July 12, 2006
Page 1 | Page 2 | Page 3 | Page 4
To those of you who read the blog and also listen to the podcasts (first, thank you!), please note my episode one podcast disclaimer: I had not seen a rough cut of the show as of that recording, so all of my babble was exclusively from memory. As of this writing, I’ve seen a rough cut, my memory is jarred into position, and I’m STUNNED about all that escaped me when making that recording. I’d like to promise that it won’t happen again, but one never knows. It’s times like this when I invoke “make it work” to myself!
Season 3 is launched! For our first challenge, Heidi announces that the source for this design is the contents of each designers’ Atlas apartment. The designers may only use the contents of their own apartment, but they may use ANY of that apartment’s contents (and they may not use things that they brought with them). They have 15 minutes to source in the apartments -- and all materials that they source must fit into a laundry bag that each designer received. I anticipated that they would simply GRAB anything and everything within reach, CRAM it all into their bag, and make material decisions in the workroom back at Parsons. For the most part, I was correct.
And also for the most part, I was quite pleased with the designs. However, issues pertaining to the fit of the clothes on the models proliferated. Fortunately, the judges were inclined to be more forgiving than less, because it was the first challenge. But listen up designers: the forgiveness is going to cease!
The divine and prolific Kate Spade is our special guest judge.
Keith wins! Keith edited his rather daunting cache of materials down to navy bed sheets and red buttons from a duvet cover. He created a halter dress with overlapping diagonal panels in the front and a fishtail in the back. The dress was beautiful and the construction laudable. The design was innovative, but I was concerned -- very concerned -- about the absence of innovation in his choice of materials. I mean, bed sheets? They’re cotton fabric, just like what he could purchase at MOOD, so what’s the challenge? I was certain that the judges would praise his design, but admonish his dull-normal material usage. Wrong. They celebrated every aspect of his work for this challenge, as demonstrated by his WIN. So: Shut up, Tim!
(Immunity comes with this win, so Keith cannot be eliminated in the next challenge.)
Comments
Ginny wrote:
Do you think Jeffery will fall into the "Santino curse", as HEidi had compared him to? I don't and hopefully he'll go far!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 8:40 AM
Linda wrote:
Hi Tim, I totally agree with you about Keith's dress. Great dress, but just a length of fabric. Also loved Laura's coat and Ula's dress.see ya Linda
posted on July 13, 2006 at 9:17 AM
Linda wrote:
Hi i forgot to tell you...it made me sad to see the apartment all torn up. Linda
posted on July 13, 2006 at 9:20 AM
cinda wrote:
I personally think they made the wrong choice in removing Stacey . Jeffreys outfit was sommething a baglady would wear . She should have been given another chance I'm sure you who voted against her know that you made a BIG mistake , after seeing the show . Jeffrey has NO talent , or personality .
posted on July 13, 2006 at 9:50 AM
Dee wrote:
I honestly thought that Laura's execution was ice, but almost predictable so runner up for her is fine with me. I actually thought the little red and white dress with the built in necklaces was really eyecatching, and I thought should have won. The winner's blue dress was boring. I also thought the leather skirt number was terrific. I wanted it! The coffee filter dress was up there too.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 9:53 AM
Peggy wrote:
No Tim, you are right, the winning dress was NOT INNOVATIVE -- pretty yes, minus the distracting oversized necklaces -- can we say ugly! The judges clearly did not listen to their own challenge. But this viewer has and says to them-- You are OUT!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:20 AM
Katie wrote:
Tim, you are correct, Michael should have been one of the three finalists and should have WON. Talk about creative...coffee filters, but also it was extremely feminine and fit perfectly. I think we will see great things from him...
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:24 AM
Max wrote:
I was very dissapointed that Robert Best didn't win this challenge. His dress was beautiful and modern. I thought Sarah was right to go. Jeffery is an ambitious designer, and his ambition got the best of him. The featers on the runway show? I wanted Jeffery to stay because I knew he would make some interesting designs this season. So with sarah down, the good designers remain. My personal favorites are Alison Kelley, and ROBERT BEST!!! His dress was awesome.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:25 AM
LINDA MONGAN wrote:
THE FIRST SHOW WAS A WINNER. LOVED IT. ALTHOUGH I AM STILL DISSAPOINTED YOU FOLKS DO NOT GIVE MORE YOUNG DESIGNERS A CHANCE. THE NEW YOUNG TALENT IS COMING OUT OF COLLEGE. I ALSO THINK THAT SOMETIMES THE DESIGNERS ARE PICKED FOR PERSONALITY REASONS NOT THEIR TALENT. I FEEL A GOOD DESIGNER NEEDS TO BE MARKETABLE. SOME OF THESE DESIGNS ARE JUST NOT WHAT WOMEN WILL WEAR. THE BIG MONEY I FEEL IS IN DESIGNING FOR WOMEN WHO ARE EVERYDAY. MOTHERS, CAREER WOMEN ETC. THESE DESIGNERS ARE JUST TOO ONE NOTE.
THANKS, LINDA
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:25 AM
Jenny wrote:
Tim - I agree that Keith's dress, though well-executed, was not innovative - for that, I was torn between Laura and Robert (with a slight edge to Laura). However, am I the only one who thought Michael's dress resembled Chloe's figure-skating dress, slightly? I guess that thought came to me after viewing Michael's audition.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:35 AM
MadBlogger wrote:
I was impressed with Laura's coat. Not something I would wear but I enjoyed looking at it.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:38 AM
Paige wrote:
I loved Michael's dress. To me, he thought more "out of the box" by using materials other than the obvious (curtains, bedding). Stacey's design was cute, but boring! She didn't change the materials much. It looked like a "draping 101" project. Plus, she couldn't use the equipment.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:45 AM
Suzanne wrote:
I think Michaels dress was simply beautiful. He was the winner to me.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:51 AM
Andrea wrote:
I absolutely love this seasons contestants. I feel that they are more diverse, interesting, and talented than the contestants of the previous two seasons. ALso, I love that TIm discusses aeach contestants designs. I hope he keeps that up. Bravo for season 3 of Project Runway!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:51 AM
Karen wrote:
Keith should NOT have won this challenge - way too boring. Robert's dress was so interesting from the front AND back - simply stunning. Laura's coat was gorgeous and different and I absolutely loved it. Michael's dress was also extremely clever. These three were the best in my opinion and I was rather surprised about the judge's decision. They picked the correct two that were the worst, but I think I would have sent Jeffrey home instead. At least with Sarah's dress, although the execution was poor, it was better than Jeffrey's mess - which was ugly beyond words.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:52 AM
Gregory wrote:
I watched Project Runway last night. While I liked the clothes, I think that some of them need sewing lessons. Stop into Sew Fast Sew Easy for sewing classes, sewing machines, sewing patterns, patternmaking classes and more.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:53 AM
c wrote:
what's up with the low expectations for michael? he brought some sophisticated pieces to the open call and displayed great creativity in the first challenge. i think he'll be a stealth contender for the top 3.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:53 AM
Carol wrote:
Hi,
Great show. I would love to have seen more of the other garments. The show seemed to focus on the work of the people who ended up in the bottom 3 and the winner. We didn't get to see any of the other garments while they were being worked on, and we barely get a glance of them on the runway. There were some very interesting looking pieces that I would have liked to have seen more of.
What's with the phone in? That is kind of a spoiler while you are watching, because then you know ahead of time who is going to be in the bottom 3.
I look forward to this season, looks like alot of talent and alot of possible hissy fits and confrontations. I can't wait to see who gets asked to leave!
Carol
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:55 AM
Sandy wrote:
I loved the first episode, especially when the designers had to return to the apartments they had destroyed and sleep there amid all the mess. One thing, though---everytime Malan started speaking it made me think of Austin Powers. I expected him to say, "Yeah, baby! Oh, behave!"
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:00 AM
Kelly wrote:
Can I just say that the what really keeps me coming back to Project Runway is how much I LOVE Tim Gunn! You are totally my favorite person on that entire show, and your blog is THE best!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:06 AM
James wrote:
I am SO excited about the season and all of the talent. I have predictions about the roles various people will assume. I am conflicted about Stacy's elimination. I think she has some talent, but it is a problem that she can't use the equipment. I simply did not like Jeffrey's dress. But he brings some of the Santino arrogance and drama, so he probably will stick around for a while. And Robert Best -- mucho talent. His current job actually seems dreamy. Finally, I also loved the coffee filter dress. Can't wait until the next episode. I hope Jeffrey will be out, but I doubt it.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:09 AM
Samantha Fisher wrote:
Didn't the promos say "A First" as someone will be asked to leave? Sounded like a designer broke the rules and was busted...but it didn't happen. I found the judging ODD, to say the least. The coat was magnificent and creative, as was the short white dress with red bows in the back. In terms of losing, I really thought Vincent's whole deal--dress as well as hat--was terrible. I think he got the sympathy vote--that's ok this time. Let's hear it for 401 K dumping?!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:09 AM
Kristin Pratt wrote:
I loved the Road to the Runway and the first episode. It was interesting to see the how much the designers took from the apartments and how little of it the actually ended up using. I think it was fabulous that they then had to return to the destroyed apartments and sleep in them! I agree that they phone-in is a SPOILER! You found out who was in the bottom three halfway through the show! I don't need an i-Pod that much.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:17 AM
Cyndi wrote:
I thought Michael's dress was beautiful and the most innovative. It also reminded me of Chloe's figure skating outfit, but I loved that too (thought it should have won), so that was okay with me. Keith's dress was a little boring.
