Blogs
- Jay Rayner
- Wobbly Bits
- Jay Rayner talks about women's breasts. And doesn't apologize for it.
As I’ve mentioned before, I am very much experiencing Top Chef Masters from a distance. I only get to see the show if the international delivery service gets the DVD to me on time – no such luck so far this week - and the rest of it comes via the Web. Indeed, in an act of shameless narcissism, I only really get a sense of what part of my appearance made an impact by searching Twitter under my own name the morning after. So shoot me! This week, apparently, it was my announcement that a properly set panna cotta should move like a woman’s breasts.
Shock, horror. Rayner mentioned breasts. And not ones belonging to chickens. Women’s breasts. Even more shockingly, apparently, I did so in front of two women, who presumably didn’t know they had them. This kind of thing, what feels like a puritanical knee jerk reaction, does make me laugh. Here in the UK readers of my column expect such language from me. All us UK restaurant critics bang on about wobbly bits all of the time. I really didn’t think it would be such a big deal. We measure the doneness of a steak by pressing our fingers against the ball of our thumb when the hand is closed; why shouldn’t we measure the quality of a panna cotta in a similar way? I can promise you I made filthier comments which I’m sure never made the cut. I have a particular aversion, for example, to being told something has been cooked ‘with love’. As I said during one recording if love was wanted I’d go call my wife. From chefs I wanted dinner. I didn’t want a ... anyway, enough.
On to the canapés challenge. Critics love canapés. It means we get to eat the whole dish. Plus they are designed to deliver a hit of flavour which is a boon for our tragically jaded palates. Then of course there was the fact a bunch of chefs who normally only stand at the pass had to produce enough food each for 300. Happy days. Even at this distance from recording the show certain of those dishes still resonate with me. Nils’ scallop with smoked potato was a staggeringly sophisticated, if tiny mouthful. It was a lesson in precision. If anything his salmon with Napa cabbage was better, even if it did initiate the war of James’s tongue. As he has written in his own post, he admits to a certain sensitivity. Personally I think the department of defence should put that tongue into the lab for analysis. If it’s as sensitive as James’ claims it must have a greater use.
There were a couple of calamities, prime among them Lachlan’s deep fried pineapple speck thing. I used to think you could improve almost anything by dumping it in the deep fat fryer. But not this. It was a waste of good pineapple.
But one of the stars for me was Michael’s spicy, rich, slightly crisp, big-fisted prawn. More to the point, being British and foul-mouthed and infantile, I loved the fact he called it a pissed off prawn.
A big name chef said piss! On camera!
Now that’s what I call television.
Jay Rayner is the author of The Man Who Ate The World, published now in paperback by Henry Holt.
- 08/02/2009 - 3:50pm
- Leslie Stavrowsky
Jay,
Why would you have an aversion to being told something has been cooked "with love"? Come on! Art
Smith didn't say his food had been cooked "with sex." It is simply a fact that lots of people express their love and affection for others by cooking good food for them. They want to give people something great to eat that they will truly enjoy. What's wrong with that? Get over it!
- 07/23/2009 - 12:48pm
- Quori
well...as someone who loves Coupling, Fawlty Towers, Vicar, Allo Allo, etc etc - I will quote coupling..."You have 8,000 words for breasts." "and counting!" Wobbly Bits...I LOVE IT!
- 07/22/2009 - 3:17pm
- jcb
Wish I had some clever comment about your British sensibilities. Suffice to say you are a breath of fresh air in an otherwise stale environment. This country elected George W. Bush to a second term. Need I say more? I see fellow Brit Toby is coming back to Top Chef-LV.. Hurrah !!! Hope to see you on the critic's panel again soon, and often. I have become a fan. Thanks for your educated palate and insightful commentary.
- 07/19/2009 - 9:20pm
- MartiV
Please tell the producers that the music background it to loud to understand all of the commentary. And, I am not hard of hearing.
Thanks
- 07/19/2009 - 8:20am
- FanFare
Your point about our Puritanical notions getting the best of us is well taken. I was more surprised and less offended by your analogy of the panna cotta. In retrospect, it was funny.
Nils didn't receive very high marks for his sophisticated offerings. Did his dessert bring down the entire effect?
It seemed as though the judges actually preferred Rick's food. Had he not blown the QF, he might have won...
- 07/17/2009 - 10:24pm
- Quincy
For what it's worth, sir Jay, saying "breasts" on the Bravo cable network is pretty much on par with saying "the" on any other cable network, so you're not needing to defend a thing!
This was a highly-entertaining episode and not just because of the verbiage. Great challenge, great dishes, great work by all four chefs. But indeed, as someone who considers the pineapple the world's most perfect food (it goes with absolutely anything), I consider that deep-frying idea just abominable.
- 07/17/2009 - 8:31pm
- adriana
Am I crazy -- why does Jay Rayner look exactly like Marco Pierre White on nbc's Chopping Block??? Is he the same person?
- 07/17/2009 - 1:46am
- James
First of all, it was good to have you back on the show, your edge was sorely lacking last week (no offense to Gail Simmons, who I love). To be honest, I had not heard the panna cotta/woman's breast guideline, but I loved it the second I heard it, a perfect description! Good luck on the future DVD delivery, and thank you for the entertaining blog.
More Top Chef Masters Blogs
- Michael Got Hosed
- While Harold enjoyed all the food during the 'Top Chef Masters' finale, he thinks Michael Chiarello should have taken home the win.
- Read Entry
- Highs and Lows
- James Oseland breaks down the hits and misses of the final meal ... and gets a little misty-eyed doing so.
- Read Entry
- A Bacchanalian Feast
- Rick Bayless had Kelly at mole.
- Read Entry
Top 5 by Bravo -- What's popular on BRAVOTV.com this week
-

