Medusa wrote:

Vincent deserved to be kicked out this week. Alison's design, was by far better. Fine art???!!! I couldn't believe he actually said that with a straight face. The dress looked like a grade school poster made into a TUBE-LIKE costume. I still can't believe the judges didn't think of Alison's talent and potential when they decided she should go, and neurotic Vincent deserved to stay. I'm in disbelief!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:23 AM

Liz wrote:

Oh, Tim. Thank god someone said it. Vincent has skated thru on every show when I think he should have been the very first one 'aufed.' Last night's episode was a TRAVESTY.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:24 AM

Kristen wrote:

"But I guess Vincent has the last laugh; he’s still in. WHY?"

Because he makes for great television.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:26 AM

diane wrote:

Okay, while Allison's design was not the best, I am willing to cut her some slack just like the judges cut Kayne slack because overall she is very talented. Vincent however, is the worst excuse of a designer since Wendy Pepper. He consistently designs poorly constructed ugly clothing that no woman in her right mind would wear, he gets lambasted by the judges but then passed on to the next round. That means the producers are keeping him on for comic relief or drama. It this were a real design competition, not a tv show, he would be gone. Angela has had a couple of hits but she is in no way on the same level as Allison, and this week's outfit looked like something from outer space. She needs to go.
Uli can design dresses that don't have halter tops. Who knew! Laura is playing it too safe, her lines are classic but I am getting bored with her. I LOVE Michael. He is the most consistent designer of the group, thus far. Having said that, I do think Jeffrey's dress was a little more innovative than his and deserved to win. Of course, that would have made him even more full of himself than he already is. Robert should have designed a dress like the foil design for last week's Jackie O challenge instead of the linen/rope contraption.
Overall, I am glad Michael is getting more face time.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:27 AM

cheryl wrote:

if anyone's dress is influenced by schiaparelli, it was definately jeffrey's, and not laura. elsa schiaparelli was (i think) the first person to use a newsprint pattern in textile and the trompe l'oeil belt was defiantely a schiap kind of touch. loved this dress!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:29 AM

dana ny wrote:

Alison out? Vincent and Angela in? Somestimes, one must question the judgement of the judges (and yes, even the producers). BTW: Does anyone remember the episode in which Nina Garcia praised bradley's "sculptural" outfit (the one, though I love you bradley, made the model look sort of like a beehive up top?) Nina certainly did not extend that same courtesy to Alison, even though her piece was much better constructed. Even though her outfit was not extremely wearable, Alison clearly has tremendous talent, and to boot her while the likes of Vincent remain is not only tragic, but also ill-advised for the credibility of the show.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:30 AM

allison wrote:

Tim you have said exactly what I was thinking!!! Kudos to you for telling it how it is. My friend and I were practically crying when Alison got outed. WHY NOT VINCENT? It doesn't make sense, it makes me so angry. He should have been out after the first episode.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:30 AM

Dana wrote:

Good show last night. Michael's dress was good, but I thought Uli's was better and Jeffrey's was the best. It was a great design - I can't believe it was made from newspaper! And although I really like Laura, I am still scratching my head as to why she is so confrontational. Maybe she spends so much time with her kids, she thinks it's her job to tell everyone her opionions. Too bad she's so unpleasant - I think she could be great. Can't wait for next week's show!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:37 AM

Dee wrote:

Oh Boy!!! Let the games begin.

I couldn't believe it. Vincent in??? What's Up With That? The dress didn't just look my 1st grade craft project but IT was my fist attempt at making paper dolls at age 6. Come on give me a break.

It's down to 8 now and and most of the people left (except Vincent) I think have a fair chance at making the final three. With every auf now, I will be hurt by the outcome. Even Jeffrey and Angela have a fair and fighting chance, since they have both shown some genious at certain points.

Okay, at first I was not quite sure about Michael's dress. I love Michael and it was a great dress, but I liked Uli's, Laura's and Jeffrey's. I even liked Robert's but I guess he wasn't creative enough to make the top three considering his past two mis-steps. I think Jeffrey didn't win because what the dress didn't have in "design" was really made up for with paint.

I think there will be a lot of complaints posted against Michael but let me say this. The silhouette, the bustier, the design was beautiful. Really take a second look you will see what the judges see.

Finally, I am sorry to see Allison go but only with Vincent staying. I think she had some stiff competition through the next 4-5 challenges so she may not have made it to the final three. She was never a favorite of mine and in the last two challenges (I hate to say it) Angela pushed a little ahead of Allison in my oppinion. I do agree with Tim though her dress was sculptural and pretty to me. I am sorry that it did not flatter the model.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:38 AM

Mary Mac wrote:

That's it!Fire Michaels Kors....Fire Nina Garcia!! How absurd that Allison would be let go before Vincent. At least her design FIT the model. Vincent has been in the "low score" catagory for almost every episode. Why, oh WHY would it take the "professionals" so long to see that he is stuck in the 60's! Next...I adore Michael. In fact, in my opinion he WILL be in the remaining top three...but come on...Jeffrey HAD this one. Even Michael Kors said it was the ONLY dress that 'flowed'. So....what happened? Robert was a very close second ( beautiful...kudos for not boring us this week!) and Kayne just plain lost his mind. On the bright side, we didn't have to witness Angela jumping up and down on the runway like a three year old that has to go potty.
BOO -hissssss for ousting Allison, guys.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:39 AM

Jess wrote:

all i can say is : I LOVE MICHAEL!!! Michael is fabulous and deserves to win the final at the end. Also, Kayne is a great designer. He had one mess up on this episode but he'll move on and do wonders as usual. As for Jeffrey, I was not liking him at first but as the season goes on, he grows on me more and more. He is a great designer with a nice edge to him, but he could definitely do with an attitude adjustment. Same goes for Laura. She is a classy and elegant lady but all her stuff is starting to look the same to me and she really needs to get that pointy nose out of the air. I love this show and am completely in love with Tim Gunn!!! i watch it EVERY wednesday night and TiVo it and rewatch it till the next one comes on a week later! keep up the good work guys and good luck Michael!!!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:39 AM

Laura wrote:

Tim,
In your opinion, why is Vincent still around after 3 weeks of poor showing, but Allison is eliminated? Doesn't the show need to keep good female designers around? It seems like a repeat of last season - it's the "Boy Luck Club."

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:42 AM

Theresa Corral wrote:

Hey, my daughters and I would love to see some real people as models. or at least models with curves!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:44 AM

Lara wrote:

Why oh why is Vincent still in??!!?! I thought it was easy to see who was going to be out last night but boy was I wrong! Alison's dress might not have been the best but she has shown that she has talent. Vincent has only shown that he is half (or totally?) crazy! What were those judges thinking? I was honestly yelling at my TV, and I'm sure I wasn't the only one!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:44 AM

Christy wrote:

I CANNOT believe that Allison was kicked off the show!!! Vincent has consistently performed HORRIBLY (compared to other designers), while Allison has consistenly performed well. Although both the producers and judges make the final decision, this episode made it clearly obvious that the producers are more concerned with creating "drama/excitement" by keeping Vincent on the show...I think they need to step back and realize that people (at least myself) who watch the show want to believe in its credibility and I now have serious doubts...Allison, made if you had acted like a freak you would still be on the show!!!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:44 AM

ILovedAlisson wrote:

We're back to Season 2: just as the judges should have obviously kicked out Santino instead of Daniel in the lingerie competion (you call that lingerie, seriously?) and instead of Nick in the final 5 (come on Santino, it was falling appart on stage), and the judges kept keeping him because of the drama value he added same thing is happening now.
Vincent is demented and his dresses have consistently been bad: green dress, Twiggy dress, this dress, first dress (remember the hat?). But he's so weird and disses everyone. Allison was great and had consistently great dresses, and at least her model could walk in her dress. Their kicking Allisson out is clearly a sign of their being interested in the drama that Vincent was adding.
On the other hand, I love Michael, good job, you're great!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:49 AM

Dee wrote:

I'm with you, Tim. I really think this last elimination was a miscarriage of justice and honestly, it made me lose a little respect for the show.

Vincent has pretty much proven himself to be a poor designer. He has almost consistently been in the bottom three and for the most part his designs are laughable. His basket-on-the-head design wasn't just a fluke; it was a good predictor of what was to come.

Alison, on the other hand, has been one of the more adventurous and truly stylish designers. It has been exciting to see what she has made for each competition. The design for this show missed the mark, but did it really miss the mark more than Vincent's design? I was looking forward to seeing what Alison would produce throughout the show and I'm a little peeved that the judges chose to dismiss her. They harped on her for designing one outfit that makes a woman look big, but they don't seem to mind that Vincent has designed multiple outfits that are neither functional nor attractive.