I didn't think Stacey deserved to go home. I would have chosen Jeffrey.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:18 AM
TalentedMrWelles wrote:
Great comments Tim, I agree with most of what you said. I thought Keith's dress was beautiful, but I think Robert should have won. I HATED Vincent's fugly sack dress and that awful basket hat. He should have been Auf'd!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:19 AM
Caron wrote:
I too was very curious about someone being asked to leave "a first" the promos said. What happened with that?
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:20 AM
Todd Babbitt wrote:
What a great season this will be. My only concern is that the designers are too good. WHAT too good. Yes. I can see that once the bottom four or so are dropped off, that this talent group will produce such high quality that the show will lack the usual "how could the judges keep Santino-Pepper etc...emotion". Yeah it will be thrilling to see all the fantastic and beautiful garments, and I will be glued to the set no matter what, but I wonder if this season will lack the drama of the past ones. And it is in the end all about the drama!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:21 AM
Derek wrote:
Dear Tim,
We love the show so much that we bought the 1st and 2nd seasons on DVD and recently signed up for cable TV so we can watch season 3. In addition, we really enjoy and learn from your interactions with the competing designers. Whenever we watch an episode, we each try and pick the winner of the design challenge (not very original, I know). For the 1st episode of season 3 last night, my boyfriend picked Laura to win and I picked Robert - but as you know, we were both wrong. Oh well, better luck next time. The show is so much fun and we both think you are terrific!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:41 AM
Wendy S. wrote:
OMG - What a character Malan is! I hopes he sticks around for many episodes - he has already become that person "I just love to hate". Thanks for the laughs and entertainment.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:43 AM
Rosie wrote:
Hi Tim,
I was very disappointed that Keith's dress was the winner. It was not very innovative. I think Robert Best's dress was the best and most innovative. I also loved the coat and the coffee filter dress. I liked Stacey's dress a lot better than some of the ones that weren't voted off. Looking forward to seeing the rest of the shows!!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:47 AM
Molivia wrote:
"Project Runway" is off to great start. I agree with Tim and Jenny that Michael should have been among the top three while I too thought of Chloe's figure skating dress. The use of coffee filters showed MIchael's creativity and perhaps ability to edit but he needs to show more original designs -- more of himself.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:50 AM
Marvie Ross wrote:
Tim: Congrats on the fabulous season opener. Love you, undeniably the star of the show.
Disagreed with the judges on winner: Michael's dress by far and away the most innovative and lovely. Loser deservedly out.
My money on Laura and Robert duking it out for the prize. Can't wait for next Weds!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:51 AM
Crone wrote:
yeah tim you'll be the reason i watch this season. you and heidi. im hoping that someone somewhere will pop up and be like santino and make songs about you and andre going to red lobster or something.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 12:00 PM
Lolita wrote:
Tim Gunn, I love you!! Thank God for your blog, or we wouldn't know your opinions and other interesting details. I agree that Michael's dress deserved much more attention from the judges, it was innovative and beautiful. I feel they chose the wrong winner, based on his limited use of materials, his dress while very nice, was very common. Robert was the winner in my eyes, that dress was stunning to look at!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 12:03 PM
Shoshanna Moser wrote:
Looks like the third season is off to a great start, but no one on Project Runway is EVER more entertaining than Tim Gunn! You really make the show sing, and are one of the major reasons many of us keep coming back.
Keith's win has to make one wonder what the judges were smoking that made them completely forget what this challenge was all about. A far better choice would have been the furry coat, or the fabulous coffee filter dress (which was not only one of the most innovative designs since Austin Scarlett's use of corn husks, but was also one of the very few dresses that was actually pretty-- albeit in a fluffy sort of way.)
I do feel, however, that everyone involved in the casting of Project Runway should be profoundly ashamed of themselves for their decision to exploit the "great TV" potential of a man clearly one Prozac away from an across-the-board breakdown.
In the last two seasons we've seen what the stress and emotional strain of taking part in Project Runway has done to strong, focused, and basically well-grounded individuals; what on earth will it do to someone like Vincent? And what excuse could there possibly be for putting him in that position? Are we really supposed to believe that this man passed the psychological evaluation referred to in your blog as one of the hurdles faced by Project Runway candidates on their way to becoming finalists?
We in the audience are well aware that in the considerations of who is cast (and then remains) on Project Runway, talent is not the only factor-- personality plays a very big part. (Santino, for example, should by all rights have been out a number of times-- and unquestionably so after the lingerie challenge-- but was kept on because his presence made the show more exciting and significantly amped-up the interaction between the designers.)
For Season 3 you've brought in several colorful types who will undoubtedly contribute a great deal to the entertainment value (if not the design quality) of the show. But Vincent should not be there; you know it, and your audience knows it. I hope that Project Runway is prepared to take responsibility for what happens to him.
That one, very disturbing factor notwithstanding, the potential for the third season promises to be the best yet, and I wish you the very best of luck.
Shoshanna Moser
http://www.pbase.com/shoshanna
posted on July 13, 2006 at 12:03 PM
Jacqueline wrote:
Ooohh what a great season this is going to be. Keith should not have won - I agree with Dee - looked good - simple but where was the innovation of using various materials? I liked Michael's and Laura's - Robert is going to be definately in the top 3. His dress was stunning and unfortunately, the detail from the duvet was skipped over on the skirt. Kayne (sp?) the pagent dress designer will also be one to watch. I too was disappointed to be baited with "I'm going to have to ask you to leave" in the previews and then not see the results. I played my tape over 3 times thinking I had missed something.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 12:08 PM
Mary Ann wrote:
How could Robert not have won?!? At the very least he used more than one item to construct his dress and it was a classic design with a fresh twist. I loved it! I understand Keith's Carol Burnett/Gone with the Wind reference, but still I found no innovation in his design. I agree with the person that said Micheal's dress reminded her of Chloe's skating dress, however, I still found it to be original in it's own right and fantastic, by the way. Looking forward to the rest of the season! Later!Mary Ann
posted on July 13, 2006 at 12:09 PM
EasyMac wrote:
Last night's show was great! I am so glad Project Runway is back! YAY! My vote for best was MIchael - it was innovative, simple in design, well executed and looked great on the model and runway. I did like Robert's dress too except for those huge red bows on the back, I think I'd have reduced their size, :P. As for the loser, it should have been Vincent, obviously. His execution was as bad, if not worse than Stacey's and his design was atrocious! My 7 y/o could have designed that. But Stacey blew it with not using the machine - that definitely hurt the execution. Again, so glad to have Project Runway back. Love ya Tim!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 12:15 PM
Veendah wrote:
Dear Tim,
I Looove the 1st show. I agree that you have more interesting designers here. You and the judges did a great job at casting them. I'd have to agree with most of the comments. Keith shouldn't have won, yes..his entire outfit had drama.., the big hair, the big neckales, but the dress is way...boring, and like you said, "it's made of cotton bedsheet!", just like regular fabric you buy at MOODS. He has so much confidence, this win just made him way...too cocky. I absolutely adore Michael's dress with those coffee filters...it's divine. Robert's was cute too...innovative and I can see the Barbie influence. Vincent cracked me up, I was in stiches watching him trying so hard to send that basket down the runaway and actually put in on his model's head. My Gosh..., I have new respect for those models, they really put up with a lot, don't they. Tim, I can't wait to see the next episode. Who on earth did you ask to leave? It looks like someone is going to get booted out before the runaway. I can't wait!!! Oh..btw, Malan creeps me out. His laugh just sends creepy crawlers on the back of my neck!! HHhhuuuuuhhhh.....
posted on July 13, 2006 at 12:21 PM
Adjy23 wrote:
Hey Tim,
I agree the materials used for the winning dress weren't all that creative but I loved the design. I do think that there were other people who could have made it into the top three, especially the coffee filter dress. Overall, I mostly agreed with the judges' opinions. And I'm sorry Vincent's design was just plain garbage. Oh, and that awful basket he dared to call a hat. For someone who has been in the fashion business that long, I really expected more. Can't wait for the next episode. Luv Ya Tim!!!!!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 12:21 PM
Collin wrote:
I absolutely LOVED Laura's coat. Michael's comment was dead on "that's so her!". I also really liked Michael's coffee filter dress as well as Robert Best's design. Both were very stylish and were something you could see people actually wear. I was disappointed with Jeffrey's design and agree that it was just too much. However, I like that his perspective seems to be quite different than the other designers. I think his designs will add some variety to the runway which is important, because his style does appeal to a large audience that can be sometimes ignored in the fashion world. Great first show! I can't wait for future episodes!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 12:24 PM
L.Nichole wrote:
I absolutelty LOVED the 1st episode! Kudos to Project Runway and Bravo for keeping it creative and fresh. It was hilarious watching the designers rip apart their rooms only to find it left in shambles upon their return at the end of an exhausting day!
I think this round of designers are the best yet in terms of experience...but where's the personality? Past designers such as Jay, Austin, Uncle Nick, and even Santino kept us watching and laughing...I hope the new designers' personalities can match their talent. I'll definitely be watching!
