Back in November, Andy Cohen shook things up in the hair department with a brand new ‘do that we dubbed “The Andy.” His new look received mixed reviews—Jersey Shore’s Pauly D loved it, but Andy’s parents had a different opinion: “Oy, your hair :-(” texted his mom. “We aren’t fond of it.”

It looks like Mama Cohen isn’t the only one who takes issue with Andy’s new coif. On last night’s Watch What Happens Live After Show, Tabatha Coffey weighed in saying that she much prefers the old hair. “I think you have gorgeous hair,” said the salon makeover guru. “The new hair is like this little pompadour thing, and I know, come the summer, you’re going to be hating it.”

But don’t worry, Andy. Not everyone is displeased with your styling choice. Tabatha’s fellow After Show guest Fred Armisen gave the new cut a thumb’s up.

What do you think of Andy’s haircut? Weigh in in the Comments section!