May has been a revealing month for Andy Cohen. His life was literally turned into an open book with the release of Most Talkative: Stories From the Front Lines of Pop Culture, and he even admitted to Wendy Williams that he's made out with Lance Bass. Then on Wednesday night's Watch What Happens Live after show, one caller posed an interesting question to Andy: What girls would he want to, as Andy put it, "do it with."
After mulling it over a bit, Andy said "Remember when Jenny McCarthy was hosting Singled Out? ... I love a blonde, and you always want what you can't have -- an aryan," he joked. Is that it? Nope, there's one more that Andy admitted.
"It was Jenny McCarthy, then I went into a Cameron Diaz thing where during Something About Mary she'd do those dances with her ass," he confessed.
In the after show, guests Steve Guttenberg and Joey Lawrence also let callers and Andy pry into their personal past, including both being asked who their best and worst kisses were. Guttenberg's worst? It's an Oscar-winning acting legend -- a male one. Watch the video below to find out who and tell us in the comments who your celebrity crush is!