At this rate I predict Vincent will win the show because it looks like he can send anything out on the runway and not get kicked off.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:50 AM

melondrama wrote:

Tim, I love you, God and the whole world know I love you. But- Alison's model is PLUS SIZE??? Is it numerically literal now? Is anything over size 0 plus now?
I guess the "plus" in plus-size now stands for "plus, she can have children!"
Give us girls a break, man. This is getting depressing. Seriously. Do you have any idea how much pressure we're already under to never eat anything?
You made me cry. Bad Tim.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:52 AM

Jordan wrote:

UGH! I absolutely agree. I am devastated to see Alison go, and I can't believe that Vincent managed to stay in. I think it's really outrageous that Kane got to stay in because "He knows how to make clothes" when Alison got knocked of and everything she has done has been different and great looking. It's pretty crazy, because some things are not done because people haven't thought of doing them - that's what Alison creates - and some things are not done because they are BAD IDEAS! THAT is what I think Vincent does and that makes me really sad that Vincent stayed and Alison had to go. I hope we see her again soon.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:52 AM

Mindy wrote:

Apparently I should rethink my day job and become a fashion designer on Project Runway--it doesn't seem as if much talent is required (i.e. Vincent). The man is consistently in the bottom three, and he still manages to remain on the show. Granted, Allison's creation was a disaster, but her prior work was consistent and beautiful. Kayne created a disaster for this challenge, but he remained on the show because the judges knew he was talented (despite this one flaw). The same should have applied to Allison--her work this time was hideous, but she should have received an equal pardon in light of her overall creations. Vincent should be gone, out, finished--he's not entertaining, he's annoying. At least Santino (from Season 2) was interesting to watch--some of his work may have been equally as ugly as Vincent's, but he was thoroughly entertaining (remember his Tim Gunn impersonations, which were flawless!). Please tell me this man is "auf'" on the next episode so the beauty of the other designers may shine through.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:55 AM

Beth wrote:

Tim... How can you say Allison had a plus size model?!? What is she, a size 2? I think that is a slap in the face to those of us who are true plus sizes.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:56 AM

Darrell wrote:

Alison is out? You've got to be kidding me. Vincent has not made one palatable outfit. I guess the producers feel that his kookiness has some entertainment value. Both Robert and Kayne seem to have gooten a free pass based on past perfomance and Alison should have gotten one this time also.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 8:57 AM

marcy wrote:

This week's challenge was a bit out there but interesting. I know it cant be easy coming up with these challenges each week. I do so wish Tim would do a show of his own. His style, grace and charisma is unsurpassed. He is by far the most eloquent man on tv. His speech and clothes are always impeccible. I recently saw Heidi new commerical for the seamless bra. BRAVO HEIDI. Last week I picked my first copy of Elle Magazine everrrrrr. Ok, I am sold I brought a subcription. First fashion magazine I ever brought a subscription too. I however was a bit disappointed that there wasnt more of Chloe's designs in the magazine. I was expecting more of a spread. However, I am sold on the magazine. I have been searching and searching for months for Style Tape or Styling Tape, and have not been able to find it. I live up in Westchester County, NY. Any help anyone can give me to steer me in the right direction would be greatly appreciated. I have also searched online and cant find it. Project Runway is fabulous. I hope its around for many many years to come.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:02 AM

msprem wrote:

Alison shouldn't have gone home this week. Kayne's and Vincent's designs left more to be desired than hers. Her fatal mistake was the hairstyle she chose to go with her dress. It took the look from questionable to absurd. The judges couldn't get past the hairstyle AND the dress, to see that her design wasn't the worst of the week. This was her first misstep and it is bewildering why Vincent is still there since he skates on the edge every week. I think they want him there because he is good TV material, so keep him in the mix. That's fine when the group is larger, but when it is getting refined, the best designers should remain and the weakest should be gone.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:06 AM

BonnieD wrote:

When will we lose that psycho Vincent? His craziness is overshadowed only by his incredible self absorption and misogyny. In fact, the gender tension this season is bothering me. I hate to see Laura engage in it with those guys, because it just gives them vindication. Alison! Too cute for words, you will go far.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:09 AM

Dana wrote:

I can't believe Alison is gone-- she has TONS more fashion genius than Vincent. The fact that he made it past the space cadet Miss USA dress is still puzzling. Maybe this is some cruel prank Project Runway is playing, keeping him on? I am thrilled that Michael won again-- I am rooting for him and Uli!!! Can't wait till next week!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:10 AM

Lisa wrote:

I think there is going to be a riot, boycott!! We are going to lose a lot of fans. Where to begin? First of all Tim Is the Fashion God. His advise is gold. People who don't listen are stupid. He saved Kyen, Vincent but Alison didn't so that is why she was out. He told her that her model is fat! They have to design something that looks good on their model. I think Jeff's dress should have won! Uli second and then Robert. I hated Laura's dress so plain!!! She does the same stuff. She should keep her mouth shut at the end. Vincent has his own style and ideas he is not a judge. Don't blame him for Alison's lose. Kyne was funny, he knew that he screwed up but the dress was still nicely constructed, wearable just the color was crazy. Alison's dress reminded me of my "Candy-Baby -Doll Raver Days". Michaels dress was Ok, loved the gold bustier but Jeff should have won. Angela's was cute, very wearable to the village.The judges are insane. Do they judge on just one out fit or the all the dresses so far? Vincent will be out next. Just a thought "could u imagine Bradley doing this challenge" LOL. Finally I just stared at my TV as the show ended shocked!!! That Allison was gone. No worries I am sure she has a fantastic job now. So I don't feel sorry for her. She will be missed.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:12 AM

Grace Starr wrote:

I do not understand how Allison could be out!!! Vincent has created nothing to this point that could be considered "design". There is nothing he has created that I would purchase. He tells Angela to step back 3 feet, to be quiet and do nothing, yet it is the "nightmare of his life", in a previous episode. Allison has been at the top in every challenge and I do include this one. I believe that Tim's voice should be heard and his opinions weighed when the judging takes place.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:19 AM

Matt Pasca wrote:

I agree with Tim whole-heartedly. The judges REALLY bungled this challenge's decision. Alison has consistently made some of the best pieces this season, and even though hers was not great, it still looked like a garment. Vincent has consistently made head-scratching pieces that either don't make sense, don't look good, or don't wear well. And he's 49 - if he can't do it by now, lose him! I don't get it. I can't help but feel the producers prefer Vincent's Woody Allenishness to Alison's sweetness, and that was the final decision-maker. :(

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:26 AM

Isadora wrote:

Hello Tim!
My name is Isadora and I'm from Brazil!
I love Project Runway as well as you!! I'll have to be honest with you.. your comments are the ones that i really take into consideration. They are really bright, intelligent and kind at the same time.

I've been following season 3 from the internet, and i had to say something about alison's exit! i got reaaalllyy disappointed when i read your column... she was one of my favorites, she had the knowledge about structure, the feeling and background that any designer needs... well... i'm just sad that she left the show..

luv ya tim!!!! i wish i could get to know you, i'm a fan of yours!

kisses!! beijos...

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:31 AM

Ken wrote:

This was the worst judging EVER!! Vincent and Angela both should have been gone long ago. Alison has been consistently strong and only had one sort of off day (not even that bad). I don't get it!!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:47 AM

jd wrote:

Unbelievable!

I am sure now that this show is fixed in order to create maximum drama rather than beautiful clothing.
Evidently, the producers and judges have decided that it would just be boring if the only remaining designers were actually talented.
That Allison is out, but Vincent and Angela are in is perfectly ridiculous, especially beacuse both of their outfits in this challenge were atrocious, both in taste and construction. Vincent has consistantly turned out poorly concepted and constructed crimes against humanity and it seems Angela has not learned her lesson from the positive attention she gets when she complies with a less is more idea of design.

It also makes me wonder if the judges are not biased against the plus-sized model.
Their comment that the gorgeous pleated waist made her look bulkier was patently not true, as evidenced by the still pictures above.

I am disheartened enough to not watch the rest of the show on television, but just come to the website and read Tim's Take each week.
His is the only voice of reason, and apparently, of taste as well.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:48 AM

Lisa wrote:

As much as I love this show, this is the last straw - it has really lost any credibility with me. Why don't they just have the producers sitting out front on stools with Nina and Michael? There isn't any other explanation for keeping someone who has been in the bottom 2 over and over and made a craft project that would be barely acceptable for a third grader, but getting rid of someone who has been in the running for a win every week, someone who has demonstrated amazing style. It's such an obvious ploy to keep a lunatic on the show for ratings purposes, and eventually that tactic is going to backfire.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:49 AM

mary sue wrote:

It is an absolute outrage that Allison is out while Vincent (and Angela) are still there. Even Tim could hardly stomach it.
Angela's creation was, as he said in his blog, like a school craft project. The construction of the garment was TERRIBLE. Vincent has been terrible every single episode. And yet Allison is out. That's it! Too much rigging the result. I am going to stop watching as of now.

Also, although generally I think Michael is a good designer and Jeffrey is not, last night Jeffrey deserved to win.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:49 AM

becca wrote:

Hi Tim,

I agreed with you about Alison's dress, although I thought the judges were right in their criticisms too. I liked the shape, I liked the pleated obi (or cumberbund, or whatever that center element is called). But I think that where Alison went seriously wrong was the Mini Mouse hairstyle that she explicitly ordered. That made an already outlandish outfit just cartoonish and the judges were right in saying that she had not considered the size of her model and how she was making her look (ridiculous was how she looked).

But that one misstep shouldn't have got her bumped from the show, not when walking disaster Vincent is still on. Vincent must go. He's hateful and he makes ugly clothes.

Speaking of hateful, Jeffrey is a sour, petty little man, isn't he? He had a cool dress that one of the judges rightly called "ugly-beautiful." It was a great dress that he marred with his graceless loser act.

Michael: all the way. He's got it. Jeffrey was a strong contender for that challenge, but so was Laura. You don't see her bad-mouthing Michael. Why would anyone bad-mouth Michael? He's a great designer who seems to have decency and integrity (and maturity and probably a host of other qualities!).

