Bravo Insider Exclusive!

Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, sweepstakes, and more!

Sign Up for Free to View

Poll: Did Shep Choose the Right Girl?

Vote now - plus find out which final girl has a new boyfriend! 

By Rachael Roberts
A RelationShep Twist: Shep Chooses Bella

"Shepard shocked RelationShep audiences in the season finale when he left behind the two finalists Priscila and Peyton followed his heart up to New York City to get his girl - Bella! Shep realized he was chasing a feeling, and that feeling was with the New York city gal. Talk about serious romantic comedy vibes! Shep himself said he felt he was in a Woody Allen romance, stopping at a bodega for some flowers, hoping that Bella felt the same. Watch the heart pumping moment above and try not to say "Aww."

But what about Priscila and Peyton? Both finalists seemed to be perfect fits for what Shep was looking for. Priscila proved to be someone who could challenge him - and take care of things. Petyon had an immediate and deep connection with Shep, but proved to have a wall up in her final days. Either way, both did not see the break-up coming. 

Shep Tells Priscila That She's Not the One

Shep Breaks Up with Peyton

But don't feel too bad for the ladies, Peyton, for one, has moved on. Shep said of Peyton in a recent interview with, "I saw her a few days ago, she has a new boyfriend, so I'm happy to see that. I'm sure it didn't take long with her looks." Shep added that he has hopes for the furture with himself and Priscila, "Maybe we can all get together someday and laugh about this whole crazy experience, that would be fun." 

Did Shep choose the right girl? Considering we know now what happened with Bella after that season finale, do you think Shep made the right decision? Vote now! 


Read more about:
Want the latest Bravo updates? Text us for breaking news and more!