By the way...my choice for last night's winner is Michael. Thanks for not using a bedsheet or a curtain...innovation is key!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 12:25 PM
Chris wrote:
I loved Robert's dress and have been a fan of his work with Mattel/Barbie for many years. I wonder if he has left or is leaving Barbie? It seems odd that Mattel would allow him to participate in Project Runway and state he wanted to move on to producing his own line if he was still working for them. I also thought Michael's use of the coffee filters was creative and beautiful.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 12:31 PM
Traci wrote:
I have a website suggestion. Would it be possible for the website to have pictures of the rear view of the fashions as well as the front view? Many of the most engaging aspects of the designs are from the rear including the winner's, Keith's, and Robert's. I would like to be able to click on the picture of the design and get a rear view, too. Thanks for your consideration.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 12:34 PM
Jeanine Curtis wrote:
I totally agree with Tim, that although it was beautiful and well made, Keith was not very innovative in his choice of materials. Laura, on the other hand, completely WOWED me! I wish she had won. Jeffery should have been the one to eliminate. It was ugly from start to finish. And the feathers? Puh-leeze!! As far as innovation goes, Michael takes the prize... who would have thought to make a dress out of COFFEE FILTERS???? But he pulled it off beautifully. Seems to me that the judges forgot the theme of the challenge. Finally, about the phone in vote... that's a spoiler for me. To know who's in the bottom 3 before we even see what winds up on the runway takes some of the fun out of it.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 12:35 PM
Piq wrote:
First off, my husband said I must email Bravo to let them know that we are extremely grateful they are giving us another awesome season of PR so soon after the last. We have been faithful followers of the show since PR1, and make certain that no matter how busy our lives become, Wednesday at 10pm is our little date night. Thanks for that.
I was a little torn last night. I think in the end the judges got it right, but any of the three could have easily been shown the door. Malan borders on the ridiculous. I'm waiting for someone on the boards to point out that they went to high school with him in Iowa and that his accent is about as fake as Madonnas.
Great show-as always. Thank you, Bravo.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 12:40 PM
Peter Z. wrote:
I also agree with Tim: Keith's winning design was not innovative. If this pattern continues, I predict a replay of the Season 2 episode where the final four designed a dress for Iman. Good designs, but safe and boring designs.
Another thing - I understand that it is important to create some conflict on the show by mixing more experienced designers with less experienced ones. But, it seems that some of the more experienced designers are a little TOO experienced. For example, the Matel designer talking about working with Isaac Mizrahi. Isn't part of the fun taking someone like Jay or desperate housewife Wendy and putting them in an exciting and new environment where they can blossom?
posted on July 13, 2006 at 12:43 PM
brandy wrote:
i was surprised that michael didn't make it into the top 3! his dress was so innovative...wasn't that the point? and the guy who used only a bed sheet (read: played it safe) ended up winning (and *sure* this was the first dress he ever made)? i was bummed about that...but still it was a great show! love laura's coat, too!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:03 PM
TCho wrote:
I was surprised too that no on-air praise was given for Michael's dress. There were a lot of strong designs, but coffee filters is just so creative. I think he should have won.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:04 PM
Loretta a/k/a WINGA wrote:
Laura's work is reminiscent of Erte's paintings.
Love it!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:06 PM
Marsha wrote:
This is the only "reality" show I watch and a good part of the reason is Tim. I think your critiques are constructive without being mean and you certainly have a sense of humor too (the whole Santino Andre-Tim skit from Season 2 comes to mind!) I totally agree about your comments from ep 1 of season 3, but I don't think the judges saw the same things you did. I agree with the person above who said the judges forgot about the challenge - Keith's dress innovative? Not. Wearable? Definitely. Maybe that's what they were thinking. Maybe a little less of Heidi explaining the premise and the rules (we got it already) and more of the judges' analysis would help me.
It was also interesting to see what prior winners and runners-up were doing (or not doing). See ya next week.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:10 PM
Erin wrote:
I was rooting for Vincent to get off at first, but when it was announced I decided I agreed with the judges. Though parts of his design were, uh ... 'questionable', he construction was pretty good. Stacy's however was not -and did I see earlier in the show that she didn't know how to use a sewing machine?
I wondered about the "project runway first" as well, but from the looks of the next week's preview, that's when it happens ...
(Tim - I love seeing you on the show every season! Even if some of the designers drive me crazy sometimes, you're always awesome and fun to watch :) )
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:13 PM
PSMike wrote:
Have to agree with Tim and many on the site. I think you need to have contestants who make for good tv, but c'mon: The immediate focus on Mulan (is that his name? Wasn't that a Disney character?) and Jeffrey seems to imply they're gonna be here for longer than necessary. Michael's dress was great, but until I read this blog I had no idea it was made out of coffee filters. I liked it that much more. Laura and Robert....awesome. It'll be interesting to see (esp. Laura) if they can do anything else, or end up being like...damn..what's his name from seaon One.. who could/would only do couture. A good start, but careful...it's showing some cliched habits.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:17 PM
Suzette Landis wrote:
I think Laura is a standout talent in this group. She's got a very unique point of view and her execution is fascinating. She's not bogged down by "the fashion industry." She knows what she likes - very feminine / very classic - it seems to work.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:17 PM
llmrysnshn wrote:
Loved Michael's use of the coffee filters. It was a creative use of something you wouldn't think of using. I also loved Laura's coat. The minute the model came out, I knew it was hers. I think she should have won it because she did what the task required: make something that tells who you are as a designer. We may find out later that all her designs are alike, which may not work to her advantage later on in future challenges, but I thought she won it. Also, why is there one designer on every season that doesn't know how to work the sewing machines?????
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:18 PM
Anna wrote:
Everybody seems to think that Robert's red and white dress should have won, but I have to say the two big red bows on the back made the model look like a Christmas tree! aka: Too much!! Sometimes, less is truly more. And regarding Laura's coat, I have no idea why everyone (including the judges) love it so much. It is shapeless and hideous, just like Laura's overly exposed sagging boobs!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:21 PM
iman wrote:
I loved the coffee filter dress- quite interesting and very, very creative. Plus, the way the ensemble stayed on the model and didn't rip/move. That was brillliant!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:23 PM
Becca wrote:
I absolutely adore this show!! My thoughts from last night were that
I truly believe Laura should have won. This challenge was to show who the person is as a designer and I can see Laura as being a very well to do, distinguished, classy lady and her coat exemplified that. I feel she embodied what the challenge was and executed it with distinction. I look forward to seeing more of her work as well as the other designers. (I loved the outfit she was wearing when she entered Atlas, where did she get it??) I loved Michael's coffee filter dress, I was absolutely blown away when they said it was made of coffee filters. I would totally want a dress that looks like that, way to go, he should have been in the top three for innovation. Vincent's whole thing was hideous and I was in shock when he wasn't told aufweidersen, however, he seems like a genuine guy and I was happy to see him get another shot. Can't wait until next week!!!!!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:25 PM
Sara wrote:
It seemed obvious to me that Stacey was voted out to save some craziness for television. Her dress was beautiful and the boy short was a really sexy idea. Vince's dress was a jumble of trash. It didn't show any creativity and there didn't even seem to be any sewing involved, Jeffrey's outfit was completely outdated. That kind of messy rocker look was over YEARS ago. If Project Runway is going to start moving in a predictable pattern, it won't be any fun to watch.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:29 PM
Eileen Sullivan wrote:
I thought the first show was great, it looks like a lot of talent assembled. I thought Laura's coat and Michael's and Robert's outfits were the best three. Vincent should have been offed, however, everyone should know how to use a sewing machine, Stacey!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:29 PM
acw wrote:
honestly, i think that judges did not take into consideration the fact that this challenge was about innovation. everyone except for michael went with the obvious. michael should have won. i mean, seriously, how many people do you know that can make a dress out of coffee filters?? also, vincent's dress was hideous, not just the hat. i just hope vincent redeems himself in the next challange and that michael continues to blow everyone out of the water!!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:31 PM
tantejoan wrote:
Just popped in to say that last night, the perfect curtain-raiser for the kick-off of PR3 was Emmett McCarthy's sale/party at his boutique, EMc², complete with many Season 2 designers and models and....Tim Gunn! Who is even more gracious and handsome in person, if that were ever possible. Great evening, and I love my Kara Janx dress.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:42 PM
Jennifer wrote:
Wonderful premiere! It looks like it is going to be another great season of PR. There were some great designs! It's hard to choose a favorite this early on. However, the first "Auf Wiedersehen" should have gone to Vincent. I feel bad that he cashed out his 401K to pursue fashion but can you say "UGLY"? No woman in her right mind would ever wear something like that! He should have been OUT!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:48 PM
lili wrote:
Gotta say I was stunned when Keith won. Was not the whole point of the challenge to see what the designers could create using at least some non-traditional materials? Much like the supermarket challenge of season 1 or the flower district challenge of season 2? Keith's dress consisted entirely of, wait for it,... cotton fabric and buttons! Zero innovation. Zero use of non-traditional materials. I could have given it to him if he had at least fashioned a brooch out of a fork or something! But buttons?!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:49 PM
Michael wrote:
Hello, Tim - what a great bunch you have to work with. Let's see these challenges in the future - MATERNITY , PLUS SIZES & THEATRICAL COSTUMES. You can't ignore the mothers - they want to be chic and they spend money. Plus-sized women need clothes, too - not every American woman is a size 4. Costuming will definitely make the innovative skills come out. Just to mix it up - throw in a children's or men's wear challenge. Michael, Laura & Kayne are my favorites so far. Episode 1's winning dress lacked innovation but execution was nice. A little too much on the beads but they helped make it. Heidi, Tim - we love the show - carry on!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 1:51 PM
david wrote:
I also think Michael should have been more of a contender. He obviously had a vision from the get go, only getting coffee filters--as opposed to everyone else who just grabbed everything. I like Robert, but his dress was TOO Barbie doll for me. I also thought Laura's coat was cool. Keith's dress WAS boring. Was shocked to see him win. I also liked the leather skirt with the top with all the flowers.