Laura: it's too bad she was so upset at the injustice of Alison's auf'ing that she went off on Vincent. He's so obvioiusly there because the producers think they'll keep us more engaged by tuning in each week eager to see him finally get the boot. Alison *did* make an elephant of an outfit, and while she's certainly got more talent in her little finger than Vincent will ever have at all, I didn't think she was one of the stronger designers. So don't blame Vincent for Alison's departure: blame the producers and her own unfortunate lapse in judgement.

Kayne: well, everyone has their moments of bad judgement. Fortunately Kayne chose to do so when Alison did as well, and he's got a stronger track record to back him up.

Still not wowed by Robert, which is suprising.

Wow, Uli actually made something that wasn't a halter dress! It looked good too. But I won't be able to root for her until I see her create a more fitted, tailored top for women, with seams and buttons. Enough of the Love Boat dresses!

I'm rooting for Michael all the way. Michael, Laura and Kayne in the final 3 would be interesting. I don't think the producers will be willing to part with viscious drama queen Jeffrey and his petty tantrums, so it'll probably be him, Michael and: Uli, Laura or Kayne. Vincent's gotta go, Angela's days are numbered, and Robert has yet to impress.

Tim, what an excellent teacher and mentor you are -- I realize we don't see all of your interaction with the designers, but I was impressed with how constructively supportive you were in advising Vincent, while remaining honest. His work is so atrocious, and his response to feedback is so ungracious, that I think in your shoes I'd be hard-pressed to even bother looking at his stuff -- let the judges tear into him as they will. Why help him last another week by giving helpful hints? The fact that you do attests to your own character and strength as a teacher. Bravo!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:51 AM

beth wrote:

For the first time, I feel very disappointed in PR and I'm afraid that the show might be "jumping the shark." After last night's show, it was clear that the producers and/or NBC execs have their grimy little fingers tightly into the cast-off selection. Apparently they want to see poor Vincent implode on camera. There is absolutely NO entertainment value in Vincent, he is an awful designer, how he got on the show is a mystery to me. Angela was talented and should have been kept. I am really, really disappointed in the show.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:52 AM

NRod wrote:

This show was such a shock! Allison shouldn't have been the one to go and I was really upset Vincent got away with another crazy horrible design. If you look at the actual designs from each show Allison definately outweighed Vincent in not only style but taste and execution. Do we not remember the crazy basket UFO hat?? I was so sad to see Allison not win the Dog Challenge when she was clearly the winner and Uli continues to produce the same dress in various patterns. But to see her off the show, it was sad indeed.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:53 AM

Melissa Ferner wrote:

I am so shocked that Vincent remains on the show. Get rid of him! He's a loon! Not only that, I just do not see the talent. Alison was a very talented designer. You all all freaking crazy for choosing to emlimiate her over Vincent. CRAZY! I have to wonder now. Was he "planted" on your show to make sure that things would never get boring? Is he still there to act crazy and entertain us viewers? If that is the case, then you have ruined a poor girl's (Alison) potential all for nothing. She's an amazing designer and I love that she's different. I can't believe that you did that! I have always agreed with the judges' choices (okay, except for when Austin was eliminated) but not now!!!! What are you thinking Heidi???? I think that Heidi's outfits are getting scarey! She should rethink her choices. Michael wears the same thing for every show. I am pissed about Alison.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:54 AM

Amanda S. wrote:

So glad that Michael won. He's adorable.

Vincent is insane, and needs to go home. He just makes me cringe.

Poor Allison. She was so sweet and sincere. I thought her dress was pretty, but the hair was awful. And I hated how they kept referring to her model as "big," "zaftig," etc. She wasn't "big" by any stretch of the imagination. This is the reason so many girls have body issues. The perception that you're "fat" if you're not a size zero is what makes girls starve themselves. Ugh.

Finally, a note to Laura. PLEASE stop wearing all the chest baring, slit down to your navel tops and dresses. They are really, really, really not flattering on you. Bring the point of the "V" up a few inches, and you're fine. But showing off your pasty white sternum and big brown moles is really not working. Sorry to be harsh, but this episode it really started to grate on my nerves how often we saw a shot of Laura's white chest, with a breast nearly popping out of her dress. Egad!

LOVE Project Runway. I schedule my week around Wednesday night. It's the best.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:55 AM

sandy wrote:

This is my first post ever, so forgive me if I do not know the protocol. I truly feel that Allison should not have been auf'd. They let Kayne stay in because he knew how to make clothes, even though he had a bad evening. In other words, they let his body of work stand. So why wasn't Allison extended the same courtesy? She has consistently had great work and was even in the top two twice, now all of a sudden due to one bad misstep (and I know, it was bad!) she is eliminated while Vincent remains. I just don't get it. I realize at the end, the producers also have a say in who is in and who is out, but come on!!!!! I don't mean to be tough on the guy, he seems really sweet, and his portfolio from the initial audition process seemed very elegant and classic. I have not seen any of that so far. On a high note - Kudo's to Michael. I thought his outfit was classic and well thought out. I really liked how he thought about the materials in terms of fabric. And, even though I'm not sure I like his attitude, I must say Jeffrey's outfit was a stand out as well. Very creative and innovative which is what they were going for.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 9:58 AM

Deb wrote:

Ridiculous.
I agree with so many of the statements already posted---it does make you lose respect for an otherwise-wonderful show when the judges make such horrible decisions. Vincent has not made a single decent outfit---and then he argued when the judges asked him about it! (I 'get off on it' ?? Really. Eww). Guess they feel bad that he cashed in his 401K...but he's a big boy..Let him deal with it. Clearly, Project Runway has Project Drama as a subplot....or Vincent & Angela would be distant memories by now...

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:01 AM

Robin wrote:

I can't add much to what's already been said; I am shocked that Allison is gone and Vincent is still there. I guess making a woman look "fat" (a size 4 or 6, what a cow!) is the worst crime you can commit in fashion. No one will ever convince me that decision made any sense.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:04 AM

JB wrote:

Alison's dress wasn't all that great but I think Vincent should have been kicked out instead of her.

I liked Laura's dress, simple but elegant. That's Laura. No matter where she finishes in the competition, someone will offer her a job. She has a clean, sleek style that many women love. Not everyone wants an innovative, trendy, garish outfit.

Michael's dress was OK but I'm not sure if I would have chosen him the winner.

I didn't like Jeffrey's dress, but he did put a lot of work and thought into it.

Vincent is creepy and should have been out. Did you see the look on the judges' faces when he said that the dress excited him? He was essentially implying that the dress aroused him. Yuck! I would not want him designing clothes for me.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:08 AM

dewey wrote:

This challenge was my least favorite in two-an-a-half seasons. I see the point of catching the designers off-guard and of putting them under pressure; but, as anyone can see by the results of this challenge, this one was a big loser. Garbage in--garbage out. Poor Allison. At least she was trying to make something pretty out of ugliness. I guess if her model was "zaftig", we have no hope of seeing healthy shapes on the runway. Too bad. D-.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:08 AM

Ginny wrote:

Vincent's dress was just a pice of paper with junk thrown all over it. Any challenge that includes innovation, he fails miserably at. (Remember the "Pookey-hat". An alien with an ugly dress.) Almsot every challenge he has done horribly, but Allison excelled in almost everything. Loony Libretti shoudl go... NOW!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:11 AM

Kelli wrote:

Tim's assessment of Vincent v. Alison is right on. Her dress, while problematic, required skill and design ability. His was merely a messy afterthought. He should be well out by now--he designs ugly, uninteresting stuff. I think the show's interest for most people is the talent, not the silly histrionics. They did Alison and their audience a disservice by outing her. We don't want to see more of Vincent, already! Heidi's dislike of Alison's outfit, because it made the model look fat, is just laughable. Please! Uli's outfit made her model look like a Hershey's kiss on steroids. Kayne's mess looked like a deflating balloon. And quite honestly, I thought Michael's dress, while styled well, wasn't all that interesting. I think the whole premise of recyled materials was flawed. The audience wants to see beautiful, real designs, not arts and crafts from trash.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:14 AM

Bee wrote:

Horrible!! I can't believe Alison's out! She has had consistantly strong designs, and I didn't think this one was as bad as the judges made it out to be. I thought the mix of folded and crumpled paper looked rather elegant in its own way, while Vincent gave us yet another atrocious disaster. His model could not even walk! His dress looked like a grade-schooler cut out a dress-like shape from butcher block paper and glued little pieces of crap all over it. What were the judges thinking? Like Kayne said, he thought the only way he would make it through with his not-so-great dress would be if the judges were smoking crack...Maybe they were. As for the winners, I'm very glad Michael did it again. He really understands the challenges, and I think he has a unique viewpoint that no other designer has. I think he has a very real chance of making it to the top. (Though I did think that about Alison.) Laura's stuff is flawless and beautiful, but perhaps a little too "clean" for some people. Angela was starting to grow on me with the last couple of challenges, but this silver jumper was just plain ugly. As for Jeffrey, well, he's a dick. His newspaper dress this time was the first thing from him that did not look like vomit, but even after being told he narrowly missed winning, he couldn't bow down graciously. Instead of vowing to make something even better next time, he had to put down Michael's dress for being boring. (Which it so obviously wasn't!)