Housewives O.C., Gallery
Reunion Recap: White Trash and Househubbies
Flip through behind-the-scenes shots of the OC reunion special!
-

Housewives NYC, Blog
Bethenny vs. Jill: Blog Showdown
Why is Jill feeling "very defensive"? Read the Housewives tell-all blogs to find out!
-

Kell on Earth, Personality Quiz
What's Your Style Personality?
Are you sporty? Chic? Preppy? Punk? Find out your signature style!
-

Housewives NYC, Gallery
NYC Housewives Out and About!
Flip through shots of Manhattan's hottest 'Real Housewives' hitting the NYC social scene!
-

Shear Genius, Do or Don't
Rate Headshot Looks of Stunning Starlets!
Which stylist captured their model's personality with the best two looks? Rate the 'dos here!
-

Top Chef Masters, Previews
The Return of 'Top Chef Masters'
Get a sneak peek of what's on the menu for the 'Masters' in Season Two.
-

Top Chef Masters, Video
Take A Kitchen Tour with Tony Mantuano
Go behind the scenes of Spiaggia with 'Master' chef Tony Mantuano!
-

Top Chef, Recipe Finder
Hungry? Browse our Recipe Finder
Find hundreds of Top Chef dishes in our recipe finder!
-

Top Chef, Jacques and Julia
Cook with Jacques and Julia
Learn from culinary masters Jacques and Julia to create delicious dishes.
-

Top Chef, Behind the Burner
Tips: Cooking with Cognac
Go behind the burner with Chef Hugo to learn alternative uses for cognac.
-

Shear Genius, Do or Don't
Rate Headshot Looks of Stunning Starlets!
Which stylist captured their model's personality with the best two looks? Rate the 'dos here!
-

, Out and About
Bravo Stars Take NY Fashion Week!
From Bethenny Frankel to Tabatha Coffey, check out your favorite Bravolebrities at Fall 2010 Fashion Week!
-

Housewives O.C., Game
Dress Like An OC Housewife!
Mix and match looks inspired by Housewives to create the perfect OC-approved outfit!
-

Kell on Earth, Personality Quiz
What's Your Style Personality?
Are you sporty? Chic? Preppy? Punk? Find out your signature style!
-

Kell on Earth, Game
Ultimate Fashion IQ Quiz!
Are you fashion forward or clueless about clothes? Test your style savvy here.
-

Top Chef, Bravo Shop
Quickfire Wines
Inspire your inner Top Chef with a Napa Valley hand crafted Quickfire Wine!
-

Top Chef, Bravo Shop
Top Chef Apron and Cookbook Gift Set!
Look and cook like a real 'Top Chef' with an embroidered apron and official TC cookbook!
-

Top Chef, Bravo Shop
Top Chef: Quickfire Cookbook
Flip through 75 of Top Chef's best Quickfire Challenge recipes!
-

Housewives NYC, Bravo Shop
"Shoulders are the New Boobs" Tee
Rock the hot (and hilarious) new Real Housewives of New York City t-shirt!
-

Housewives ATL, Bravo Shop
"Who Gonna Check Me Boo?" Tee
Make Sheree's one-liner into a fashion statement with the ATL-inspired tee!
Get Mobile
- Take Bravo With You.
- Get games, show updates, and more on your cell phone.
- Message & data rates may apply.























Comments