Katie wrote:

OMG, I am so happy that Keith is going home. He made many beautiful outfits, but was probably cheating the whole time. He was also way to self-conceited for project runway.

posted on August 2, 2006 at 11:16 PM

Julie wrote:

What a surprise, Keith was kicked off! NOT. Everyone knew it was going to be him. Anyway, I have to say I didn't really like one design a whole lot. I thought they were ok, but not stunning and wowing. Angela was saved by Laura and Michael, it's a good thing she picked and listened to them, otherwise we'd have another lovely puffy skirt with horrible little rosettes. I'm so glad Robert is staying! I think he's great and I hope he doesn't leave so soon. It's amazing that Alison and Jeffery pulled off Keith's look. They really seemed to work well together and did an outstanding job. But how is Keith's absence going to affect the scheduling of auf'ing people?

posted on August 2, 2006 at 11:20 PM

Sherrie Gogerty wrote:

Tim -- since we have an unexpected departure, could you folks POSSIBLY consider bringing Malan back??? He is really good television, apart from being a talented designer. I for one would love to see him return. The same situation presented itself on Top Chef when one of the contestants had to leave because of the imminent death of her father. They brought back one of the chefs who had been voted off in a prior episode.

Please bring Malan back...

posted on August 2, 2006 at 11:29 PM

Cuse wrote:

Hi Tim,

Where is the Cloisters video mentioned in the commercial? I live right next to it, and would love to watch the clip.

I

posted on August 2, 2006 at 11:40 PM

DEBBIE,CLOUMBUS OHIO wrote:

WAY TO GO ANGELA!!! YOU SURE SHOWED THAT EGOMANIAC/NUTCASE VINCENT HOW TO BE A TEAM PLAYER!!! LOVED YOUR TEAM....HOPE TO SEE THEM IN THE FINAL!

posted on August 2, 2006 at 11:41 PM

Ben R. wrote:

Tim,

As ever, your comments are insightful, well-spoken, and, frankly, *interesting*.

The more I read of your blogs, the more confused I am that some of these interpretations don't make it on air. What better way could there be for viewers to really get to understand some of the design elements of the show than a edited flashback track with your commentary as the introduction to each episode?

I'm always left disappointed in the episodes because I see more of the reality television and less of the design competition. Giving viewers like me an opportunity to collect our thoughts and evaluate what's going on as we watch, as though we were able to have our own Project Runway sketchbook...well that could really enrich the process of watching (a whole lot more than text-in voting).

Have I been surprised at the losers thus far? No, not so much. Do I miss them? Not particularly; my favorites are still in.

But I miss you, your intuitions, your assessments. You have more contact with the designers as their mentor, and yet you aren't given any sort of closure within the boundaries of the episodes.

Truly, you're my favorite element of this show. So, by all means, "Carry on."

posted on August 2, 2006 at 11:41 PM

Michael wrote:

Quote of the season: "Full tilt boogie Angela extravaganza of puff"!

posted on August 2, 2006 at 11:44 PM

Marsha wrote:

I think Angela's best move was in selecting Michael and Laura to work with. She had to know that the two of them, especially Laura, would keep her in line and more down to earth than she's used to. It was a brave and smart thing to do and saved her. They seemed to work well together too. And it was almost like everyone else was waiting for Angela to implode and they sort of forget about their own work.

posted on August 2, 2006 at 11:46 PM

Sarah wrote:

I was so sad to see Bonnie go! I think that she had a lot more to offer. On the other hand, I'm glad that Robert was spared--he has so much talent, even though his design was a bit off the mark this week. I am shocked and disgusted that Angela was the winner! I agree with you, Tim. If Michael and Laura hadn't stopped her, it would've turned into a gaudy mess like the rest of her clothes. I guess we'll have to put up with her for another week. Hopefully she won't last much longer!

posted on August 2, 2006 at 11:49 PM

redgrrl wrote:

tim, darling tim!...what would we do without you? your erudite analysis of the shows are just wonderful to read...you have such a care and love for fashion and the designers! it is SO evident in every word, both written and spoken and all the perceptive suggestions you make during the show! thank you, tim! we love you, tim!

posted on August 2, 2006 at 11:50 PM

Danielle G wrote:

Angela wins! And without a bubble skirt!
Oh Tim, you crack me up. I loved her outfit, but I'm done with her. So, now Keith is gone and Bonnie is gone, (which until the dog challenge I didn't even know she existed) is there going to be a special "at the end of the show it turns out everyone stays", a bringing a designer back ( cough cough MALAN cough cough) or a recap besides the reunion (please please no) to fill the void- since each episode contains someone being voted off (except the reunion of course)?

posted on August 2, 2006 at 11:53 PM

Elizabeth Marsack wrote:

I thought Keith was slimy. He had a slick way about him that I didn't trust. That isn't to say he didn't have talent as a designer; the orange dress he designed with the dog was stunning. But he just seemed to think he was above the rules (perhaps because he was so talented?) I didn't get the impression he wanted to learn from the other designers. It boils down to arrogance. For the sake of his talent, I'm sorry he's off, but for the sake of teaching him he's not above the rules, I'm not.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:03 AM

Debra Kistler wrote:

When Tim kicked off Keith, I was so happy. It was only a matter of time before he got thrown off, he never wanted to follow direction, or thought he could get away with anything, ex. when he made the outfit for the women and her dog. He did not follow direction,he didn't make anything for the dog. Then tryed to say he made the couler and got caught in a lie. I am sure that wasen't the first time he lied about something, but it was the first time he got caught. He seemed to have an attitude and thought he was better then everyone else. I think he actually thought he was going to win in the end. I did not like how he treated his fellow co- workers, as if they were incompetent. It was only a matter of time before he got caught not following the rules and got kicked off. I would never buy a piece of clothing from his line, his personality ruined every garmet he made that was beautiful to terrible.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:04 AM

Lauren wrote:

Well, I'm sad to see Keith gone. He was an ah-mazing designer and I don't see why he even risked having those books. He certainly did not need them. I don't disagree with them for kicking him off though. Rules are rules and need to be followed. Especially something as important as this. I'm glad Angela won, though a bit weird at times, I've come to like her. I think Alison and Jeffery did very well, considering their "handicap." Alison is one of my personal favorites, along with Kayne and Laura. I don't think Laura is reconginized enough. Uli is also an ah-mazing designer. As of right now, if I had to make a prediction of who would win, I would have to say Uli or Laura. Possibly even Alison. Good luck to all! I love this show!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:05 AM

clusseau wrote:

Cheers for Angela! That was Great to See!
(and Remember to Say ThankyouThankyou to Michael and Laura!).
Two words for Keith: Kara Sann.
(Dude, you were Toast after Schmoozing Mood's!). Both of them could have WON if they'd follow the Rules! And for the 11% who didn't think Keith should go- Please be more careful when voting- you must have clicked the wrong button...

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:05 AM

wilson wrote:

To the 11% thought Keith should stay- This is Bravo. (Maybe you were looking for MTV???)

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:11 AM

Alli wrote:

Keith - what a waste. It was bad enougn that he lied his way out of a bad spot last week, but he blatantly thought that the rules of the contest were something he could thumb his nose at on a regular basis! I agree with the rest of the contestants when they expressed dislike!
Robert - pull yourself together dude! You're a great designer, but got way off course this week.
Angela - count your blessings and Kiss Michael and Laura's butts daily!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:14 AM

Kelly wrote:

The models are always background pieces, but it was interesting last season when there was a fight over certain models and why they're actually important for more than just looking pretty.
I think it would be fun to have the models choose a designer (but not one they've already worked with, or they'll pick the same people.)
Just an idea.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:21 AM

Beth wrote:

Tim,
After each episode, I eagarly sit down at my computer to read your blog. It's like the icing on a cake. Your insights into the designing process, quiet observations and gentle critiques add so much more to my enjoyment of the show. Parsons & Project Runway is very blessed to have such a wonderful mentor for their designers.Carry on!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:21 AM

TK wrote:

I had basically the same order of finish, but with Robert ahead of Alison. Personal taste difference.

I'm so glad we finally got to see more of Michael, Angela won because she chose the absolutely perfect supporting team, and Bonnie is gone. What more could I have asked for? And they didn't give Angela immunity, so she could still be purged next week, I'm sure she'll find a way to (figuratively) hang herself unless she can get Michael and Laura to do her work again.

A shame about Keith, what a stupid stupid stupid way to blow your chances! We all make mistakes and we all learn to live with them, but some are more visible, long lasting, and bizarre than others. Too bad he couldn't just get a warning, but it wouldn't be fair to keep him on when everyone else is following the rules.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:24 AM

lexi wrote:

does this mean that Malan can come back?