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:15 AM

Louisa wrote:

What a shame last night's show was. Michael is being set up to win. They'll keep Vincent on for a while for laughs. Kayne will go back to the "Jon Benet" world where he truly belongs and Jeffrey will design for the rock stars. I was hoping Alison would win it all - she is truly talented. I won't watch any more - it is definitely fixed and getting boring. Give Tim his own show!!!! Stop insulting him and us.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:15 AM

Anita wrote:

Tim-

I totally agree - if Kayne is too be given a pass because he makes great clothes (and I'm glad he was because except for this misstep I've loved everything he's done) but shouldnt the same apply to Allison. Vincent has been consistently in the bottom of the pack. I dont necessarily think that past performance should influence the judges unless as in this case it comes down to a choice between 2 bad designs.

BTW- Alexandra a "Plus size model" could we get a little real world perspective here- what is she a size 2 or maybe even (horror) a 4 compared to the others size 0?

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:16 AM

Orleans wrote:

Shame on you, Bravo. I'd like to hear honest commentary from the judges--and the producers who surely must have guided them to this decision-- to justify eliminating Allison rather than Vincent. This may have been an attempt to keep viewers hanging on, but you have probably only succeeded in alienating us. Who wants to watch or participate in this design "Quiz Show?"

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:19 AM

pam wrote:

I don't even want to keep watching the show. do the judges keep in mind how the outfits will look on tv?

ugh. allison should've stayed.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:21 AM

Maya wrote:

I cannot believe that Allison was let go. Why the double standard? Kayne let crap be shown on the runway, but they took into account that he consistently did good work. Why wasn't Allison given that same courtesy? And Tim, plus size?????? Zaftig???? I am a size 6, not much bigger than that model--am I plus size as well? I don't consider myself plus size and she sure wasn't. Anyhow, Allison's dress was unflattering, but she is a wonderful designer and I was looking forward to seeing what she would do the rest of the season. This show is so rigged it is not even funny. Vincent consistently puts out crap that is poorly constructed and that no one in their right mind will wear, yet he gets to go on??? I am beginning to think that it is just for the drama he creates. Also, Laura--*yawn* Her looks are boring. Someone should also tell her that someone who has no chest like her should not wear those low cut outfits. I really am tired of seeing her ribs and sternum. Angela has only had one good outfit this season. I don't understand why she was allowed through ahead of allison either.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:22 AM

Paula wrote:

I am *so* disappointed! Allison out!
Amazing - I thought Tim said that Project Runway had integrity and seriousness of purpose! Apparently Tim forgot to tell the producers of the show.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:24 AM

Slick wrote:

I loved Michael's design and I love Michael, and I really don't like Jeffrey or any outfit he's done up until now. But I love, love, loved his dress in this round. I loved the colors, the shape, the belt, the intricacy of the top. I thought it was phenomenal.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:24 AM

martha wrote:

The credibility of the show is seriously in doubt after last night's episode. I can't add to the comments that have already been made about why Vincent does not deserve to remain on the show, other than to note that his failings include a complete inability to think. It does not appear that he understands his own concepts, if that word can be applied to his constructions.

But as between Alison and Kayne, there is another reason why the judges should have kept Alison, in addition to the comments already made here. The show is a contest for the best "designer", not the best gown designer. Alison has shown that she knows how to design and sew a broader range of innovative, fashionable clothes than Kayne has. If the show is genuine, the judges need to snap back to reality and take such matters into account.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:25 AM

Lisa Harmon wrote:

Hang your head Heidi! Vincent should be out, Alison in! Producers, this show, you clearly revealed your true agenda of having a great show run into the ground due to keeping the drama queens as opposed to real talent. Double shame on you! Vincent should be gone based on his dress (Art 101) and the number of times he has been in the bottom 3! Hello? Why did the judges not take that fact into consideration for elimination? Tim, find a way to bring back Alison! I'm finished with watching this show! It's sad to realize how Producers have taken a course for ratings, as opposed to the original intentions of the program. Talent vs Drama. I can watch Laguna Beach if I wanted to watch "Drama". Ouch, baby!
Heidi, I'm not buying what you are selling!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:25 AM

Okan wrote:

Allison was wronged. Her outfit had style and creativity. You could definitely see that she's a true artist. On the other end of the spectrum was Vincent's kindergarten art project. Someone should warn Vincent about the dangers of snorting glue.
I'm so glad that Michael won another challenge. Mostly because he beat Jeffrey, hahaha. :) Someone should tell Jeffrey that it's better to let someone else compliment your work because otherwise you come across like a pompous a**--oops, too late!
Finally, I love Laura! She knows how to tell it like it is, and her work is consistently fabulous. Laura, I hope you make it to the final three, because I'd love to see a collection of yours.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:27 AM

Judi wrote:

Unbelievable is all we can say! The producers obviously decided this episode's outcome...which takes away all credibility. To keep "poor" designers on for "good" TV makes this show the loser and will cause many viewers, like myself and my daughters, to stop tuning in. Allison's outfit was not that good but it is the first outfit that was not great...while other designers have consistently produced sub-standard oufits week after week. I thought Bravo had produced a great show to highlight designers who are worth watching but all they have produced is yet another reality show focused on emotional outbursts and petty human jealousy. All they are producing from loyal viewers is a stampede OUT THE DOOR! No more Project Runway on our TV...I hate ridiculous reality TV shows!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:28 AM

Cindy wrote:

I have never chimed in on this show before, but losing Allison is the last straw. I just shut off the TV in digust. And Vincent and Angela are still in?? I love Michael's work, it is full of amazing energy and a subtle air of divinity, but Jeffrey put together an amazing outfit this week. What does it take to get that kind of talent noticed? Nina, honey, you are boring ME!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:28 AM

Kris wrote:

I can not believe this decision. Allison out for making her model appear larger!! I still liked it. And if, if, her model was plus size what's the deal? Most designers who have clothes on the market can't design for plus sizes either. So don't kick off Allison for something that most established desingers can't do.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:32 AM

Lindsay wrote:

Was anyone else creeped out by Vincent "getting off" on his creation? I know I was. I completely agree with everyone's complaints over the judges letting Allison go while keeping Vincent. Especially after deciding that Kayne should stay because he has proven himself as a good designer. Allison may not be quite as good, but Vincent been consistently poor on the show. I'm not sure if they keep him around for the entertainment factor though, since they were willing to kick-off arrogant Keith. Plus, there's always Jeffrey to cause a stir, and Laura is becoming more outspoken as well.

Go Michael, Uli, and Kayne!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:34 AM

Nina wrote:

Get real, people- if you love to hate Vincent, there's your reason for why he's still on. The question is, what the heck is Robert still doing there? His dress was such a yaaaaawn. It was Angela's Audrey dress in tin foil. BO-ring. His look last week was sloppy and boring. He should have been ousted last night. Instead we lost someone with vision, someone who takes risks. If she were a guy, like Santino, they'd have kept her and every week complained about her unruly, untameable 'Allison-ness'.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:34 AM

Debbie wrote:

Come on! Vincent has to go. In some respects, I think this challenge was unfair in terms of earning someone the auf. I know it was about innovation but wasn't the first challenge of ripping the apartment apart enough already. I think Allison got shafted and Vincent's 15 minutes of fame ended weeks ago. On another note, while Michael (my favorite) did a wonderful job and his explanation allowed us to visualize the elements in terms of fabric, I think Jeffrey should have won this challenge.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:35 AM

Mena wrote:

In reviewing the pictures from last night's show, I feel it was the combination of hair style and larger (taller) model that did Alison in. What a shame - I so looked forward to her creations and sweet outlook on things each week. I guess minding your business, making the most of a bad situation, doing your job well and helping others makes for bad TV.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:36 AM

Katherine Mills wrote:

Dissapointed and shocked! That's the least I can say about what happened last night. Alison is out and Vincent is still in it? Alison has a lot more innovation, class, style, and sense of fashion (and wearability) than Vincent (who so far has only managed to stand out based on cooky hats, spacy sholderpads, and awful "art"). I'm completely dissapointed that Project Runway is going for the drama instead of the talent! Vincent's been on the chopping board many times because of his incompetence and lack of leadership, taste and talent! I agree in that this show's OVER for me! I'm so sad because I really looked forward to Wednesdays and watching all the amazing fashion. But it's obvious that the show's focusing on the people's ability to create tense moments (i.e. all the time dedicated to Jefrey vs Laura, Vincent vs Angela/Laura). So sorry for you Alison! I really would've liked you to go all the way... I was looking forward to wearing some of your clothes! I agree with you Tim... WHY is Vincent still in? And was Alison's dress all that bad? Bad enough to get her Auf'd? I'd much rather look a little chubby in something that's different... than "tall and lean" (as Heidi put it... which by the way not everyone can be!!!!) in something that's awful and more like a child's work of art (Vincent has shown that he definitely is much a child in soooo many ways!!!). Anyway, I don't think I'll be able to "carry on" watching PR after lats night's dissapointment. It's hard to take the show, challenges and judges siriously now. Wish Tim would've been a judge to knock some sense into them all!!!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:41 AM

JustK wrote:

I believe the main reason that Jeffrey didn't win is that he glued the newspaper to muslin to make a fabric, while Michael used the materials as he found them.

Other than that, I'm with everybody on the Vincent debacle, and also on the Tim Gunn bandwagon!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:42 AM

Barbara Roman wrote:

Last night I lost alot of respect for this program. Vincent is still in and Alision is out? Can anyone please justify this from a design standpoint?

