The anticipation had been long coming - on and off for about 15 years to be exact - when Lyle Mackenzie proposed to Catherine Cooper. Lyle rounded up the Charmers following a chartered boat ride, but what could have been the greatest night of his life turned into one of the most disappointing. To the Charmers' dismay, Catherine was ultimately blindsided by the question and postponed acceptance to an undetermined date. Now it's time for you to weigh in: what should Catherine have done?
Southern Charm Savannah
Catherine Says No to Lyle's Proposal
Heartbroken doesn't begin to cover this moment as Lyle Mackenzie's proposal is rejected by Catherine Cooper.