Bravo Insider Exclusive!

Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, sweepstakes, and more!

Sign Up for Free to View
The Daily Dish The Real Housewives of New York City

Brynn Whitfield Admits to Previously Hooking Up with *This* Vanderpump Rules Cast Member

Brynn Whitfeld said she'd "been there, done that" with a certain VPR regular — and revealed which Bravo star she's been DMing lately.

By Jax Miller

The Real Housewives of New York City’s Brynn Whitfield just dropped a bombshell on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen, claiming she has a history with one of Bravo’s most eligible bachelors.

How to Watch

Watch The Real Housewives of New York City on Peacock and catch up on the Bravo app

During a game of “Swipe Right or Call it a Night,” Andy asked the RHONY newcomer whether she’d swipe left or right for a handful of Bravo guys, including some cast members from Vanderpump Rules. Although she was uninterested in Tom Schwartz, she had this surprising reaction to another longtime friend of the series.

Did Brynn Whitfield kiss Peter Madrigal?

Brynn swiped left for SUR manager Peter Madrigal, claiming on WWHL that she’d “been there, done that.”

“I was in my 20s” the Housewife laughed after Andy said he knew the two had made out in the past.

RELATED: Sai De Silva Teases Upcoming Friendship Drama with Brynn Whitfield: "A Huge Surprise"

In December, Peter — who’s climbed the ranks from busboy to manager at Lisa Vanderpump’s SUR restaurant since VPR Season 1 — gave an update about his dating life, describing a “rough patch” with a woman he’d been seeing since October 2022. The mystery woman came months after Peter “went out a couple of times” with Raquel Leviss.

Daily Dish Vpr Peter Madrigal

Peter also previously hooked up with former VPR cast member Stassi Schroeder.

Brynn didn’t divulge any more about the alleged hook-up with Peter. However, she agreed to swipe right for Below Deck Down Under’s Captain Jason Chambers and Summer House: Martha’s Vineyard’s Amir Lancaster.   

Sitting alongside The Real Housewives of Atlanta’s Marlo Hampton, Brynn said she was single, though she previously admitted to having eyes for Shep Rose of Southern Charm.

Has Shep Rose flirted with Brynn Whitfield?

Brynn wanted to keep it hush-hush whether her “crushy crush” had reached out to her, but upon Andy's prodding, admitted Shep contacted her on social media.

“He’s very sweet; he’s very smart, very sweet,” Brynn told the WWHL host, explaining their correspondence was “all P.G.”

Brynn Whitfield at Watch What Happens Live in New York City.

In Episode 4 of RHONY, Brynn explained she was “consciously uncoupled” from the last of her three ex-fiancés, Gideon.

“I’m not married, so obviously, I don’t have it all figured out,” Brynn said in the RHONY confessional. “Also, I think, had I been married, I would have just been on my third divorce by now. So, statistically, I’m actually setting myself up for success because I never want to get a divorce.”

On WWHL, fans reached out and asked Brynn where she and Gideon stood.

Referring to Gideon as “the British Disney prince,” she confessed the pair were “still talking.”

“I feel like the chances are now 25% [that] we might end up together,” said Brynn. “It’s a bare market.”

Andy asked if being part of RHONY Season 14’s all-new cast has had any effect on Brynn’s dating life.

“OK, dudes love it,” said Brynn. “They do! Straights like it.”

Brynn explained to Marlo that although men loved the idea, none were keen on appearing on-screen and that they were “busting out the N.D.A.s."

Which football player did Brynn Whitfield date?

While willing to date men between age 29 and “still breathing” — as stated on WWHL — Brynn has teased several past sexual trysts during RHONY Season 14. On Episode 3, during a game of “Two Truths and a Lie,” she claimed she “reverse cowgirled” two of three men: a professional athlete, a Saudi prince, and a governor.

The governor, it would transpire, was a lie.

WWHL fans asked Brynn if she could tease which professional athlete she played giddy-up with, but Brynn kept her cards close to the chest.

“Super Bowl winner,” was all she divulged.

Watch all-new episodes of The Real Housewives of New York City Sundays at 9/8c on Bravo and the next day on Peacock.

Want the latest Bravo updates? Text us for breaking news and more!