Andy Cohen Drank Amber Tamblyn's Breast Milk — and Maybe Blake Lively's, Too

Andy Cohen and his guests are always sipping cocktails in the Bravo Clubhouse. But on Wednesday night's Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen, the host indulged in a very different kind of drink: breast milk.

After learning that WWHL guest Amber Tamblyn's husband David Cross tried her breast milk, the actress offered up a bottle of it to Andy to taste. After some hesitation and squirming to the soundtrack of Amber leading the audience in chanting, "Chug," Andy actually sipped some of the breast milk. "It's sweet, and it's good with a tequila chaser," the WWHL host said while taking a swig of his cocktail. "That's the closest to a breast I've ever been."

Amber actually knows what breast milk tastes like herself, having previously tasted that of famous friend and Sisterhood of the Traveling Pants co-star Blake Lively. "So now, technically, if that went through me, then you've technically had Blake's and my breast milk together," she told Andy.

That actually made Andy feel a little bit better about the situation. "So does that mean I've done it with Ryan Reynolds?" Andy joked. "'Cause that would make it all better."

In case you want to know what breast milk tastes like without actually having to try it yourself, Andy and Amber described it as tasting like honey or sugar mixed in the milk. So now you know. 

See what else Andy, Amber, and WWHL guest Tinsley Mortimer dished about during the WWHL After Show, below.

After Show: Is Hugh Laurie a Grinch in Real Life?