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:31 AM

Becky Kling wrote:

I really miss Malan - I thought he had a good heart and was more talented than many of the others who presented their designs. Now that I've watched the last segment where Keith is out, I miss him even more so. It hurt my heart to see Malan leave, and I'll never watch that part of the series again because his sense of failure was so poignant, and so much of what we all go through to attain our goals. We all have a fear of failure, but when he was confronted with it, he handled it with an emotional grace that gave him an even greater dignity than I thought he was capable of. I wish the best for him in all things, and know that his designs will land him in a good place, because he's an incredible designer.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:38 AM

Shannon Mann wrote:

This episode was so anticipated! I'm a little dismayed at Keith's behavior but I don't think this will be the end of him nor is he a laughing stock. He was and is arrogant but he did some nice work. I'm glad Angela was successful at the challenge. She worked very well with her team mates and seemed to have learned a lesson from the last team work debacle. My husband's cousin got me hooked on this show last season and now I've made my husband and 12 year old son (who watches for the models) addicted to Project Runway.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:39 AM

lana kloch wrote:

i cannot read tim's writing. it is in small script and is colored blue and disappears into the white background. can there be a change. thanks, lana

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:44 AM

Jane wrote:

It's sad to see Keith go but it was pretty clear something shady was going to come up with him. He was really talented and too bad his arrogance was just a coverup for insecurity.

Without Laura and Michael, I'm sure Angela would've messed the challenge up..

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:44 AM

Sandy V. wrote:

I love this show! Thanks to NBC for showing a couple of repeat episodes on Monday nights, where I was intrigued enough to follow it's regular broadcast on Wed. on Bravo. It gives you a very good perspective on just how creative designers are/have to be. I'm hooked!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:46 AM

laura Sauls wrote:

What the hell!!! Bonnie was the BEST!!!
Are you kidding me>?!! Bradley's lazy ass should be out! this show now sucks and i am not watching anymore.
Pathetic to not see the genius behind the design.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:59 AM

nic wrote:

and without a bubble skirt!

oh how i adore you tim gunn. it's just too good.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 1:10 AM

MaryMAc wrote:

I's a bit sad and extremely annoying that Angela could have actually won this challenge. If it hadn't been for Michael and Laura, she would have lost simply on her 'rosette obsession'. Their influence toned down the garment and placed those nasty little buds where they actually fit. What's worse is , she actually thinks this vindicates her as a 'designer'! The only thing left to do now is.....CONTINUE TO WATCH until Angela has to fly solo again and her true colors( and pom poms) resurface.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 1:17 AM

allie wrote:

I thought Keith deserved to be kicked off. I loved how michael and laura kept angela in check, she clearly thinks those rosette things are cute, but they are awful!! I love Tim Gunn ... sooooo awesome adorable even.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 1:34 AM

Kate wrote:

Tim, I'd like to commend you for your ability to encourage and nurture without coddling. The show makes me miss Parsons, where I went years ago; the foundation year was quite Runway-like, in that challenges were thrown at us in all sorts of disciplines that we never thought we needed to master, made us anxious, sleep-deprived and crazy, and were great for us.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 1:34 AM

Liz wrote:

Good show! Glad Keith's gone, hopefully he gets off his high horse and uses his powers for good and not evil in the future. I was sad to see Bonnie go and glad Angela managed to be a good team lead. It's funny that Robert and Bonnie, the ones who knew how to present the best, didn't deliver very good designs...

posted on August 3, 2006 at 1:34 AM

AP wrote:

WHAT???? are you joking THATS the reason why he got booted? wow talk about dumb!!!

Man i would have backed up the whole "He cheated because he sent in someone elses work" but THIS? c'mon he still showed some pretty cool stuff.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 1:35 AM

Tibby wrote:

I do not like the fact that Angela won. She should have been kicked off in the Third episode. But one thing I missed? WHAT DID KEITH DO????? I guess I'll have to wait until tommorrow morning.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 1:46 AM

Samantha wrote:

I'd just like to say that I think Alison and Jeffrey did a wonderful job on finishing a design that was not their own. I feel that they should have won the competition, but not because they had a disadvantage. I truly thought that Alison and Jeffrey's finished product was VERY well done and something that would probably appeal to the younger and edgier customer. But I also agree with Tim, maybe their outfit was too edgy for INC. But kudo's to Alison and Jeffrey for making it work.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 1:48 AM

www.hipcandy.blogspot.com wrote:

Not cool Keith. Illegal pattern books in a fashion design competition? Not cool at all.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 1:50 AM

Nancy A. North-Gates wrote:

Tim, thank you for your insightful comments on the designs and how the sketches became the finished product. I love the way you critique and give advice to the designers.

kungfumom

posted on August 3, 2006 at 2:01 AM

Andrea wrote:

For this challenge, Angela seems to have "redeemed" herself, but I can't help but wonder if she wasn't simply strongly influenced by the others on her team. I certainly didn't agree that Allison's outfit was a winner this time, even given the Keith fiasco handicap. But I am totally neutral on them kicking off the person they kicked off for this challenge. Neither of the losing teams had anything to offer for this challenge. But the BIGGEST loser of all was HEIDI's ridiculous outfit that she presented herself in on stage. I'm sorry, but she is just too OLD for that crap! Who the h*** designed THAT? In fact, I don't know who designs any of her clothes. For someone who is supposed to be some fashion expert herself, she never wears a DAMN thing flattering. But oh well....I guess it's her name and wooden image that sells.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 2:09 AM

Ann Marie wrote:

Dear Tim:
Thank you for the clear explanation of the rule-breaking incident that aired tonight. I wonder, however, why he wasn't thrown off the show last week for not completing the assigned task (not sewing a costume for the dog.) It seems to me that was a break in the rules / explicit design instructions that should not have been overlooked. Also, what about the "bargaining down" of the overspend at Mood? That received air-time but there was no comment by Project Runway as to the legality of that "strategy." Do others get away with it from time to time, as well? Haven't we seen other designers forced to purchase less fabric over such price issues? Thank you for your part in such a great show, Tim. Ann Marie

posted on August 3, 2006 at 2:18 AM

Caline wrote:

I am not sure if the show can get more obnoxious at this point! Keith's breaking the rules is no bigger crime than the simple fact that Angela is still on the show and wins a challenge. When I saw those little flowers that she makes, I wanted to puke! No wonder I don't own any INC clothing. And Robert's only mistake was to have Vincent on his team. That man is so negative, he's like the kiss of the death spider--whatever that means. I'm done with the show.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 2:21 AM

Amy Watkins wrote:

I would just like to say, i absolutely do not think Angela would have won without the influence of Laura and Michael. Without their taming influence she would have bombed just like in the other challenges! So i say "Way to go Laura and Michael".

posted on August 3, 2006 at 2:23 AM

Chuck Gerrish wrote:

Typical reality TV fare so far, as the talent gets kicked off, as the resident retards KOoCOo For Coco Puffs Vincent, and RainBo Brite addict Angela, make themselves at home.. When I say talent I mean Malin(sp?) and Keith, and not the little chubby chick who looked and dressed like she just finished at shift at UPS. Late!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 2:24 AM

ModelTia wrote:

Wow....good designer, bad decision! I appreciate the thoughtfullness and discussion of the designers and the decision by the producers. Sorry Tim had to be the messenger but I am sure there was no debate (or it appeared that way). I love this show because I think the competition is of the quality of the Olympics and most pageants. So Keith's books can't be tolerated...no action would have compromised the integrity of the show.

Congrats to Alison and Jeffrey for stepping out of the shadow and leading the effort to bring someone else's vision to the runway! I am sure in your world, this won't be the last time!

Okay...off the soapbox. I LOVE Wednesday nights!!!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 2:24 AM

Joycelynn Barlett wrote:

I have had college classes in sewing, pattern design,draping and dress design,also tailoring. I Know the stress of the challenges and I love the show. You certainly caame up with an amazing show. Keith,s true colors came out and Angela redeemed herself (with help from Laura and Michael.) Now the show's second guessers will have a hard time guessing what's next, I LOVE YOU AND THE WHOLE SHOW!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 2:32 AM

Sherry Hamilton wrote:

Dear Tim,

Thank you for explaining Keith's departure from the show. Many of my high school students are fans of Project Runway - and unfortunately, like Keith, believe it's OK to do anything to "win." Project Runway showed us that there are real and hardfast rules, and most importantly, that breaking the rules have consequences. Thank you for showing us that important life lesson.

Sherry Hamilton
A.B. Miller High School
Fontana, California

posted on August 3, 2006 at 2:37 AM

Shirley wrote:

Tim,
Thanks so much for your "Tim's Take" after each episode. Especially this one. I really appreciate the details about why it was wrong for Keith to have those books in his possession and specifically what made it a dismissible offense. Also, a few posters commented about Keith's sketch book and how it had images of other's designs. Some posters even provided links so that we could see for ourselves. Yes, I "linked on" to see for myself. You cleared that up too. You are so needed Tim. Without you there is no "Project Runway."

Keith being kicked off the show is akin to Gabriel being kicked off "Last Comic Standing." He broke the rules by bringing in a Blackberry. No outside communication is allowed. Because of that show I knew someone was being dismissed on PR due to contraband, but fashion and pattern-making books never occurred to me. Then Keith made a second faux pas by using the Internet. How self-destructive.

Loved Angela's design concept, but we all know that Angela won because she had two of the best designers in the competition on her team!! She is nobody's fool. However, I can't wait for her to hang herself again next week.