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:44 AM

Chrystyna wrote:

Like everyone on the boards, I am so gobsmacked that Allison is gone and Vincent remains. The point of the challenge was to make it wearable, and even if Allison's wasn't the most flattering to her bigger model, she was able to WEAR it. Vincent's model could not. And as much as I have liked Vincent personally - but hated all of his clothes - he was amazingly arrogant about it. I was glad Laura lashed out at him. I think the judges are giving him way too much leeway due to his once being a designer of some note. Perhaps there is a reason he no longer is. Certainly his attitude is poor. I find it really appalling, and hypocritical that the judges gave Kayne the benefit of his body of work and not Allison or Vincent. If they had been consistent, they would have booted Vincent and kept Allison. Perhaps she is too pretty and nice and there is a little "cattiness" going on on the catwalk!! Kudos though to my other favorites, Michael and Ulli. Although truth be told, Jeffrey maybe should have won.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:45 AM

John wrote:

Wow. Unbelievable. We should be directing designers to take a chance, success or fail. Not be harboring such mediocrity and laziness. Sometimes its not the battle you have to win, but it's the manner in which you win or lose. Good job getting rid of the best designer on the show.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:45 AM

Siri wrote:

NOTE TO PRODUCERS: Keeping kooky designers in for the sake of t.v. ratings makes the show FAKE. This was bad t.v. people, a waste of my time. When good talent is sacrificed for drama, it's a turn off. I'm certain the only reason Vincent is still in is because the producers think he makes for better ratings. This week, it's not the recycling materials that stink, it's the episode.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:45 AM

Tracey wrote:

I'm glad to see I'm not the only one. I was so upset to see Allison booted and Vincent still there. Allison on past challenges has done very well and messed up this one time, because her original idea didn't work out. My 7 year old daughter could have made a better dress than Vincent. Michael's design was great but I thought Uli's was better. I'd wear Uli's before Michael's.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:47 AM

Sarah wrote:

Allison - if you're reading this; I am so angry. You should be going to Fashion Week! Vincent - what the heck are you still doing on the show? You have been on the chopping block, um, almost every (if not every) challenge thus far. No doubt the Producers kept you on because you're nuts, and make good TV.

I'm not even saying Allison's dress was the best either, but come on...neither was Kayne's, and they let him by because his designs are consistently well-designed, and so were Allison's. Give me a break - we need some new judges.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:48 AM

Lisa wrote:

I can't believe Vincent is still in when his model could barely walk in that "thing" he created. Allison's might not have been the best, but it sure as heck wasn't the worst. I thought it was rather elegant to tell you the truth. Kayne's was also bad. Vincent was terrible in the challenge he teamed up with Angela and yet she took all the heat on that. I'm tired of Vincent's drama and the man has absolutely no taste. I hope he goes next.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:48 AM

patrice wrote:

Oh my word.
My frustration with the judges has reached epic proportions.
I am puzzled weekly by their apparent blindness where Vincent is concerned. They kicked Katherine off for a too-simple dress when all Vincent sent down the runway that week was a black tank dress. At least KG's dress had interest on the bodice. Vincent couldn't be bothered with a bodice!
and this week, lordy!
Allison's dress at least resembled a dress. Vincent's extraordinarily ill-fitting sheath looked like his model had been rolled in a cheap carpet and then thrased around in a garbage bin.
what on earth is keeping him here? do they feel sorry for the resident crazy man?
are they afraid he will go 'postal' if they kick him off? surely we can rely on Kayne; if he was able to root out Bradley's books i have faith that he would have found any semi-automatic weapons lurking in vincent's closet. please, please, please. put vincent out of our misery.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:50 AM

sydney wrote:

Project Runaway, it turns out, is like pretty much every other creative industry in this country. Men skate by on half-baked ideas because people "believe in their talent." A woman makes one misstep and she's OUT. In the past few years, the number of women musicians in the New York Symphony has increased fivefold. Why? Because now musicians audition in back of screens. The judges can't tell what they look like, and can't subconsciously attribute more talent to one person just because he is a man. They only hear the work. Perhaps Project Runway should do the same thing. Then maybe the young, talented women on the show wouldn't be sent home so quickly (remember how Bradley's atrocity beat out another young woman's simple but lovely green dress) while their less talented male peers are continually cut slack and overpraised.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:54 AM

Senovia wrote:

Why hasn't Jeff won a challenge yet ???????? the man did an awesome job on the recycled material dress he should have won and Yuli makes the same dress over and over again just in diffrent colors why hasn't she been booted yet she soooo sucks!Mike Knight did kick ass on the hot pink outfit but Jeff should of won the last challenge Jeff you kick ass buddy stick with it!Vincent is out of his mind please someone boot him!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:55 AM

Doreen wrote:

What is wrong with being "plus sized"? Most women I meet are not a size 2. And why is it so terrible that your model is bigger than the rest? I would kill to be that size. I'm a size 16- and thats on a good day! Will there ever be challenge where the designers have to design for a plus sized women? Bigger doesn't mean ulgy!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:56 AM

BBMOMMA wrote:

I do not expect that you people will publish this, but here goes.
Dear Tim,
Even my complete love for you and your talent can no longer keep me a viewer of this show. This episode does it for me. I've had it with this show. I have loved the show since episode 1 show 1, but this season has been too suspect from the beginning. I fear Tim that you are now associated with a show that will take you down with it. Shame on you all at Bravo, especially Heidi, Michael and Nina, you are respected pros of the fashion industry and have been brought down by tv execs. Respected pros no more.

I love Michael's work, but this weeks winner? What does it take for Laura or Jeffrey to win a challenge. This week was clearly the time, they were brilliant. Laura turned trash into a pristeen treasure, the judges continue to praise her to the high heavens but never a challenge recognition and Jeffrey's design this week was a work of art and surely the winner.

But the straw for me is Alison's going home over that insane wanna be designer Vincent. Tonights highlight and breath of honestly and fresh air was Laura calling Vincent out for being the inept designer tht he is (BRAVO LAURA).
Grant it Vincent and Alison had the least desirable designs, but at least Alison's looked like an outfit with intricate Oragami design, while Vincent's looked like toilet paper plastered to a model and decorated by Kingergardeners. Week after week Vincent presents absolute trash and is passed along. Alison has shown talent, innovation, creativity and all the attributes of a designer on her way to success.

I am done! This show is no longer enjoyment, it is insulting to designers everywhere and a biotch slap to all viewers!

Well by all the blogs I have been reading, not only is Bravo getting "Aufed" but viewers will be letting Macy's know that viewers do no appreciate such a retail giant being involved in what has become a suspect show in more ways than one.

I adore you Tim and sincerely hope that this does not take you down with it. I look forward to seeing you starring in you own show re: designing one day.

Shame on you all at Bravo, Macy's and the judges. Shame, Shame, Shame!!!!!!!!!!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:57 AM

Sarah G wrote:

I was shocked - astonished - and almost cried along with Allison for her unfortunate and undeserved departure from last night's show. She has shown grace, charisma, character, and not to mention PURE TALENT throughout the competitions. The dress she created, albeit not perfect, was by no means worse than the absolute JOKE that Vincent created. In terms of time management, she had to rethink her idea based on the fact that her original one could not be sewn... in my opinion, what she came up with to replace her original idea was far better than Kayne's redo! Her idea was polished and beautiful in comparison to Vincent's travesty. If you have learned anything in this show, your dress doesnt have to be the best, you just have to hope someone else's is worse than yours in order to stay for another challenge and another chance to prove yourself. Kayne and Robert have gotten these chances, why not Allison? The hair on Allison's model was horrible, I think that was the nail in her coffin. I loved Allison and looked forward to her ideas every week. I think she and Jeffrey should have won the dog challenge as well, considering theirs was gorgeous and they were short a person! Jeffrey, Allison and Uli were my top three favorites, with Michael a close fourth. But I digress. Vincent's presence on the show is making me queasy! If he is not GONE in the next challenge, I may be forced to stop watching because of illness! I think that Allison deserves another chance, bring her back! (Like on top chef when one contestant had to leave because of her father being ill, they brought back someone who had been let go... I think it would be GREAT for ratings - since that's what seems to be the reason for Vincent hanging around - to bring Allison back to prove herself!!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:57 AM

jb wrote:

I am currently reconsidering tuning in for this show again after last night's elimination. Vincent's designs have been consistently disappointing. His look last night was reminiscent of something you'd see pinned up in a kindergarten classroom. Allison was robbed. I was really looking forward to seeing more of her beautiful creations in upcoming episodes. I'm really questioning the judges credibility. BTW--if I have to hear Vincent say that his dress "really turns him on" again, I gonna be ill! Perhaps they should get a room...

posted on August 17, 2006 at 10:59 AM

karina wrote:

How can Alison be out and Vincent still in? What the heck! I love this show but I hate that for the sake of controversy bad designers are still in... like being tourtured by Wendy Pepper making it to the final... that was grueling. Vincent is done, he should have stopped while ahead and stayed in retirenment from fashion (when he quit in the 80's). He is like a whinny old jewish mother! (no ofence to jewish women, there is just no other way to describe him) I can't stand listening to him and I have to because I love this show.
And then there is Angela... she is like a designer for a second hand store or something. That grunge flower child mix is just awful and she is awful.
Arrggg!!!
Alison, you will go a long way!!! We are sad to see you go!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:00 AM

Anne wrote:

Am I the only person a little disturbed by the misogynistic tendencies shown by Jeffrey and Vincent? Arguing with other designers is one thing, but they reserve their nastier, more violent comments for the women, particularly Laura. I get that Laura might not be everyone's cup of tea, but I would hope that someone who desires to design for women would not make it their habit to hope that women they don't care for have strokes or pitchforks thrown at them.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:02 AM

April Ward wrote:

The only way to get the producers to understand that we don't approve of their unfair tactics against Alison (and others), is to stop watching the show. Money talks, and if their ratings go down because people are tired of seeing designers being treated unfairly, the producers will have to change up.

