The Top 10 Plead the Fifth Moments Watch the full versions of Andy's favorites. 01:33 How Hung Is Shaq? 02:33 Kathy Bates Toked With WHO!? 01:08 Susan’s Secret Hollywood Hookups? 02:05 Shagging Jack Nicholson 09:22 After Show: Nick Lachey Pleads the Fifth! 02:12 Khloe's Choice: Kanye or Scott? 01:52 Andy Cohen Pleads the Fifth 01:56 Snoop Dogg Plays Plead the Fifth! 03:07 Kelly’s ‘PT5’ with Anderson 02:12 Choking Andy How Hung Is Shaq? Shaquille O’Neal says that he will not Plead The Fifth, so Andy goes in deep. As it turns out, Shaq could go in a lot deeper. Kathy Bates Toked With WHO!? During a game of Plead the Fifth, actress Kathy Bates revealed that she once shared a joint with another famous Hollywood actress. Susan’s Secret Hollywood Hookups? Susan can only plead the 5th on one of our questions, and they’re all juicy! Shagging Jack Nicholson Meryl Streep wins the Oscar for truth telling on 'Plead the Fifth.' After Show: Nick Lachey Pleads the Fifth! Part II: Nick Lachey sounds off on Joe Simpson and 98 Degrees dish on their favorite song. Khloe's Choice: Kanye or Scott? Khloe Kardashian Odom reveals which of her sisters' beaus she would bone on the very first 'Not Plead the Fifth.' Andy Cohen Pleads the Fifth Jimmy Fallon gives Andy Cohen a taste of his own medicine in 'Plead the Fifth.' Snoop Dogg Plays Plead the Fifth! In a round of Plead the Fifth, Snoop Dogg talks about his supposed beef with Oprah and ranks Katy Perry, Mariah Carey, and Britney Spears from least to most difficult with whom to work. Kelly’s ‘PT5’ with Anderson Since Kelly and Anderson are no strangers to hosting a show, Andy gives Kelly the opportunity to take the driver’s seat and play a round of “Plead the Fifth” with Anderson Cooper. Choking Andy Shannen Doherty dishes on Alyssa Milano and chokes Andy in a very memorable game of PT5.