One last thing: When Vincent said that Robert's skirt and top were too plain I almost fell off my sofa. Did he forget last week already?

posted on August 3, 2006 at 2:42 AM

Jorge wrote:

It didn't come as a surprise that Keith got the axe. Who didn't see this coming when he outright refused to follow the rules and didn't dress the dog? When he brought menswear samples to the audition to Project Runway, a show about women's fashion? Or when he negotiated with the shop clerk for a discount on his material? I would hate to think that sociopaths such as Keith are allowed to stay to add to the drama of the show. Kinda weak. I watch the show for the talent, not for the BS. Oh, and why Michael keeps getting overlooked when he is clearly a strong contender to take the top spot is beyond me. Michael, quick, create some drama so the producers won't throw you out!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 2:44 AM

JoAnn wrote:

Since Keith was forced to leave, everyone I know shouted "hurray. " Is there anyway you'd bring Malan back in his place? When Cynthia had to leave "Top Chef" another chef who had been voted off came back. As teachers, we all just loved Malan because of his honesty and standing by Katherine.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 3:20 AM

Danielle wrote:

I am so sick of Angela. The only reason her project looked good was because of her teammates. I mean, they stopped her from destroying a suitable garment with disgusting rosettes. Se is so annoying. I am actually surprised that she did not make yet another "inspired" bubble skirt. I have never seen somthing so unflattering. Her designs are completely juvenile and lack-luster. The garment she made for doggie style was awful. It actually looked poorly made and un-even. Ick. Please get this styleless mid-west hack OFF the show.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 3:41 AM

gregg wrote:

This was a turning point for the infamous Angela - even though I think she has no style, vision, or talent, somehow she managed to "win" this round with...gasp!...more of those horrid lil' rosets! For Pete's sake, what's going on here?! While I agree with kicking off Keith for his crossing the line (twice) and disregarding the rules ('cmon, no one likes a cheat!), the irony is that Keith is/was one of the most talented designers on the show and, judging from his previous wins and raves from the judges on execution and style, Keith had a very credible shot at WINNING the Third Season crown. Now, of course, we'll never really know. A few more things: Vincent is a hack, Jeffrey is underrated, and Michael is (most baffling of all) totally ignored once again - can it really be a racial thing? I hate to play the race card, but Michael has consistently shown ambitious, stunning, & totally spot-on looks since the first episode, and still he gets hardly even screen time or kudos - c'mon guys, do the right thing: axe Angela, keep the rest. PR should be about design skill, not "difficult" reality TV personalities that spike ratings, no matter the lack of genuine talent.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 3:47 AM

Alma wrote:

I just want to thank you and the producers of PR for the more professional tone this year.
The foul language last year really took away from the respectibility of the contestants.
This year is so much more enjoyable and the fewer "blips" are so appreciated!
Well Done!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 3:51 AM

shante wrote:

I think that Angela was the BIG surprise here! then again, being the underdog, she TOTALLY had to show that she does belong on the show. I think, though, that she showed wonderful insight in bringing in two people who ALREADY complement one another so that they could keep her 'quirkiness' stylish and sassy without becoming 'too much'. I have visions of a whole PANT LEG with those damn rosettes! ROCK ON, angela, YOU CAME THROUGH!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 4:27 AM

Karen wrote:

I'm with Tim: just sick. Likewise: Why-oh-why-oh-why? Why did he have to push the rules until they were forced to do something? I love Keith, but especially I love everything he's designed. And I know he missed the point of the doggie challenge by not designing for his dog---but darn it Nazri walking down the runway in that gorgeous dress with Morgan draped on her like that, and the chain---that was the sexiest thing I've seen. (And I'm a straight woman---I just wish I could look that good!) Keith was right. Putting clothes on that dog would have been a crime. Now a large element of spice and anticipation is out of this season (similar to what would have been if Santino had been kicked off or eliminated early on). Guys you love, and hate, and hate to love but you can't help yourself. I could see Keith being manipulative, it was clear he was doing that with Tara when he pitched his design to her. (And what a gorgeous gown he made for her.) But by the end of the season, I think Keith would have been one of the 3 and we would have understood the whole man better, as we did in season 2. I hoped Keith, Alison, and Uli could be the final 3. As it is, I don't know now. I liked Kayne and his designs, but the way he talked to the other guys --he was mad at Keith over-and-above Keith breaking rules---seemed too much like a personal vendetta. Now Kayne is not high on my list, I'm mad at him. (Who was it, by the way, who followed Keith and watched him go on the internet??) And what was Kayne doing snooping in Keith's stuff? And Uli, who seems so down-to-earth and imminently likeable---she's revealing some pretty ruthless qualities herself (like knowing there was something wrong with their outfit but saying it's Bonnie's fault and she has immunity so she doesn't care; and saying so blithely that she thought Keith had an unfair advantage having Nazri so she just 'took her away from him'---just as cold and unattractive as how Zulema did her switch, actually more so, like murdering with a sweet smile on your face. It's a competition and there's nothing wrong with wanting the best model. But you don't have to be cut-throat about it. I was all in Uli's camp, but now the jury is still out for me..) Finally, it's true that Keith shouldn't have done what he did, but I don't believe it was giving him an unfair advantage, I think Tim is right that it was a security net. Keith, I'm not laughing at you. You have incredible talent and taste. Plenty of successful people have done things far worse than you, so realize you don't have to become a saint, you just have to learn how to do your thing w/o crossing those uncrossable lines. You'll be sorely missed. And if they'll let you, please come back.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 4:32 AM

Pat wrote:

I am glad that Keith was kicked off, I think he should have left last week. They were supposed to design something for the pooch and he stuck a bracelet around the dog's neck! But this week he ended up hanging himself. What I don't get is why did they have to vote a designer off when Keith was told to leave.They went from 12 to 11, now they are at 10....or will they bring someone else back?

posted on August 3, 2006 at 4:50 AM

Claudette K. Stone wrote:

Tim, I love to read your blog! I was hoping that no one would be auf'd since Keith was asked to leave! Will Malan be brought back to even the numbers or will there be a week when no one is auf'd? Keith seemed petulant, refusing to take responsibility for breaking the rules. It seemed that leaving the set would be a greater infraction. And, what a surprise ending with Angela! I love P-Run!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 5:21 AM

Lisa wrote:

Michael & Laura should've won--not Angela! If it weren't for Michael & Laura, Angela would've produced more tacky crap. Plus, Michael has been outrageously overlooked. He should have won the 1st and 3rd episodes!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 5:51 AM

Jaime wrote:

I definately think that keith should have gotten kicked off the show. There are rules for a reason. In reaction to the sketchbook he presented at try-outs, I understand that designers have clips and references of designs and pictures that they find inspiring . I am also a fashion designer currently enrolled in school getting my masters. There is a HUGE difference between having clippings of other designers clothing for inspiration and putting those same pictures through photoshop and putting a filter over it to simulate a drawing. That alone should have been addressed way before the broken rules during the show. It is plain and simple, he fraudulently passed other people's designs as his own. ANYONE can do that.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 6:12 AM

Stephanie wrote:

First of all, can I say poor poor wittle Bradley.. His demeanor makes me think of a sad puppy. Personally, I love Bradley, even though I'm certain he will be gone within the next couple of episodes. Secondly, can anyone BELIEVE that Angela was involved with anything good??? Crazy, except I fully agree with Tim that her tacky taste was only saved by the other designers' input. Kudos for Angela that she actually seems to be learning from what the judges have to say. I'm glad to see that she actually CAN work with others... BUT I do hope she goes soon as I do not think she has anywhere near the amount of talent to qualify her for the rest of the show.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 6:26 AM

Maria Arsuaga wrote:

Excuse me? Now I might understand how Keith without any prior womenswear experience could "fit" a model so beautifully. Sorry, he was looking at the books at night, remmeber Emmett, how hard it was for him with his background to construct!!!! Hellouuu!!!! I thought Keith was leaving because he asked for a discount t MOODS...

posted on August 3, 2006 at 6:53 AM

Diane Johnson wrote:

What I love about the show this season is that you give the designers enough time and money to really be creative and show their talent - and that's why I watch the show in the first place. They are all amazing and diverse.

The model selection process this season assures that the top models will make it to the NY runway. It's a much better process.

I thought Keith was very creative - but now wonder how much of that was Keith. It would be informative if you were to put the post rules that the designers must follow on your web site.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 7:06 AM

lynne wrote:

As much as I'm sad to see Keith go, loved his work. I'm very disappointed in Kayne's tattle-telling to the producers. Kayne went from one of my favorites to now one of my least favorites. This win at any costs mentality is not a good look, ie Wendy Pepper. I know the main ingredient of the show is excellent design talent, but I want to be able to like the designer too. I cannot respect someone who squeals. And lastly Kayne, you also took away an extra episode; instead of losing one person, we lose two. Shame on you Kayne.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 7:07 AM

De wrote:

Wow, it looks like I may be the first to post. Loved Angela's design, regretably it was the best of the night. But here I go again Michael, get's much less respect than deserved. He and Laura really made this happen. No disrespect to Tim who is so right in your observation, but you could see that from China on the show last night. What was Bonnie thinking. It was really bad. The tunic was a combo of my old sweater dress and a cowl neck I wore on my 7th grade picture. I liked the Keith design, although I thought those open circles right on my hips would have been a non figure flattering mess.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 7:57 AM

fay wrote:

Michael and Laura should be the final two. It's interesting how the production is playing down both of them, especially Michael. We don't see or hear much from him. But out of all the of the designers his has been the most consistently solid and on-the-mark. His coffee filter dress was a knockout, his model/doggie outfits were HOT and he obviously has great style. I think he and Laura will end up duking it out amongst the final 3... perhaps with Uli or Kayne as the third.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 8:07 AM

scott wrote:

I'm sorry Keith was asked to leave. I agree with Tim's podcast/blog that the show really had no choice, and that Keith is a very talented designer. From listening to Keith's exit interview and Tim's podcast, it seems like there was a lot of hurt going around. Yes, he brought it on himself, but I for one wish Keith nothing but the best.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 8:25 AM

Melissa wrote:

At first I thought Keith just had some issues, but I am now convinced he has the whole subscription.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 8:25 AM

Barbara wrote:

Tim,

Here are my thoughts on Bonnie's and Robert's creations.

