marcel clearly took chances and was creative and innovative, isn't that what they drilled into them all season??? and to switch up at the last min.....oh PLEEEEEEEEEEASE! Same ole' same ole' crap from Ilan, what was cutting edge about his dishes? Most of Ilans dishes looked unappetizing. How can you reward that? OMG very very disappointed with the decisions of these judges.
Can't wait for your restaurant to open. Please keep us up to date on your happenings.
Thanks Harold.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 11:06 AM
Jill wrote:
Hi Harold - Ilan doesn't come close to representing a Top Chef. He lacks everything you represented when you won; a good cook and a classy person. He's a disgrace. I truly hope, like you, that next season the focus is on the food and cooking aspect. And I agree with you the contestants should not have been allowed to bring things from home - the competition is much better when everyone starts from scratch at each challenge. Good luck with your new restaurant!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 11:10 AM
Wendy wrote:
I agree with ceejay that the first season chefs all seemed smarter and more knowledgeable and ready to be crowned Top Chef. Maybe it was the nature of the challenges or just the way this season's chefs spoke, but to me they all seemed as if they were only a few steps ahead of a burger flipper (not that there's anything wrong with that - no offense to burger flippers). I had picked Ilan early on as a front-runner, but I lost enthusiasm when he revealed he was such a weasel encouraging others not to help serve Marcel's dish, egging Cliff on to hold Marcel down, egging Elia on to accuse Marcel of cheating while he stood silent. Everyone is making the comparison of Ilan and Harold when there isn't one. Sam is most closely the gentleman chef that Harold is. I admire Sam for using his time off to study pastry; I admire him for helping to serve Marcel's dish when Marcel refused to help him; I admire him for not accusing Marcel but suggesting Elia and Ilan just wait for the judges' decision; I admire him for choosing to work with Marcel as an opportunity to learn about chemical gastronomy even though he clearly did not like Marcel as a person. Now there is a top chef without a title.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 11:12 AM
CP wrote:
No, not a dedicated fan base. As much as I enjoyed watching you cook Harold, Season 1 is over, and has been over. Season 2 was worse than any MTV reality show, and Season 3 won't happen in my house - in my mind Top Chef is over for good.
I hope your restaurant goes well, I'd love to taste your food one day.
Once I watch the aftershows online (didn't watch the finale - who needed to after the leak?) I'm outta here.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 11:19 AM
marie wrote:
When I saw yesterday the finale, my first thougth was Harold should be the winner again,.. frankly I think that top chef 1 finale was by far much better that this one. First of all the didn't have to pair food and wine, what I think is quite a challenge,.. your food even of your oponent had more quality, more variety than ilan and marcel's food.. and let me tell you that Ilan was my favorite since the first episode because remembers me of you, although I love spanish food, I think perhaps sam would be a fair winner in the middle of this lack of competition..., sorry but is no the first time i feel this, the same happened with project runway, the second season with daniel v, santino, cloe, much much better than the last season, by far...
posted on February 1, 2007 at 11:20 AM
Ryan wrote:
Harold:
It is great to read your blog and even better to agree with you about everything.
But I'm sure you won't read this - just glad to see your followup to the erroneous end to season2.
-Ryan
posted on February 1, 2007 at 11:25 AM
shelly smith wrote:
Harold you are a stand-up kind of guy. You have what a Top Chef should have. Season 1 with you guys was fantastic to watch. Season 2 .... well .... disgusting, especially seeing Ilan win. I believe a better name for this Season would have been Top Crybaby because they had so many on there. They say it's all about the food but it's not. Top Chef should have dignity and class also. Marcel far exceeds Ilan in those areas. I have seen people call Marcel immature but I do not feel he is. Anyone who was immature would have behaved very differently when attacked the numerous times that Marcel was attacked. I cannot even begin to express how appalled I am with Top Chef right now. They have, once again, rewarded the Jerry Springer Show behavior and attitude. A show that started out as a great and classy show has quickly gone down the toilet. Are there going to be any better competitors in Season 3? If not, I am sure Top Chef will get their ratings for the people who like the fighting and underhanded tactics but the rest of us will probably just tune out. Sam claims there was no guidance in the kitchen but I'm not sure I believe that. I think Sneaky Snake Sam would have done what he could to ensure that Marcel had it rougher in the finale. I hope you keep this blog going. You have fans and we wish you all the best and tons of success in the restaurant. I hope you are going to keep us informed of it all. If I get to NY once you get it open I will be stopping there!!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 11:41 AM
Gail wrote:
Well, the Marcel and Ilan bashers are having a great time, and everyone is upset about the outcome. (Can we all please try to spell Ilan's name correctly?) But while I enjoyed Marcel's trips 'outside the box' and wished Ilan could have tried newer things, lets remember this: who led the team in the kitchen better? Who inspired people to work with him? Who turned others down when asked for help? And who managed to bring all their ingredients to the final kitche? A top chef is so much more than a great cook- he needs to be able to work with people, to inspire people and to enjoy being WITH people. While we all seem to agree that Sam fits the bill, he wasn't there. Of the 2 final contestants, it's clear that Ilan is better suited to supervising a team (at this point in his career) than Marcel. They both have a long way to go, but Ilan, for all his whining and griping, can work with people, and not antagonize. (Just remember- Marcel and Elia were great friends in the beginning- what did he do to antagonize her so???)