Project Runway has shown itself to have no integrity. It can no longer be taken seriously and doesn't deserve not one more Emmy nomination.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:02 AM

Janet M. wrote:

I have been sewing and designing clothes for 40 years, so I am enthralled with Project Runway. I thought it was about "designing fashion". My mistake. It's really a soap opera and the judges are tasteless idiots who don't have a clue. Vincent refered to the "nightmare of his life" when he worked with Angela. I submit that the real nightmares are the clothes he designs. Alison made a slight mistake this time, but do you not consider the excellent quality and taste of her previous work? To ask Alison to leave when she is standing next to the worst garbage on the runway is a blunder beyond comprehension. Has this Country's taste level sunk so low that we reward the psyco-nuts because they are "entertaining" and punish the truly dedicated, focused, and talented among us?

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:03 AM

chicgeek wrote:

I'm a tremendous fan of Project Runway, but this season is beginning to leave a bad taste in my mouth. Granted, we are watching a television show that relies on a certain amount of drama to keep the audience interested or entertained, but I'd wager that the average Project Runway viewer isn't tuning in to catch the latests catfight. I, for one, am far more interested in what's going on on the catwalk, and when poor designers like Vicent are allowed a free pass because they "make good t.v." I'm tempted to stop watching altogether. If I wanted "drama" I'd just flip over to MTV's next mindless reality show, but goddammit I want fashion, or at least a semi-reasonable facsimile. Casting the likes of Santino, who was a talented designer with an outsized ego, is one thing, but putting someone so utterly clueless on the show for the sake of boosting ratings insults the viewer's intelligence.

Angela, for all her quirks (not to mention the rosette/fleurchon obsession), has some talent. She nailed the Audrey Hepburn look and has shown herself to have a firm grasp of construction. I have serious problems with her taste, but appreciate her sense of whimsy when she manages to keep it under control. The fact that she's a tad out to lunch makes her fun to watch, but I'm concerned that, like Vincent, the time will come when the judges let her off for the sake of her personality rather than her ideas.

Speaking of the judges, since when has fashion been all about "wearability"? Honestly, does anyone really think that Dolce and Gabbana, to say nothing of Issey Miyake, are obsessing about whether the average American woman can actually wear/afford some of their more artful creations? I'm not saying that there shouldn't be an emphasis on construction, but to disqualify Alison for being experimental smacks of kow-towing to casual consumer taste. Fashion, like all other art forms, evolves when people extend their mastery of basic skills into the realm of possibility. Alison's dress was a perfect example, while Vincent's...garment was the fashion equivalent of a man who can't even draw a stick figure throwing paint at a canvas and calling himself Pollack.

(On a related note, if you are going to stress wearability, be logically consistent and out the ma whose dress looks as though it is literally going to fall off of his obviosuly miserable model!)

fin, rant.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:03 AM

bluesmouse wrote:

oops, my post got lost so here I go again-sorry if it ends up a repeat.

Michael's dress seemed to be completely made out of recycled materials and he made them look like expensive fabrics. It was chic and well done.

However, for the first time I understood why Jeffrey was even on the show. His creativity and skill made me sit up and take notice. His use of muslin made it hang together and flow but perhaps because of the extensive use of muslin the judges thought the recycled material was more of an adornment than an integral part the construction. I don't know what they were thinking but I thought (gulp) that Jeffrey should have won. I felt sorry for him....until he opened his mouth. The guy doesn't know the word "gracious" even exists...and Laura's tiara (& decolletage) slipped a little on that front as well. I know she just might have been upset that Allison was out instead of Vincent, but she was nasty.

I was sorry to see Allison go but her blond hair bow was a lightening rod for the judges focus on her confusion in this challenge. I wish she could have salvaged some of her original concept and "made it work" somehow. But I suspect she will get a lot of offers from her exposure on the program - she is talented, cooperative and seems like a great person. I think she will go on to great professional and personal success.

Uli's choice to stay away from (news) print was refreshing. I was glad that Robert Barbie'd his way through this one. Kayne was lucky and perhaps the judges can see great construction much better than we can on tv. And, should I ever need a lobster bib for an intergalactic beach party, I will call Angela. Heidi looks good in jeans.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:07 AM

Jen wrote:

I'm sorry...this show, which I have followed from day one of Season one, has lost all credibility with me now. Vincent doesn't even make for good television. You want a villain? There are better options in this cast.

In the meantime, one of the best, most talented designers on this season has been kicked to the curb. And she wasn't even my favorite. For me this show has always been about credibility. Last night it showed that it has none left.

I won't be gracing this show with my viewership anymore.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:07 AM

Maria Vick wrote:

Hey Project Runway producers. If you think by keeping Vincent, I'm going to stay around and keep watching the show for the drama, you're wrong! This show is a joke, has absolutely no credibility left. Myself and all my friends are disgusted and will no longer watch this travesty. And what the heck is wrong with plus size models or being big? Heidi Klum needs to think about the 97% of women out there who are larger than a twig.
Auf Wiedersehen to YOU, Project Runway!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:08 AM

rtish wrote:

Let's just face it, the viewing audience seems to be speaking loud and clear that this eposide was a lower moment than most. You guys did choose these models, so why the commentary? Also, Heidi's comments several times about size and weight just made her and the juding all the more shallow. Focus on the garments and the creativity. I watch because I am impressed with how creative your designers can be on a shoestring budget. It's awesome! Of Course the show is over now, and these are all tapings, I hope you will learn from these wonderful comments to make a show that is somewhat based on talent, I believe this show can stand on that, get tougher and release these designers that don't have it and keep the audience amazed and watching because you have a great show about RAW talent. Now, that would be a "Project Runway"!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:09 AM

Ashley wrote:

I am shocked! Allison auffed? Over Vincent and Angela! Poor Allison she gave no excuses for her creation. She was in the same boat Kayne was in, she ran out of time plain and simple. The only difference was she started out with a very cute skirt. Kayne's outfit was appalling to start with. And Allison stood up for the outfit that was sent down the runway. She didn't cop out. Yet Kayne, Vincent, and Angela was kept over true potential. I am in total disbelief. And to think of the beautiful peices we could have seen from her is sad. Micheal's outfit was awesome but Jeffery should have taken the challenge. Kudos Jeffery! Judges be ashamed.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:09 AM

I HATE PROJECT RUNWAY wrote:

this season is a total crock. it's not even about design anymore. from the stupid commercials with heidi laughing, to the whole "auf'd" thing, to the same music being used, to the constant bragging about being emmy nominated, to the horrible judging, to the obvious decisions to keep people on the show for entertainment purposes only. it's all gimicky. i've watched all 3 seasons and last night was the first night i actually hated the show, and it's my favorite show. i'm seriously really angry about alison. it's total bull. producers, you're not making good television. you're making people angry and you're ruining the credibilty of your show. get it together, or your fan base will disappear.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:10 AM

Antonio wrote:

I smell a RAT! Or something close to raw
tilapia. Allison’s creation was no where
close to being worse than Vincent’s
monstrosity. His dress reminded me of
those tube worms you see at the bottom
of the ocean. My first thought when Heidi
announced Allison Auf’d, was someone of
influence wanted her out of the
competition in order to hire her. If Allie
made the final three: 1.) she wouldn’t
be available to work for a very long time.
and 2.) Her price would go thru the roof.
Eliminating her now would keep her
enormous talent affordable to anyone who
wants to hire her. Does anyone else share
this theory?

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:11 AM

Tiffany wrote:

I cannot believe Kayne gets passed along based on past performance, but Alison doesn't? Vincent is always in the bottom, but for some (GodOnlyKnowsWhy) reason, he keeps being spanked along, even when he can't seem to accept constructive critisizm (someone really shoulda shut him up on the runway). I don't understand why they judges are keeping him around, he's not even good tv. Now Jeffrey, he's good tv. Last night was soooo close man! He almost had it! But, I'm very happy for Michael. His clothes are really looking great, but the whole Alison upset really took the focus off of his win last night in a big way. And what's up with Laura? She's being really nasty lately (or at least she's being edited that way!). Ciao!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:11 AM

Tammy wrote:

I have to agree with many of the other posts here. Vincent should have been shown the door. Obviously, Kayne's past record was taken into consideration (as it should be), so I think this should have also been done for Alison and Vincent.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:12 AM

Melinda wrote:

Yup--I agree that PR probably jumped the shark last night.

Keeping Santino around in PR 2 was at least entertaining, but
keeping Vincent around is nothing more than a pathetic and self-serving way of exploiting the mentally ill.

Also, Heidi, you may want to lose the skinny jeans. Talk about plus size!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:13 AM

Kathy wrote:

What were the judges thinking last night? I had thought that past performance was taken into account. I can't believe they threw Alison out with the trash for this one mis-step, when Vincent has maintained a spot in the bottom 2 or 3 in every episode other than the dog challenge -- when he skated by with a tee shirt and the model's own store-bought leggings.

And even this time, what was that black halter poking out of that cardboard box that was Vincent's dress? There was no evidence of this being constructed in the work room. I think that once again, the model wore a garment of her own to prevent indecent exposure. This has got to be against the rules but no one ever calls him on it.

I'm beginning to think that Vincent is related to one of the judges or producers. Or else he knows something about Heidi's dark, secret past.

