Heidi wrote:

Ted,
I think Hung has the technical finesse of a top chef, Dale the undisputed heart, but Casey the game and head smarts. It's time for a woman to take it all, no?
Truthfully, the person behind the food is just as important as the food itsef; look at the renowned French chef you all spoke highly of from last week's episode-he didn't leave his restaurant a single night and most of you were in awe of him as a person...him as a chef was an incredible bonus.
I would gladly and eagerly make reservations at Casey or Dale's restaurant because I would know the person behind it and would want to support that person.
Hung...eh. Fantastic technical skills but then, you can master anything. You can't be taught heart.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 12:42 PM

Fidgen wrote:

I got misty too at the revelation of Dale's rejuvenation. It took me by surprise. Maybe that's part of why I like the show. I think the best reality TV for me is watching the personal growth of the participants that happens over time in the setting of the competition. I think the 3 remaining contestants all could win and it would be well deserved. It may come down to inspiration at the finale. Casey winning I think would be a door opening for women in the culinary world. Not a reason to treat her gingerly but a pleasure to see ground breaking performances.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 12:48 PM

Joe wrote:

Ted I could not agree with you more how genuinely affecting Dale's story and win was last night. Often people will cover their pain with humor, something I believe Dale did plenty of this season. I was so proud of him for turning lemons into lemonade, so to speak in both his life and last night's challenge. Sometimes the underdog really does deserve to win!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 12:52 PM

Dennis wrote:

Thanks Ted, yet another insightful blog. I wholeheartedly agree with your statements regarding Dale being out and proud. While some viewers/readers may be uncomfortable with his sexuality, it truly is inspiring to see one of our own (yep, big ole Texas gay here!) being honest, and highly amusing, on national tv! My hope is that he wins, but we'll have to wait until next week for that, won't we? Keep blogging Ted, you're great!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 12:53 PM

SweetMary wrote:

I love ya Ted!! I can't wait until the final season of Queer Eye starts. I hope you come back for next season on Top Chef!!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 12:56 PM

Kane wrote:

I dig Dale, too. Not just because he's a big gay cutie but because he a sense of experimentation. I find that intriguing. I don't think of Hung has being necessarily soul-less but I don't find him exciting. I do, however, like Casey. I hope to see Casey or Dale as Top Chef but I worry because Hung has the full package (oooh, that's funny when I reread it).

posted on September 27, 2007 at 12:56 PM

ellen wrote:

Unfortunately, I'm afraid Hung will win. He's got the "chops". Personally, I'd rather see either Casey or Dale come out on top. They're both team players and always have been...esp. Casey. She's often made herself available to help fellow contestants even in crunch times when she could have been focusing on her own finishing touches. I've NEVER seen Hung display a "team player" quality. Sure, he may be the better trained chef, but there's more to running a successful kitchen than that. At this point they're all talented enough to be Top Chef I just think it should be someone who is going to bring up everyone in the kitchen...not just himself.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:01 PM

Roger wrote:

Right on Ted! It was so good to see Dale pull it together, be truly focused, have a "Plan B" ready to go and show confidence and poise under what I can only imagine is quite a "pressure cooker". His confessional at the end was truly moving and heartfelt. We would all love to see him win it all!

Any of the remaining 3 is truly deserving. Of course I'm also rooting for Casey as she is one of our own "Dallasites" - and her restaurant is FANTASTIC!!!!! Hung also deserves praise and recognition. AsTom pointed out, he is probably the most technically precise Chef in the competition and last night was the first time he expressed some "passion" that seemed sincere and not forced.

Whoever wins, it has been a great season and we are eagerly looking forward to see what you have in store for us next season!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:02 PM

Steven wrote:

BRAVO!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:04 PM

Christi C wrote:

I am going to go out on a limb based on the shows past winners and say it will be the most undeserving of the 3 - Hung.

I know he has his fans, and those that think he is just your typical reserved Asian that can not express his feelings. Give me a break! If he was so reserved - why the explosion (read: temper tantrum) on last night's show about how BORING Elk was? Why the vocal arrogance he exhibts show after show after show if he is so reserved? He has not been a favorite of mine ever since the QF challenge with the shellfish way back in the 2nd or 3rd episode. He showed his true colors then, and shows them every show.

Casey and Dale show class - they demonstrate a depth of character that goes beyond just the food that they prepare. They seem to have a passion to bring happiness to people's lives by the food that they cook. And eating is as close to nirvana as you can get (with one notable exception).

Hung prides himself on his technical skill - so what??? I want to eat food prepared by someone that has a genuine desire to cook for average folk. I was very offended by Micah and her attitude about Americans, and I was equally offended by Hung ADMITTING to the judges that he cooks for them - not for the Cowboys that eat beans, beans, beans.

As for Dale - I think Dale rocks and I agree 100% that he shouldn't have to edit who he is just so a few prudish right wingers can feel good about themselves.

As for Casey - I hope she wins, because women don't get much appreciation when it comes to the chef - good ole boy network. Plus she has so much raw talent - she seems to be able to cook anystyle, anywhere - shouldn't that be among the qualifications of a top chef?

I can't decide between Dale and Casey - they both have character, passion and class. I can only hope that Hung goes home and can go back to cooking for those that "appreciate" his BORING technique.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:05 PM

casey wrote:

Who do I want to win...Casey. Of course the fact that we are both females who share this great name is one reason I've noticed her from the start. For the other kazillion reasons, well I'll name a few: 1) She has GREAT instinct. Even without tasting her food I can tell the flavors always make sense together. 2) If she messes up, she deals with it and goes on. I love that she's no drama queen. Her behavior proves that a lot of times guys hold that title the best. 3) The name Casey means brave. She's brave in her decisions and acts smart. Yeah, that onion chopping moment was a little..."wha?" But she didn't stop and say, "Like OMG I'm so embarsssed, sorry guys, someone else take over..." She kept at it. In competition on nat'l tv, that's brave. In the end, her ability to keep at it, her great food knowledge, teachability, and her strong spirit make her my favorite.

I too am STOKED for Dale. I've thought he was cool the whole time, not totally sure bout his food (how much can one really know through a freakin tv?) but I could really see his growth in this recent challenge. To keep going and not give up, try something new (like a reality show!), and then find yourself again...that takes courage and strength.

And Ted, I just think you're great. You always have great insight and a great sense of humor. Thanks!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:07 PM

Josie wrote:

Who do I think is Top Chef?? I think Casey, and not because she's a girl and how nice it would be to have a female Top Chef winner. It is b/c (from what I can see on the show) she portrays all the things Tom, Gail, you, and other guest judges have been saying what a Top Chef should be. Even though this is a competition, Casey still helps the other chefs when she can. Hung doesn't help anyone b/c he wants to beat them, and that's okay (it's his prerogative), but if Hung is as good of a chef he says he is, then he should still have no problem beating his competitors even if he did help them. That's why I think Casey is better; she helps out her fellow competitors (when she can) and still beats them in the end. She has heart!!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:12 PM

Sheridan wrote:

Ted, I always look forward to your blog! Even though I am a straight woman, I totally agree with you about Dale being openly gay, but why do you call him "bad gay chef" for sleeping with cowboys? There's nothing wrong with that!I adore him, and have been rooting for him from the beginning. My gut feeling is that Hung is going to win, though Casey looks very strong. Hopefully Dale will pull it off, despite this.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:12 PM

Amy R wrote:

I love this show! Thanks for your comments and insights Ted. It is interesting to get a "behind-the-scenes" look into the competition. I'm kind of hoping "soulless" Hung doesn't win, but I have a feeling he will. Technical skills and all that, blah blah...I would be happy with a Casey or Dale win. Love them! And, for the record Ted, I completely agree with you about Dale being out and proud on TV. Good for him! I had this same convo with my husband last night...if you're fine with watching a man and woman go at it in a movie or whatever, you certainly shouldn't have an issue with a gay man talking about his trysts. Anyhoo

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:14 PM

Chris wrote:

Ted,
Love the blog. Wanted to see you in Princeton, NJ last weekend, but missed the festival. Bummer!! Hope you liked Jersey. Anyway, I'm rooting for Dale. On the gay thing, when the show first started, I thought Dale was straight. He wore a shirt reading "I love hot moms". Who knew?
Keep up the good work. All the best.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:14 PM

liz wrote:

I can say with a huge amount of delight, that I will be happy regardless of the outcome. All three are solid competitors with excellent skill sets and all of them seem to be reasonable human beings as well. Thank heavens TPTB have recruited real chefs again rather than a bunch of drama queens.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:15 PM

roxy wrote:

1) i am really embarrassed to be "into" reality tv and am very self-conscious about it.
2) i really, really hope dale wins, but i don't think he will. but i HOPE he will so much that i spent $0.99 texting in a vote for him last week.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:17 PM

Sarah wrote:

Hey Ted!

Thanks so much for your comments...along with everything else I know you've been super busy as part of The Fab 5 (can't WAIT for the season to start next week) but really wish you were on TC more. You've got a great point of view...both knowledgeable and humorous..a tastey combination!

In reference to Dales open comments on the show....I say GO DALE! I find him forthcoming and genuine and laughed out loud at his cowboy comment. Those who were offended (other blogs), get over it and get with the program!

