Marcel found himself right where you'd think he'd want to be -- in the kitchen of Wylie Dufresne, whose work he's been duping for years. Rarely have a contestant and a challenge been so well matched. To return to the baseball metaphor, if ever Marcel had his pitch -- this was it. And yet he played it safe. For such a brash young man, he really dialed it back this week. His comment about Tiffani's melon dish, that she was "showcasing technique just to do it," was both absolutely on target -- and something he's chronically guilty of himself. But not this week. This was a relatively restrained Astro-Boy, playing it safe just when he had his best chance--and best audience (one would think) for a shot at greatness.
Richard, in his wisdom, recognized his own tendencies to overreach -- and like Marcel, reigned himself in. Maybe too much.
Jamie's tomato soup was weak -- but unobjectionable. Make that very weak. She may as well have gone back to the hospital to check out those stitches. Angelo's contribution was everything you'd expect of Angelo at this point. Creative and generally excellent.
Tre's swordfish was impeccable though less inspired than Dale Talde's contribution. Dale's winning dish brought home how much he's grown since his "Angry Dale" period. Or should we now call him "The Artist Formerly Known As Angry Dale"? He did everything right this week. He identified who he was cooking for (Wylie) -- and even more shrewdly, what he loved. (Eggs.) He acknowledged his own strengths and weaknesses -- realizing that "molecular" was not his area of expertise -- but managed to pay brilliant homage to the Dufresne style in spirit. He executed his dish with flawless technique, making something that managed to be creative, fun, pleasurable to eat, and supremely delicious. In short, he used his head, heart, senses, and skills to maximum effect. This week, he was truly the Top Chef.
Right on point, Mr. Bourdain. I will miss Dale L. It appears that Stephen matured a lot since season one. He and Dale showed class in their departure, unlike Jennifer and Elia.
LOVED the elimination challenge. I'm a bit surprised though at the result, I figured the other two were the ones going home. With that said, both Dale and Stephen are very different than they were in their initial seasons. Stephen, as you and others have remarked, isn't as "kitchen" anymore, so that may have been his downfall. Dale at this point in Season 3 was unsure of himself and his career. Being eliminated in week 3 of Season 3 would have likely caused him to quit the business. Now, he's confident and he knows this is his calling, elimination notwithstanding. I'm very proud to see how far Dale has come.
And speaking of Dales, let's talk about the other Dale, who has also changed a LOT for the better since his first season. What a world of difference!
Oh my, Bourdain!
For all of the snarling and snarky comments...you've exposed yourself for what you are, a truly nice guy! A teddy bear. Blog on, big guy....love your writing.
def. balls: Being able to walk into unknown situations and deliver what is asked, regardless of how comfortable you are with it, with style.
Kudos to you Mr. Bourdain for pointing out the positives in both of these chefs. I really believed Dale would go further, but when that dish came out with popcorn and peanuts my mouth dropped. Sorry to see him leave. I was glad that Steven admitted he was out of his eliment. Mr. Bourdain people may think you are a little harsh at the JT but I don't I think they need someone harsh because they are at an AllStar level and the stakes are higher. Your harshness will push them beyond measure :)
Nice to see Dale T. growing into his kinder/gentler/older persona.
Ditto Steven--he's so much easier to like now.
Really sad to see Dale L. go.
Very wonderful to hear such kind words from Mr. Bourdain. And he even sounds like he means it.
Dead on the mark Tony. Mediocrity isn't going to win this competition and by the way, thanks for the decrease in F-bombs. I hate the constant, non stop annoying bleeps that usually accompany your commentary
I'm a big fan of Anthon Bourdain. He's got a great palet and amazing knowldge of the food around the world: How it should taste, how it should look and how it shoukd be prepared. I've had my share of French food, but it's not all fine dining. You can finf the best food ever made from the streets of Southern France. And not just in France, but all over the world. Those Michelin stars don't always mean that the food is excellent. Eat what the natives eat and your world will turn around, at least foodwise. I've had dinners in 2 Michelin star reataurants and Boullabaisse cooked by simple fishermen, and I would always go back to the fishermen, rather than eat in an overpriced reastaurants.
I cringed when Tre said he was doing swordfish. Oh, no! You're going to serve Tony Bourdain swordfish? I haven't had swordfish since I read Kitchen Confidential. And I'm never having it again.
Great blog! Thank you for your detailed opinion on who rose to the occasion and who failed and why they failed.
Very pleased that Tony mentioned the class and professionalism of Stephen and Dale Levitski. What a contrast from the first two chefs to be eliminated, both of whom went on school-girl hissy fits after being eliminated. These two men worked hard and played straight the whole way. No stomping feet, no on-air histrionics, just disappointment and class. They both clearly identified their weaknesses and why it was time for them to go. Both thanked the judges. What a breath of fresh air.
Also, the food this week looked amazing. This is where Top Chef shines.