Bonnie's just needed some tweaks and that would have been a great outfit. I loved the jacket with the big pink buttons as a starting point.

1. She should have picked a drapy, flowie jersey material for the top and pants. Pink was OK for the top and she should have picked a dark chocolate brown for the pants. I liked the sleeves on her top. The long lenght was a great look. All she needed to do was make the top really fitted to the body, including the neck. That would have worked if it was a schunched turtleneck and not a cowel. The pants should have been real flowy. Wide and swingy when the model walked and that would have been perfect. The brown belt that Bonnie made would have been perfect if she put it on the coat to start. And the look would have been really neat if the model took the coat off and moved the belt from the coat to the pink shirt, low on the hip. Now I would buy that outfit at Macy's and feel really comfortable wearing it to the office.

Sorry but there is no hope for Robert's outift. I was really disappointed since he is one of the best designers. He really should have been kicked off but I'm glad he wasn't. I want to see more from him.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 8:28 AM

Mary Chambers wrote:

PLEASE BRING MALAN BACK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He was so funny and I really enjoyed watching the show when he was on it. You really should consider bringing him back on.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 8:28 AM

CEG wrote:

Argh!!! I HATED this episode!!! Not because Keith got kicked off (what a dope). Not because Robert temporarily (I hope) lost his mind and designed a a scary outfit worthy of JCPenney. And not because sweet Bonnie lost. I HATED it because that FREAK Angela won and then acted like she actually was responsible for the design and execution of the outfit! God that woman irritates me. I wish Michael hadn't been so kind (or was it just self-preservation) to literally throw himself between One Note Hippie Mama (poofy skirts) and her #!$%! rosettes and the pants. "My signature...that I'm so crazy about right now" -- how about just crazy period? This is one of the things that really irritates me about the show -- a designer can do three awful things and deserve to be kicked off and then do something like this and get to stay. That means the Wendy Peppers and Kara Janxs (?) get to make a lot further than they should.
Finally -- PLEASE give us more Michael!!! That kid obviously has a lot of style and skill, but we never see his stuff up close. And, give Bradley a shot rather than making him the show's Charlie Brown. His riff last night "I'm a squid without an ocean" was hilarious. Carry on.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 8:31 AM

Sandra wrote:

I really hate these team projects. From school to reality shows, they never showed the individual talent of the team members, and so it was on this episode. All of the designs were boring and unimaginative, and I would have preferred to see their individual concepts rather than only 4 designs. This episode was the worst of all seasons- no more teams please!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 8:34 AM

K.C. wrote:

It's really sad that Kayne is catching flak for telling on Keith. HE SHOULD HAVE. If they were taking a test would it be fair for Keith to have notes while everyone else has to remember their information without help? It seemed like the guys sat around discussing what to do when there was really only one option.
I'm glad that Michael and Laura won, not Angela. Her taste leaves much to be desired, and she chose the best two designers to save her from herself. It was too obvious who was going to win, though. There was no way that Keith's design was going to win this week simply because no one really knows if he used the fashion books or not. He says that he didn't, but who knows?
So many people are saying that Michael is underrated; one of the posters said that it might be racial. I really disagree with that. Michael doesn't really cause mess or drama, so why would he get a lot of screentime? However, his designs are divine and PR, more than any other reality show (to me) focuses on the talent of the contestants instead of personalities. Michael, your day is coming! Keep your head up!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 8:40 AM

shaxgirl wrote:

Tim! Someone besides me loves The Cloisters!! Whenever I recommend a visit to friends going to New York, they just looked pained and say, "No! It's just a bunch of medieval stuff." (cue trantrum) Thank you, Tim, for the lovely endorsement of The Cloisters--the best kept secret of New York!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:00 AM

Ami wrote:

As the cliche' goes, "It's not what you know, but who you know." In Angela's case, she knew Laura and Michael would be her greatest assets and she capitalized of their prowess of their insight and execution of her vision. Perhaps, losing the poof extravaganza and wearing the lime green appliqued pant-did something for Angela's psyche? Did she dress for success suddenly? Bonnie, a seemingly nice girl, with a powerful design for the challenge, created end product that can be proudly merchandised to the Bea Arthur fan club....Good luck to all. Keith-car dealers can reap from your (tricks)talents....

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:02 AM

Nordica wrote:

It was surprising, to me, that Keith, a menswear designer, could turn out such beatiful clothes for women. His construction was perfect but now we know where the designs came from. He knew what the rules were and chose to ignore them. So his demise was his own creation. I do feel that Michael's designs are totally overlooked and cannot understand why. He and Laura saved Angela and I hope she realizes it. Malan really deserves another shot as he has the vision of women's fashion. Granted, his Miss Universe gown didn't make it but was it any worse than the assistant camp director fiasco that Angela created? If only for his class and humility, he deserves another chance. Thanks for the opportunity to respond.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:02 AM

Mar wrote:

Good for you Angela! Congrats

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:07 AM

Lisa wrote:

It is about time Bonnie left her designs were very plain, bulky, and just ugly. Keith was always a cheater. Don't forget that he begged the fabric store to reduce his bill that alone is grounds to be kicked off. And he was too arogant to make a dog outfit. I am sure he will get a great job bec he is talented. I was very disappointed in Robert and Kayne. They are my favorites. What they did was very plain and poorly fitted. Are they getting tired and giving up. As for Angela she proved herself those stupid flowers actually looked stylish, feminen and beautiful! Sure she had plenty of help but come on it was her idea. I love PRW!!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:12 AM

Katy D wrote:

It's good that they kept tp the rules and sent Keith packing. To those who say he was an amazing designer, are you sure he didn't get help with those patterns? Not only did he have books but he also left
the group. Where do you suppose he went?

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:13 AM

Mary wrote:

Did anyone else catch on to Keith's other cheat? At Mood he asked for, and got, a discount, which meant he wasn't working within the same budget as the other designers. When I saw that I knew instantly that he was the one who would be out. Tim thinks that Keith's cheating was due to some insecurity. I don't. I think he probably takes as many shortcuts in his regular life as he did on the show. Keith's career is toast. He's been exposed on national TV as a cheater.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:17 AM

syl wrote:

Give Keith a break. He was by far one of the most talented designers on the show and I'm sad to see him go. Even though he deserved to go because of the rules violations, he doesn't deserve to be bashed. He was very apologetic and totally understood the reasons he was given for being kicked off. His violation doesn't take anything away from him being an amazing designer!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:20 AM

Ell wrote:

Way to comeback Angela!! I really loved the outfit. I would wear something like that more than I would have worn Keith's vision. However, while I believe Keith should have been asked to leave, I think Kara Saun should have had a stricter penalty as well for her violation. It was just as serious!! At the most, she should have been the first to leave after the show at fashion week and not allowed to stand as one of the final two. If this show is going to enforce the rules and not tolerate any infringement then they need to do it uniformly. Why was Kara Saun allowed to stay? I'm hoping that Vincent leaves soon. I really can't stand his attitude and personality. Anyway, carry on designers!! I admire your talent.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:21 AM

Linda F wrote:

As much as I don't like Angela, because of her obvious character flaws, I have to admit that I liked the outfit her team designed. She was smart enough to listen to Laura and Michael who are amazing designers. I did think it was bad sportmanship to celebrate so much in front of Jeffery and Allison. Itls a shame that Keith didn't follow the rules and argued with the judges, he has ability.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:21 AM

basquette wrote:

I don't question the decision to boot Keith unceremoniously and quick-like. What I have serious problems with is Bravo's refusal to comment - until now, that is, after the damage has been done - on these rumors. OK, I get that he's wicked, he breaks the rules. I get you have ratings to support. I even get that there's some liability issues here (I'm a lawyer). But what I cannot support, understand, or frankly stomach, is the silence that greeted these rumors. Bravo could easily have published a statement saying just what Tim said here several days ago, before the story got picked up in major press outlets. Keith may be a rule-breaking scoundrel, but if he's truly innocent of this charge, Bravo sold him up the river. Bad form, guys. And very disappointing.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:23 AM

dewey wrote:

Since we're airing rumors...how about the story Keith had for himself that he had never done womens wear before PR? I hear "false!". Is this another of his deceptions? In any case, good riddance to a very disagreeable contestant.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:25 AM

bonnie wrote:

Kayne's squealing didn't sit well with me either. I can actually relate to Keith - I don't care to blindly follow rules either. But on a nationally (internationally?) televised competition, you should expect that rules will be enforced. Keith is going to benefit, in the long run, by this very tough lesson. You can break some rules, but you have to know when and how. Kayne has dropped in my estimation considerably. I wonder if he would have been as concerned about pattern books if Keith hadn't been such a strong competitor. Now is the time for the remaining designers to ROCK their looks and compete on pure talent and creativitiy.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:35 AM

leah wrote:

I was very sorry to see Keith go. I understand that he needed to be sent home for breaking the rules, but I really would have liked to see what he could have pulled off at fashion week. The one thing I hope he's learned (aside from not cheating), is that he has a real talent with women's design. I really hope to see his work in the future. Keith baby - you do have fans out there. And Tim, as always, your words are so inciteful. How do you read those judges' minds??