Thanks again for your contributions....they make for two of my favorite shows on the idiot box!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:20 PM

kc wrote:

Thanks for the info on Dale currently waiting at Sola in Chicago. My husband and I had been wanting to try the restaurant for awhile and knowing Dale was there sealed the deal. I was very impressed to see him hustling for the patrons with passion and humility, as if he had never appeared on Top Chef and did not have this finale hanging over his head. As we left, I congratulated him (he was not our waiter, sadly) and told him we were pulling for him. He seemed completely taken aback, which led me to believe that he did not make it to the finale. Last night, I was pleasently suprised to be so very wrong. Regardless of the outcome, I am just happy that Chicago is receiving well-deserved attention in the food scene and think Dale is a fabulous representative of what this city has to offer. I cannot wait to see what Bravo has in store for the finale and for next season.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:21 PM

rachelh wrote:

Ted, you keep it up! You're great reading, your criticism is constructive. You show kindness in your posting and judging. As for the gay man card, whatever. Consenting adults. Being kind and funny, like Dale and you seem to be, are more important.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:27 PM

SJH wrote:

Hi Ted-
I absolutely agree with you (and posted so on Tom's blog) about the QF. Yes, by all means, use something that is locally fresh- trout. But why the sterno-on-a-tree-stump-boy/girl scout conditions? Afer last week's straight-up cooking episode, this challenge seemed silly, especially since it was part of the finale.

I do sense some negativity towards Hung. I actually thought he showed some humble pie , which we have never seen before (admitting that his food was not his best) and he was quite obviously nervous when describing his EC fare to Eric Ripert (lordy his accent is sexy!) You may not believe in his heartstring-tugging monologues, but anyone who watches him can clearly see that he truly LOVES cooking.

I also have to say something about Dale: in the beginning, I really liked him and thought he seemed like a nice guy. Towards the end, he seemed extremely whiny (did he REALLY think that Hung should have shared his knowledge during the Le Cirque QF?!) and his trucker-mouth language was/is totally tacky and a big turn-off. I couldn't care less about his gayness - that has no impact on how I perceive or feel about someone. (eg, I think you, Ted, are awesome, period. Not because you are gay and not despite the fact that you are gay) . I also am not into labeling people - that's Lorren, my Jewish friend, that's Jane, my Chinese friend, that's Dale, he's gay ....

Casey is awesome- would be happy if she won. But, as is the pattern that TC editors have created, it was obvious that Casey's dish was not going to be good. In all 3 seasons, when one of the cheftestants states "I'm from so-and-so place, and I can cook ------", a failure inevitably follows. Another example : during the BBQ challenge, Tre mentioned something about being from Texas and knowing BBQ- his dish was terrible.

Nuthin' much to say about Brian- didn't feel strongly one way or another. Best of luck.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:37 PM

Amy wrote:

It never bothered me to hear Dale talk about his sexuality. I actually think his transparency is part of what makes him endearing. As for who should win....I want it to be Dale, I think it will be Hung, but I think Casey deserves it. (If that makes sense.)

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:39 PM

Austin wrote:

Ted,

I am a right wing Chrisitan conservative working at a right wing Christian conservative lobbyng group in Washington DC. Love the show. You are the best. Hung wins.

Austin

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:50 PM

Colin wrote:

Well said, on all accounts. I am also proud of Dale, and I felt for him a lot when he opened up at the end. (I still think Casey's got this in the bag, though, unless Hung's arrogance doesn't impede his performance as it usually does and he manages to pull of something mindblowing.)

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:51 PM

Flora wrote:

I think it will be Casey. But my heart is with Hung. To me he is the true chef of the bunch. Dale and Casey are cooking now, but there were times I think they played the game and hid. Hung was always out there, always trying, always creating, always cooking.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:54 PM

Jack Lin wrote:

Ted
you are a bit hard on Hung. After reading Adrian's blog, I found more sympathy for Hung. I too am a product similar to Hung, of immigrant background from East Asia. I can tell you that when your whole family is cooking and more, Hung was taught to be competitive, and sought out approval (technique - as it is a more tangible measuring "stick") for mark of excellence, rather than taste, as it varies from person to person.

Although not in the culinary field, I am in realm of organic chemistry. I can relate to some of Hung's trials and tribulation. Similar to Hung, I was technically sound as a chemist, but needed to be more creative and imaginative as I move forward in my development in graduate school. I hope Hung can improve both as a chef who would cook with more of his passion, but may need to understudy with someone who can bring passion and a bit of humilty to him. I still think he has a career in food, but needs some soulsearching to break out of the shell he is on now.

Jack

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:55 PM

miltonia wrote:

You are hilarious, Tim, and I love your personality assessments. Very insightful. i agree that Hung seems to be the type of kid who would draw his arm close around his exam so you wouldn't cheat off of him. Dale is super cool--love his whimsy and I think that comes through in his cooking. Casey seems to be the safe one. The all-around solid one. The consistent one. I'm suprised you didn't go into more detail about how her looks have or have not come into play in her career. I thought that one episode from Le Cirque where the chef said she was good-looking was just totally off-putting. I'll bet Casey has had to put up with that a lot. It's such a burden to be attractive and talented, isn't it? Glad you survived Miami. I grew up there, and the frizzy hair in each episode reminded me of why I needed to leave that humidity-infested swamp.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:55 PM

Jack Lin wrote:

Ted
you are a bit hard on Hung. After reading Adrian's blog, I found more sympathy for Hung. I too am a product similar to Hung, of immigrant background from East Asia. I can tell you that when your whole family is cooking and more, Hung was taught to be competitive, and sought out approval (technique - as it is a more tangible measuring "stick") for mark of excellence, rather than taste, as it varies from person to person.

Although not in the culinary field, I am in realm of organic chemistry. I can relate to some of Hung's trials and tribulation. Similar to Hung, I was technically sound as a chemist, but needed to be more creative and imaginative as I move forward in my development in graduate school. I hope Hung can improve both as a chef who would cook with more of his passion, but may need to understudy with someone who can bring passion and a bit of humilty to him. I still think he has a career in food, but needs some soulsearching to break out of the shell he is on now.

Jack

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:55 PM

Scott S. wrote:

I couldn't agree with you more on the trout. They should have had a kitchen to work in. At this point in the competition enough already with the standing on one foot and hand tied behind your back , now cook schtick.

Your current blog brought me back. I appreciate your explanation on all therein. I assure you that you can find intolerance on both sides of the political spectrum and you should not ignore it. You should not let your preconceived notions that those on the right are not as intelligent or are less tolerant. The vast majority of us are either just right or just left of center -- so get the chip of your shoulder.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:58 PM

Rebecca wrote:

Ted,

You are SO wonderful. I enjoy your insight and expertise. I think Casey may win.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 1:58 PM

Bonny wrote:

This is your best blog yet! Earlier in the season, you seemed somewhat tentative and eager to please. In this blog, your writing is effortless, warm, and engaging. Thanks!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 2:02 PM

alabama cook wrote:

Ted, you crack me up! I had a boyfriend who was funny and sweet and could cook, and 20 years ago did the smart thing and married him. If Dale hasn't found someone who will appreciate him, he will. I too was happy to see Dale win, even though it meant Brian's demise. And like many judges and bloggers, I don't see Hung's heart in his food. Last week's challenges were extremely technical, mimicking someone else's food, and he did the best. But to cook with intuition, which is to cook with abandon, I just haven't seen that in Hung.

Casey has surprised me these last weeks. Like Dale, she is coming on strong at the end.

I'm looking forward to the finale, though I'll be sad to see the end. I've enjoyed this TC the best of all three.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 2:03 PM

keely wrote:

The Quickfire challenge was bloody ridiculous! I am wholly surprised that the contestants weren’t required to fashion a glad trash bag into waders, chaps or a vest to be judged by Tim Gunn. The elimination challenge was almost as bad – what a mockery of theses talented chefs. What will the challenge be next week- recreating a Sandra Lee Tablescape followed by homage to Paula Dean’s Tuna Casserole? This was a dreadfully disappointing episode.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 2:03 PM

Alice wrote:

Ted,
As always your blog is a fun read. Thanks for the entertainment.

Please tell me they are not going to torture these chefs one last time by making them wait until next week to find out who actually is the top chef. From all the ads I have seen about making the announcement "live" for the first time ever it is really beginning to sound that way. If so, that was really a mean last thing to do to them after all the pressure and frustration leading to the last episode. I hope I am wrong in this "assumption".

Thanks again for a good read and enjoy your final season on your show.

Alice

posted on September 27, 2007 at 2:04 PM

Mead wrote:

I'm a little surprised but a lot pleased to see Ted take Dale's back regarding Dale's forthrightness about his sexuality. Although Dale's obviously more up-front than I am, I think Ted's on-point a lot more than some straight people realize -- gays go through life with constant reminders that we live in a mostly straight society... it's that fact that makes some straight people uncomfortable when Dale says something like "I'm queer and I'm gonna outcook your ass."