Good crop this year. I like Michael, Laura, Robert and Kayne the best so far.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 2:01 PM
Christy wrote:
I thought Michael's dress was so fantastic I mean coffee filters and the dress wasn't to sheer to wear . Loved Malan's jacket.Michael and Malan should have been in the top 3 .I thought that thoose 2 showed real style and sophistacation with the materials given.Honey, I love fur and bling as much as the next person but Laura come on .Seriously girlfriend, think outside the box add some funk.
Don't sleep on my man Micheal !!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 2:09 PM
J.B. wrote:
I have to say that Alison's potato-sack dress was certainly in my personal "bottom three" last night. I do agree with who finally left, however. I did not see a particularly bright future for a person who could not use a sewing machine when in the future, the time-constraints become much more challenging. Besides, doesn't everyone want to see what the "crazy man" Vincent will do next? It seems as though he has one foot in the insane asylum and the other on a banana peel...
posted on July 13, 2006 at 2:18 PM
Jolene wrote:
Hello Tim,
First let me say that I have watched the first two seasons MANY MANY times and couldn't wait for the third season.
Not that it means anything, but I thought that Keith's dress was darling and for what he said was his first time designing a dress, it was great, but it was basic...he used a sheet and that was about it. Oh yes..and some buttons. Where was the imagination? I expected more...as the other cast members showed with some of their designs. They had more guts to try using a variety of materials. I feel they followed the task that was given to them more than Keith did.
Robert's sweet dress, Laura's marvelous coat, and Michael's use of coffee filters were, in my opinon, excellent and followed what was given to them as the task. Even Vincent's quirky dress was more than *just a sheet*.
Keep up the great work. I look forward to Wednesday nights and reruns!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 2:19 PM
Robbie McNamee wrote:
Personally... I loved Jeffery's style and the story he told in his model's showing of the outfit. Yes, there was A LOT there, but I found it a lot more creative and interesting than most. And, contrary to what Cinda said, I think he has one of the strongest and boldest personalities in the entire cast. I didn't care a whole lot for Robert's dress until I saw the bows, and then I loved it. I think he'll go very far this season, at least I'm hoping so. I think Keith's wasn't extremely innovative, but it seemed the most cohesive. I can actually picture that dress being in a store somewhere, and I loved the necklaces that he used to compliment it. Vincent should have gone. There didn't seem to be anything, in my opinion, that "worked" with his design. Auf wiedersehen! :)
posted on July 13, 2006 at 2:22 PM
Robin wrote:
I LOOOOOVE Progect Runway!!! There is no better reality show! This seasons opener was classic with the designers ripping their living spaces to shreds!! I cant wait till next week to see if they have to continue to live in the destroyed apartments!! Thats brilliant! And boo to the judges for giving Keith the win! Roberts dress was far more interesting and true to the challenge!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 2:23 PM
Christine wrote:
Vincent's dress reminded me of Betty Rubble's dress from the Flinestones. I have very minimal sewing and fashion experience, and even *I* could've put together something better looking than that...
posted on July 13, 2006 at 2:30 PM
Brodie wrote:
I love reading Tim's Take, but am having a LOT of trouble reading it this year. The small blue type is killing me. Does noone else have this problem?
posted on July 13, 2006 at 2:31 PM
michelle wrote:
I still can't over the fact that Vincent didn't get the boot. He wasn't even in the bottom 2! I was also a smidge surprised that michael and uli weren't in the top 2. they're designs were much more unique and creative than Keiths. Though, i suppose Keiths dress was the most easily wearable which is why he must have won.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 2:54 PM
Jenna Scandone wrote:
the fact that the simple design won is a bad sign for the season. the contestants will see this as a sign to go safer than not. personaly i saw robert's dress and laura's coat as far more inovative and beautiful than keith's dress. keith also found it nessisary to accessorise while robert managed to utilise items from the appartment as accessories, and incorperated them into the dress. the discovery and use of fur in the coat on laura's part was innovative, and the fact that she made an evening coat in the first challenge was ambitious and clever. i agree with you for the most part, of course, you are the one with the degree after all.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 2:56 PM
Tammy wrote:
I loved Robert's dress with the combination jewelry attached, especially how it was incorported as part of the back a la straps. Vincent, poor guy, I really think there's some talent there and I hope he sticks around long enough to show us. I was shocked by the winner. A sheet? So what! Stacy may have an MBA, but sewing 101 is learn to use a machine. The judges saved her a lot of time. Can you imagine the poor thing having to hand sew every piece, especially consider the time restrictions?
posted on July 13, 2006 at 2:59 PM
Kathe wrote:
I agree with the whole mess that was Keith's win. Booooring! If you took away the beads, it would be a boring halter dress. It didn't even have any life to it when the model walked down the runway, and models can bring ANYTHING to life! The buttons in the back were poorly displayed and should have been a handicap instead of a strength. Just don't get it. I remember the first episode of season #2 where the girl (name escapes me) was eliminated because her dress was pretty but boring. Are these not the same judges?? My top 3 are: Robert, Michael & Kayne. Top 5 include Laura & Uli. Keith's would round up the top ten, but only because it was slightly better than Jeffrey's, Stacey's, Vincent's, Katherine's & Brad's.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 3:00 PM
Ines wrote:
Tim Gunn, You are the Highlight of Project Runway! YOU Make It Work!! Love your Blog!
I definately think Vincent had the worst design. Michael should have been asked to stay on the runway, his dress was the most innovative and pretty too.
Between Robert and Keith, Robert should have won, his dress was beautiful and used different materials. Keith's dress was nothing special, you've seen that dress a million times and he only used a bed sheet!
Although I think she would have been gone soon (for lack of sewing skills) there were worst creations than Stacey's!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 3:12 PM
Bill wrote:
Love the show - Laura's coat was gorgeous and I think she should have one. There are several very good designers on this year and I'll look forward to seeing what happens. But - What was with posting the final 3 during the break before we even knew who they were?
posted on July 13, 2006 at 3:12 PM
Timi wrote:
Tim Gunn you are Project Runway! Your interactions with the designers are always interesting and your sense of humor is refreshing.
That said what were the judges thinking in episode one of this season???? Keith's outfit was not innovative and I have no idea what statement it made about him as a designer.
Laura's coat was THE winning number no question about it.
The materials she used to make it were innovative and the design was all her. Even Michael Kors commented that design showed Laura's personality as a designer. I look forward to seeing other designs from her. She is definitely a contender for the top 3 if she continues to show designs like her first one.
Michael's coffee filter dress was also innovative (use of the filters were, but dress style has been done)
All in all the quaility of designers in this third season are fantastic!
What a diverse group of talented personalities.
A fun season to look forward too.
Timi
posted on July 13, 2006 at 3:14 PM
Nicole wrote:
Am I the only person that thinks Michael's coffee filter dress completely ripped off Chloe Dao's skating outfit for Sasha Cohen?
posted on July 13, 2006 at 3:14 PM
Nicolette wrote:
hey - instead of putting random photos of the designers working could you do photos of the outfits walking down the runway like you used to?
its helpful to have it right next to your text when you talk about dress specifics, instead of having to remember what they looked like
posted on July 13, 2006 at 3:16 PM
Karen wrote:
Tim, I really appreciate your thoughtful commentary each week. The students at Parsons and the Project Runway designers are lucky to have a mentor who, I believe, truly wants each one of them to succeed.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 3:22 PM
Kim wrote:
Hello! I would just like to say as a dance choreographer I find this show extremely inspiring and one of the only reality TV shows worth watching. I had the pleasure of meeting Heidi Klum at a fashion show in 2000 and she is the sweetest, most down to earth person!
Although I loved Keith's dress, it wasn't as innovative as some of the others...the dress with the coffee filters was adorable! I also love Laura and Robert's Best's style, I can't wait to see what happens next! "Carry on"!!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 3:27 PM
rachels lehcar wrote:
Did no one notice Michael's garmet?? It was made of COFFEE FILTERS!! So cool. I think Bradley might do something great too. But Jeffery is going to be the one that will entertain us!!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 3:30 PM
Shel wrote:
I agree with the call in thing, it really kind of ruins it for the rest of us who don't really need an ipod. Robert should have won with Laura as 2nd. Love the show, your the best Tim!!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 3:32 PM
blah wrote:
Keith is such a liar! He has designed women's clothes before. HE worked for this line Wyeth by Todd Magill!I thought his dress was cute, but it's just not innovative. Michael Keith should have been in the running, the coffee filters dress was pretty hot and innovative. I like the architect lady too, she could have taken off some of the blings and still rock the coat.