The chef's may have riffed on the food but you definitely riffed a nice jazzy blog (more Dave Brubeck or Thelonius Monk, definatly not Kenny G). I personally love the straight-take-no prisoner’s comments you make but equally love when you wax poetic on the positives of the chef’s. I was sad to see Dale L go, but at least he took it like a man. He has always been fun to watch and listen to, and I am sure will be missed in the house, I really loved his exit comments on being invited to TC#16 or something like that, the senior competition. Have to believe this was a great challenge for you all to judge too. What foodie would not have loved that experience? This is by far the best season of TC and love that you are a judge. Realize I am oozing a lot of praise but one final comment is in your blog your voice (verbal) really does come though. I can hear you speak when reading the blog. What fun it was to read.
Having been in quite a few head shops in my time, I knew exactly what you meant when you said it. Sandlewood, of course! Really made me laugh.
I was surprised that Fabio didn't go home for his amature dish over Dale but from Anthony's blog now I know why as Fabio's dish actually tasted good. I didn't interpret that from the judges as they were eating.
So the question of the day is this: Suppose you were a mega-star owner of a multi-million dollar culinary enterprise and you were looking for two chefs to hire for top-level positions. Who would you choose? Elia and Jen, or Steven and Dale? Let me see; such a hard decision! There is more to being a chef than putting food on a plate. The willingness to listen, take criticism from one's diners (Dale cooked for his diner rather than just to "show off") and the willingness to learn--all these are characteristics of greatness. Making a gracious exit is so endearing
Bourdain admitted in Kitchen Confidential that he wasn't the best chef when compared to some of the all-stars in the restaurant industry. Yet his knowledge for food and his mannerism is truly astounding. A man with a seemingly rough exterior is actually a 'nice guy' at heart. I love your books, No Reservations, and anything that is Bourdain related. Your blog is very entertaining so keep up the good work!
Very enjoyable blog -- just when I was starting to get upset (what about the women? Do THEY have balls?) you neatly addressed them and their strengths/weaknesses.
Really enjoyable read; especially happy you gave some props to Fabio. We suspect his food is tastier than the judges or editing make it out to be; glad to have confirmation.
Funny you should mention head shops.
This topic came up recently at work and the youngest one among us(mid 30's - the rest of us are in our 50's and 60's) had never heard of a head shop. Our collective response was a disbelieving "Oh maaaaannnnnn."
You can always be counted on for a witty response.
Great Show...Top Chef is back where it started - competitive, chefs acting honorably and complex great cuisine...Tony, I see you are toning it down a little from the first show...I love the hardcore Bourdain and I'm hoping that you don't become to adoring of Fabio to make amends for your reaction to his first meal...Keep it real! It was time for Stephen to go home and he acknowledges that ..I was cheering for Dale, but it was over when he described the dish...He knew it wasn't his best and left with his head up....I'm a happy viewer, keep it up...
Great episode. Great blog offering from you this week. Remarkable as much for what you didn't say as what you did.
Ditto to Eric C's comment! Elia & Jennifer should both be ashamed of themselves as they turned in their knives as left. You didn't shriek and curse your way onto the show, no need to do it as you exit! Good riddance!
I love reading about how the judges came to their decision. You just can't get that much behind the scenes information into one episode. I was truly inspired by this week's episode and I'm looking forward to eating at the featured restaurants. As a side note, I don't think Jen had her best moment last week, but I can kind of understand her epic flame out. With little sleep and constant attacks on something I created, I doubt I would have fared any better. I'm positive that her judge's table attitude came from a hurt and disappointed place.
While I agree the most recently dearly departed have huge cojones, no need to worry about the women. A few of them have 'brass ovaries'
Dale and Stephen should frame this blog, and post it in their restaurants, as they will likely never again have such a well written and heartfelt review of their food and their personal strengths again in their professional careers!
Rest assured, Tony, "balls to the wall" is completely appropriate - and accurate - to describe Antonia, Casey and the other women, if by that you mean they gave their best effort and went full-out at the challenge. Because the phrase "balls to the wall" doesn't actually refer to testicles at all. It refers to the brass balls (yeah, stop laughing) on a Porter governor, which was one of the first governers, or controllers, designed to regulate the speed of a steam engine's vertical shaft (I can hear you from here, all the rest of you dirty minded so and so's). It works on a pulley/linkage system and has brass balls in the middle - to make a long story short, when it's at maximum speed the centrifugal force makes the balls try to fly outwards, so they're literally "to the wall".
So the term is more adequate and appropriate than you knew - and this is literally the only way I can repay you for the wonderful blogs you give us - especially last week's!
Great comments and insight into the eliminated chefs. I am curious to see if Dale refines that dish and actually puts it on the menu at Sprout. His food is all about unexpected yet fabulous "journeys" as you consume the dish. On the show it looked off-putting and sounded terrible, but I'll bet you he could really pull it off with a little trial and error.
If you really want the best of the best, go with Dale and Jen. frustration and exhaustion make people act crazy and Jen is a phenominal chef.