About the TC Trout Quickfire... given that the Big Four have arrived in Aspen and the judges are really supposed to be focusing in on who is the best chef, Ted, don't you think maybe TC should have developed a Quickfire that would have really showcased skills? At leats one cook had a treestump table that fell over because it was on uneven ground, which doesn't seem to show off someone's skills. Hopefully the final quickfire will be a little more even.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 2:13 PM

techchick wrote:

You asked-I think it will be Casey, unless she lets the pressure get to her as was alluded to in the tease for next week's show. Casey totally knocks me out! Her food is right on, and she does amazing, creative, and delicious things with whatever task she is given. She handles other people quite well, even when they are totally out of line, and to me, this is a great indicator of who should be Top Chef. She, so far, has been unflappable, which is rare to see in a Chef of her caliber. Dale is really a close second, but he does let the pressure occasionally get to him although he manages to think on his feet. Hung is definitely talented, and I think with a few years of maturity under his belt and a better attitude towards team work, he will be a force to be reckoned with. He is simply too immature to be Top Chef, no matter how we wields a knife.
Thanks, Ted, for saying what needs to be said about Gays on TV. We are who we are, nothing to be ashamed of, and deciding to hide it from discussions or interviews emotes a whiff of shame or wrongness to our individuality. We love who we love, nothing more, nothing less. Thanks for continuing to have a backbone. Can't wait for QE's final season! xoxo

posted on September 27, 2007 at 2:18 PM

Kim N wrote:

I would love to be the first to proclaim who I think will be the winner, but I can't. I love all three of them for very different reasons. There is no way TC can disappoint me with their pick this year!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 2:18 PM

Hoover wrote:

Ted,
Your blogs have been such fun to read, thank you for the entertaining words. I think Casey truly has what it takes to run a fine restaurant in every way. Hung is a little narrow in his classic only focus. Dale is a little wild and doesn't have the knowledge of the other two. Who will win? Let me open my Glad container and see.....I think Casey will win.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 2:20 PM

Shanes wrote:

Some spot on commentary, Ted. I agree, Dale's revelation at judge's table should go down as one of the most poignant and genuine moments in reality TV (something I suspect the genre was intended to capture at its incipience but has largely failed to accomplish). Dale is a fine role model, for gays and straights, chefs and us mere commonfolk. It's sad that anyone would be put off by his embracing his identity, but such is the heteronormative culture we still live with - yes, even in the Times-reading, Prius-driving, Cheney-hating world of Bravo Land.
Trout challenge was a little too whacky for this late in the competition, but as long as it's not one of those "Make a Pasta Dish Using Any of Our Fine Selection of Prego Ready-Made Pasta Sauces," I'm happy. [Please, Bravo, with ratings this high, do we really need all the product placement. I thought that's what commercials were for.] As for Eric Ripert, he always comes off as insightful and formidable but shockingly stiff. Eric, enough with the Al Gore impression (circa 2000). Show some more personality. You don't need to be a Tony Bourdain, but something better than the Bernadin XG-3000 robot would be nice.
All in all, a great episode, something hard to do on the heel's of last week's stellar FCI showcase. And can I conclude (my rambling, discursive diatribe) by noting how Padma has really come into her own as a host. She is phenomenal this season: sincere, spritely, and forthright. Bravo.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 2:25 PM

jim wrote:

Ted--thanks for your insights and comments. You are on target about being out and proud. Hung needs to go away. I love Dale, but Casey is by far the most consistent one of the lot. Casey will be the winner. (Besides, they need a woman to win--we've had two men already!)

BTW--Sam should have won Top Chef 2. Ilan, oh please!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 2:37 PM

Rique Harshman wrote:

Hi Ted,

Thank you for your blog! I've enjoyed reading your coment this season.

I totally agree with you about Dale! I am glad to have an openly gay chef on the show, too. But what I find more admirable is that he admitted to being in such a state of depression before entering the Top Chef competition.

I appreciate his honesty about his depression; his story was a truly inspiring one. He reminded us that dream jobs and relationships can be temporary, and it is okay to be depressed just so long as we pick ourselves up again and push through, full steam ahead. Bravo to Dale to returning to the kitchen after such a difficult year!

Now I'm really rooting for him to win!!

P.S. Why are people upset that Dale keeps mentioning the fact that he is gay? Haven't they noticed that in nearly every episode, Casey comments on how great it would be to have a woman win Top Chef, and how challenging she finds being a woman in the kitchen? Are these critics of Dale also upset about Hung and Sara M. referring to their experiences as immigrants?

Personally, I am just so happy that these chefs feel comfortable, secure, and honest enough to share their backgrounds on national television and give us personal insight into their food.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 2:37 PM

Sue wrote:

My call is Casey for the win. The judges have loved her food. Ripert said her food has "soul," which is so much more important than having technical skills. She's good at presentation. She's creative. She can work within many cuisines (as opposed to someone like Brian or last season's Ilan, who seem to keep repeating what they know). She's humble, which is nice in a winner who makes many public appearances.

And I admit, I'd love to see a woman win.

And thanks for sticking up for Dale. He can talk about his boyfriends and his life as much as he wants - isn't that what reality tv is for? The cheftestants on this show are so restrained compared to people on other shows who throw their lives and every opinion in our faces. Dale is a great representation that there are talented, fun, cool gay guys (and women) working in every profession in this country. (Watch out, haters - a gay man could have cooked that meal you're eating!)

posted on September 27, 2007 at 2:39 PM

Jenni wrote:

I would love it so much if Dale won this. I've watched this whole season and been really impressed with his dishes-- which is hard when you're just watching and not tasting the food (an unsolvable dilemma for this show, unfortunately).
I think he's the most creative of all the chefs of the season, and the most unassuming.
This season, I think all of the contestants were good people. I liked everyone and appreciated that the producers seemed to focus on the food instead of the backstabbing. It's refreshing, and I think it sets Bravo reality shows apart from some of the other networks.

A tip for judges-- describe the flavors more for us. As a viewer, it can be hard for the audience to appreciate why decisions are made because we can't taste the food. This season has gotten better about that, so maybe you're all aware of it, but it seems important to point out.
Maybe this is the trap of the reality tv world, but last season, audience members were basically left to decide based on personality and not food. More descriptive judges' comments make all the difference, along with the slightly longer shots of the final products. Describe the flavors and textures of the food and I think the audience will salivate more in future seasons!

thanks for a great show!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 2:53 PM

Alejandro wrote:

I want to see Casey or Dale win. I think on that period between NY and Aspen, someone approached Hung and told him that just in case he doesn't win top chef, he should try and enamored viewers who would go and eat his food with a story. I don't buy that whole "this goes for inmigrants story", is as fake as he is. Tom said it last night: "he is the best chef, technically" loved that technically, yes he has good techniques, but I think a good chef take risks, pours his heart on his food and is humble enough to admit when he screwed up. Dale and Casey have showed this a million times.

I also agree with the whole Dale being gay and talking about it, let him. Let him show the world that its okay, that we are normal, that we are the same, you go Dale.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 2:58 PM

Albert wrote:

Ted -- Thanks for the line about "The Other Side of Aspen." It was my morning chuckle. This is why we need a gay judge on TC. (Speaking of which, by my count, all three remaining cheftestants like men, no?)

posted on September 27, 2007 at 3:00 PM

galwithagun wrote:

Hey Ted!

Love your blog!
I just wanted to let you know that you need to add another Republican, or more appropriately Conservative, to your count.
I also wanted to let you know that not all on the "Right" have a problem with Dale's openess. I applauded his honesty and like his character, and it has nothing to do with him being gay or not. I appreciate yours. So, don't put all of us Conservatives in the gay bashing court.
To those who don't like it, you don't have to watch.
I think Casey will win. I don't think she is better than Hung, but if you have watched the last 2 seasons it is the chef the others like to work with that wins. Hung has made too many of his old competitors mad. Dale is great to work with, but I think he will choke.
Anyway, looking forward to next week's episode and reading your blog Ted!!!
Galwithagun

posted on September 27, 2007 at 3:01 PM

julia wrote:

Casey, Hung,Dale...they are all terrific...I think Hung's cultural background and the difficulty leaving Vietnam (it's not an easy out..the govt has to approve your leaving) plus the language barrier make it difficult for him to express his "soul". This was a great season because whoever wins they earned it!!!

P.S. Hung is a team player...remember the restaurant wars and Sara's kind words about Hung!!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 3:02 PM

Amy wrote:

Hi Ted!!
First, love, love, love you and I'm really looking forward to the Fab Five's return, but I wish it wasn't the final season!
My heart is with Dale. His soul is in this and I'd love to see him shine. But......I'd really like it if a girl could win sometime. Go Casey......and Dale!!!????

posted on September 27, 2007 at 3:07 PM

Fiona wrote:

I think I am the only person I know who likes Hung. Must be my right wing conservative Republican leanings!
In spite of it, I hadn't noticed Dale going on about his gayness! I am too busy waiting for you to do something about his HAIR!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 3:14 PM

Kelly Roberts wrote:

Hello, Ted:

What about the percentage of registered Independents?

I am hopeful that Casey will win. From the mid-point of this show through yesterday's viewing, she's been consistently the most focused, creative, and correctly-interpretative-of-the-challenge chef.

I'm keeping my fingers crossed. If she doesn't, I'm thinking a road trip to wherever she is working would be well worth it.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 3:16 PM

Riley wrote:

Why do you have to bring politics into TC? I'm a conservative who loves the show, could care less who's sleeping with who. BTW, I'm also very intelligent, which must confound your stereotypical leftist prejudice. Go Hung! He's the best chef and I think he exhibits plenty of 'soul' in his work.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 3:21 PM

Andrea wrote:

Ted,
As always, your blog is informative and entertaining.
As for the winner, my money is on Casey.
I previously did not believe that Dale was as talented as some of the other chefs. I'm not sure what made me think that, but I have since changed my mind. As a straight woman afloat in a sea of ignorance (I live in West Virginia) I'm thrilled to see Dale proud and unapologetic of who he is. He's talented, he's likeable, he's kind. He's doing society a favor by reminding America that he's also gay, providing evidence that those qualities can all exist in one person. I know I have some neighbors who haven't learned that yet. Plus he's absolutely HILARIOUS- I'd love to hang out with him.
I love Casey too. She's a STRONG woman, talented, competitive yet empathetic. I love it that she's an example of a professional female who doesn't break down and cry over every little thing, or start petty drama for no reason. She's an excellent role model.
I want to like Hung, I really do. I can usually manage to like him for about 70% of his camera time. It is when he makes statements that show that he believes himself to be superior and beyond criticism that I can't stand him. If he doesn't like being critiqued, perhaps he shouldn't have gone on this show?

posted on September 27, 2007 at 3:22 PM

Robert Breton wrote:

This is the best Top Chef ever. I loved hearing the personal stories of each finalist. I like Dale a lot--he's very down to earth and has a good heart. It was very touching to hear his peraonal story. I'm very happy to see him reclaim himself as a chef. I have no doubt that Dale will be on top of his game once again. While Hung comes across as arrogant at time, he's been through a lot and is a fierce competitor. I'm routing for Hung to open his own restaruant and set new culinary heights. I also like Casey a lot--I can tell she has a good heart and is passionate about her food. She may not be classically trained but has without doubt a talent for making good food.