Robert Best is adorable,his dress was cute.
Yay for Project Runway!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 3:38 PM
Patty Michaels wrote:
I absolutely think Stacey was the right choice to go. How in the world was she going to work week after week if she can't use a sewing machine?? There is no way she was going to "hand-sew" her way to Fashion Week!!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 4:01 PM
Jan wrote:
Season 3 started out great, but I was very disappointed to be baited with "I'm going to have to ask you to leave" in the previews and then not see the results -- that just wreaks of "false advertising!" I agree that the phone-in is a DEFINITE SPOILER! I like to make up my own mind as to which designers will be in the bottom three of the show! In my humble opinion, Tim Gunn is...pardon the pun...the glue gunn that holds Project Runway together.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 4:12 PM
Kath wrote:
I just have to say, kudos to comment-poster Sandy who called Milan out on the Austin Powers-esque accent. I'm thrilled to see I'm not the only one who caught that last night! I, for one, am skeptical of how real a person Milan is...
Good show to Robert B., who I agree topped Keith's design. Episode 1 was fab, do I honestly have to wait a whole week for another new episode? How will I ever survive?
And glad to see you, Tim, how I wish I could attend Parsons if only to have you as a mentor (and I'm not even a designer...)
posted on July 13, 2006 at 4:17 PM
Donna wrote:
Michael's outfit reminded me of what my granny did back in the 60's and 70's with doll dresses. She used milk strainer filters to make gowns for dolls and then crocheted the tops. They were lovely. Michael should have made the top 3!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 4:23 PM
Claire Keaveney wrote:
Vincent's design reminded me of the ensembles Lucy and Ethel modeled in Paris, too! Welcome back to America's gay uncle. We love you.
ps Unfortunately, Maran's design reminded me of the design Lucy had to model in Hollywood when she had a sunburn.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 4:26 PM
Katie wrote:
PR3,
I do not understand the hoopla about Michaels "coffee filter" dress! It was straight out of Martha Stewart Living from a year or so ago. It was in one of the Halloween issues. They made a Cinderella type outfit, complete with wig, using boxes of the things. BTW has the subject of having Marf as a guest judge ever come up? If she has done so excuse my ignorance. I only started watching PR mid-season 2 so I have no real reference points for season 1. Well, "Carry on"...
posted on July 13, 2006 at 4:34 PM
Derek wrote:
I would like to add my voice to the suggestion made in this blog that it would be terrific to see a pic of the back of each design, as well as the front. Often there are many distinguishing and elegant features only visible from the back. Thank you.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 4:57 PM
RaMina wrote:
oh my goodness i can't stand jeffery already. he's so arrogant it makes me sick. and his dress was horrible. the jacket hem was uneven as well, which really bothered me. it's like he's trying to be santino but without any of santino's charm or wit. i thought laura's coat was amazing. i would buy it if i say it in stores. and michael's coffee filter dress was so beautiful. his model looked like a swan, but in a good way, not a bjork way. i wish stacy had stayed. i think she had potential.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 4:59 PM
Janet wrote:
Tim, The first season was a great new experience for all. The highlight was you being introduced to the world. The second season, to quote Michael C., was "underwhelming". I was so looking forward to the season 3. Having spent many years in the fashion industry, the show has been a great sharing opportunity for me and my 19 yr old granddaughter. However, Tim please save season 3. With all the talent and promise for a great season 3, with the painful winner of episode 1, what are we to think. Is it time to change the judging panel, I think so! Tim and producers it is up to you now to save the future and the integrity of the show. Tim, ITS TIME TO MAKE IT WORK!!!!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 5:02 PM
Rebecca wrote:
Hi Tim,
Loved the show last night!! I think Keith played it really safe and was surprised he won.
My top choices were Michael and Robert.
I was so excited that we didn't have to wait so long for PR3. Thanks for making the summer TV lineup worth watching!!!!
And in response to another posters' comment about putting new grad students on the show, I'm glad to see some older adults for a change on TV. I think the PR has a variety of diff. ages in every group.
Looking foward to next week
posted on July 13, 2006 at 5:12 PM
Jen wrote:
Hooray for Laura! Her soundbite still lingers...age and motherhood can be "a slippery slope to sweatpants and a minivan". How true! Fashion boils down to whether or not you care to dress your very best...not how much you spend on your clothes(thanks, Michael, for the coffee filters).
PR's designer personalities drive the entertainment aspect of the reality series but episodes also challenge me to pay more attention to how I'm dressing myself. Tim, I'm looking at my closet and I hear your voice saying, "Make it work"!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 5:46 PM
K wrote:
Michael, Michael, Michael! Coffee filters? Too smart, too creative,too cool! I saw the runway component of the show but had know idea that he used coffee filters. Very architectonic use of the material. He's got a great model too. He should prove to be a top three contender.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 5:52 PM
T.R. wrote:
Sandy, I giggled outloud about your comment concerning Malon (aka Austin Powers). My thoughts exactly!
I was definitely impressed with Michael's coffee filter dress. Since he's from Atlanta (my town!), I am definitely pulling for him. Go Michael!
I absolutely loved Laura's coat. So classy! I'm looking forward to hearing more from her and seeing her work.
I do think Robert beat out Keith when it came down to it. More innovative, imaginative and just plain classy.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 5:52 PM
Debbie wrote:
Great first show! I love Project Runway..Keith Should NOT have won. I hardly sew and I could have made that..Plus the attitude. Laura's was beautiful and Micheal with the coffee filters.. Unbelievable. Now that was creative and that's what they should have been voting on. I'm not sure what they were thinking last night. But I can't wait to see more. Yeah for Project Runway!!!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 6:42 PM
ch wrote:
LOVED the show last night!
Tim was right about the navy blue dress. I loved the coffee filter dress and even more the dress with the red bows in the back. I also thought Kayne did a great job in rising to the true challenge.
Malan cracks me up - looks like Prince, sounds like Austin Powers. Just know he'll be telling someone to "behave" soon!
I can't wait for next week!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 6:48 PM
Allison wrote:
As strange as it sounds, I've picked a favorite already in Malan, even if he is quite flippant and snobby. Most ( most mind you) with such an attitude can back it up, and I get that kind of feeling from him. I predict top 5 at least. Unless he gets mouthy with the judges. You can't really tell from the first episode either way.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 6:48 PM
C. V. wrote:
I agree that Keith's dress was NOT innovative in the least. I remember back when Nora WON for the blue dress made from a vinyl chair (I think it was a chair) and those who did not innovate were admonished. This first show was good but I have no idea why the judges would make such a horrendous mistake right out of the gate.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 6:53 PM
Danielle wrote:
I agree with the majority of the comments Keith did not deserve to win. His design was NOT innovative, it was creative and nice looking yes, but Robert beat him hands down. BUT I believe that Laura deserved to win overall, her design was exactly what Heidi described the challenge to be, which was to take materials from the apartments and create a design that defined "you" as a designer.. and that's exactly what she did, it had LAURA written all over it!! I was dissapointed for sure!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 7:09 PM
Jen wrote:
It was kind of wierd to se a new cast on Project Runway. I'm so used to seeing the familiar faces of season 2. But I was plesantly pleased with the first challenge! Way to think out of the box! I did wish that the designers had gone off on a little more on a limb and shown what kind of statement they are trying to make with their clothing, but, I still look forward eagerly to the next episode!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 7:23 PM
Lauren wrote:
I am facinated by the way the show has evolved. It appears that no one seams (ha!) to stand out at this point. Just looking at design skills, that is. Stacey was definatly weak, however, this is T.V. and the editing can be spun (ha!) in any direction. I would really love to be the fly on the wall in the workroom and the "runway"
Oooooh! what fun that would be!!!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 7:33 PM
Sue wrote:
I have to say I loved Michael's dress. I thought that he was the most ingenious of them all, using coffee filters. Who would have thought it would be wearable. Keith didn't deserve to be the winner. He played it too safe, at least stacey was trying to be creative. Brandon's ensemble just didn't cut it for me. It made his model look like the pillsbury dough girl. Maybe if he would have taken the feathers out of the comforter it would have worked. I can't wait until next week.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 7:35 PM
Lina wrote:
Season 3 is off with a bang. Congrats on the Emmy nom. Ya'll deserve it!
I was really disappointed that Keith won. Far too conventional - and that ego! Good to see some of the promos for the season include a come-uppance for him. Loved Laura's coat and Robert's dress, too.
With 15 designers, it's so hard to get to know any of them. I guess that's the same every season, though.
