Remember When Justin Bieber Sang a Duet with Bethenny?

Bethenny Frankel hasn't been shy about her Justin Bieber fandom. (She even called the 21-year-old a "genius" following the release of his Purpose single "What Do You Mean" back in August.) A love for the Bieb is something The Real Housewives of New York City mom shares with her little peanut, as seen in this throwback clip from her Bethenny daytime talk show. Check out Bethenny and Bieber singing along to his megahit "Baby" in 2012, all while her little girl looks on adoringly. (Thanks to Kyle Richards for reminding us of this adorable moment.)