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:36 AM

Nora Sinclair wrote:

It would be wonderful if the producers brought Malan back. Yes, the brown dress did look like it was carved out of a log -- but it was an original idea. And he's such a character and makes for such great TV. BRING BACK MALAN!!!!!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:39 AM

Juanita wrote:

Thank you, PR, for handling the "Keith" debacle in such a respectful manner toward the other contestants. The remaining designers deserved the spotlight, not Keith, and you gave them their moment. Keith's dismissal was brief, giving the audience a chance to focus on the designers and their creations. You all handled it very well.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:44 AM

Carol wrote:

So was Keith the villian or is there still another baddie? Broken rules certainly deserve someone getting the boot, but it wasn't as big of a scandal as I had hoped it would be. Keith didn't turn out to be such a villain afterall, because he really only hurt himself. I'm sure we'll all be treated to endless interviews with Keith proclaiming that he would have won if he hadn't gotten the boot and that everyone was jealous of his talent and were threatened by him, so they turned him in.
I agree with everyone else that Angela won largely because of Michael (show more Michael!) and Laura (show less chest) I loved Laura's quote about Angela and the full tilt boogie puff. The outfit was the best out of the 4, but overall, I didn't care much for any of the designs. Maybe they'll look better when I watch the show again.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:45 AM

Adrienne Smith wrote:

I am so glad that Keith got kicked off this week! He really should have left last week when he designed that GORGEOUS orange dress but didn't do anything for the dog. And this business about him being on the internet and having the how-to and pattern books just shows that he feels that following the rules is beneath him. But I don't doubt that we'll all be seeing him again, somewhere. He is an amazing talent, and if he could just rein in that over-weening ego of his there's no telling how far he could go.
Personally, I love Laura's work. She has a great sense of style, and if it weren't for her and Michael, Angela would have been a definite goner. But, alas, Laura's designs, while classic and chic, are a little too safe to win. Let's hope blabber-mount Kayne is the next to go. What a rat!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:48 AM

leilani wrote:

I was going to suggest that perhaps it was the gentleman from Macy's in charge of their Inc brand who should have been voted off, since he was the one who selected the styles which would be executed. At the runway judging the ladies gave the lowest marks to the teams they felt whose stylistic concepts were off the mark, the exact same concepts for outfits which had been chosen by the Inc guy in the first place!You explained that the final incarnation of the garments of the lower rated teams didn't fulfill the promise of the sketches, so that mitigates the insult somewhat,but we are perilously close to an inherently unfair situation where the teams were given the go ahead to do outfits that Heidi & Nina were guaranteed to criticise as concepts without regard to who had asked them to be done in the first place. In devising the challenges I think it would behoove the producers to make sure they don't come across as rigged set-ups to get the people off that don't make good tv. Viewers will accept almost anything except when they see people getting a raw deal. Other than that, I still say the designers this year are a cut above those of years past. But please add me to the exponentially expanding list of people wondering why it is that Michael, one of the most talented guys you've got there, doesn't get more airtime. Tim: can you please remember to address this unfathomable mystery in your next blog entry? It's really beginning to make people out here a little paranoid, even those of us who aren't black -what the heck is up with the production "blackout" of your only black cast member?

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:50 AM

Ms Math wrote:

Glad to know that you have rules in place that are solid and binding! When you break a rule, you must pay the price. Thank you for this bit of REALITY!

Several who posted have been requesting that Malan be brought back because PR is now down a designer. While I really liked Malan and would be very happy to see his return, I'd like to point out something that seems to be overlooked. One of the PR Blogs (either rucker or andy - can't remember which) mentioned in a blog that the dog challenge had to be moved up (it wasn't scheduled until later in the season so there wouldn't have to be so many dogs) because a company pulled out. Coupled with the extra designer being asked to leave would mean PR is right on track for the number of designers and challenges available. Of course, they could have found a replacement company by this point. Just thought I would point this out to everyone.

I too, was happy to see Angela pick the right people to help her out. She listened and collaborated well, and Michael and Laura did a good job of not being so worried about working with Angela that they undermined her design.

Both Robert and Bonnie had issues this time. For me, the cowl neck in the hideous color just did me in for Bonnie's design this time. Yet, I have liked the other things that she had done so far, so I'm sorry to see her go. Cudos to Robert to pulling it off, when his design this time, was off!

As to the poster who said they now didn't like Kayne for "tattle-telling", I'd like to say a few words. Shame on you! Firstly, Kayne discussed his concerns with fellow designers to find out their opinions. ALL OF THEM were outraged. The winner of PR wins a lot. Not only the money and support, etc. but fame, and a house hold name. It's the world series for up and coming designers. With what is at stake, the other designers did not have any choice but to turn in Keith for his cheating. And it is my understanding from the Bravo website and the subtext written beside the episode teaser, that Kayne AND Robert AND Michael went to the producers. So, if you are upset at Kayne, you'll need to open that net of dislike to include them as well.

You'll also notice that in the edited footage we see, that Kayne mentions "there are THINGS going down". The other contestants also knew about Keith's several hour disappearance. And while not much has been made of this in the footage, that is a big NO NO. Especially to the other designers who are shut off from their entire world for this experience.

Bravo to Project Runway for teaching the ways of the world to both the young people and adults who are watching this show. When you break a rule, you must pay the piper!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:52 AM

Laurie wrote:

Okay, if you listen to tim's podcast-the producers were already wondering and Kayne's story just confirmed the validity of the rumor. And the thing about Keith bolting from the van is just shady.

What I didn't understand was why Tim had to tell Keith in front of his whole apartment. It was so odd to have Vincent lying on his bed while Tim is telling him all of this. Maybe the bravo lawyers said it had to be done on camera with lots of people as witnesses, but it just felt insensitive to me.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:52 AM

Lilli wrote:

My first thought as Keith was kicked off was "Are they brining back Malan"?
Glad to see so many other fans feel the same way. Keith was talented, but over confident. Michael and Lara ---Angela should be in your debt. She would never have a design at Macy's without you.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:56 AM

EasyMac wrote:

First, I have to remind you Tim how much I fareeking love you. You are my favorite part of the show. I love your comments, assessments and style.

Second, I am so glad PR had ethics and enforced the rules and chose to boot Keith. It gives the show credibility, which is a good thing because this season was beginning to look like all the other reality shows: drama and quirkiness vs talent. Keith's arrogance and need to cover his insecurities was his downfall. He clearly has talent (his dress from episode 3 was gorgeous) but he needs to learn that it takes more than raw talent to succeed. Um, try a little humility, dude.

Third, Angela is an awful designer (and seamtress) but she knows who to pick for a team. I sincerely hope she made those choices because she realized how talented Michael and Laura are, and how much they would help her. There is no way she would have won this challenge if Laura and Michael hadn't been there to control the situation. In the end the outfit was very well made and IMO, deserved to win.

Fourth, PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE show us more of Michael! He is so talented and because he's not a drama queen, quirky freakoid he doesn't get any camera time. PLUS he meets the challenges to a "T" every week. I love your work, Michael!

Fifth, love you Tim, love the show.

Carry On!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:58 AM

biancaneve wrote:

So glad to see Keith is gone - he may be a talented designer, but clearly lacking in integrity. And bravo to Kayne for having the courage to say something about Keith. No one likes to turn someone else in, but when you're aware of a major violation and do nothing about it, then you're guilty as well. To those people who think Kayne is just a tattle-tale, I say the world needs a few more tattle-tales. Maybe we wouldn't have as many corporate and political scandals (Enron, Tyco, etc) if more people were willing to stand up and speak up when they see wrong being committed.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 9:58 AM

Ms Math wrote:

I think that both Angela AND Vincent learned from their earlier Team Challenge debacle. Angela obviously collaborated well. Yet this time Vincent had to be in Angela's shoes. He obviously wasn't happy with Robert's concept and the total look, but he wasn't negative to Robert, and didn't try to sabotage the clothing by sewing it incorrectly and making extra work for his team.

When it came to the runway, and he was asked for his comments, he very simply said that it was Robert's design concept, and he was only too happy to help. This is class. He could have gone the Angela road and said, "Oh I hated it, it looked like something I wore in high school, blah, blah, blah," and tried to save his own ass. When what he said was classy and non-confrontational.