posted on February 1, 2007 at 11:44 AM
Julie wrote:
I would stand in line for weeks to eat at any restaurant of yours. I wouldn't stand in line for five seconds to eat at any restaurant of ANY of this seasons contests. I'm very disappointed in this season and I hope next season the producers will cast a little less drama and a lot more class back into the show.
Thanks Harold for an intelligent, respectful blog. I can't wait for your next phase because you are and deserve to be a star!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 11:46 AM
Sara wrote:
Harold, if they give you the chance to continue on with TC - please do so. Your appearance and participation in the season helped validate show. The over commercialization of the program has gotten disturbingly out of hand, so it's nice to have someone involved who truly cares about cooking/cuisine and maintains a high level of integrity. (Chef) Hats off to you!!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 11:47 AM
Tim wrote:
Hey Harold, well there goes the kitchen! I know the judges were the ones who actually tasted the food and all we saw was edited TV, but Ilan is a disgrace to cooking and professionalism. It seems that the only original thing he brought to the kitchen was drama. From my time in a kitchen I know that's one thing the crew can do without, but I guess reality TV is a different animal. Hopefully next season will have more creative food and less petty drama. Good luck with your restaurant! You're still Top Chef!
Tim
posted on February 1, 2007 at 11:54 AM
Kevin wrote:
Great episode! I know that you all have your opinions, but these chefs cooked for some of the biggest names in the business...and they were impressed!!! Bravo always pulls through with their finales.
Good luck to you Harold!
I'll be sure to keep an eye out for your restaurant opening.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 11:56 AM
Rebeca wrote:
Hi, I'm from Costa Rica and I know that this final episode where you got to be the TOP CHEF happened a long time ago but here we saw the final just yesterday and I'm really happy that you were the winner because you deserved it, you showed througout the days that you have everything to be a Top Chef like working as a team even if you're the chief and make everyone to work confortable while they're near you and off course the great food that I wish I would've taste. I hope that you open your restaurant and I wish a lot of success for you and your co-workers. Congratulations HAROLD you made it.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:08 PM
Lynn wrote:
SHORT RIBS WITH ROMESCO SAUCE PLOPPED ON TOP IS CREATIVE???? Give me a break. Marcel, I think Tom C. put it the best: you will be (if not are now) the SUPERIOR chef because of your creativity, well-thought out and beautiful presentation, and yours would be a restaurant I look forward to eating at, one of these days. You are the WINNER of this show, and because of your open-mindedness and vision, you will be truly a TOP CHEF along the ranks of the Best. Ilan -- he'll be a line chef somewhere, blogging about the $100k he won, a total has-been.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:18 PM
Patrick L wrote:
Chef Harold,
A gentleman to the end, you are. I am not sure I could say the even modestly nice things you have said here about Ilan (I can't even call him Chef Ilan...how about Line Cook Ilan), especially if he called me "F***ing boring" on camera and that was televised nationally and internationally....the man has no tact and no class to speak of, and his young age is no excuse. He is a one note cook, doesn't use his own ideas, but copies them all from the menu of the restaurant he worked in in New York (I understand he has left there?...please don't tell me we will have to endure him as part of Season 3 of Top Chef...I am not sure I could stomach that!). I also thought the behavior of Marcel's sous chefs was a hinderance and not a help to him...but who was surorised with that? They all hated him and certainly would assist in abotageing his performance. I don't think he ever really had a chance with that group of the four loser chef hanging around. Too much influence.