It's hard for me to pick who I want to win. Dale is my "fan favorite", Hung is technically the best chef. but I think Casey is the best and will win. But all three are deserving of the title "Top Chef". Can't wait for next week's finale!

I also like Casey. i think she is the most talented

posted on September 27, 2007 at 3:22 PM

Michelle wrote:

Another attack on the "Right" out of left field. Please stick to food commentating please.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 3:26 PM

Jill wrote:

Dale has the courage to be who he is and to wear his heart on his sleeve. I don't think many people get the courage it takes to do this on national televsion. Clearly you get it Mr. Allen.
I adore Dale, he's funny, smart, creative, vulnerable cute and his "brain farts' (Anthony Bourdain) make him even more endearing.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 3:27 PM

Lisa wrote:

Actually, based on the previous seasons, Hung has the least chance of winning. Tiffany and Marcel both had lots of cooking abilities, but in the end it is the ability to also lead others that has been more important. Hung is not a very friendly person, and it will depend on his attitude towards his helpers that may decide his fate. Both Dale and Casey have a lot of personality and can easily win their assistants loyalty. I happen to be a Dale fan, but I can't predict anything. However, I can say that Dale should definitely have a bright future in a kitchen after this show, regardless of winning.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 3:35 PM

Anita wrote:

Ted,

Great post, as always! I did, however, really want more of your thoughts on the Elk challenge and how the gang faired--what did you think of that particular Cowboy/girl catered challenge?

I thought Brian went 'a bit' overboard--but, he seems like a big personality with BIG food to back it up. I don't think the dish lacked flavor--just focus. Brian's a cool guy and he'll bounce back, I have no doubt!

Dale's revelation of his tough year just made me misty! He is a sweetie and it was powerfully moving to hear him say that he's a chef again! Go Dale! I felt that his quickness on his feet, his ability to run with it when his "A" game fell through really got him that win! YAY Dale!

For me, however, this competition comes down to Casey and Hung. Hung with his technical genius and Casey with her big 'ol heart. Dale is the darkhorse--he COULD pull out the win and I would be glad to see it--but, his lack of consistancy in this season (as a whole) could be a mark against him.

The more I watch Hung, the more I like him! He started out so cold and harsh! He's hasn't turned inot a cuddle-bunny by any means! But, I've seen him open up more--him saying that under different circumstances he'd have been right in there helping Brian but, that this was a compeition was spot on and I applauded him for it. It IS a competition and he wasn't going to help the other guy! Good! He didn't stand there and mock him either! Hung is cool, he's calm, he thinks on his feet. He could very well be a winner.

I will admit to pulling a bit more for Casey! It would be lovely to see a woman take the prize (we came close with Tiffany!). She's warm and caring and passionate--it would be lovely to see her win.

Great casting this season and a great final because, honestly? I'd be thrilled with any of the three remaining chef-testants!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 3:49 PM

Joan wrote:

I agree - Hung needs to go. I couldn't reconcile the "it's all about passion and food" guy we saw last night with the "this is boring, this is stupid" guy we've seen all season. Why has he kept his personality - his cooking "soul" out of his dishes instead of taking something he thinks is boring or stupid and making it over in his style? Unless, of course, he doesn't really have one. Here in Texas, we call that "all hat and no cattle." Veiled Casey vote? Nope. I'll come right out and say it: Go Casey!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 3:53 PM

foodslut wrote:

Isn't technique supposed to work in service of flavor? Casey already got screwed twice in the previous (Cirque/French Culinary) episode when judges talked about her dishes (both quickfire and elimination challenge) having the best flavor and taste -- yet she won neither challenge. Although it's hard to get rid of the horrifying image of Casey mincing onions in the relay race (hey -- even us rank amateurs can dice a little speedier than that!), she has shown daring in conceptualizing dishes and the ability to wow people with flavors in her execution of those dishes of late.
Why should Dale not talk about being gay? Did anyone ever tell Tre not to mention he's African-American when he was talking about wishing to impress a particular judge? In season one, did anyone tell Tiffany not to mention her gender when she was discussing perceptions of her being pushy? Unless we want to eat food prepped by an automaton (ahem -- note that no slurs follow that straight line), then gay is part of who Dale is -- and I for one find that knowing more about who he is makes me more eager to try his food. More is the pity that Trio's gone -- Cheer on our ChiTown boy so we can all have a chance to eat his grub!!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 3:57 PM

Trish in NoCal wrote:

Ted,

Add me to Bravo's conservative viewership (and one who believes that love transcends gender). As far as who will win....

The problem I have with Hung is that he tells the judges whatever he thinks they want to hear. He tried to say he put "a little lemon juice" on his trout in the QF, and when Eric Ripert questioned him, he had to admit that he hadn't. He talked disparagingly about having to cook for cowboys and how uninspired he found the elk to be to work with, yet when asked by the judges what he thought of the challenge, he claimed to love it. The guy has some sort of emotion chip missing and while he has exhibited highly proficient knife skills and a superior knowledge of classical techniques, I agree with those who say his food lacks soul.

I like Dale a lot, and was amazed to hear that he hadn't cooked for a year prior to the competition. I admire his strength and belief in himself. I think his downfall lies in overthinking his dishes sometimes, but last night he showed an incredible ability to switch gears.

Casey has been my favorite since early on in the season. I admire her ability to stay focused and to see her dishes through from conceptualization to final presentation. I have seen many viewers make comments that suggest she's only made it this far because of her looks, and that angers me to no end.

I hope that Casey can pull off a win, and do it in such a way that no one can question her talent - but that would mean that Hung would have to completely fall apart and I have a hard time seeing that happen. Still, my money's on Casey.

Thanks for your insights via this blog, Ted - and I hope that we'll see more of you on the next season of Top Chef.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 4:05 PM

JennyJ wrote:

Hi Ted,

Great blog as always!

You asked so I'll tell you: Dale and Hung-- two polar opposites-- are my favorites to win. Either one of them , I'm happy. They both bring thought and personality to their work. Unfortunately, I'm not on the Casey party train. If she takes the TC prize, I may be tempted to curl up in one of the Glad Family of Bags. I just don't get her AT ALL. Maybe she's a nice person but she doesn't seem like a major chef.

In any case, thanks for your pithy remarks and insightful comments. Can't wait to see you again on QE. Cheers, Queers!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 4:11 PM

Pat wrote:

Ted
I love your comments - as a (Republican) Mom, I especially loved the rebuke to Dale. I am equally proud of my openly gay sister and my straight son... but I dont need to know about either's conquests.
But enough about that - Casey & Dale have been my favorites since the beginning - Hung is not a team player and does express comtempt when he wants to, so he can be emotional -just when HE wants.
Casey wins it all.. but I'd be really happy if Dale wins two in a row and takes it all.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 4:13 PM

Klayton wrote:

Tom,

You are absolutely correct about the inspiration Dale brings being a strong, out, gay man! I'm proud of both of you!

Klayton

posted on September 27, 2007 at 4:19 PM

Raphael wrote:

What is up with all the Hung haters? Wasn't it made clear by the judges in previous seasons that the "drama" is of no consequence at the judge's table? I'm very certain it was you Ted who said "I don't care about the backstage drama" It is the final product presented at the judge's table that matters. I'm pretty certain that was you. With that said, why do any of the cheftestants have to qualify their passion for cooking? I'm quite certain you and Chef Tom have said "it is not about personality. It is about the food" So make it about the food. I'm not especially interested in knowing whether you think Hung's experience rings true to you. Who the hell are you to judge Hung's experience in America? Who are you to gauge whether his experience rings true? Ok, I get it. You favor the gay man and/or the cute little White woman from Texas, versus the Vietnamese straight man. Good thing there is no bias on your part, eh Ted?

posted on September 27, 2007 at 4:23 PM

anne wrote:

Dale should be just exactly who he is
and nothing else!
Who do I think will win....?
Not a clue! I think any of the top
three would do the title proud.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 4:46 PM

Yena wrote:

I was truly pissed off when I saw that 68% of TC viewers voted for Hung to be sent home. Thanks America for ganging up on the 'heartless immigrant with no soul'. Does a person really have to wildly gesticulate their emotions every time they want to come across as sincere? Hung may be a bad actor, but he is undoubtedly a great chef. When all the other cheftestants looked pissed off or scared, he was the only one in every single quickfire and elimination challenge to truly see them as joyful and fun challenges for him to undertake. For that reason alone he deserves respect.

I'm really sick of everyone whining about him not being a team player. He has helped out whenever he could just like everybody else (example: Restaurant Wars, Boat Challenge - to name a few). He also stated that if this was a real life situation, of course he would've helped Brian in this week's challenge, but they're not living in reality, they're living in reality TV. This is a competitive field, a place where each individual wins on his or her own merit and no one else's. It's as if people keep forgetting that [very important] fact. No holding hands with your safety buddy like in grade school. It's one of the reasons why this show is so badass.

