I can't believe you guys sent Eduardo home over Calvin! I agree Eduardo is a one-trick pony BUT at least the guy can sew. Everything Calvin makes looks like it should be in the sale bin at cheapy-shop!!
Well I'm off. I had high hopes for this program and was willing never to return to Project Runway even in The Fashion Show's off season, however with the removal of Eduardo the Fashion Show has proven to be nothing more than another Project Runway, mimicking the worst and most unbelievable decisions--probably for 'good tv'.
I do not think it works well that Isaac is both advisor in the showroom and judge on the runway. I think he has to be either coach or referee, not both. He cannot help but bring a bias to the runway depending on whether or not the designers accepted his guidance.
I think Isaac should either be either advising in the showroom or judging on the runway-not both. Coach or referee? Can't do both jobs. I think Isaac in both places creates a disadvantage/advantage for the designers depending on his advice and whether or not they follow it.
Judges say what??? Eduardo go... really... before the pig coat (oink couture?!)or Calvin... at least Eduardo's clothes are always sophisticated and beautiful and were head and shoulders THE best on the runway last night... wow... what a stinker... oink!!
Eduardo was the best one there, his designs were always beautiful & well made. The stupid pig coat was ridiculous & ugly.
I gave my chance to the show, but after seeing Eduardo leaving and a tasteless "pig coat" yes, excentric, but below the standards that the show was trying to maintain, this show is "out of my Wednesdays' entertainment schedule". Can't keep watching. I'm very, very disapointed.
Isaac, Same question to you as to Iman. Why do you say Eduardo does the same dress. Week 1(Cocktail dress) , Week 2 Bodies Exhibit( No Ruffles), Fem Fatale ( High collar, but not a ruffle), lost and found episode( pants and top) No Ruffle, Wedding dress( No Ruffles), Futuristic look with Plaid( No Ruffles). Please tell us why your panties are in a bunch with Eduardo
The designers need to have someone on their side, someone that can show love, not just criticism. That can be you, Isaac. Iman's coldness needs to be balanced. Love the show!
It was a sorry decision by Iman and Isaac to send one of the most talented designers home before and untalented, unpopular, and uncivilized person such as Calvin. Compare their track records on the show-DUH!!!! You lost this viewer.
Extremely disappointed that Eduardo was eliminated. He's the best and I never thought he did the same dress over and over. Each dress is different and beyond beautiful. It's only right he sticks to what he does best.
And yes, it really feels like a fake contest when they chose Calvin to stay over the really talented Eduardo. Not sure if I want to follow this show anymore. What's the point really???
Well, I am not a blogger and have littler time to wash TV but was liking your show untill you decided that Eduardo was the next to go. Really? You are a real Joke. You let go of someone who has been consistently doing well; An experience designer over two kids, one of then just out of school and decined an ugly coat.
Neither i or anyone I know will ever tune to your show. Edwardo did not deserved to leave. your show is fake, fake fake. Terrible judges
The title of the show should be changed to FASHION SHOW: MEDIOCRE COLLECTION.
Extremely disappointed that the show's best designer was sent show this early oven a no talent, all drama Calvin...It appears that this show is rewarding mediocre talent and good TV drama over real talent...The show and it's judges totally lost credibility in letting Eduardo go. Eduardo has the most wins and was always in the top 2 or 3 designers for most challenges...I cannot believe that someone who has not one any of the challenges or even ended in the top 3 designers each challenge will remain...doesn't past showing and performance of the designers matter even a single bit??
After this episode, I will not be watching any other episode of this joke of a show...Can't wait for Project Runway to air again since the judges on that show have never made such a bad decision as this episode.
I don't know who you think would wear these clothes, after watching the show tonight 1/18/11, I was very dissapointed by the winners. I never see anyone in the real world, or pictures of the stars that would wear these winning outfits, I cannot express how bad this show is, I will not watch the final show, nor will I watch it if it comes back on the next season. Lets have REAL clothes that people would wear, not these half finished, unfitted, barefoot in the snow rags.
Isaac's shoes were so adorable on the January 18, 2011 show. I loved the Nature theme of the show.It is exciting to watch such creativity.It is thrilling to watch this show.
Several episodes ago I said I would never watch again but last night I was flipping channels and saw an ad for the finale and there was no Eduardo! but no talent Calvin was still there.
Seems as if I made the right decision weeks ago not to continue to watch.
The designers on this show not only can't design but seem to have no imagination, no sophistication and bottom line most can't even sew. Most of the things that go down the runway look like they are held together with a basic whip stitch AND CALVIN'S "things" (won't call them clothes) are the worst.
Back to Project Runway at least they can sew.
Love Calvin and glad he is in the finale. If he was sent home last night I would not be watching the finale. Kudos to the judges.
Add my comment to the rest: The Producers and Judges succumbed to valuing cheap drama above fashion. What a shame, and mistake. The never-ending repetition of Calvin being a jerk/poor designer does not make good viewing. I tune in to see fashion in the making, not this boredom. When Eduardo and Cesar were sent home that did it for me. Who is Calvin sleeping with?
Agree we needed to see more from Issac than 'Hello Darlings'. Season one gave us some of his thoughts, this season we get Ms Icycle instead. Not a good choice. I'm Out of Fashion.
I was so shocked. You criticized Cesar for his hem being irregular then chose HOUSE OF Nami. I usually like Dominique's designs a great deal but think she got sucked in by Calvin...Yuch!! These garments could maybe be called art works (or bad artworks) or maybe could belong in a museum for examples of body coverings before needles etc were invented. Calvin only drapes his garments...As you all said previously fashion should flatter a woman's body... and Isaac, you and Iman both have asked who would wear such and such and where would they wear it. Now I ask you WHO and Where would these be worn and be appropriate????? The stunning models look haggard and slouchy etc. You all missed the boat on this and to think this means Cesar won't get the chance to make a collection and CAlvin will????? I already know what his line will look like. What a bummer...