Bravo Insider Exclusive!

Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, sweepstakes, and more!

Sign Up for Free to View
The Daily Dish The Real Housewives of New York City

Erin Lichy Teases *This* New York 'Wife Will Be in the Season 14 Reunion Hot Seat

Erin appeared on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen to answer some of our burning RHONY questions.

By Jax Miller

Fans will recall when The Real Housewives of New York City’s Erin Lichy made a fuss about Jenna Lyons’ priority seating on their way to Anguilla, and now she’s spilling who may be in the hot seat for the Season 14 reunion.

Who will be in the RHONY Season 14 hot seat?

How to Watch

Watch The Real Housewives of New York City on Peacock and catch up on the Bravo app

Erin appeared alongside Karamo Brown on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen — available to stream now on Peacock — to dish all things RHONY during a game of “Big Apples of Your Eye.”

RELATED: What the OG New York Housewives Have to Say About RHONY Season 14 (UPDATED)

The Tribeca defender and real estate agent had to choose between fellow newcomers Jenna and Brynn Whitfield when asked some burning either-or questions by the WWHL host.

Andy asked which of the two would be in the reunion’s hot seat, though Erin started to give one answer before changing her mind.

Erin Lichy at Watch What Happens Live

“Probably a bit more of — maybe, I mean, me,” said Erin. “But Brynn. Brynn, too.”

It’s hard to tell, though Erin will be Andy’s left-hand woman, as seen via the RHONY Season 14 reunion seating chart. With Andy front and center, in descending order, it will be Erin, Jenna, and Sai De Silva on his left. On the opposite side, it’s Jessel Taank immediately to Andy's right, followed by Brynn and Ubah Hassan.

During the show’s red carpet premiere party in July, Sai said Erin was the one who caused the most drama this season, referring to Erin as “a sh-t starter.” On a previous episode of WWHL, everyone (except Erin, of course) pointed to Erin as the show’s number-one drama queen and elected her as the one with the most to answer for at the reunion.

However, at the premiere party, Erin maintained Brynn caused the most drama this season.

What Erin said on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen

The reunion hot seat wasn’t the only hot topic discussed on the September 17, 2023 WWHL episode. Left to decide between Brynn and Jenna, Erin had to answer a host of questions by Andy, starting with whom Erin trusted more with a secret.

RELATED: Is Tribeca Up and Coming? Fredrik Eklund Weighs In on Jessel Taank's Comments

Her answer?

“Both of them,” Erin answered after a little bit of thought. “I trust them both.”

RHONY Cast at Bravocon 2022.

Jenna was Erin’s answer to which Housewife was more business savvy, as well as the one who was better at apologizing. It was a hard pick for which one had more grievances with Erin, though once again, Erin chose Jenna, given “the first-class thing.”

When asked about who between Jenna and Brynn was the better listener, it was a confident “both.”

Erin also had to decide which Housewife her husband, Abraham “Abe” Lichy (or Abe the Babe, as coined by Brynn), liked better, and Erin clarified that “he loves them both.”

Jenna was a no-brainer for Erin as the Housewife who knows all the hot spots in New York City, though Brynn was chosen as the one Erin would invite back to her Hamptons home for a month-long stay.

Safe to say, Erin wasn’t happy when Jenna ducked out during the women’s late-night festivities in the Hamptons, as seen earlier in the season, claiming Jenna “doesn’t even deserve a room.” (But don’t worry, the friends hashed it out and all was forgiven).

Lastly, on WWHL, Erin said it was a tie between the two for who had the better personal style.

“I like both of their style,” Erin admitted. “It’s very specific.”

Fans can catch up on episodes of The Real Housewives of New York City, airing Sundays at 9/8c on Bravo and streaming the next day on Peacock

Want the latest Bravo updates? Text us for breaking news and more!