The Real Housewives of Salt Lake City cast member showed a different side of her style in the Season 2 After Show.

Jen Shah, Meredith Marks, Lisa Barlow, Heather Gay, Whitney Rose, Jennie Nguyen, and Mary Cosby tell all in this deep dive into Season 2.

"I was 100% certain Jen was pulling a prank" says Whitney of the moment when officials swarmed the Beauty Lab parking lot.

At first Jen thought the call was about a situation involving someone she had placed a restraining order against years prior.

Security cam footage supports Meredith's accusation of Jen's employee, and Heather Gay confirms that the same person had also stolen from her.

Lisa, however, says her emotional reaction to the Jen Shah news was "normal for me."

"Meredith is not surprised by anything," says Heather Gay.

Meanwhile, Jennie Nguyen tells the women not to jump to conclusions: "Stop thinking she's guilty unless we know she's guilty."

Meredith Marks explains why Jen using cash for large purchases could mean something...or nothing.

In the RHOSLC After Show, the cast opens up about threatening text messages some of them received, and the rumors surrounding Mary Cosby's church: "Lisa was trying to expose Mary as a criminal."

Lisa also wonders why Meredith Marks wasn't more suspicious of Mary: "It's easy [for Meredith] to find all this information on Jen, but it's almost like she is interested but not interested in any information on Mary."

Lisa Barlow breaks down what she knows about religious trauma and her friend Cameron's experience in Mary's church.

Jen reveals who was on the other end of that shocking first phone call, but some of the women are not convinced that she's telling the truth.

The women discuss a suspicious Uber ride that Jen took and wonder what she could have been hiding.

Whitney believes that Jen and Lisa were behind the scathing texts and DMs she and the other ladies received: "Even though Jen is so nice to our faces, she still works in the dark with Lisa."

When Meredith's son Brooks and her daughter Chloe received similar threatening text messages from different random numbers, she had to get to the bottom of it.

Heather Gay has Whitney's back: "Whitney has been the most loyal and most supportive of Mary from Day One."

Based on the allegations in Jen's indictment, Meredith feels in her heart that Jen was responsible for the threatening texts Brooks received.