All three remaining contestants are without a doubt great chefs who each deserve to win for his or her own reasons. And while it would be great for the next Top Chef to be a woman or a gay man, it would be just as great for the next Top Chef to be an immigrant. They all love food, and despite obvious appearances made by Casey and Dale, I think Hung loves it more. Also, Andre Soltner said he would rather hire Hung! On that alone, Hung has already won "Top Chef".

posted on September 27, 2007 at 4:47 PM

Kevin S. wrote:

Once again, thanks for the insight Ted. Always a joy to read your blog after another TC. I have been rooting for Casey all season. Not just because she's extremely attractive, but because I think she is the most genuine chef on the show, in my opinion. Until last night, we didn't really know anything about Dale, other than the fact that he was gay, not that there's anything wrong with that. Now, to here his story, it's understandable that he faltered along the way during the competitions but has finally found his footing. I'd like to see him and Casey step it up next week and send Hung packing. Either Dale or Casey would be ok in my book. Hung, well, he said it on the first show. Some needs to be the a$$hole and he's it. First he says he hates the challenge of having to cook elk. Then, at judges table, he says he loved the challenge. The whole sad immigrant story would have gotten to me if he hadn't been such a two faced liar about the challenge. Sorry all you Hung devoties, I don't like him. He's this season's Marcel but at least Marcel didn't appologize to anyone for being himself. Hung, well, enough said. One last note. Did anyone else notice that since Howie and Sara left, the "F" bombs have subsided? I'm retired from the U.S. Navy and trust me, most sailors don't swear like those two. Bravo should put a little "keep it clean" clause in the rules for this show. I'm a bit tired of Americans thinking that foul language is ok. Anyway, you rock, TC rocks and can't wait until the final finale. Later.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 4:53 PM

Kris K wrote:

Hi Ted!

LOVED the show last night, I think it was the best eppy yet. My heart goes out to all 4 of the cheftestants. Sorry to see Brian go, but it was his time. I wish him continued success back home.

I honestly don't know who I would choose for Top Chef. All 3 chefs are brilliant in their own ways. I was happily surprised that Dale won last night, and his story of unemployment, and getting dumped brought a tear to my eye.

Please don't label all conservatives as gay bashers or haters, that is so patently untrue. What consenting adults do in private is their business, not mine. You'd be surprised to know that conservatives value all American's civil rights. So please go easy on us, ok? Don't make generalizations. Thanks.

Anyhoo, I cannot decide who will be the Top Chef. Casey has really stepped up to the plate, Hung is amazing (I don't care if he's cocky, the dude is GOOD!), and I have Loved Dale from the very beginning.

I am SO excited for the finale next week, and I'm glad you will be in Aspen judging w/ Tom, Padma, and the guest judge. And, I thought E. Ripert was so damned sexy, what a nice surprise! (I still adore my hot baldy-man Tom C, though).

Cheers! Looking forward to seeing you on Queer Eye Oct 2! You rock!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 4:55 PM

Jo-Ann wrote:

Ted! Love your blog so much. I adore Dale, including his "gayness". Some people just do not get it. He is funny and personable. Dale reminds me of Jeffrey from last seasons Project Runway. Jeffrey had literally hit the gutter and pulled himself out to make something of his life and become a success. Dale's story last night was touching.. I was a total mush listening to him. Whether he wins or not, he is a chef again. I hope he wins, I really do. Casey is sweet and very talented, and if she wins I would not be unhappy. I just love the story of Dale... can't help it. Ted.. if Dale win's I guarantee a good cry. His reaction to winning would be from the heart.. don't ya think?

Thanks... love ya... you always make me smile!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 4:58 PM

Amber A. wrote:

I have given up being able to predict what will happen on TC. Dale, Hung or Casey deserve the title. Unlike last season, when after Sam's elimination, I didn't care about the outcome, I am on pins and needles waiting to see what happens. It looks like it will be a great ride to the finish. I am rooting for the popularity underdog... I cast my vote for Hung winning the title.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 5:02 PM

Pistol Pete wrote:

The shock for me was when Tre was eliminated. I always considered him the best. But now, Casey is the man, oops, woman. Stupid of me to not have noticed the difference...But I day dream. Casey will win hands down. Hung can't put his true emotion in it. To much of a mechanic, like Marcel, no inner heart. Dale is overwhelmed by being this far and is to emotional. Casey, however is cool, calm and focused. Can't chop an onion to save her cute..though. However she will win.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 5:03 PM

Mark wrote:

I would love to see Casey win. Living in Los Angeles where there are so many talented female chefs I find it hard to believe the show could go 3 seasons and not have a female winner. Regardless, what a great season and if the show makes more people aspire to chefdom, I can't wait to benefit from it.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 5:17 PM

KatD wrote:

Dear Ted,
I liked you so much more before reading your blog. Maybe it's the irrational Hung hatred you and Tom seem to share. (Probably no coincidence there, as you seem loathe to question or criticize TPTB on this show. Foreshadowing a loss? I hope not.)

There is nothing "icy" about Hung at all. If you asked most viewers, "Who's the most intense? Who expresses the most feeling about cooking?" I'm certain the answer would be, "Hung".

Also, your comments about his parents have a demeaning, negative tinge to them. Like Tom's crack about not showing enough Vietnamese influence in his cooking (WTF?), it's totally inappropriate to make those kind of assumptions. I'm quite sure you know nothing about HIS real life hardships and sacrifices--or his parents feelings about any of it.

I think many of the guest judges (including some of the other TC bloggers) would agree that Hung shows not only technicality and artistry, but also great passion for cooking.

I felt bad for him when Tom said, "We don't see you in food" (menaing "We don't see you in your food", but sounding like it was the wrong career). He looked crushed. I don't see how he can win when Casey (sorry, "Case'") is clearly getting the winner's edit. But one can hope....

posted on September 27, 2007 at 5:28 PM

VIckie wrote:

Ted...
Im lovin' your blog..thanks for keeping me entertained!
I hope Dale wins, but my gut is saying Casey.
As far as Dale and his sexuality, I for one don't care. He's drop dead sexy regardless of his preference!!
Thanks for making my day..
Vickie

posted on September 27, 2007 at 5:34 PM

Lisa wrote:

Hung is a fake. I don't believe he was sincere when he was telling the Judges what moved him to be a chef. Once he heard Ripert tell Casey during the Quickfire that he felt she put her soul in her cooking, he used that to try to fool the Judges with his ramblings (kind of like how he heard one of the Judges tell Joey he really liked that watermelon drink and then Hung copied it during the bbq elimination challenge at the beginning of the season). I find him so irritating. I wonder if he does "everything" fast? Gross.

I love Dale, but I really, really hope Casey wins. She scared me last night with that raw Elk, though - yuck. Good luck Casey!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 5:45 PM

Katy wrote:

TC contest is not a place for experimental; it is school's homework / practice. Dave tried plan A; failed, then tried plan B. He dumped the food out because of his mistake. Would I hire him for my restaurant, no, I don’t have the money to waste because of his experimental. Sorry Dale, please look for other restaurant. TC is do it right at the first time.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 6:21 PM

Phil wrote:

Ted,
As a republican, I'm sad to hear that you think everyone on the right is a gay basher. My issue with Dale the past few weeks is his bad decisions (plating 17 dinners for 18 airplane passengers) and bad food (his effort last week). That said, Dale deserved to win with his elk dish, which was by far the best use of elk and creativity that was shown for that EC. I was moved by his story and definately became a fan of the Windy City's offering.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 6:51 PM

gymomisita wrote:

As a Dallasite and a woman I'd love to see Casey go all the way, but my heart belongs to Dale. My daughter and I were so excited to see his win last night! As someone said before me, having found himself again - he's really already won. He's got a brilliant career in front of him whether he takes the TC crown or not. They all do.

As to Hung - his sudden attempt to show us his softer side seemed disingenuous to me. He is who he is. I often wonder how much of what we see is edited in just that way, so that we have just that reaction.

It's been an entertaining season. Thanks for your wit and wisdom.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 6:56 PM

anne wrote:

I wont be too disappointed whoever wins. I think it will be Hung or Casey. They have all shown a lot of talent. It doesnt bother me that Dale has spoken about being gay. That takes a lot of courage. This season has had a more well rounded talented group of chefs, although I loved Marcel in season 2.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 7:12 PM

Rex wrote:

I am not a chef, in fact, I can hardly cook, but I do know sports and I imagine the value the teamwork applies in the kitchen just as much as it does in a sports environment. That being said, I compare Hung to Kobe Bryant of the Lakers. Like Hung, Bryant has it all - Tremendous talent, skill, ability - but he's not a TEAM player. Bryant couldn't get along with Shaq, even though, together, they had won three NBA titles. The Lakers chose to keep Kobe and let Shaq go, and even though Kobe is still a great player, the Lakers haven't won anything since. On the other hand, former Laker Magic Johnson was extremely talented as a player, but he was also the consumate team player and elevated the play of those around him. The result? Five NBA Championships. So who would you rather have leading your team, Magic or Kobe? Hung may be able to get things done individually, but in this competition he hasn't demonstrated any sense of teamwork. Based on that, he doesn't qualify to be Top Chef. That is my non-culinary analogy.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 7:13 PM

Joo wrote:

I can't believe people are accusing Hung of lying about his passion for food or about his reasons for competing. He already said an episode or two ago that he wanted to prove that an immigrant can come to America, work hard, and become a success. It's obvious that his heritage and his experience growing up is a major motivation. His response was no less believable than Dale's story about depression and ex boyfriend which came out of NOWHERE. People are just basing their judgment on Dale being the humorous interviewee with a glib tongue versus Hung the arrogant ESL competitor who butchers plural versus singular at least once an episode.
Also I don't think Hung's response was based on Ripert's comment to Casey about soul. I think he was responding to Tom's critique that he didn't see Hung in his food, implying that Hung wasn't passionate about food. Hung looked flabbergasted by that remark.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 7:15 PM

Dug wrote:

Hung all the way!!!!!!!

There are no gays in Vietnam or, apparently, Iran.

If you're not Right, you're Wrong.