I'm annoyed with the whole text messaging spoiler thing. Bravo, if you're going to do the text messaging thing, pick three people at random, not the bottom three!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 7:44 PM
JHD wrote:
Why aren't more people talking about Uli's stunning dress? Robert's dress very cute. The horrible saggy mini should have been among the losers. Laura's coat was spoiled by the shiny bits in my opinion. Keith: navy with red buttons? bleah. Also, has any woman actually worn a fishtail hem? Why do the designers think we want this. I think the asymmetry is a lot easier than making the hem perfectly even -- so it's a cop out. I agree: Please ditch the spoiler call-in!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 7:57 PM
Lili wrote:
Michaels dress was the winner to me. Hellooooo the challenge was to use the items in the apartment. Keith's dress was cute but boring (He and most of the designers did not listen to the challenge) I was disappointed on the 1st episode. I was expecting creative garments with very little fabric. The judges did not even judge or focused on the challege themselves.... MICHAEL should of WON.... coffee filters... come on... that was great
posted on July 13, 2006 at 8:10 PM
Jenni wrote:
I think the main problem with Keith winning/Stacey leaving is that one of the things Heidi said to Stacey before giving her the "auf wiedersehen," quite clearly, was "You did not use innovative materials." Well, neither did Keith - but he won!! I agree that Stacey should have gone, but the judges should NOT have given that as a reason. It sets up too much of a double standard.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 9:15 PM
Debbie wrote:
Tim,
Loved the "Road to the Runway" and the first episode. You guys really know how to "Make It Work!!!!" It was great to see the designers from the previous seasons as they helped choose this season's contestants and talk about what they've been up too. Austin Scarlet was my absolute favorite from season 1 and those wedding gowns he's doing were absolutely beautiful. This years contestants look to have quite the range and I see lots of "drama" potential for this season. Gotta love it. I'll be cheering for Michael and Robert up until the very end. The only other comment I have is, "Where's Andre???"
posted on July 13, 2006 at 9:16 PM
Kiki wrote:
I think Keith won because it looked like something Kate Spade would have designed herself. Laura's coat was so beautiful that I had a dream I was wearing it after watching the show! I think Michael Kors wasn't digging the leaves at the bottom of the coat and that's why she didn't win. I love that bio video with the Mommie Dearest reference. Does anyone remember Uncle Nick from season 2? "This ain't my first time at the rodeo!"
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:01 PM
Mary wrote:
"In the real world, there is no explaining yourself." Kudos to Nina Garcia. Straightforward, well put, and so true!!!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:01 PM
Arietta wrote:
I am sooo glad PR is back; I love the show! I have to agree with many before me that Keith's dress just didn't meet the requirements of the challenge. I loved Laura's coat and Michael's coffee filter dress; Laura's coat was most definitely her and she used many items from the apartment in its creation. Michael's dress was also a creative use of things found in the apartment. Like Shoshanna (poster above), I also feel that Vincent is somewhat unstable and should not have been cast for PR. Maybe he will survive and surprise me and everyone else; time will tell. Traci and another poster have a fabulous idea of posting rear-view photos of the designs online. And Nicolette's idea to post photos next to Tim's column is also spot on! LOVE PR -thanks for another season! Bravo!!!!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:02 PM
Rhonda wrote:
I don't think I've ever been more wow'd by a show before. I amjust so hanging on the edge of my seat waiting to see what the next episode will bring. I thought Vincent's dress was just ghastly! I hope he redeems himself in the next show. Everyone looks so stressed but seem to be having fun at the same time. I loved the idea of the coffee filter dress, so inventive! Ah well I'll stop babbling and go finish making my teal skirt.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:15 PM
patrick wrote:
Are you kidding me??? I was on a train during the first showing of the new episode/new season and couldn't wait to get home tonite to see it all. Why is Vincent still with us????? He displayed a complete lack of talent....seconded only by Keith's absolute lack of innovation!!! Come on judges, make it work! You truly did forget the point of the producers' challenge....Tim, I wish u were a judge! Thank god Keith didn't use that placemat, tho. Still, there was 5,000 times more innovation with the coffee filters..let's get our heads on straight, judges!!!!! And, Nina, perhaps that black electrical tape over your right shoulder was YOUR idea of innovation....hmmmmm. Can't wait til next week!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:23 PM
Stroll wrote:
After the first show, I'm rooting for Laura and Michael. And Tim Gunn MAKES the show!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:40 PM
Danica wrote:
Hi Tim,
Love the show, and I'm dying for the next episode. In regard to this episode, all I can say is:
Vincent! What were you THINKING?!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:41 PM
Karen wrote:
So glad that PR3 is on. We don't miss an episode. I thought Vincent should've been off, not only for the hat but for the sack on his model. Robert's was adorable and Laura's was elegant. BTW, I also have an extremely difficult time reading Tim's comments. Not so with those posted. Help.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:44 PM
Stroll wrote:
P.S. Upon first site of Vincents hat...thing...he should have been booted off immediately.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 10:44 PM
emily wrote:
I think I might be the only one who liked jeffrey's jacket and dress. togther, not so much. but separately i thought they were gorgeous. my top three would be (in no particular order) robert, michael, and katherine. i was shocked when michael and katherine weren't in the top 3. i loved her coat and thought the dress underneath was a fun splash of color. keith won....BOO!!!!! his dress was pretty...-ish but i thought he took the easy way out. and he has a big freaking ego. i would've like to see vincent out. i could have made that dress better if i was 3 years old.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:06 PM
mary wrote:
Hi Tim,
I just wanted to say welcome back and tell you how much my daughter and I love the show. We think your great. Sometimes we wish you could be a judge, but then we would see as much. Keep up the great work!!!!!
Paige and mary
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:11 PM
Cindy Buzhardt wrote:
Tim:
I don't get why Laura's coat is being so overrated. I think with that piece of fur, anyone could've come up with an acceptable piece. I didn't really like those ornaments either. Seemed like you would see it in a JC Penny catalog in the "dressy" section. I personally liked Michael's. If it hadn't been for the fact that Austin and Chloe already used the technique, the idea might have seem more innovative. To me, it was far more innovative than the winner's and was also very pleasing to the eye. I have so much respect for your advise for each designer. You don't ever butcher them, but always encourage them and try to bring out what's positive. Looking forward to watching the rest of the season!!
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:14 PM
Debbie S wrote:
Tim,
I love the show and am glad to see that it has not degenerated like some of the other shows (ie Rockstar). I enjoyed the Road to the Runway show and the first episode. I too think Robert should have won, but was not too disappointed to see Stacy gone.
I really like Vincent and was glad he wasn't sent home. I think everyone should give him a chance. If you watched Top Chef you saw Dave's breakdowns, yet he made it through the show and was a real winner in my eyes. I like Vincent's off beat personality and style.
Thanks for making Project Runway a great entertaining show. I am looking forward to the big surprise.
posted on July 13, 2006 at 11:32 PM
Janine wrote:
I think we're being a little hard on Stacey about her sewing machine problems. Tim Gunn, am I right in thinking that the industrial-type machines in the Parsons workroom are not very much like a home sewing machine? Stacey's audition clothing was made well enough to get her a spot on the show, after all.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 12:21 AM
Veruca wrote:
I to be perfectly honest did not like Keith's dress at all. I have a feeling that he was lying about never having designed womens clothing before. I also think he seems cocky. Why did Vincent not get kicked off the show? He loved his hat, but obviously did not have the courage to back it up. Also I think putting immunity on the show is a bad idea, it makes people who are really good designers leave the show, plus the person with immunity never seems to make as good a garment as they would have if they did not have it. So far so good!! Can't wait for next week.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 1:39 AM
Leslie wrote:
Can anyone explain to me why Vincent wasn't Auf'd?
Was it because the judges saw something in him that they didn't see in Stacey? I'd personally much rather wear Stacey's nightgown than Vincent's cotton trashbag.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 1:45 AM
margie wrote:
Stacy should have been out. Judges were on point about execution considering they werent aware how inept she was in terms of using a sewing machine. Still I thought Michael should have won--how innovative--using coffee filters; who knew. This design was perfect considering time constraints and the challenge. Still the guy with the basket hat is a basket case; He is out of tune. I do wish him well based on his previous experience but some people dont make it in the business simply because they suck and not because the competition is fierce. In his case, he sucks. Oops about using the 401K.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 2:29 AM
Julie Blake wrote:
Loved both the Road show and the real first episode. It seems everyone is pretty much in agreement about the negatives of the shows - hated the phone in - too much of a spoiler - you get enough veiwers without that gimmick.
Glad to see Micheal and Nina back as judges - they are the best - both judgemental and constructive in their critisism. I know they don't get to see all that we do, conversely - they get to see the designs close up as we can't, so, although we may not always agree with their decisions, we are not always the best judges - we would be invited guests on the panel if we were - haha!
Tim - you truely are a great personality and the show's biggest asset. I agreed with your advice about using more from the room for the blue dress, but the judges thought otherwise - I agree with another listing - that they may have forgotten the Challenge themselves.
Anyway, looking forward sooo much to the next few weeks....
Dislike Malan already.....
posted on July 14, 2006 at 2:47 AM
Barb F wrote:
Am I the only one who thought Bradley's design was HIDEOUS!!?? How he made the first cut and received no questions or comments on his design is beyond me. When I saw that down comforter with the grey tweed something or other walk down the runway, I thought surely this guy was history!
posted on July 14, 2006 at 3:05 AM
DANA wrote:
Tim,
I loved the first show. Bravo! I especially loved the behind the scenes/audtions. Santino was so calm and collected for these calls. I loved seeing some of the really bizzare fashions. What was up with the lady in the space suit? I thought Laura's coat and Robert's dress were the best. Carry on.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 3:18 AM
Sherri Starr wrote:
Hi Tim,
You are the BEST part of PR...you do "Make it work"...I was so disappointed in the winner last night...are the judges getting jaded or what??? Robert, Michael and Laura were by far the best....it should be another great season.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 3:23 AM
Michelle Martinez wrote:
Hilarious! I immediately turned to my friend and said "do you remember that I Love Lucy episode???" when Vincent's "hat" hit the runway.
