Whether in binders or manila envelopes, Bravolebs’ reunion receipts over the years have rarely disappointed. So of course you know that Andy Cohen has some thoughts on the matter.

During an October “Ask Andy” segment on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen, one fan got the resident reunion host to spill the tea on whether he loves or hates reunion receipts. “Um, I think they’re amusing,” Andy replied, before elaborating, “Sometimes they’re horrible, so that’s funny, too. It’s like, ‘What are you proving and why? No one cares about this.’”

Elsewhere in the Q&A, the WWHL host also dished on everything from his dream Househusband cast for an Ultimate Guys Trip to his favorite “one-season wonder” Housewife to how he really feels about Vanderpump Rules’ Tom Schwartz and Raquel Leviss “allegedly hooking up” at Scheana Shay and Brock Davies’ August wedding in Mexico. Check out all of Andy’s responses in the video below. 

One recent example of reunion receipts that likely comes to mind is the envelope that Lisa Rinna brought to The Real Housewives of Beverly Hills Season 12 reunion. Though viewers got a glimpse of Rinna’s receipts in the opening moments of Part 1, the envelope never reemerged from behind the couch’s pillow. On the October 31 episode of his Sirius XM show, Andy revealed that the contents had to do with the Elton John gala drama between Lisa and Sutton Stracke.

“We talked about them, and she whipped the receipts out, and we wound up cutting the whole thing because we were done talking about the Elton John AIDS Foundation. Like, enough is enough,” he said during the November 2 episode of Andy Cohen Live.

The same day, he further addressed Lisa’s claim that her envelope also contained information related to her incident with Kathy Hilton in Aspen, Colorado. “She never entered them to the court for consideration. We never got to them,” Andy admitted. “We didn’t cut them out of the show. She never handed them over during the show. And so that is the tale of Rinna’s receipts.”

Watch WWHL on Bravo Sundays through Thursdays and the next day on Peacock. Catch up on the Bravo app.