As far as the win goes, I was surprised that Jeffrey did not win. He made the most wearable piece in my opinion, and it was very colorful and beautiful.

Loved Tim's blog as usual. I am so glad that Tim is frank about his opinions.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:15 AM

gil wrote:

At times, I do not completely agree with the judges' final decisions, but I do understand their rationale and point of view. However, this week their decision completely angered me because Allison is clearly a superior designer with great execution who still had a lot of potential. Vincent is not a contender for the final while Allison did have some hope. I'm outraged.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:16 AM

Jennifer wrote:

Allison doesn't need Project Runway to succeed. She is very talented, apparently easy to work with, and she has tremendous character. (She didn't complain about her model's figure when every other designer would've whined about it to the judges). Vincent is a nutbag. Enjoy it while it lasts Vincent, because you definitely aren't getting any job offers after the show is over.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:16 AM

Susan wrote:

I am shocked Vincent did not get auf'd. His model looked like she was wearing a paper towel tube with a bunch of confetti thrown on it. I swear I threw up in my mouth a little when he said the dress "turned him on." YUCK. If they gave Kayne a pass based on his previous work, Allison should have gotten one too. The only reason Vincent is still on is because the producers are hoping the ratings will go through the roof when he finally snaps and stabs someone with a pair of scissors in the work room. I'm really disappointed with this one, and I really question the contest's credibility.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:16 AM

Colleen wrote:

First, to re-state the obvious: Vicent = boo, Allison = yeah. I was upset that there was no mention of Angela's heinous outfit. Come on! She wins one challenge and now no one notices how AWFUL she is?! Her and Vincent must go! It's not even good TV, it's just obnoxious!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:17 AM

Serakon wrote:

I'm glad to see that my fellow PR junkies are in agreement with me about Allison's ouster, but I just had to add one more voice to the choir:
- Allison deserved another chance--her designs and unique point of view throughout the competition should have carried her over this (alleged) misstep. It wasn't my favorite, but it was far better than the atrocities perpetrated by Angela and Kayne. Angela's garment was over the top ugly, and a return to the form that we all expect from her. It's obvious to me that the only reason she won the INC challenge is that she was smart enough to pick the two most "tasteful" designers to be on her team and rein in her nutty sensibilities.
- Yes, Laura has impeccable taste. Her clothes are clean, handsome, and beautifully tailored. If she wants a career in fashion I'm sure she can forge one. I'm just not sure that she is the next "Great American Designer." I know, I know, she has a distinct style (albeit a little Cruella DeVille for my tastes), but does she have the imagination and the courage to be really adventurous with her designs?
- Vincent is definitely being kept around for the drama he brings to the show. His designs, even if one wants to call them "editorial," are horrendous.
- Hallelujiah, Michael! His designs have been strong all the way through, and he carries himself with grace and dignity. He is definitely my favorite to win the competition.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:17 AM

Tami wrote:

Allison's model is "plus-size" ??!! What! The fashion industry has no concept of what's plus-size. Come on, fashion folks! Design for real women, not starving waifs!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:18 AM

DesignHo wrote:

OhMyGod. I just looked closely at the photos of Vincent's trash dress. It has a TAIL! A tail, for God's sake. What were the judges thinking? Do they just keep him on the show because they know it will piss people off and keep them watching for the drama?

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:20 AM

Erin wrote:

Why is Vincent still there??/ Yes, he's crazy, yes, he's drama...BUT overall, he has NO TALENT and other people are being kicked off because the producers think that by keeping him they are keeping viewers? Not true. Fans of Project Runway want to see fashion, not crap. Vincet can claim all of his work is fine art, blah blah blah, but it's not even that. Even the avant garde has a certain level of taste and pleasing aesthetics. Vincent needs to go away from the fashion world FOREVER.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:21 AM

Sebrina wrote:

WHY, OH WHY IS VINCENT STILL IN????????? Are you kidding me. I think Allison has been very consistant in what she does and loves. Vincent has not been. He has been in the bottom 3 ever since the show began. I can't believe the producers are keeping him around for ratings. The show is off the hook and people are watching. So, why let Allison go? Anyway, I do think Jeffrey's dress was better than Michael's, and "I'm not trying to play a captain and save a ho". I love you Michael and I think you are very talented. You definately have a chance at winning. However, in this challenge Jeffrey's dress did move better and seemed to flow better on the walk way. But hey, back to back wins, you better sew some clothes. I also loved Uli's dress and Laura's was great and funny. Although I don't understand why Laura decided to get into it with Vincent, when it was an emotional moment for Allison. Kayne, I don't know what happened and I'm glad that Robert pulled himself out of his downward spiral. Anglea's dress was so her and I thought she did a good job. Tim I love your take on things. You mentioned that Project Runway holds integrity very high, then once again, why is Vincent still in? "Carry On".

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:22 AM

stella wrote:

Let me preface by saying that I am very, very sad that Allison is gone. She was a sweet girl and a great designer (although her hairline was disturbing at times). However horrible Vincent's dress was (and it was pretty bad) it at least covered his model. Allison's dress didn't even meet in the back. She designed a dress but didn't consider her model. I don't think Tim said she was a plus-sized model; Heidi said she looked like one. The dress that was on the form didn't even look like the same dress after it was on the model, it was so small. Plus the hairstyle -- yick! Just horrible. And while I agree that Jeffrey's dress was beautiful and more innovative -- I can't think of why or where I would wear it. The proportions of the skirt from front to back are too long and it looks a bit cartoony. Artistic, innovative, well-constructed, yes. Wearable by most of the population, no.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:22 AM

Edwn wrote:

Based on this week's show, it is clear that the producers and judges are taking "the little reality show that could" and trying to make it into Bravo's "Laguna Beach."

First, Heidi was not previously a judge, nor should she be considered one now. Of course, she had no problems expressing her amusing perspective, but Bravo should not be including her in its dim-witted "mean judge-nice judge" studies because it has failed to demonstrate that she has the skill set to be judging those outfits. In last week's show, I believe she actually went first and the panel seemed annoyed by her actions. Keep Heidi at what she is good at, discarding models we don't particularly care about (because we never learn anything about them), introducing the respective challenge and finally, executing her gruff mannered send-off for the losing candidate.

More importantly, last night's show has swayed me into abandoning "Project Runway" as a viewer altogether like many of the viewer's who have posted before me. This saddens me a bit because I have followed the show from the very first episode. For that reason however, I have been able to mentally document where the show started and where it is clearly headed.

Regarding last night's show, I credit Allison for maintaining her dignity and not going into the reasons she ended up with the piece she presented. From the outset, Allison focused on creating something that looked articulate and beautiful, which had a lot of potential. As we all know, she encountered disappointment once she tried assembling it. Nonetheless, her last minute creation demonstrated far more talent and complexity than Vincent's piece. Taken on the whole, I don't think several models looked very flattering in the clothes they were wearing and it was made evident that the model she worked with had a unique figure, when compared to the others. In retrospect, Allison's losing design was still better than all of Vincent's pieces combined!

In sum, it is clear that the show's producers have failed to realize that the world of television is also characterized by the claim, "one day you're in and the next day you're out" After deleting the show from my Tivo scheduling, I am here to report you are OUT!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:22 AM

Jen wrote:

I have been a loyal fan since day one of PR and I have to say, last night was the biggest disappointment in 3 seasons. Allison has made some amazing pieces thus far and even won a challenge and Vincent continues to be the most unoriginal, ridiculous contestant on the show. I would be embarassed to be a judge and know that they have let him stay on so long. Is anyone actually looking at what he makes? No one would ever put anything on that he made. 4 very competent designers have been sacrificed for pathetic Vincent so the producers can keep the show dramatic and that is sad.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:22 AM

Linda wrote:

Hi Tim, I too was sad to see Alison go. I was very interested to see what she could do with future challenges and not the least bit intersested in seeing what Vincent would do. We actually had not seen much of Alisons designs to this point. Her first dress I really didn't like with that pouchy look in front..great "doggy" outfit.. but the gown challenge and the Macy's challenge were not her designs. And I didn't really like her Farah dress either. That said, I think she had potential and I feel like she was cut short. Viewers do like watching nice, sweet, sincere people working hard to create. I hope the producers wake up next season and realize that. Your viewers are not typical reality show viewers and we don't respond to that type of, frankly, garbage. I will add my voice to the chorus of criticism about the "plus size" references. Unbelievable!! wake up!!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:22 AM

Susan wrote:

Laura is very elegant in her designs, but as one person said, she's designing for her and no one else. She is very confrontional, but does anyone remember the video of her kids beating and hitting stuff in what look like a Gap Store? Are the kids showing Laura's true nature, a little hellion beneath an extremely polish facade. I love Laura's designs, but found this one well, a bit boring. The "for nuts only" was the only redeeming value, a bit of wit there. Laura's coat for the first challenge of using room materials (all IKEA, at that) was my favorite of the first challenge.

Michael's personal facade is so street, but his stylings are as elegant as Givenchy with a street edge. You can tell he loves the female body and it shows. I'd been pulling for him.
Robert is my personal favorite. He's got the potential and the capacity to exceed both the elegeance of Michael and Laura. His Jackie O outfit could have been so gorgeous for that was the perfect icon for him. I've been a fan of Robert's since the audition where Tim expressed his joy over Robert's skills and talent. Go Robert--just don't bore us!

Vincent, yep, so many here are right, what keeps this guy here except that he makes good TV? Even my unfashion conscious honey is saying "Get rid of Vincent." We'll see alot of Alison, I was sorry to see her leave. It'll only get better as the show goes on. But Vincent, why?