Having read Shiite on a stick here and there, thought it was my time. Good show.....keeps us all coming back for more. When does Season 4 start?

posted on September 27, 2007 at 7:17 PM

Christina wrote:

I am rooting for Casey - unflappable, artful, modest yet seriously talented Casey.

Hung could definitely win it but he is all about technique - the flavors don't look like they would stand out to me.

Dale on a good day could win it, on a bad day, definitely not

posted on September 27, 2007 at 7:22 PM

Christina wrote:

Love you ted! Casey and Dale are where its at. I'd rather eat their food any day - let Hung go cook for those technique automatons :)

posted on September 27, 2007 at 7:41 PM

Teighlor wrote:

I haven't ever gotten the "icy" vibe off of Hung; he just seems kind of young and goofy, yet skilled and proud, like his TC "forebearer" Marcel. It's like if Rusty Griswold could cook, he might be Quickfiring it up with his protozoan brothers Hung and Marcel.

I am shamelessly and vociferously rooting for young Dale. I tend to apply the "Who would you most enjoy having a beer with?" modality that so many others (unfortunately) use in choosing a president (And seriously, who wants to have a beer with Bush? He'd just make me run out and score blow, then corroborate whatever half-truth he fed his wife to avoid castigation). Food-wise, Dale had me at pierogies. He always makes food that looks ever so préparez pour être mangé.

With the exception of Dale, this season is not unlike watching flies mate.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 7:52 PM

Juliette wrote:

Who will win? Well, Season 1 made Tiffany the villain and Harold the nice guy. Tiffany won.

Season 2 couldn't make Ilan into a nice guy (proving there are SOME limits to editing), but edited as much as possible to at least try to make people dislike Marcel. Ilan won.

Therefore....

Since Season 3 is giving Casey ("Case" as Tom fondly calls he),the "America's Sweetheart" edit and trying to make people dislike Hung (even turning "highly skilled" into a negative)....

Very easy call. Casey will win.

Still I can hope....Go Hung!!!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 7:53 PM

Mary Hart wrote:

Ted, thank you for pointing out that although Hung's litany about his immigrant background is true, the way in which it was expressed smacked insincere. In addition, the more he goes on about soul -- gimme a break, it's as though he'd hired an image consultant who gave him the words, but not the tune.
I'm pleased you defended Dale's right to make sexual references. Will admit that at first I was put off, but brought myself up short: would you ahve the same reaction is he was hetero? NO, and in working on my tolerance, I've come to appreciate Dale's humanity, and am pleased to have recognized consciousness raising. (Whoops, I just admitted to being a child of the sixties!)
I enjoy your wry/warm sophistication, Ted, and you're always a welcome additon to Chef's Table.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 8:21 PM

chef from south park wrote:

go hung !

posted on September 27, 2007 at 8:32 PM

Max B wrote:

Does anyone else see that everyone in the quick fire was trying to scale the trout. WTF? You don't scale trout has anyone ever cooked it before you don't need to scale it.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 8:43 PM

Danelle wrote:

Well said Ted! I was SO happy to see Dale win last night. After putting himself on the lin time and again, it finally paid off! It was a great moment & I hope he still plans on opening a restaurant in Chicago so I can make reservations! Kudos to Dale. I think the whole issue with him being gay is ridiculous! Get over it people, he isn't insulting us straight! Don't we have bigger issues to look at?

It was great to see some emotion from the judges this week. Chefs are artists and if they don't take the judges comments to heart then they do not belong there. And is was great to see the judges show a softer side and allow the chefs to give some personal insight to their dishes.

I do admit I am pulling for Dale and Casey. It was great to humanize Hung, but I think he needs to develope another aspect of himself.

Good luck to Brian, it was fun to watch you!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 8:49 PM

Catherine wrote:

Hey Ted,

Republicans have heart too. I love Bravo. T.C., P.R., Q.E.. Isn't it wrong to stereotype a group of people and because they might have a few common beliefs. I totally support gay rights. Have several gay friends.

If you met me you'd like me and we could easily be friends.

Looking forward to the new season of Q.E.. Next to you I really love Thom. He's hot. Sometimes I get disappointed when I find out a guy is gay only because I wish I could date them.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 8:53 PM

Charlene wrote:

Ted,
Usually, your blog is hilarious and insightful. This week, though, your comments about Hung were troubling. By describing him as "icy," emotionally unconvincing, and a hardworker who keeps his head down, you (unintentionally) reinforce many of the existing stereotypes about Asians and Asian-Americans. Call him arrogant if you want. He often comes across that way. Call him someone who isn't a team player. Just don't use language that brings to mind a set of harmful and troubling attitudes.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 9:33 PM

Lee wrote:

Ted,

I sincerely appreciate that Dale is comfortable with who he is and has confidence to express himself. However, the "Dale as the 'Big Gay Chef'" angle that has played repeatedly throughout the season has become tired, and is an over-simplified presentation of someone who, I imagine, has a far more complicated and interesting personality.

I suspect that much of this can be attributed to TC editors. I wish that the editors had left a few of the many "Big Gay Chef" references on the cutting room floor, and replaced them with a few more details associated with Dale's rise, fall, and rebirth as a man and chef. I find that story to be far more intriguing.

Thank you for your blog. I enjoy reading your commentary and appreciate your perspective. I look forward to next week, and hope you will continue to be a part of TC for seasons to come.

P.S. Count me as one of your (many) Republican fans.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 9:38 PM

Shannon wrote:

SHUT UP TED. SHUT UP.

I am sick of a cooking blog being the springboard for your political ideology. I am on the Right and damn proud. I appreciate fiscal and personal responsibility. Sorry if that makes me provinical.

I don't care who sleeps with who and many of my friends over here on the Right feel completely the same (SURPRISE! We also care about the environment and think a woman should be able to choose! Egads! The Earth has changed tilt!). I think sexuality is overblown in this country- both hetero and homo- and I wish people would simply be content and discreet. Maybe seeing a boob wouldn't be seem so torrid if we didn'y have overt acts of sexuality discussed at every turn.

I hope Dale is more than a gay man. I hope he is a fine son, decent friend, etc. There is no need to make a distinction about about being a homosexual in this capacity- it is TC, not The Bachelor.

I know I don't want to be soley identified by who I sleep with, I'm sure Dale feels the same.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 9:41 PM

Fravo wrote:

In regards to Dale, this isn't Top Gay, its Top Chef. He deserves to be in the final because he stepped up his game at the right time, and he has taking chances that have paid off for him. I am glad he is there, and I like his catty one-liners, but I don't think he should win for being gay just like I don't think Casey's being a woman or Hung being Vietnamese is more important than the food they prepare.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 10:02 PM

Violet wrote:

I hope Hung will be judged in the final, base on his talent than his personality.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 10:09 PM

Joe Ticer wrote:

Ted,

I am very disappointed in you. Your condescending description of Hung is bordering on racist...and coming from someone who must have experienced isolation and discrimination growing up....I find your insensitivity unforgivable.

Just because emotions are worn on your sleeves, as our society seems to relish in...you seem to get giddy pleasure in mocking somone who takes pride in skills and creativity in their cooking. Just because Hung does run around and prance around like a fool is not a definition of heart and sould.

Shame on you for not trying to be sensitive of other cultures and people. Truly sad that you are kept on this show!
--jc

posted on September 27, 2007 at 10:25 PM

dave wrote:

Dale's gonna bring it home for Chi-town. It's about time the 2nd city got some love. Im very excited for Top Chef Chicago...hopefully we see Charlie Trotter and Grant Achatz (health permitting).

PS-when you are in Chicago next, get some encased meat from "Hot Doug's". you will thank me for the rest of your life.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 10:41 PM

RonOfKs wrote:

I was SO excited when I mistakenly thought I'd seen Ted Allen, a man I admire and respect for his seemingly polished perfection, make a grammatical error! "What botherered me was the conditions" (versus "...were the conditions.") Of course, the implied "That which bothered me..." makes the singular tense correct. I'm not bothered that Ted was correct, after all, only that it felt SO good to feel the connectedness one feels when people they've placed on a pedestal display our shared vulnerability for making mistakes. But honestly, Ted, you don't need to make grammatical mistakes for me to realize that you have deep insight into that vulnerability we all share, which is why I enjoy watching and reading your comments so much. I loved your comments about Dale's openness about being gay, because you're speaking from that center of humility, with your own formidable, refined and dignified voice, reminding everyone that, at our core, we're all much more alike than we are different. Very few of the weekly bloggers here can move me to the point of tears like you can. (But, then again, I live in Kansas, so what the *@!# else do I have to occupy my time!?! ;))) Keep up the good work!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 10:47 PM

Jon wrote:

Look, I am getting really tired of hearing the comments about how Hung does not have the heart to cook. Being from Vietnam, he has probably surpassed more hurdles in life than Casey and Dale.

Last time I checked, Top Chef was a cooking competition, not a talk show. Casey can't cut even cut onions - why should she win? She, more than anyone else on her Restaurant Wars team deserved to be cut. (It was an egregious mistake to cut Tre... he, more than any other chef, had more to show us I think.)