As a Ron Guidry fan from that era, I think there's a certain narcissism and self-involvement that goes with being a Reggie Jackson type which runs counter to running a successful, anything, other than being Reggie Jackson. Hell, even Jackson was booed more than cheered when he was with the Yankees.
But, as you point out, always swinging for the fences results in a less than .300 batting average. Which in the restaurant world is a losing proposition. Plus, hitting a home run with empty bases has less value to the team than loading the bases and letting the team build momentum and keep driving runs home. If anything, home runs kill momentum in an inning because the bases are now empty and the pitcher isn't defending anything.
So if the goal of a chef is adulation on the occasionally successful dish he or she prepares, while sending out seven of ten that generally suck, then Dale's aces. But if consistency is required of a chef, then he has some work to do.
Just like Heather Mills got Pauls singing voice in the divorce(did you see him on SNL?) We get the articulate and the venacularly gifted Anthony Bourdain. A review so refined, it is almost like a gift. Those chefs, both male and female do have balls, I sometimes am afraid to cook for my mother, I could not imagine being in their shoes. But, waffle and veal? Only if I ate the brownies first!!
Balls: The desire and ability to do what needs to be done trusting yourself to do what you know you can do.
I think Mr. Bourdain's comeuppance by Fabio on the previous show may have helped him be more logical, compassionate and, hopefully, less bitchy, as a judge.
Tony, i have read just about every thing you had written, you come off as this bad assed new yorker chef. But the eulogy you gave to Dale and stephen's top chef exits shows your love of what it takes to cook.
Bourdain writes the way I talk, going off from the main topic to dwell on some unrelated topic -- or rather something only he sees the connection to -- and I get to understand why my husband complains about me. But I enjoy reading him, b/c his insights are right on target. I particularly like this article. :)
Thank you for the wonderful, as usual, take on this week's competition. I was happy to see Dale win and sorry to see Dale go. I will not miss Stephen as I felt he was a pretender. I am finding this season exciting and your participation a great addition.
Rock it out Tony! I'm sorry Fabio got his feelings hurt, but good tv is one where you come up with your classic one liners. I miss the "Love Child of Betty Crocker & Charles Manson" or "tastes like doll head" one liners of seasons past.
Fabio is sadly out of his element and won't admit it to himself. He's one "testa dura" as we say in my famiglia.
No Dale? No thanks. We were watching for his redemption. Several others deserved to go. Dale? Not so. No need to watch further because as for the others: who wins? Who cares? 3 Lost viewing homes in this fam...we'll look for Dale's fare in real life when visiting Chi-town. Does Bravo read or care? Don't know, but my DVR has more room to record now that this show is off our list.
"Reggie was looking to cream that thing, pulverize it, drive it out of the park, over the cheap seats, beyond the stadium and into the East River..."
C'mon, Anthony, every Yankees fan knows that the East River is in foul territory. Reggie would have wanted to park one on the roof of the Bronx County Courthouse.
Love the comments - I've always felt that neither the cheftestants nor audience had much feedback on those dishes which were neither winners nor on the elimination block.
My viewing of this episode was a bit cursed from the beginning, so last night's rerun was my first time to see it all the way through and see what the teaser bit about food that tasted like a "head shop" was about. Coming from an era where sandalwood and patchouli were both the cover up and the pretense (some very ordinary record shops wanted to seem like the other kind, you know, just as many kids who didn't touch anything illegal knew how to act high), to even think of food scented with sandalwood seems...odd. And, for me personally, Stephen's dish might have had a very unpleasant outcome. Sandalwood has had a lasting guilt by association ever since a 1971 field trip (geeks' tour for winners of a research forum) to Chicago when I brought home a suitcase reeking with pungent, cheap sandalwood incense and a raging case of food poisoning from a restaurant at O'Hare Airport. Tossed my cookies at the National Merit candlelighting. Ewwww!
You said on the episode last year in which the chefs competed at different restaurants that one of the chef-owners was part of the "first press" of celebrity chefs.
S'il vous plait, Monsieur! I believe that honor goes to the one and only Julia Child, does it not? Perhaps you meant of his generation? And as a tangent, I'll say that as a diplomat brat growing up in the 60s & 70s in various African & European cities, one of the things I respect her for most, as most do, is having been one of the original people to bring sophisticated cuisine into American dining rooms and kitchens. The current celebrity chef trend is fun and interesting, but also generally, to me, irritating as hell. I've always revered "artisan" breads, various ethnic yogurts that taste like what I grew up with (north African), Algerian lamb, etc., but now I discuss these things with snobby/snotty foodies, who attempt to one-up me in my knowledge and taste. Please! The "celebrity chef" trend, and the foodie movement, is great for me in terms of availability of better products, but it has its drawbacks: a. items I like are more and more expensive because they're trendy; a. the classism of some celebrity chefs, and foodies, is supremely irritating. There are great palates everywhere, not just in celebrity kitchens.