So This Is Why Katie Maloney-Schwartz's Cat Eye Always Looks So Good

Katie Maloney-Schwartz always has the best beauty recommendations, no matter your budget. The Vanderpump Rules makeup-lover has introduced us to a wallet-friendly concealer that instantly masks dark circles, an overnight moisturizer that "replenishes your skin," and a foundation that works like magic (seriously!). Now, the Pucker and Pout co-founder is sharing her secret weapon for the perfect cat eye. (Catch up on Vanderpump Rules here.)

Recently, Katie told The Lookbook that the one beauty product she can't live without is liquid eyeliner, but not just any liner will do: The SURver specifically called out Fenty Beauty Flyliner and Kat Von D Tattoo Liner as her must-haves. 

So which one is better? Katie vouched for both eyeliners, and shared that each one is "amazing." 

Watch the video above to see the rest of the Vanderpump Rules cast reveal their favorite beauty products — and for those in search of a good liquid eyeliner, you can shop Katie's top picks below.