It's like Election 2000 again. People on this blog want to vote for the chef they prefer to have a beer with - not the one who is most competent. At this point, it's a slam dunk that Hung should win it.

posted on September 27, 2007 at 10:58 PM

Tannya wrote:

Without a doubt, I think Casey will end up being Top Chef. It will be a close race between she and Hung, and honestly, I would like for Hung to win. A lot of the chefs who don't win on this show go on to have great careers but for Hung it's about more than boosting his career. For Hung it's about making his family proud and in his culture, that's where his stellar work ethic comes from. Having said that, Casey has consitently wowed the judges with the taste of her food. With the time, ingredients, and freedom to put a polish on that flavor and present a truly spectacular dish, I think she will pull it out. Dale, I love you, you big, gay chef, but it ain't your time. If Top Chef was about heart and personality, you'd win, but, alas...
Don't give up on your dreams, Dale. Your time will come!

posted on September 27, 2007 at 11:01 PM

Deborah R wrote:

I'm tickled to see you'll be there when the fat lady sings and can't wait to read next week's blog. Who will win? I can't imagine--and won't that make for a grand evening of suspense? Who do I want to win? That's tough, too. As a woman who's been verbally slapping the noses of male bloggers for labeling Casey "eye candy," I'd love to see her take the prize. Though Hung's arrogance is infuriating, there have been moments throughout the season when he's seemed almost vulnerable, and yes, even soulful. I could live with a Hung win. Then there's Dale …

I posted last week that Dale has been my sentimental favorite from the get-go, though I couldn't imagine why because our life experience couldn't be more opposite. And then I listened to his story, and I understood. Though I'm not a chef and haven't recently been dumped, my creative journey of late has mirrored his. I'm still trying to find my way home, and hearing him say "I'm a chef again" was an unexpected gift of inspiration. Some things do indeed transcend gender and sexuality--and the television screen. So if Dale wins … well, tears of joy will be shed at my place.

And since I can't resist …

Raphael: You've accused Ted of favoring the gay man or the cute little white woman over the straight guy. But in an interview that aired on the show earlier in the season, Hung said he's bisexual. Any other theories on Ted's bias?

posted on September 27, 2007 at 11:24 PM

Kailuacats wrote:

I like all three finalists. Being a semi-right wing conservative Christian (I'm pro-choice, so I'm the raving liberal in my family), I find no problem with Dale or his sexuality. I DO, however, like what he does with food. AND, I think he'd be a real fun guy to party with. Casey, with a few blunders (Sriracha in ice cream? Bleh), is still worthy of the finals, as is Hung. I, also, think Hung is one of the technically best chef in this season. I do not, however, agree that he shows no heart in his cooking. I did not like Hung for a long time. I started liking him when they had to cook out of the glorified "roach coaches." He was actually having a great time being one of the "guys." He may not be as "lovable" as Casey and Dale, but I think I can partially realize where he is coming from. No, he's not your "reserved Asian." He is, however, a person who is proud of his background, family and cooking. As proud as Sarah is. I think most people who live around people who have immigrated from Southeast Asia will realize the hardship they, or their parents, had to endure to make it to our country. Their desire to make their parents proud imbues every action with energy and love. Hung has made mistakes in the kitchen, mistakes of enthusiasm. His sin was not being sensitive to the feelings and work ethics of others. So be it. I still believe he could be an excellent executive chef if he could learn from this experience (maybe working with Tre, he seemed to bring out the fun in Hung). That said, I hope Dale wins because of his heart and passion. I hope Casey wins because of her imagination and just plain good food. And, finally, I hope Hung wins so others will know that you can come from nothing and, with imagination and perseverence, achieve excellence in whatever you do. There, that wasn't too bad, was it?

posted on September 27, 2007 at 11:32 PM

Jess Haberman wrote:

Ted,
I always look forward to reading your blog, but this episode in particular made me wish you were sitting next to me on the couch just to get your immediate reaction. I'm totally with you about Dale. I don't think he's THE top chef, but I'm still rooting for him. And I also agree with you about Dale's (imo) fairly sporadic comments related to his sexuality. Not to have a "we're here, we're queer" moment or anything, but Dale's got it right; he's got a lot to be proud of and it's inspiring to see him realize it after being through a rough patch. I wonder if those same gay-silencers have the same problem with Hung's "I swing both ways" comment... somehow, I doubt it.
Keep it coming Ted!!
Jess

posted on September 27, 2007 at 11:42 PM

redlem wrote:

Good for Dale, why you would think otherwise is beyond me, except for religious reasons.

Upon reviewing the opening credits I dont know why I did not pick out Casey as a Finalist. The whole hair flipping thing works and serves as a major marketing item and tool.

I have predicted that she will win, the onion cutting episode, and my only question is how much it cost Eric Rippet to say that she has soul, perhaps a little of his?

posted on September 28, 2007 at 12:04 AM

prudence wrote:

Brian is a class act you say? I guess it depends on what you consider to be class. I thought the man made to much noise and he failed to cook a number of times. I was never impressed with him.

The first part of Dales story was heartbreaking. I'm pleased there was an avenue like TC to get him motivated again. As far as the breakup, that's more information than I need. It's not unusual. Most of us have been through something like that at one time or another.

I have realized from day one that Hung (who I'm not crazy about) is passionate about the food he prepares. His personality or lack there of in no way suggests to me he cooks without heart and soul. Say what you will but one really has nothing to do with the other.
When I eat out all I want is a good meal. I don't care about the chef's personality as long as I'm pleased with what's put in front of me. I'm more than likely not going to meet the chef anyway.
Working with a number of chefs I can tell you many of them aren't very nice. The taller the hat the more obnoxious they become. (not all but some)

I believed everything Hung said. Why would he lie? For you to say it didn't ring true but you believe it was true, makes absolutely no sense to me.

Most of us know by now that Casey is favored by many of the judges. Each time I read some of these blogs I'm overpowered by that fact. Anthony's blog almost rammed it down your throat.
It seems your partial to Dale as well.

I'm not taking anything from Casey or Dale, especially Casey. She seems to know her stuff, but so does Hung. He deserves a little credit too. It seems the closer we get to the finally, the more he's being criticized. They were cooking Elk in the EC. What asian flavors did they want him to add?
It seems to me they cook within the guidelines they are given. Turn him loose on his own if you want him to cook ethnic food. I thought Tom was really harsh and coming out of left field with that one. It seemed like an unnecessary put down. I don't think it was racist (I don't believe Tom would so that) but it was certainly uncalled for. A comment like that leaves room for a wide range of interpretation.

posted on September 28, 2007 at 12:27 AM

matt wrote:

Teaching at Berkeley, I would occasionally have students like Hung: talented, intelligent, creative, and self-involved to the point of being almost incapable of noticing the needs and feelings of others. That last is what people are reacting against in Hung, but I have a hard time holding it against him or others like him. It may be some years before they ever encounter another of their talent, and arrogance can easily set in. Their singular devotion to themselves fuels their art.

That said, I think there is also a cultural dimension to how he comes across. He comes from a culture valuing harmoniousness (I think that shows in his dishes) and discouraging self-aggrandizement, but he is being put into situations, that, except for the restaurant war (in which he was a fine team-player), reward competitiveness and showmanship. He recognizes the situation for what it is and is trying to live within its rules, but, I think, the fit is awkward, and he doesn't always know when to go with his instincts.

Let me also add that I am enjoying more and more Dale's way with words. It's at a level we rarely see in reality tv.

posted on September 28, 2007 at 12:29 AM

philosifur wrote:

I think the percentage of conservatives who watch the show is higher than you think. There is still opportunity before decrepit dotage envelopes you to recognize in the fullness of time that conservatives were, and are, largely correct.

As for who will win....clearly the real competitors are Hung and Casey. Dale is the dark horse.

Of Hung and Casey - I think Casey has the edge. If Hung will add a little more of himself to his finale cuisine, along with those much ballyhooed technical skills, he could easily come out on top.

At the end of the day, I would say it's too close to call between Casey and Hung.

posted on September 28, 2007 at 12:34 AM

Angie Adair wrote:

Thanks for letting us know where you stand on Dale's openness. Gad, it's so awesome that he doesn't have even one toe in the closet. No one should have to hide being gay. It's two thousand freaking seven; get over it, people!

I predict Hung will win. I'd rather it were Casey, but I think he's overall the better chef and can draw on a better set of skills as the competition climbs to ever higher levels. This is pretty much how Season 1 played out. Harold's classical training gave him an obvious advantage that became more and more clear in the finale. Dale seems like a fine chef but has consistency issues and scatterbrain problems that will probably bring him down. Maybe.

posted on September 28, 2007 at 12:46 AM

Brian E wrote:

If all the Queer eye episodes are not in the can, Wouldn't Dale be a great candidate for the "Queer Eye" treatment? I'm sure He's ready to be made over and re-enter the dating scene. The final ascension out of his depression!

posted on September 28, 2007 at 1:03 AM

John wrote:

Holy Cow -- Ryan Idol interviewed by Andy Cohen and now a reference to "The Other Side of Aspen"! Woot! Bravo should come out with a Project Porno reality show! Love the blogs!

posted on September 28, 2007 at 1:16 AM

Susie Sandula wrote:

It's between Casey and Hung, Ted.

posted on September 28, 2007 at 1:34 AM

Virginia wrote:

Ted,
My first time here, and apparently, I've got some catching up to do on my reading. I'm delighted that it's funny as well as accurate. Thanks for both.

Casey is my #1 pick to win the title this time around. The girl's got her game on these days.

I thought Dale's story was a bit much, to tell the truth. Having been dumped by both a job and a guy, I wanted to shake him by the shoulders and give him a "you coulda had a V-8"-esque smack upside the head. With his charm and good looks, not to mention his finesse in the kitchen, he should never have let his own self-esteem dip so low.