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:23 AM

Nelson wrote:

I guess we now know your true agenda, producers. This isn't a competition about talent but about who gets you the highest ratings. SHAME ON HEIDI and SHAME ON THE PRODUCERS! You lost your credibilty with a lot of us, Vincent should have been auf'd!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:24 AM

Paige wrote:

Michael Knight is great! I hope he wins! To be honest, I liked Jeffrey's design better, but I gotta give first love to anybody representing the dirty south. We are so out numbered by the LAers and NYCers. I have now added Angela to my okay list, but Vincent is OFF! What a freak- a- zoid! He must have been planted by the producers. Nothing he does makes sense. Poor Alison! She's made so many wonderful things, and to be kicked off because of one bad outfit (unlike Vincent who is consistantly bad). I mean, Kayne's Christmas tree thing totally sucked, but they must have kept him on because of past performances. WHATEVER!! Think I'll try out for Project Runway next year. I have to be better than Vincent. My schtick (that I constantly tell the cameras when interviewed) will be how I had to sell my child on the black market in order to come on the show. That should get some sympathy from the judges when I repeatedly churn out tacky, wiggity-whacky outfits!!! What a come back for Robert. PROPS! I love how at the end of the episode, Laura started getting all "Mommy Dearest". I had hoped she would go on undermining and belittling Vincent until he rolled up into the fetal position with his thumb in is mouth. Unfortunately, the voice of reason put a premature halt to the verbal assualt. Was that Kayne?!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:25 AM

Janet wrote:

To keep Vincent on and dump Allison is a crime and clearly an indication that the show is rigged. Lets make sure we have an inadequate designer with a crazy personality. He has consistently designed ugly clothes with little or no flair and bad construction. The show does not need this - we enjoy seeing great design and nice people like Allison and Uli.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:26 AM

Mary Vee wrote:

This show proves what they'll do to keep people watching. Vincent is super-eccentric (and a horrible desginer), Allison, not so much (stable and talented). But this should not have over-ridden Allison's consistency and vision throughout the series. Ugh. Vincent sucks, are you kidding me? Kudos to Laura for going for the jugular backstage, even though it clouded Allison's farewell. I think it was on all the designer's faces (Vincent's too!) that this was a "fixed" finish.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:28 AM

Jennifer Greenberg wrote:

Well, it's obvious that talent has nothing to do with this show anymore. It's all been said, thank God for Tim's honesty. Project Runway has lost all credibility. Why Malan and Alison are gone is question enough, but to see that Angela and Vincent are still in defies reason. Thank you, producers, for ruining yet another interesting TV show that actually had potential to be cool.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:29 AM

Michelle V wrote:

Tim, I really think you should branch out into your own show. It's obvious your critiques are genuine and make much more sense to the viewers than what the judges (both on and off screen) are giving us. I thought this show was about true creativity, class & style, not based on 'tv material'. It's obvious the show's loosing it's lusture and viewers since Vincent obviously isn't proving to be true "tv material". I'll be sure to catch up on each episode on-line rather than actually watch the show.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:29 AM

DesignHo wrote:

RE: the judges, specifically Heidi: She is beautiful, but she wears some of the most hideous clothes I've ever seen. Some of them far worse than Alison's design.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:31 AM

Suzanne Spaugh wrote:

It's hard to believe that Vincent and Angela are still in. Allison was by far a better designer then either of them. I think her design was very tasteful. I'm very saddened to see her go.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:31 AM

Chris wrote:

Project Runway is about TV NOT FASHION. Last night was a travesty. The only reason Vincent was not aufd' is because he makes good TV. Allison's design was far better and this was the only time she screwed up; her proven potential surpasses any stupid recycled material challenge. Evidence of Project Runway's preference for ratings over fashion was also displayed last week. The only evident reason for why Michael won over Kayne was because the producers wanted to reach out to the African-American/ethnic audience (like myself). The show is getting stupider by the minute... Alison deserved to be in the top 3.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:32 AM

Jill wrote:

By aufing Alison, the credibility of the show is definitely in question. Producers should be concerned with the lifespan of such a great series -- most reality shows fade away after a few seasons but this one has the potential for longevity because in theory, the competition is based on talent and ability, not gamesmanship and personality. Don't blow it with these transparent decisions!

I would also add that the episodes are becoming too predictable -- focused on 3-4 designers who you know automatically will be top or bottom because of the attention they're getting. I would have liked to see what went into that crazy dress of Angela's even if she was in the middle of the pack!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:32 AM

lorne wrote:

The decision last night was about the show only. Not talant. I thought the decision to keep Vincent and oust Allison was tacky and had no class. It had nothing to do with merit.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:32 AM

Anne wrote:

It seems like Alison was being held to a higher standard than the others. The judges kept pointing out that as a woman, she should design more flattering clothing for women. If one of the male designers had designed the same dress for the same model, would he have been kicked off, or would it have been forgiven because, naturally, a man can be forgiven for making unflattering clothing?

I am growing tired of the comments about Alison's model. Please. Tim isn't saying she's a plus-size WOMAN, but that she's a plus-size MODEL. She is bigger than most models; you can't deny that.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:34 AM

Jen wrote:

I agree with almost everyone's comments. Allison is by far a better designer and has shown that she has a much broader range of skills. Vincent is only on for the drama, if I wanted a ridiculous reality tv show I could go somewhere else. However, I watch Project Runway because, at least I thought, it is credible. For example actually kicking someone off for breaking the rules is a bold move.
Vincent needs to go, Angela should have gone when she made that atrocious camp outfit, and in my opinion Allison has way more taste and talent than some of the designers left. I am also glad Michael has been getting more face time. I have loved his designs from the beginning, and as the judges did say last night, he truly thinks about it and really constructs his garments well. I am very sad to see Allison go, and very disappointed in the judges for not moving her on, especially when they have moved on Angela, Vincent, Robert and Kayne after serious missteps. Hopefully Vincent will finally go next week.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:34 AM

g wrote:

Bring Allison back you rating sellouts!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:35 AM

kaypbee wrote:

Vincent's dress was AWFUL and his track record has been less then stellar. Allison should not have gone home. Her dress wasn't great, but it was better than Vincent's and her previous work has been much better than his. And Vincent saying he "got off" on his dress???? That's just WEIRD!!! I am so disappointed in this week's decision.

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:36 AM

cathi wrote:

Tim,
As you can see, PR is beginning to "auf" itself if it doesn't treat the competition fairly.
Allison has consistently made good clothing - her outfit in the dog challenge was stunning.
Vincent has just stunned me with his design stupidity.
Perhaps you and Heidi should do a "job-swap" one episode. She would see what they are REALLY up against, and you, already knowing what goes into all of this, will be able to be a better judge.
The producers should keep their noses out of this. After all, when did you teach them at Parson's?

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:36 AM

Phyllis Stansell wrote:

Guys, just like in seasons past, the designer with the worst design will not necessarily be the one to go. What we must remember above all is that this is a TV show. And they are going to do whatever is best for the ratings. Do you think Wendy Pepper actually deserved to be in the final 3? No, but people hated her so she was there until the bitter end. Watch, enjoy, but don't get too caught up in who wins.....it doesn't mean they are the best just that they were good for ratings!!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:36 AM

Smiles wrote:

jeffrey should have won this one. I think Michael is the best overall designer and I like him the best as the most versatile and dynamic designer. his look for this challenge was very good but jeffrey, abrasive as his personality may be at times, was just a little more innovative. and I absolutely agree that it was a big mistake to let Allison go. She is much better than Vincent, Angela and Kayne. I still think Laura may have a few surprises up her sleeve (although she needs to bring them out immediately). As for Kayne, we've seen the extent of his work with the gowns. it wasnt surprising to see him falter when asked to think outside the box(almost said outside the tumbleweed-DOH!). I also doubt that Kayne has any passion or aspirations beyond using the show to help him become the biggest sparkly dress designer in his home town. If the producers are thinking about bringing any of the axed designers back to fill the gap with Keith leaving, Allison would be the best choice by far. Along with Michael, she is the most versitile designer on the 3rd season. I think she would have been in the final 3 if she hadn't slipped this week

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:37 AM

Jerrick wrote:

Lets start a petition, Auf Vincent!

I give my first signature! Any other takers!

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:38 AM

Someone who *never* posts wrote:

Seeing Alison, one of the consistently excellent designers on the show, get kicked off last night, left me with a bad taste in my mouth. So bad, in fact, that I will not be watching the show anymore.
I watched 'Project Runway' to see cool designs and talented designers in action. By kicking off one of their most talented designers, in favor of keeping one, whose mediocre and often bizarre performances have consistently earned him low scores, the producers did not create good Reality T.V. They merely managed to dilute the talent pool, thereby diminishing the quality of the show. Oh yeah, and offending everyone's sense of fair play. Good thinking...

posted on August 17, 2006 at 11:39 AM

d-nice wrote:

very cool that it seems all viewers are on the same page..

Vincent STILL in???

He shoulda been kicked out from day one for the infamous "basket hat" (*the SINGLE worst thing I have ever seen oon the runway). He can only be alive because he makes for good TV.

Poor Alsison. She's very talented. Super sweet. And prettier than any model on the runway. If she needs a guy to console her... (*sigh)

Also, the judges are way off this season. Michael should have won a couple of early challenges but should have placed second in the last two. Kayne won last week and Jeffrey won this week. Seems