For all you Vincent haters, he may be cooky, but he's loving life. Give it a chance yourself!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:02 AM

Jillian wrote:

I miss Keith.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:04 AM

Lynne wrote:

Tim-
Does Angela get full credit for the outfit? Will her name be the only one submitted to INC? If so, she should be ashamed. Laura and Michael took her concept and made it a workable piece of wearable art. Laura should also be credited with finally showing her how to take those "signature rosettes" and making then useful instead of abundantly and inappropriately placed. Having gotten this kind of help, Angela now has a big advantage, because for her, it was like going to a GREAT DESIGN CLASS in the middle of the competiton.
It was past time for Keith to go. He has a talent, but he's obviously very insecure about himself. He displayed contempt for the rules from the very start, and so he probably shouldn't have even applied for the show. He did not seem to believe that he would be held to the same standards as everyone else, and was very self serving.
I'm not sure why last night's challenge produced such bad results. I really didn't like any of the outfits. Nothing showcased the talents of the designers. I prefer the individual challenges. The group challenge either targets the leader too much as in Malan's case, or gives them too much credit as in Angela's case.
I know that people are wondering if Malan is coming back. I hope that you don't bring him back this season, but allow him to participate again next season (please do it again!) so that he can start out with a fresh new group of designers. He really does deserve a second chance.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:04 AM

Rose wrote:

PLEASE GIVE "MALAN" ANOTHER CHANCE HE WAS AWESOME ON THE SHOW PLEASE PLEASE BRING HIM BACK!!!!!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:05 AM

Becca wrote:

PLEASE bring Malan back now that there is a vacancy!!! Although this has already been taped, I guess you cannot, but it would have been terrific. Angela, Laura and Michael were a fabulous team and complimented one another well. Laura and Michael have fabulous taste and impeccable skills which grounded Angela and I really give Angela a lot of credit for listening, well done!! I just went on Macy's web site and ordered the outfit :))) I can't wait to see it on, I loved it when I saw the completed piece, although Alison and Jeffrey did a remarkable job and I loved their work. It seems the two of them have a bit of the same type of style, very "hip." I look forward to seeing what they do in the future.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:09 AM

Debbie wrote:

My first comment is to Lynne, who wrote that she was now very disappointed in Kayne for his squealing on Keith and this "win at any cost" attitude. first off, most of the male contestants discussed the discovery of the illegal books and the breaking of the rules and decided together that it should be brought to the attention of the producers. This is a contest, not a popularity contest and there is a lot at stake. I think the win at any cost attitude was Keith's for having the books in his posession knowing all well that they were against the rules .

Now for the rest of the show. I was actually shocked when Angela was chosen as one of the team leaders but she was smart for the first time and picked herself an excelent team. Michael and Laura guaranteed her success. Had it not been for their talent handling of Angela, it could have gond a lot differently. They persuaded her to turn potential "Rosette Hell" into stylish buttons that actually accentuated the piece nicely. Angela, you showed that you can be a team player, with vision, good judgement and that you can live outside the bubble skirt!!!! Allison and Jeffery did an excellent job on the design that Keith left them with. I really thought it was a close call between their work and with the desing that Angela's team did. I guess I was rooting for them a bit more since they were working at a disadvantage but still pulled it off beautifully.

Robert's team - What happened???? Even Barbie wouldn't have been caught dead in that outfit with that "rear view" slit. EWWW.

Bonnie's team - just plain EWWW.
Sorry.

One last comment - I have to agree with what a lot of others have said. I hope that since two left tonight that maybe, just maybe the producers will bring back Malan. PLEASE!!!!!!!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:20 AM

Ann wrote:

In order for a story to be tragic, there must be a tragic hero who has over-weening pride---enter keith. HUBRIS was his tragic flaw and it caught up with him. While we can all understand the drive to succeed, "the at all cost way" will usually catch up with you. The downfall was even more interesting to watch because most of us have already learned this lesson the hard way though, fortunately, not most of us had to learn it on national television!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:20 AM

Allison wrote:

Please, oh please, create a montage of the odd-couple friendship of Laura and Michael for the reunion special. Maybe to the tune of "Ebony and Ivory" I love that they appear to be the best of friends during this competition, but there is still a lot ahead.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:30 AM

nina b. wrote:

I first thought Keith was going to get kicked off because he copied runway designs for his portfolio. On tubescanboard.com, if you go to PR you will see Keith's design next to runway outfits done by professional designers, but I guess all well and ends well. It's funny with Keith they actually showed all the designers this time.

Angela lucked out with Michael and Laura as partners because without them she would've messed up the outfit like she normally does. Michael and Laura are becoming my favorite ones on this show.

I don't get how the judges said Robert's design was too boring, but all of Vincent's designs have been boring, but they never say anything about it. I liked the jacket, but not the other piece, just the jacket.

I didn't get Bonnie's design at all and what is up with Bradley. He's
like a little boy los, anytime I look at him and the way he acts, he always remind of a little kid who's afraid or is the outcast.

All in all, this was a good episode, finally the judges made good decisions, the right person won and the right person lost. Finally, they showed everyone, Michael got more than two glimpses of airtime.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:31 AM

Krystal wrote:

Angela may not be so bizarre as many of us have thought--remember Jay was a quilter and crafts person and he won. She could surprise us all if she gets a grip on her personality--if she can internalize Laura and Michael's restraining influence. Otherwise she will be eliminated, or degenerate into a scapegoat like Wendy and Zuelma from previous seasons. Each season has a wicked witch--I hope Angela can stay above this. I am also reminded of Chloe who was dissed by Santino, Daniel, and Kara, and then went on to win.

Each person who was eliminated deserved to be eliminated. Like Tim says--somebody had to go. It only takes one bad dress to get eliminated. Sooner or later all the lesser talents well get eliminated; it's just a matter of time, and then we're down to the final three. It's a process.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:36 AM

miranda wrote:

I agree that Keith had to go for violating the rules. But I'm curious about one point: Last season on Top Chef, Stephen went online for information about desserts, an area of weakness for him. Why wasn't this against the rules, when recipes are easier to find on the Web than fashion designs? Would Keith have been sent home if he had merely consulted the Internet? I ask because both shows are produced by the same people.

I rather liked Bonnie's coat; it had a nice retro vibe. Too bad the rest of the outfit was so literal that it just seemed "out."

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:36 AM

Mari wrote:

PLEASE bring back Malan. PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:38 AM

Emme wrote:

I'm glad Keith is gone--a talented designer, yes, but also an arrogant egomaniac (and not in an entertaining way, like Santino). I'm sad Bonnie had to go, because I've really liked most of her looks, but I adore Robert (I'm still upset that he didn't win the first challenge!), so, in the end, I'm happy with the outcome of last night's episode. Although I don't much care for Angela or her design aesthetic, she was a wonderful team leader--when she made her comment about "this is how a team is supposed to work", I was right there with her! They had a true collaboration going on. It was her design, her vision, but Michael's lining fabric and Laura's rosette buttons (adorable, by the way) added to the garments so beautifully. And even if you absolutely hate Angela, you have to admit that she showed incredibly good judgment in snapping up both Laura and Michael--not just because of their considerable individual talents, but because they work so well together. In fact, they are my favorite thing about this season so far: the little soul-mate friendship they seem to have found. Hope to see them both in the top 3, and Michael for the win!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:39 AM

eldetee wrote:

Angela's outfit was nice, but now it's on Macys.com for $257! And we saw them make it for $100 in retail fabric prices! It really works for INC but don't you think these prices are a little out of line?

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:43 AM

Marianne wrote:

I absolutely CANNOT stand Angela anymore...I'm surprised she didn't change her mind at the last minute and throw one of those hideous poof skirts on the model...Jeffrey and Allison's outfit was, by far, harder to construct and a lot more fashion forward than Angela's...and exactly how was it inspired the empire state building? the only reason this outfit wasn't as awful as her other 3 was because of Michael and Laura. SEND ANGELA HOOOOME!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:52 AM

Jen wrote:

Is Kayne driving anyone else crazy? Some of the things he says come across as just plain stupid..."I'm from the South, and we love color." What? And while I applaud the professionalism used with the whole Keith fiasco (what a waste of talent, even if it was somebody else's), I find it annoying to listen to Kayne tattle like a jealous school boy. Couldn't this have been picked up by the producers alone? If you show him practically pocketing $20 at MOOD, why is it Kayne's whining that gets the job done?

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:55 AM

Marsha wrote:

I was frankly, very happy for Angela because Vincent was so horrible for her to work with in the first group challenge. She may not be a great designer but at least she has enough sense to take advice and criticism. Bradley-how pathetic. He has flown under the radar screen but it is time for him to be shot down.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:57 AM

fashionista wrote:

My main complaint this season - not enough Tim!! He comes in, offers a couple of right-on-target comments and leaves. No real interaction with designers, no conversations, just not enough Tim!!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:58 AM

Debbie wrote:

I think Tim was being very kind to Keith. His claim that he never used the books is as credible as his claim that he designed four different outfits for the dog. Clearly, he is a person who feels it is OK to bend the truth.

On another note, I am thrilled with the level of maturity and professionalism of the most of the designers. They seem like a great group.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 10:58 AM

Sherry wrote:

Angela is a one trick pony. Even though she was saved by Michael and Laura this time, she will be gone soon. I think we have yet to see Michael's best. Watch him to come on strong as the show continues. I agreed with Heidi, their
outfit looked more expensive than $100. Sorry to see Bonnie go. After watching the dog challenge show again...did Alison have a sour grapes look on her face?

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:01 AM

Kathryn wrote:

Katherine needs to come back, since she was the last one voted off.

