Toby Young

Toby Young explains why he fought for a victory for Stefan.

on Feb 25, 2009

It is hard to watch last night’s episode and not feel sorry for Carla. Her cooking got stronger and stronger as the season progressed and she looked poised to cause an upset. Her appetizer was delicious, her first course was even better, and, for a moment there, all the judges thought she was going to win. So what went wrong?

Two words: Casey Thompson. OK, that’s a bit harsh. It’s more like Casey was sent to test Carla: Will she or won’t she follow Casey’s advice? And she failed. Not that Casey is a bad cook. It’s just that her style is completely different from Carla’s. Carla stated at the outset that what she wanted to do was give us her version of meat and potatoes — and if she had only done that she might have gone on to win Top Chef. But Carla listened to Casey when she told her she needed to make her meal more complicated, that her simple, down-home style wouldn’t be good enough to win the competition. That was crazy, since it’s precisely that style that had got Carla into the final, but for some reason — whether because she lacked confidence or because she was too nice to tell Casey to take a running jump — Carla abandoned her plan and went with Casey’s. Result: Carla’s second and third courses were a disaster.

Eliminating Carla was the easy part. Deciding between Stefan and Hosea was fiendishly difficult. For the first time in Season 5, Tom and I were completely at loggerheads. We’ve disagreed before at Judges Table, but never like this. In tonight’s episode, you get a glimpse of this when my voice suddenly goes all high — it’s the moment when I’m defending Stefan’s dessert, but that scarcely conveys just how passionately we disagreed. It really was a bun fight.

I asked Tom at the outset whether the same rule applied to judging the finale as it did to all the other challenges, namely, that we had to disregard everything the chefs had done before and judge them entirely on their performance that day. He said it did, but with one caveat: if we whittled the finalists down to two, and there was nothing to choose between them, we could bring in their past performances as a tie-breaker.

As far as I was concerned, that was exactly the situation in last night’s episode — and, for that reason, we ought to give it to Stefan, who clearly performed better over the course of the season than Hosea. My argument went like this: Stefan and Hosea tied the appetizer and the first course; Stefan won the second; and Hosea won the third. So that was one win each, deadlock.