Bravo Insider Exclusive!

Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, sweepstakes, and more!

Sign Up for Free to View
The Daily Dish Summer House

Carl Radke Got Called Out in Reunion Moment That Didn’t Air: “I Will Die on That Hill”

Amanda Batula and Gabby Prescod clashed during the previously unseen Summer House Season 8 reunion moment.

By Allison Crist

Carl Radke and Lindsay Hubbard's intense sit-down on the Season 8 finale of Summer House — during which they broke up and called off their wedding — has been a huge topic of conversation for the exes throughout the two-part reunion, but it was actually Amanda Batula and Gabby Prescod who found themselves weighing in on the matter during a previously unseen moment that can now be viewed as part of the extended and uncensored reunion episode streaming exclusively on Peacock.

How to Watch

Watch Summer House on Bravo Thursdays at 9/8c and next day on Peacock. Catch up on the Bravo app.

The newly uncovered moment begins with Lindsay and Carl going back and forth over his willingness to have their aforementioned conversation on camera. As Lindsay put it, "You would've thought, OK, maybe there was an off-camera moment to have a conversation about how you're feeling."

Carl then pointed out that they did have an off-camera discussion about their relationship days prior on the drive home from the Hamptons. Lindsay, however, replied, "My point is, you committed to a forever by proposing to someone. It shouldn't just be swept away in two weeks or two months."

"What's the playbook for that?" Carl responded. "I don't think there is one."

Here's What You May Have Missed on Bravo:

Carl Radke Lists 7 (!) Reasons For Calling Off His Wedding to Lindsay Hubbard
See What Carl and Lindsay Revealed to a Producer After Their Explosive Breakup
Carl “Swears” He Wouldn’t Have Called Off Wedding If Lindsay Had Done *This* (EXCLUSIVE)

Amanda, for her part, agreed with Carl. As she put it, "There's no right way to break up." 

That's when Gabby weighed in. "Definitely not doing it on f-cking camera is a way," she said. "I'm so sorry, I will die on that hill."

Amanda didn't argue, though. Instead, she replied, "I understand. I've had some sh-tty things happen to me on camera."

The Summer House cast at the Summer House Season 8 reunion.

The discussion continued, but it was reunion host Andy Cohen who ultimately set the record straight regarding Lindsay and Carl's filmed conversation. 

Did Carl Radke call Summer House producers to film his breakup with Lindsay Hubbard? 

According to Andy, no. As he explained to the cast, "You guys don't decide what is shot on this show — production decides what is shot on this show. [Lindsay and Carl] had this horrible weekend, production wanted to follow up and see the aftermath of this terrible weekend. They shot [Carl and Kyle Cooke], they wanted to shoot [Carl and Lindsay]."

Andy added that he asked production whether or not they knew Carl and Lindsay were going to break up, and he said, "They told me they did not know." 

To see more previously unaired moments from both Part 1 and Part 2 of the Summer House Season 8 reunion, stream the extended and uncensored episodes exclusively on Peacock.

RELATED: Has Carl Radke Started Dating Since His Explosive Split with Lindsay Hubbard?

Want the latest Bravo updates? Text us for breaking news and more!