Robert's dress was the winner in my book, the back was beautiful.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 3:33 AM
Monica wrote:
I'm not entirely disappointed about Kieth's win because I think his dress was well-made and looked good, despite the fact that it could have been a little more creative. However, I really wanted Laura's coat to win. It was simple yet classy (albeit noisy!) and totally her.
I was satisfied with Stacey being Auf'd, simply because the girl didn't know how to work a sewing machine! How was she going to "get by" in future episodes? However, I thought Vincent deserved the cut more than she. I think his lackluster dress and rediculous "hat" are proof of that.
I was really disappointed that Jeffrey's dress and overcoat got such a negative reaction from the judges (and from other commenters here). I agree that he may have "outdone" himself in making something so ambitious, but I really like his style. I'll even go so far as to say he's my favourite. ;)
I'm really rooting for Jeffrey, Malan, Laura, Kayne and Allison this season.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 7:00 AM
Jo wrote:
Jeffrey, it is so wonderful to see you again in the show. I have not missed a single episode of Project Runway since the beginning and most of it is because I value your judgement. I believe Laura is the most classic designer and I absolutely loved her design although she might have problems when the judges demand more of a haphazard design to clothing which I do not like. She may just win this.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 8:06 AM
Nicole wrote:
Man, I agree with most everything said here. I'm glad to see I'm definitely not the only one who loved Michael's coffee filter dress and felt that one should have been in the top 3. It should have been Robert, Laura, and Michael, with Robert winning. And yep, the bottom 3 where would they should have been, and I'm even glad Stacy was out, though she seemed to be the most level-headed one of them. It seems like it should almost be a criteria that the contestants know how to work basic machines. And I TOTALLY agree with the Malan-Austin Powers reference! So true. What is with that laugh? He just seems so...weird. Hooray for PR3 during the summer! I was so psyched when I first heard it would be on so soon after PR2 - I did not like the thought of waiting.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 8:54 AM
Karen wrote:
To all who are participating here, and to the wonderfully interesting Tim! [BTW, what makes Tim so great? He's honest, serious about his craft, and kind to the contestants simultaneously!]
Anyway, real point here is this: I find it frustrating when the runway show begins at how FAST it goes! I want to really SEE the end results. The talk-over by the designers has become very predictable and actually takes away from time spent looking at the design. Maybe have the designer's picture inserted in a corner--picture within a picture style. My suggestion is to cut-down on some of the production footage to fit the Results in! I would suggest ALWAYS having the models by the designers--it is simply a good visual in a visual medium.
Overall, a really entertaining show. One more thing: all reality shows do this, but it's becoming OLD:
Heidi (or whomever): "Your challenge, designers, is to create a dress for Barbie."
Designer (pick any) immediately: "Heidi told us our challenge was to design a dress for Barbie."
Repetition makes it worse than watching a weather report on a local station--or a golf match, for God's sake!
posted on July 14, 2006 at 9:12 AM
Elizabeth Phillips wrote:
When is this tattoo craze going to be over? I am so sick and tired of seeing people with designs all over their body! I want Jeffrey to go home just for that reason.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 9:30 AM
Jeanine wrote:
Skeptical of how real Malan is? How about, where exactly is he from? Twice his answer has been, "I was born in Taiwan." I was born in Connecticut, but I don't tell people that's where I'm from. Cause I don't live there anymore. He is one strange character - I can see why TIm might have been skeptical of having him on Season 1 in the first place! But perhaps his design aesthetic and skill will overpower his sketchy personality. At minimum, he'll be a great character to watch.
Michael should have won - he used a wonderful, creative, "out of the box" approach. Didn't not using fabric as fabric count as anything in this challenge? And by the same token, hats off to Kayne for using a rubber door mat - the bouncing down the runway was fantastic. That was a thoughtful, animated design that definitely shows he's more than a sequined beauty contestant's gown designer.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 9:44 AM
Mike wrote:
It's virtually impossible to size up anyone's personality or lack thereof at this point. I definetly predict that we'll be seeing alot more of Jeffrey. People may be upset by his tatoos and appearance (how shocking for a designer!) but his design was clearly well beyond the rest of the pack and certainly was the most true to his actual asthetic. An asthetic that is evidently not only successful but was good enough to land him on the show to begin with.
I mean I know it wasn't a blue bedspread wrapped around a model with some nice red buttons but, you know...
posted on July 14, 2006 at 10:04 AM
Katy wrote:
i don't know who this "ula" that everyone is talking about is, but ULI is the designer on pr...get it right people!
posted on July 14, 2006 at 10:23 AM
Twistie wrote:
Add my voice to the chorus of howls at Keith's win. There wasn't one innovative thing about that dress. It was pretty, yes, but it barely sneaked under the wire as a challenge solution.
Of those left on the runway at the end, I would have been thrilled to see either Laura or Robert win the challenge. They both created truly wearable outfits while getting completely into the spirit of the challenge. I adored the way Robert's dress was pre-blinged so you wouldn't have to choose jewelry to go with it, and I was crazy about the flapper line and use of mirrors on Laura's coat.
The other people I would have considered for the win were Michael and Uli. Michael's exclusive use of coffee filters worked out exquisitely, and I thought the line and color sense of Uli's dress were both fabulous. As Tim said, I could see Uli's dress on the beach, yes, but with different accessories I could see it at a fancy cocktail party, too.
I felt the right person went. Stacey's dress wasn't particularly innovative, didn't fit right, and wasn't very wearable. While Jeffrey's outfit was a hot mess, it was at least an impeccably sewn, ambitious hot mess.
All in all, my one disappointment so far with S3 was the judging of the winner of the first challenge. Reward ambition, folks! Reward those who really USE the challenge rather than skirting it.
Oh, and I hate, hate, HATE the call in vote. I want to find out who's on the chopping block when the judges call out their names. If I want an iPod, I'll go out and buy one. Spoilers make me gassy.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 11:23 AM
Mary Cracraft wrote:
Hellow,
Please tell us, WHAT material was the BODY of Laura's wonderful coat made of (I didn't see it listed in "materials used"), and WHERE ever did she find it in the apartment??
And, WHY, specifically, did the judges think Keith's dress was better than Robert's, Laura's, or, for that matter, Michael's or Uli's (loved them!), especially when the challenge wasn't to make the most wearable dress? It was hard for us viewers to see...but maybe in person Keith's had more effect than appeared on the other side of the screen. Please explain, as this is a mystery to people all over the Bravo boards, too.
Merci beaucoup,
--dylann
posted on July 14, 2006 at 11:31 AM
Jenna wrote:
I am surprised that so many people loved Michael's dress. Very pretty, yes, but to me it seemed like something a fashion student would do for a class assignment.
I think Robert Best should have won. Keith's dress was just plain boring cloth, wearable but rather boring and not innovative in the least. Big DEAL about the buttons in the back! But I agree with Stacy's elimination. Poor fitting, lackof creativity. She could have taken those typical materials and gone wild with them.
Yeah that phone-in thing ticked me off too.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 1:02 PM
Anthony wrote:
I think the most innovative creation was Robert's. Keith's creation was nice but it was a blue material that was made into a dress and beads hanging down the model's neck. What is innovative about that? Just my opinion. I also think that Vincent should have been the one booted off! What is with the hat? Can he honestly say that that was even nice? Who would wear a basket for a hat? Just my opinion!
posted on July 14, 2006 at 1:37 PM
Dara wrote:
Hola Tim!!!
Desde Argentina seguimos a Project Runway ( pero aca estan pasando la 2 temporada)
Ya se que no me van a entender...
My diseñador preferido de la 1º temporada es: AUSTIN SCARLETT!!
2º temporada: SANTINO RICE
Estoy muy emocionada!!
P.D: Where is Andrae?
posted on July 14, 2006 at 1:47 PM
beccalynn wrote:
I have to agree with most - that the winning design did not follow the challenge. The most innovative use of material - Michael. The most representative of themselves as designers - Laura. Judges...you assigned the challenge - now judge the challenge given.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 2:28 PM
Patty D wrote:
There's nothing new to add to this fine discussion except my kudos to TIM - again, far and away the highlight of the production. Your genuine care and concern for each designer is overwhelming, which gives credence to your comments and your insight. This is my favorite show on television - in fact it's the only show I watch. It brings my family together for an hour of fun.
My vote:
Winner: Michael
Runner Up: Laura
3rd: Robert
4th: Keith
My only complaint...those dang annoying BRAVO commercials. It's almost unbearable. It's a great channel...you don't have to sell the people watching the channel already. My fingers hurt from hitting the mute so often.
Anyway, rock on PR3. Keep it coming!
posted on July 14, 2006 at 2:34 PM
Rho wrote:
A blue sheet and ten pounds of beads???? Please! The judges need to explain what was INNOVATIVE about Keith’s rather mediocre offering. Then for Heidi to tell the poor girl who got sent home that she didn’t pick innovative materials – well, I could only roll my eyes at the hypocrisy.