The other guy just still annoys the beejeezes out of me.

posted on September 28, 2007 at 2:03 AM

rainbow wrote:

Ted-
Love your blog. I agree that Dale's story was moving, but I am also moved by Hung. Hung is the best chef on the show and is constantly berated for not playing the emotion card,but just enjoying cooking and competition, by not providing Dale with a tutorial before competing at Le Cirque. etc. I was very annoyed as well with C.J.'s transparent rants against Hung and then people being mad a t Hung for not bailing C.J. out by helping him plate. I don't think Hung is as aggresive in tearing down people as the other chefs passive agressively attack him. I myself think Hung is just a lot brighter than the others in the group, and their only way of competing with the smart kid is to go for popularity- tears, smiles, charm, fake self effacement , indignation ---whatever works.
But as a fellow liberal Ted,this all upsets me on an bigger level. Don't you agree that this is where Americans get themselves in trouble in this country and around the world? Don't Americans need to start valuing the facts of skills and intelligence over tawdry emotional demands and fake moral indignation as a substitute for reason and distorting facts? Or as Bill Maher so wisely says Americans need to stop acting like a bunch of 12 year old girls in their needs from the media , leaders and society. Yes, Hung does not talk like Oprah, but is that really necessary fronm a great chef? THey even went so far as to say he wasn't cooking Vietnamese enough! So shouldn't Casey the Miss Cogeniality bore-of-a-cook(I'm sorry but if she wasn't a woman would she really still be around after raw elk and cauliflower puree? How is that so soulful?) be serving something from her "ethnic background" OH wait that is what she's doing -boring strip mall chain restauranty fare that is a little more spruced up for t.v. I mean doesn't the world famous chefs from last week speak volumes. They would hire hung period. So before all of you freak out over these comments- thake a deep breath and maybe answer me this if you took away Dale and Casey's personalities,genders,personal stories and other irrelevent soap opera stuff and just look at the facts of Hung's skill -is there any comparison? If you were Hung would you want to resort to the low road of making it about all that stuff-when actually Hung like so many people not willing to play the face game in this country get maligned.I think that stuff genuinely embarrasses Hung. Hung has too much integrity for that, and if he had not known how to prepare something at Le cirque, he sure wouldn't have tried to cheat off other people. Let's choose a Top chef the way we should choose a president next time---not the one that is "great to have a beer with but not that bright" -let's go for the best one for the actual job.

posted on September 28, 2007 at 2:03 AM

PeachPie wrote:

Great post, darlin. Agree with you on all points!

Who'll be TC? I have no idea.
They all deserve to be.

posted on September 28, 2007 at 6:23 AM

Judi wrote:

(I get a kick outta your page instructions to 'keep it clean'...I had to mute Dale's commentary every time he spoke. Why are so many of the comments on sexuality...it's a cooking show!
I love Top Chef and never miss a show. Hung has certainly made it clear that he's the most technically quallified, but Dale and Casey are best for the 'Top' spot. Top Chef should be the most creative in cuisine, and be great at motivating the chefs around him/her. Hung is not a team player at all. Casey has been a consistent, constant, positive, creative contributor..
she's the Top Chef!

posted on September 28, 2007 at 7:45 AM

Karin wrote:

Great blog as always, Ted. But as to the important stuff, what do you think of Dale's haircut?!

posted on September 28, 2007 at 8:39 AM

Andy B. wrote:

Hey Ted, nice blog. I want Hung to win, but it would not bother me who wins. After all it's only a show, and I show I loved for three years now. All three contestants are worthy of winning, and the best performance should win. In the real world Hung is the best cook, with the best technical skills. He also works at Guy savoy, enough said. At least the cast this year are all good people, and displayed minimal drama.
I may be wrong, but on the attractions for this weeks finale, it looks like Dale, and Casey are at the judges table in a frame together with Tom saying, only one of you can be T.C., then you see a splice of Hung that looks like it's from another portion of the show. To me that shows, Hung was eliminated, and it's between Dale, and Casey. Like I said, I could be wrong. Hope I am.
As for you Ted, and your continue snide remarks about Republicans. It's not nice, I mean I'm not Republican, per se', but I am mostly conservative in my views, and as a T.V. personality, you should stop insulting people. I mean, we know your a liberal, Da -Your gay. No ones insulting you, so knock it off. I have no negative feelings toward gay people. Some of my friends, and relatives are gay. Just because I'm conservative doesn't mean I'm prejudice. Anyway on to the finale. I'm excited, and glad Top Chef is coming back next season. This is the only reality series I watch, and really the only T.V. PROGRAM too. Who will be Top Chef 3. Dale, Casey, or Hung. Three good cooks. Three nice people (yes Hung too), but only one Top Chef: A immigrant man, A gay man, and a lady. Any of the three would represent, the first win in their class. Anyone of the three, would be welcomed as Top Chef. So
lets all:" WATCH WHAT HAPPENS"

posted on September 28, 2007 at 8:59 AM

nel wrote:

I've only just caught up with this seasons Top chef, and my husband kept making comments about Dale being gay, but for some reason I was sure he was wrong, in fact last night I went crazy on my husband and shouted at him and said "HE IS NOT GAY"

Well after reading your blog, I was shocked to see I was very wrong, and had to ring my hubby and say:"Dale is gay."

I don't know where I've been if people have complained about it being too obvious!

By the way - Our best friend is gay and we mean nothing by speculating on Dales sexual preference....just idle silliness.

Cheers!

posted on September 28, 2007 at 9:53 AM

ss wrote:

Ted,

I found your comments about Hung offensive. Hung is talking about soul and his background because he was directly asked these question. Nice of you to concede that what Hung says is true - that's very big of you sitting behind your computer, to concede that Hung might not be lying. Every single contestant who came onto this show wanted media exposure, money and the chance to win Top Chef. The fact that Hung is the most openly competitive makes him HONEST.

I think you should stick to commenting about food and leave hypothesizing about the immigrant experience to others - your comments do not become you.

posted on September 28, 2007 at 10:01 AM

FanFare wrote:

Hi Ted,

Your comments are cute - just like you. However, you are very biased toward Dale. I like his great sense of humor and warmth too. However, it has bothered me that just because he "puts it out there" and takes bold moves, he expects that THAT alone should keep him in good stead. It would be better if his risks actually worked out. This time, this most important time, it did. That just means that he was more lucky than smart. The other minor thing about him that I find interesting is that he actually looks like a lizard (didn't he cook that in the first challenge?).

After last week's sublime show, this entire Finale Pt.1 was a major letdown. It was frustrating to watch any part of it.
The very notion that the chefs had to run around upon arrival at high altitude was very unwise from a health standpoint. A person from sea level needs to get aclimated before doing any heavy lifting or thinking.

The cook's confessionals did not move me at all. However, it did offer some insight into them. I wondered why Dale did not cook for 1 and half years (until I watched a rerun). Casey seemed bellicose. Hung seemed uncomfortable letting his guard down. Maybe you find Hung is no more than a cooking nerd in need of loosening up, but I find him reserved; maybe introverted to the extreme. He obviously enjoys cooking - just look at his face when he chops! Brian came off as too casual in his missive. But it was his time to pack it in. He coasted along on borrowed wings without cooking a thing!

Thank you again for joining the party this season. Hopefully, you'll stick with us. Overall, it was a much better, calmer season than S-2. Your presence at JT always holds the unexpected.

posted on September 28, 2007 at 10:43 AM

Sandy wrote:

Ted,

You just hit on another side of Hung's personality that I actually like. I get the feeling that he's a lot more "emotionally bumbling" than we think from the editing. He has ego and weaknesses, sure. He has moments of being an ass, sure. Yet I've always gotten the impression that he's got such a work ethic, such an ingrained compulsion to run and hurry and do, that he has no idea sometimes that he comes off as he does. I do think a lot of it is cultural, and I think you and Bourdain together verbalize why Hung is Hung. And despite all the problems, I like him.

I like all three of the finalists for some of the same reasons. All three are human, all three have some frailties and they all have stories.

As far as Dale and his gay cowboys... he's a human being who's love life informs his cooking. That's just so shocking. Spot on, Ted.

Who's going to win? I think, given the right circumstances, any of the three can walk away with it. I think Casey might have an edge, yet if Hung or Dale have the right service... its theirs. Good luck to all three!

posted on September 28, 2007 at 10:54 AM

Pam wrote:

Wow that was a good one,a real nail biter1! I am a true fan of Casey,and I was really scared for her last night. I do disagree,however,that the challenge was too rough. If you are going to be Top Chef, you better be able to cook on a burner!!! Many of us do it all the time. Before I knew I was going to be a chef I was cooking on a Coleman stove in parking lots at Grateful Dead concerts for years, and not grilled cheese.
I also like Dale,although I dont think he should win,and its obvious all these Republicans were offended by his comments about how many cowboys he's slept with. Big deal!!! The guy hasn't cooked in a year and a half,I give him credit!!To all you Republicans, just enjoy the show,your not going to run this country into a ditch for much longer!!
Casey is my girl,I want her to win,not Hung. The immigrant thing has gone on long enough.Technical cooking skills are great,but you have to be able to improvise at the last minute,alot,in the real world,just like Dale did.We havn't seen that from Hung yet. Plus his attitude sucks!!
Go Casey go!!!

posted on September 28, 2007 at 11:20 AM

Melanie wrote:

Ted, I think you and Gail might be the same person...you're never in the same place at the same time and I think y'all have the cutest outfits on the show.

posted on September 28, 2007 at 11:26 AM

Susan wrote:

Ted, I used to really like your blogs, but lately..... what's with all the political references? As I see it, bashing is bashing regardless of who the target is. Whether you are insulting gay people, straight people, men, women, Democrats or Republicans, it's still bashing. I'm neither a Rebuplican or a Democrat and I can't stand the current trend to bash and demean either one. You don't have to agree with someone's point of view to respect their right to have one. It's really no different from respecting someone's lifestyle. I can't tolerate using the terms "left" and "right" as insults. It's not making the world a better place.

posted on September 28, 2007 at 11:48 AM

Mary Hart wrote:

Doggone, Ted, my 1st attempt didn't appear, but am persevering because your comments deserve feedback! Am standing up (for the second time), to let you know how much I appre