Keith broke THREE rules in this show alone. 1st, he went over budget and had the store fudge the numbers. 2nd, he went AWOL and accessed the internet, and 3rd, he had banned books in his possession (I don't CARE if he used them, the fact that he HAD them meant that he was prepaired to peek should he need to do so). Talented or not, this guy a walking lawsuit.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:03 AM

Paulette wrote:

What an episode!!! So, glad Keith is gone. Didn't like him from the beginning and always seemed to do his own thing. He said he didn't use the books then why have them. And that still doesn't explain his absence on occasions and use of the internet. You reap what you sew dude!! So, glad Angela calmed down on the damn rosettes. Angela, although they might be your signature on your garment doesn't mean you have to go hog wild and put them every where on your pieces. Make it subtle and "make it work". Tim, Tim, Tim love ya. My husband and I watch the show religiously after the kids are in bed. Your insight adds to the whole show. keep up the good work and god bless from the alamo city, texas

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:13 AM

Jolene wrote:

First let me say that I was glad to see Keith leave the show. I felt that although he did have tatlent for design, he just wasn't *there* on the show. He couldn't look people in the eye when they were talking to him (in the *best friend episode, Tim was trying to discuss the outfit and no doggie wear). Arrogance is good, but that attitude was ridiculous! PLUS he had nothing to be arrogant about.

Secondly, Angela should be kissing the ground that her wonderful partners walk on because THEY won that for her. She should not be smug about this except that she was savy enough to know good talent when she sees it.

I also want to see more of Tim interacting with the designers more. I seems as thought Tim was with them more in the other seasons and I love his comments. The man is insightful!

Finally, I am not too crazy about the immunity *prize*. Using that once....maybe twice in the past is good.....but not as much as it seemed to be used this season. To me, it takes away from the *competition.

LOVE this season though....I even rewatch the reruns!!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:17 AM

ning wrote:

I love the show, and would love to see more how they turn the sketches into real outfits. I mean some previous posters said that it is more reality show than the design competition. Nevertheless, I still love the show. I was surprised that Angela didn't go home last episode (designing for dogs). Because I rather wear the snowboarder's dress (I forgot what her name was) than Angela's. And last night's episode, if it wasn't because of Michael and Laura. They're the talented one. But I have to admit that she was a good team leader, she listened to her teams opinions and expertise.
Tim, maybe Bravo can make another show about how to make dresses and stuff, and you can be the host with the winning contestants as the co-hosts, and show the audience step by step of dress making. I am sure a lot of people would want to watch it, I know I would. Because a lot of home sewers don't have time or money to go to design schools but would love to be able to sew couture clothings.
Oh yeah, bring Malan back, he deserves another chance.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:17 AM

Suzi wrote:

Please bring Malan back.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:18 AM

Krista wrote:

I think that Keith should have been kicked off for breaking the rules as much as everyone else thinks too. Rules are so important for a competition and need to be followed by EVERYONE. I don't think there is a chance for Malan to be brought back though since this show has already been taped and they are all prepared to air I still can't believe that Angela won this challenge though because her past outfits have just been plain hideous. Michael and Laura definitely saved her this week.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:18 AM

pjp msu wrote:

Ok - get over Angela winning! Her design won, yes with Laura and Michael's assistance. But she was a great team leader! She asked for input and advice and lead her team to the victory. That's the point of a team challenge. Even Vera Wang has a team of people who help her carry out her vision of fashion. She doesn't sew every stitch. The next great American designer has to possess those qualities with the talent.

When Angela was part of Vincent's team, Vincent wouldn't allow her any input - in fact, didn't want her touching his design. I don't recall seeing her touch the dress. She had a bad team leader in Vincent. I'm sure even Michael Kors allows his staff some creative input. Whether or not he uses the advice is up to him.

I don't think Angela will win, but there is a niche for everyone in fashion - look at Jeffrey. Most Americans would not wear his designs but he has carved out a place in fashion for those who want to wear his style. Even Austin Scarlett found is place in designing wedding gowns.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:19 AM

Jay wrote:

If Laura was bad mommy then Keith is bad designer. BRING BACK MALAN.

Angela, like all the other comments touch upon, lucked out this week and hopefully has learned to design for the client incorporating your style, not the other way around.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:23 AM

Jolene wrote:

Ohh..I forgot to mention....even though I know this is for *models* and only extremely thin ones at that....the design made by Alison and Jeffrey was one that many women with a few body types could easily wear the outfit unlike Angela's outfit which could probably only be wore by the very thin. But hey....normal size and larger size people do not need nice clothes....

And I agree with atleast one other that since Keith is GONE....hehe....call back one of the let go designers like..oh I don't know......call back Malan?? The man had talent and his gown could have been a bit better but I thought it was different and beautiful.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:23 AM

Paige wrote:

First, please stop asking for people to come back! Gees, the show was taped months ago, and the requests are doing NOTHING!!! Glad Keith's gone. Fair is fair, and he is so arrogant, he probably thought he'd actually get away with it. That, or he's just really insecure about his abilities. Applause to Allison and Jeffrey for seeing Keith's design through. I liked it best, but it was probably too forward for INC and Macy's. Poor Angela. Lucky for her that Michael and Laura are so talented and strong willed. Robert was wack this week, that outfit contradicted itself all over the place. He def. got some credit from previous weeks. Plus those sketches he generated in 30 mins were amazing. I thought Bonnie's outfit more wearable than Roberts, but the pants were some nasty fabric and the cowl was BULKY. She didn't use her money well and went with quanity over quality. Keith and Angela did best with the money which is always a plus for mass production.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:29 AM

Lena wrote:

I felt that it was good when Keith was told that he had to leave. Rules are rules right. Could you bring Malan back he had talent.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:30 AM

Paul wrote:

Within the context of the contraband books, violations of internet use and unauthorized absences from Parsons, I have a question for Keith, how many outfits did you prepare for the dog?

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:31 AM

Evelyn wrote:

So... I actually read about a quarter of the way down the page, and then I stopped because I was already thoroughly shocked at the widespread hatred toward Keith.

This, I completely don't understand. I will admit, he was a bit arrogant, self-centered, and seemed to view himself as a cut above the rest. However, this show isn't about judging the characters of the designers (and if one was to judge the character's of the designers perhaps they should consider that Kayne "ratted" out Keith and failed to first at least consult him on the issue); it's about judging the designers' abilities. Only someone completely devoid of any style at all could possibly say that Keith's work was not exquisite! I am honestly devastated (or as devastated as I can bring myself to be about a television production) that Keith is off.

As far as the incident with the books is concerned. Yes, he broke the rules. Technically, having those books would give him an unfair advantage, although it is pertinent to consider that being originally a men's ware designer, Keith was at a significant disadvantage to start out. Regardless, it is irrevocably clear that he broke specific rules of the show and so it is appropriate (although depressing) that he leaves.

I find comfort in the fact that Keith has gotten three and a half episodes of exposure, and in that time he has shown clothing so beautiful that he will, without doubt, go places. This leads me to my next thought, which is, that Keith was my favorite designer because of his incredible talent. As a woman, I loved his clothing because I would want to wear it. Hence, I sincerely hope that he reaches incredible success (which even without Project Runway I think he will) so that some day I can wear his fantastic clothing. The minute I find out it hits stores I will surely buy some.

I apologize for the length of this comment, but maybe some of the harsher critics could soften their points of view. Further, best of luck to Uli and Alyson, both of whom I find to be very talented and definitely deserve to win.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:33 AM

Sara wrote:

Darn that Keith. He was such an arrogant so-and-so but so very talented. I hope he learns that sometimes you have to play by the rules. Keep the rule-breaking for fashion innovations. I won't miss his personality at all, but I will miss his designs. I always found myself gasping a little in spite of myself.
Angela...I can't believe it. I hope she knows how indebted to Michael and Laura she is. I do give her snaps for actual collaboration with her teammates. Vince was such a schmuck with her and it aggravated me no end that the judges seemed totally unaware of how difficult he was being. I think Michael has been the most overlooked designer there. His execution is flawless and I thought his doggie-inspired duds were gorgeous.
I love this show! More design and sewing, less drama, please!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:35 AM

Bill wrote:

All I can say is that I can't wait for Dave White's article in advocate.com for the PR follow-up. Even if the advocate isn't your thing, go to the website and read dave's weekly stuff. He did great with American Idol, now he's hilarious in his PR recaps! This totally sounds like an ad, but I'm just a fan, really!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:42 AM

Lissa Woodson wrote:

Angela's win was a direct result of Laura and Michael's influence. They tamed the wildness and even helped to place the famous "rosettes" where they would work best. Personally, Keith's arrogance turned me off and I felt that his blatant disregard for the rules last week was astounding. Karma being what it is--fairness ruled from another corner.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:42 AM

BBMOMMA wrote:

Tim, last night's show was finally right on mark. You, as usual, were the star of the show. Your confrontation with Keith was handled with a grace and professionalism that is Tim Gunn! Your interaction with all the designers re: Keith's leaving and their design development was nothing short of inspirational. It is clear to see why you have the position of importance that you do at Parsons and why you were chosen to be a key member of PR.