The top three in my opinion, using the rules of the challenge, were Michael, Laura and Kayne.
Season one was groundbreaking. Santino distracted us from a lot of dull designs in Season 2. Now I’m concerned that the judges in this Season are just missing the point and picking what they like and ignoring the challenges. I’m giving it one more show, if the judges completely whiff again, I’m out. Thank goodness for Tim’s dead-on take of each design.
P.S. can’t wait to see Jay’s show in September! Great update on him.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 2:59 PM
jrt wrote:
I thought this was a great episode. I think my top 3 would have been Uli - i really like hers but i think she is laying low right now, Kayne's - i just liked the color scheme and how it flowed on the runway, and Laura's - i am not sure she is what PR is looking for, and I hope she doesn't become a one-note (otherwise i really like her). People seemed to like Michael's dress, but I felt as if it was just a combination of two of Chloe's dresses from last season ( Ice Skating and COYB dresses), but the coffee filters was smart. (it also kind of reminded me of Austin Scarlett's corn husk dress. I am TOO excited about this season, because there is great creativity, and I think it will just get better. I hope Katherine can 'mature' because I think she has some good things in her.
** Also note Tim, the fitting will get better because now they will know their model's size. Or at least last season it got better through episodes because the designers were aware of the measurements of the models.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 3:06 PM
Meridyth G wrote:
No question Laura should have won. Perhaps the judges should be replaced every season. Michael and Nina always look as if there is an unpleasant odor in the room.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 3:07 PM
Lorenzo wrote:
Hi Tim,
You rock and you're hot.
I absolutely LOVED Laura's coat, and she is fabulous. Those mommies out there could learn a thing or two from her.
I didn't think Keith deserved to win. As someone already pointed out here, you take away those beads and there's not much left. Sometimes I really don't understand those judges.
I'm lookign forward to the new episodes.
Stay hot and fabulous, Tim.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 3:18 PM
rw wrote:
Why on earth Vincent is still there is unimaginable. He should have been the first to go.
And Malan doing his Austin Powers thing makes me queasy. Hope he doesn't last too long. He isn't fun to watch and I'm going to TIVO the episodes so that I can fast forward when he's featured. Sorry, dude, but get real.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 3:27 PM
Amanda Soisson wrote:
I think Michael will win Season 3. It's just a gut feeling, but I am pulling for him. The coffee filters were incredibly creative, and his dress was pretty.
But I did like Robert's best out of the ones that made it into the top 3. The red bows were adorable.
I liked Keith's dress, too, but Robert's was better.
I hope Vincent goes home next week. He's too kooky.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 4:06 PM
DR wrote:
I am having a very difficult time reading the print in Tim's Blog. It is almost illegible. Is it just me? Anyway, I think Michael should have been given much more attention and credit for his design and use of material. Very smart. Very out of the ordinary. Robert's dress was better than the winner's. Great show.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 4:07 PM
Paul Kaye wrote:
I agree with many of the comments made here including the fact that Keith's garment was not innovative, that the phone in scores did ruin the suspense and that it would have been nice to see some of the other designs more closely. Love the show.
Pat - Chicago
posted on July 14, 2006 at 4:24 PM
H.T.M. wrote:
Tim. I totally agree with you about Keith's dress. From cotton bed sheets to a tailored dress, not exactly a stretch. I think Robert should have won. He used a wider range of materials and created something that was very feminine, sophisticated, and subtle.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 4:28 PM
Kristen wrote:
I absolutely love Project Runway, and am so glad it'd back on so soon. Episode 1 was definately a different challenge however I must admit i like the "Clothes off your back" challenge better. That better showcases how far these designers will go for fashion. The tearing up of the apartment was fun to watch however extremely wasteful. There were tons of things that were taken that I believe designers had no intention of using. The coffee filter dress was by far my favorite, it was so beautiful and the fall of the dress reminded me of Chloe's ice skating ensemble.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 4:48 PM
Swan wrote:
I think Robert Best is the BEST
posted on July 14, 2006 at 4:58 PM
P.C. wrote:
I feel bad for Michael. He did such a great, innovative job on the coffee filter dress and it seemed like the judges just overlooked him. I'm not sure why. I think he has great potential and I hope the judges give him more credit next time.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 5:09 PM
Denise wrote:
Hey Tim,
I think you give these contestants really good advice, and it is nice to see that, infact, this year's competitions will amount to taste. I do think it could become somewhat of an exercise for the judges to learn another perspective or point-of-view since, afterall, the only constant in fashion is change.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 5:48 PM
Planet Art wrote:
I thought the down comforters just wrapped around the models was boring. Can the designers use any paints or dyes? If they had painted something abstract on the comforter, maybe that could have been interesting.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 6:39 PM
Mazell Stafford wrote:
So glad you're back. Loved the show except for call-in. Needs to be dropped as it's a spoiler. I agree that the coffee filter dress was adorable & the coat was wonderfull. I also kinda liked the dress with the ruffle thingy down the back. How about a challenge showing clothes for older ladies. We are not all 20 somethings with a size 0 figure. Barring that , show something for short folks under 5'5". We aren't all 6 ' either.I'm really looking forward to this season to see who is going to be "the Personality". I loved Santino from PR2 & Austin & Jay from PR1. I think it just may turn out to be Melan but we'll just have to wait & see. Oh yes, I also agree that the right person went home.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 6:58 PM
Keith wrote:
Welcome back, Tim! You're my favorite part of Project Runway. I agree with two comments from other viewers: the phone-in vote promotion was an unwanted spoiler and there was not enough coverage of the designs on the runway. Looking forward to another exciting season, keep up the great work!
posted on July 14, 2006 at 7:13 PM
Stacy wrote:
I have an issue with Malan. He;s too high and mighty. Hemay be talented but his attitude has me totally turned off. And Stacey should have been given another chance, she made the best of what she had, and someone else DID use the pillow case another contestent brought with them, which I believe is against the rules, though I may be wrong. But Malan needs to shape up or get out, he's annoying, and I don't think he has the talent or the drive to make it in this show.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 7:46 PM
Violet wrote:
I think Robert should've won the last challenge...not Keith. Keith's dress was plain, NOT innovative and covered up with those ugly necklaces! But Robert's dress was gorgeous. I especially loved the red strip of cloth around the waist that really added a nice touch.
posted on July 14, 2006 at 7:57 PM
Wallace wrote:
Uncle Tim! We're so proud of you and we love love LOVE season 3 already! Keep "making it work", and we can't wait for the rest of the season!
posted on July 14, 2006 at 8:23 PM
Veronica wrote:
Ahhh. The drug that is Project Runway is entering my veins. I feel the rush, the excitement! I had to slam the door on a drop-in guest and, although under the influence of Tim Gunn, I believe I said, "Closed for business."
So, once again I feel as if live is worth living and the only thing I have to worry about is Vincents's 401k and Tim Gunn's sunburn.
posted on July 15, 2006 at 12:10 AM
Arthur wrote:
I respect the judges' opinions, however, the four judges we see on the weekly show do not entirely make the final decision as to which design wins. If you read the credits at the end of the show the outcome of the runway winner is also decided by the production crew. I don't know how much of an influence behind-the-scene-production has, though, certainly Heidi, Nina, Michael, and guest judge do not make 100% of the decision. Perhaps this is due to a dire need of TV personality instead of talent, who knows. This process erodes our confidence towards the judging panel and diminishes their credibility.
I take the weekly result with a grain of salt.
posted on July 15, 2006 at 12:23 AM
Jackson wrote:
Robert, Kayne & Laura... If I have to say who piqued my interest immediately...? These 3 have my utmost attention. And Tim, do you realize you're becoming the Star of Project Runway? Well deserved and well done!
posted on July 15, 2006 at 12:35 AM
Bobby Weenus wrote:
Jeffry's design and its slandering is something that I consider a generation gap. Jeffry created a dancepunk masterpiece in my opinion, its something that in many clubs of my generation, would have been adored. As I said though, its an issue of a generation gap. It isn't what fashion was, five years ago.
I agree that the coat ruined the overall design, but the dress itself was solid.
To state that Jeffry's dress, which I would consider was the most work done on the part of any of the designers, was reminiscant to something a bag lady would wear, you obviously didn't see Bradley's design, which looked as if you bought it at the cardboard box outside of East LA.
I completely agree with Tim though on Keith's design, it looked great, but as far as effort went, he might as well have used a store bought fabric.
posted on July 15, 2006 at 12:38 AM
dee wrote:
two things:
1) i hated laura's dress; and
2) i think bradley will stay around for awhile.
posted on July 15, 2006 at 1:41 AM
Marién wrote:
Is no one concerned that their apartments are completely trashed? How could they have assigned this challenge at the very start and then expect them to stay in those apartments now with no sheets, curtains, towels, etc. The producers MUST have known that this would happen.
It just feels unfair to the contestants if it is to remain this way.
As Tim likes to say, "I'm concerned."
posted on July 15, 2006 at 3:30 AM
Zack Blanke wrote:
I really don't understand the hatred for Jeffrey's dress. It was over the top sure, but certainly not the worst in my opinion. I think he has the potential to pull out some ambitious santin