Joe designed a painfully basic cocktail dress: a simple black skirt and a gold bustier with strips of black, thereby mimicking the windowpane effect of the light fixture that inspired him. He believed that the "surprise" effect of the skirt's black tulle train would save him from humdrum-itis, but the train looked lackluster and arbitrary. Sorry, Joe. Humdrum.
Keith created a collage-like dress that was inspired by a magazine remnant he found on the street. As the judges' remarked, it was true that the volume of the layers and layers of small pieces of fabric obfuscated his model's shape, but this dress was more about being a cocoon than a form-fitting silhouette. Furthermore, since Keith's had to replace his model at the last minute (Runa bailed, so we brought back Allysa from the last challenge), a sleek fit could have derailed him.