So, It Turns Out That Craig Conover Never Asked Paige DeSorbo to Be His Girlfriend

Paige DeSorbo and Craig Conover may be in a serious relationship now, but if you had to ask how it came to be — more specifically, when the two actually became boyfriend and girlfriend — you wouldn't exactly get a solid answer. 

The Summer House cast member revealed as much during an appearance on Craig and Austen Kroll's podcast Pillows and Beer. Recalling a conversation she and Craig recently had, Paige explained, "I said, 'It's so hard for guys to ask someone to be their girlfriend. That must be so nerve-wracking. What do you say when you're like, 'Hey, will you be my girlfriend?'"

Craig's response? Much to Paige's surprise, the Southern Charm cast member apparently replied, "I've never done it." 

"I was like 'Wait, what?'" Paige continued. "Then I was thinking back, no he didn't."

She joked that she was "pissed," adding, "I've been hoodwinked." Craig, however, sees things differently. 

"I told you you were my girlfriend," he said. "Once you hang out long enough, you just know."

Austen — who's notorious for having a complicated love life — disagreed. "Not the f--king case, pal," he chimed in. "'Cause that's bit me in the ass just recently!" 

NBD, We Just Rounded Up Some Adorable Photos of Paige DeSorbo and Craig Conover, Because Why Not

The trio went on to discuss dating "icks," and it turned out that Craig actually gave Paige one early on in their relationship. "When Craig first busted out flip flops, I was like, "Ooh...'" she said with a laugh. "Now I'm just like, that's one of those icks that has turned into just an annoyance that I live with."

Listen to the full episode of Pillows and Beer here.

Watch Summer House on Peacock and the Bravo app.

Watch Southern Charm on Peacock and the Bravo app.

Watch Winter House on Peacock and the Bravo app.