For whatever reason the producers chose to remove Keith from PR, it was about time. I know that you are being your always classy self by stating that you do not believe Keith used any of the materials, however, your generosity by calling him an "exceptionally talented designer" eludes me. I have only seen designs, that to me, were clearly copies of other work in different fabric. I was relieved to see Keith go. His often scarry arrogance and manipulative behavior (i.e. Miss USA) was painful to watch.

Now, Miss Angela's win. This too was very painful to watch as Angela revels and reaps the rewards of this win, when clearly it was Laura's and Michael's win without any of the rewards, so sad.

However, I was overjoyed to finally see the judges being design judges. They actually discussed color, cut and fabric as key to any design. I look forward to the balance of the challenges being judged this professionally. Yes, unfortunately Bonnie had to go for all the reasons they stated. It was a scary few seconds when there was a chance that Robert might go because I believe that we have not seen his best yet and that when we do we will be enchanted. Great show Tim, Love you as always, Carry On!

P.S. saw your promo re: the Cloisters, it is a bit of spiritual heaven here on earth for mere mortals, look forward to the entire show.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:45 AM

mjo wrote:

You've got to be pretty tiny to wear Angela's design. The other designs were adaptable to more body types. I would love to see a challenge where the judges make their choices, then the designs are offered for sale to a group of consumers. I want the consumers to actually try things on and look at themselves in the mirror. I'd love to see whose clothes are bought quickly. I wonder if the judges and consumers' choices would coincide.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:46 AM

Bob wrote:

This is a great show - and I love watching the design process. One of the few shows in the "reality tv" genre worth any time. Thank you!

Tim, your insights and observations are wonderful! When I get to a computer after the Wed nite episode, your take is one of the first thing I go to. Thank you for sharing with us.

While I agree that Angela could/should have been eliminated in the past, that she would not have won without Laura and Michael, and that she will likely be gone soon, I congratulate her for her vision and her desire to collaborate with her team, which "toned her down." Bravo!

There are several (I count seven) wonderful designers this year (as opposed to the two or three, imo, in each of the first two seasons), and it will be difficult to predict who will make it. Can't wait for next week!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:46 AM

Cookie wrote:

Is Keith being replaced? If so I hope you guys would consider bringing back Malan, what a character. He seemed to want this the most, the season preview with his two previous auditions confirmed that for me. When he opted out the second time I felt he knew he wasn't ready. But this time he didn't get his chance to shine.

Please give Michael Knight more screen time he is such a talent, not a personality. His beautifully constructed dress are heaven (with a splash of hell for sexiness).

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:47 AM

Diana A. wrote:

Bravo to Keith, he was the best designer on the show! Kayne ruined it! Could someone please send home Angela and Vincent? They suck! PLEASE!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:53 AM

old AK wrote:

I too wondered why on earth Keith would cheat? I really appreciated Tim's speculation that it must stem from some type of insecurity. Nobody likes a cheater and I'm glad you exposed him and got rid of him (way to go Kayne!). Rules really are not meant to be broken. It's sad because I enjoyed watching him and his creations. BTW, Keith, you are no scapegoat, you are a CHEAT - big difference!!

Angela so reminds me of Wendy Pepper with her being so hideous and then winning a huge challenge. God, please don't let Angela get into the top 3 - actually, God, get rid of her ASAP!!!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:54 AM

Sebrina wrote:

Tim,
I think you are awesome. Keep up the good work and "Carry On". Ok, first, I totally agree with those who said that Angela probably would not have won had it not been for Michael and Laura. Just given her track record, I think she would have hung herself had she been by herself. It seems as though she does have some sense (which I questioned before) to choose talented designers to be on her team. The one thing I have a problem with, and it might just be me. Angela admitting that she doesn't like to sketch. So, I don't think she will be staying long or at least I hope, because I am tired of those florets she likes so much. Second, at first I too had a problem with Kayne telling on Keith. To me I thought he should of talked it over with Keith before going to the producers. However, then I remembered that this is a competiton, so you gotta do what you gotta do. In the end I understood what Kayne had done and I am glad the PR did not let it slide. Besides, Keith was beginning to show his true colors, by trying to bend the rules his way. So I am glad that he was dismissed. I think that Robert is still a strong designer, so I am glad they kept him, even though as one person put it "he lost his mind on this challenge".
I love the show. Can't wait unit next week.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:55 AM

Kristopher wrote:

I must say I was crestfallen to see Keith leave the show last night - his level of sophistication and panache, I felt, far exceeded his fellow designers. Personally, I wasn't offended by his possesion of the patternmaking book - which usually contain scale layouts of patterns or step by step pattern development instructions - as it would have been little use sitting on his bedroom shelf. If he was using it for inspiration, could he not have been just as inspired walking on the streets of New York ie - walking up Central Park to meet Tim? So although it was a rule - I'm not to upset that he broke it. I suppose it was a bigger mistake on his part to leave to leave the show for five hours. I must say though - I love rebels - people who live by their own rules (think John Kennedy) and I think that his attitude will only propel him along in an industry where breaking the rules is the name of the game. Don't be ashamed Keith - your talent won't betray you.
As for Kayne - and possibly my opinion is formed by creative editing - NOONE likes a tattletale. Though I've never felt he was talented or inventive enough to make it to the top three - I find him particularly off-putting after narc-ing on Keith - Kayne you SHOULD be ashamed.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 11:56 AM

Willski wrote:

Looking back, Keith had some serious integrity problems from the start....
He turned in those copied sketchbook things at his audition.
And last week he full on lied and said he made 4 outfits for the dog!? and then lied and said he made the collar/bracelet, until Heidi called him on it.
I have never believed his whole "I have never designed a dress before, I do menswear" thing.
PR does NOT need someone like that around!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:03 PM

Robert wrote:

Keith was a hottie, but no room in the inn for cheaters. He had to go. I think Robert and Kaine should join forces after the show, create a lable and be the wondertwins of fashion.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:08 PM

Jeff wrote:

I agree Keith did make some great pieces, but he was most likely cheating the entire time. I think it's great that Keith was kicked off. It validates to the viewers that Project Runway is a real competition.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:09 PM

Jan Lancaster wrote:

Tim, I love your blog and I wish the show would allow more analysis from you on the air. Even though Keith was good television (you have to have someone you love to hate), he was also a good designer. Please consider having posting your blog in a darker color. Those of us who are older have a hard time reading the light blue! I miss some of your words and have to extrapolate!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:09 PM

trixie wrote:

First of all let me join in on the Tim Gunn Love. That said, this season is pale in comparison to the gang from season 2. Of course it is a competition, but the reality is - Project Runway is a tv show. Something had to happen to mix it up a little, as just casting "kooky" and artistic types isn't enough. Keith has been set up to be the villian, and now he has been cast away. Such is the nature of drama. As far as the competition goes, I think Michael should have won the first challenge as his dress was clearly the most innovative. My frustration with the show started with that - as the judging didn't take into consideration what was said about what the challenge actually was about.
I am one fan that hopes things pick up as things go on....I need my weekly Tim Gunn fix.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:10 PM

Samantha wrote:

Keith: deserved to go. You know he used the pattern books. Odd that his first dress won otherwise, don't you think?
Angela: she was more likable and Vincent is the real villain. He is whiney and unappealing. Why he wasn't booted with the black deal with leggings--the dog challenge--I don't know.
Kayne: Had he not "told" on Keith, all of the designers would be impacted negatively. I'm sure he didn't like being the one to tell the producers. He looked embarrassed at having to do it. I really like him, in spite of a certain flamboyancy.
Laura: love her skill; hate her plunging neckline on such a flat chest.
Bonnie shouldn't have gone!
Tim: still the star!
Challenges this season: every week (except the destroy-the-apartment episode) has been just a delight!
AUFFED KEITH--YEAH! He was nice to Bradley, but he was a fraud...

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:12 PM

Kate wrote:

I am shocked and in a state of perpetual cognitive dissonance about this week's winner. Angela's designs are a trainwreck! I strain to find a discription for her visual aesthetic--perhaps if you combined all of the cheap clothes and the adolescent scketches of the mid-eighties and blended them in a dreadful food processor...all that is missing is the SCRUNCHIE or perhaps a banan clip. If this is fashion, consider me off the wagon!

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:12 PM

AZGirl wrote:

Why oh why is Michael so overlooked? Everything he has presented, from his audition garments to his work in lending his taste to the tasteless Angela, has been lovely and inspired. I'm hoping he becomes the "Chloe" of this season, quietly making his way through the rounds with excellent outfits, and blowing everyone out of the water with a gorgeous collection.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:14 PM

Melissa wrote:

I stick with my top three decisions from last week:

-Michael.
-Kayne.
-Uli.

(although... Laura could sneak up there too.)

I'm sort of glad Angela redeemed herself. I think she has something to offer and really just needs direction and advice. I'm glad she was humble enough to listen and to be a great team leader.

Thank you thank you thank you for showing us more of Michael. Not only is he a SPECTACULAR designer... how hot is he? haha.

and... is Bradley on drugs? Every time they interview him, its just like... wth is he talking about?? Please get rid of him. He is useless.

posted on August 3, 2006 at 12:27 PM

Lee wrote:

Why did the judges chew Bonnie out for making the cowlneck sweater -- when she made it only because the guy from INC chose it and asked her to make it? Shouldn't they have yelled at HIM for his bad taste in picking it?

I also thought Ang