Kara DioGuardi, head judge

• "A Song For You" –- Leon Russell, Donny Hathaway
• "At Last" –- Etta James
• "Maybe I'm Amazed" –- Paul McCartney

Jewel, host and judge

• "Don't Break Even" –- The Script
• "Bleeding Love" –- Leona Lewis
• "I'm Yours" – Jason Mraz
• "Answering Machine" –- The Replacements
• "Lilac Wine" –- Nina Simone
• "A Case of You" –- Joni Mitchell

Keith Naftaly, judge

• "Wonderwall" -– Oasis
• "Adore" -– Prince
• "Fade Into You" -– Mazzy Star
• "Let's Get It On" –- Marvin Gaye
• "The Look of Love" –- Dusty Springfield

Evan Bogart, guest judge

• "Halo" –- Beyonce
• "I Will Always Love You" –- Whitney Houston
• "Brighter Than Sunshine" -– Aqualung
• "Stand By Me" -– Ben E. King
• "Faithfully" –- Journey

Amber Ojeda, contestant

• "Ordinary People" -– John Legend
• "Prototype" -– Outkast
• "So In Love With You" -– Marvin Gaye
• "Love and Happiness" –- Al Green
• "He Loves Me" -– Jill Scott

Blessing Ofor, contestant

• "How Deep Is Your Love" –- The Bee Gees
• "Let's Get It On" -– Marvin Gaye
• "Just My Imagination" –- The Temptations
• "Back At One" -– Brian McKnight
• "Everything" -- by Boyz II Men

Brian Judah, contestant

• "Your Song" -– Elton John
• "She's Always A Woman" -– Billy Joel
• "Young and Beautiful" -– Elvis Presley
• "Patience" – Guns N' Roses
• "Let You Down' -- Dave Matthews Band
• "Drive" -– The Cars
• "You're In My Heart" -– Rod Stewart
• "Love on the Rocks" -– Neil Diamond

Jackie Tohn, contestant

• "Deconstruction" -– Indigo Girls
• "That Particular Time" –- Alanis Morissette
• "To Your Love" -– Fiona Apple
• "Show the Way" –- David Wilcox
• "Don't Fall In Love With A Dreamer" -– Kenny Rogers

Johnny Marnell, contestant

• "Endlessly" -– Muse
• "You Make My Dreams" –- Hall and Oates
• "Last Goodbye" –- Jeff Buckley
• "Power of Two" -– Indigo Girls
• "Alison" –- Elvis Costello

Karen Waldrup, contestant

• "Tangled Up In You" –- Staind
• "It's Your Love" –- Tim McGraw ft. Faith Hill
• "You've Got A Way" -– Shania Twain
• "I Will Always Love You" –- Whitney Houston

Melissa Rapp, contestant

• "Let's Get It On" –- Marvin Gaye
• "Secret Garden" -– Bruce Springsteen
• "A Case of You" –- Joni Mitchell
• "Samson" -– Regina Spektor
• "Steal My Kisses" –- Ben Harper

Sonyae Elise, contestant

• "A Song For You" –- Donny Hathaway
• "It's All Coming Back To Me Now" -– Celine Dion
• "Adore" -– Prince
• "I Would Die 4 U" -– Prince
• "I Don't Want To Miss A Thing" –- Aerosmith
• "Beautiful One" -– Mary J. Blige
• "Happy Together" –- The Turtles
• "I Want You" –- Erykah Badu
• "Queen of Sanity" –- Bilal
• "The Truth" -- India.Arie