Let's face it, Ilan really is just not a nice man, a man with few original ideas, a severe lack of kindness and tolerance for and toward anything different than him, and a perverse addiction to paprika and saffron (yuck! after two meals). I think your comments said alot...Marcel inspires you; Ilan reproduces the dishes from Casa Mono...hmmmm? Lets see, who's the REAL Top Chef here? I have my own choice. But Ilan won the title, thinks you are a "F***ing bore", and hates Marcel. Yep, lots of class and maturity there! I am certainly willing to see Season 3. I only hope the contestants are as mature and professional as Lee Anne, Marcel, and yourself. Some drama is necessary, but we still would like professionalism. And I certainly got the sense from Marcel's co-worker in Las Vegas that he is very much respected in the kitchen. I think I'll go with that recommendation.
Best of luck to you, please do be a part of Season 3. You are heads above Ilan as a Chef and I am sure he knows that... another thing that makes him jealous. I am but an amateur cook, but I am so inspired by what you produce.
Sincerely,
Dr. Patrick L
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:18 PM
Eleanor Fowser wrote:
I hope that you haven't passed the blogging torch on as well. Your comments have been balanced without pulling any punches, intellegent and interesting. I can't imagine Ilan producing anything other than venomous, hateful rantings.
I know that you'll be busy running your own resturant, but for the sake of those of us who are willing to give TC one more chance to prove that Season 2 was simply an abberation, please try to find the time to continue giving us your take on the shows.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:22 PM
Nicole wrote:
Harold - you are the true Top Chef and clearly you have an avid fan base here... best of luck to you in all of your endeavors!! Lee Ann also rocks and deserves much future success.
BUT - "Ilan is a good kid."?? Really?? Somehow I don't think that's the case. He will clearly be remembered more for his immaturity and bullying than for his culinary skills. As it should be.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:33 PM
Sandy wrote:
Dear Harold,
Last year Top Chef was entertaining, and I'd had high expectations for the new season. After watching some of the manical and twisted personalities (Betty acting like a Suzanne Sommers wanna-be ; Ilan with his nasty remarks and equally nasty background tactics; Cliff screwing himself over by attempting to hold down Marcel, etc.) I'm not going to watch Top Chef again. Like many others writing to the blogs, I was surprised that Sam did not make it to the finals, but I was also upset that Marcel did not win. Ilan may have gotten the title of Top Chef, but I'm not convinced he'll really enjoy any continual success other than his 15 minutes of fame. This guy really, really needs some counseling.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:34 PM
Kathy wrote:
Harold, I wonder if you have any comment about the judges bringing back Betty,Sam,Elia, and Michael to ask them what they thought about the two finalists, their work, etc.
Did they do that with your group? It seemed unfair, particularly to Marcel. Of coursee, it made for good TV and validated all the Marcel haters.
I am not a Marcel hater, I get him and I think he is great. But both he and Ilan have some growing up to do, don't we all.
There were several older competitors that acted extremely immature, namely Betty and Cliff. I hate them.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:44 PM
C Haberle wrote:
Elan? No thanks! Sniveling little puppy!
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:53 PM
Vanessa wrote:
Ahhh... Harold. I miss you. I miss the first season Chefs. I almost quit watching a few times because they seemed significantly less mature this season.
Anyways, no personal attacks but I DO feel Ilan deserved to go home as much as Cliff after the would-be shaving incident so I am significantly non-jazzed about his winning last night. I was rooting for Marcel. Are his people skills that bad or did the pack just turn against him? Let's hope Season 3 really is about the food.
posted on February 1, 2007 at 12:55 PM
Gino wrote:
Thanks, Harold, for your great blogs. Hope you let us all know
when you're up & running. Of my many disappointments in the
torch being passed to Ilan was his need to slam YOU! Didn't he
have enough fun tormenting Marcel & enlisting all the others, including even Elia finally, into that effort. Guess you became
his next target. Tom, Gail & Padma better duck,too. Though
Marcel couldn't run a kitchen staffed with his own flunkies, he offered a much more creative meal than the safe & seen before
fare Ilan did. Honestly, canned baby eels? I truly wish to offer Marcel my regrets & hope that Betty, Elia, Cliff, & Sam are
Ilan's only future patrons. As my Gramps used to say: "I
wouldn't give you a broken penny for any one of them!"
posted on February 1, 2007 at 1:32 PM
Natalie wrote:
Marcel was definiately "the class act"! I have watched these episodes over and over (cause it's always on) and for the life of me I have not seen any vindictive or unprofessional behavior from Marcel (what the hell was Elia talking about anyway?). It was all clearly Ilan that was instigating the hate against Marcel...as was Betty! The only motive I can think of is that they were clearly threatened by him (his education, and skill level, etc.). However, Elia turning on him was strange...wasn't it? It was around the time Ilan moved into her room and started sleeping with her...hmmmm?