Andy Cohen is used to being the one doing the hosting on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen and at all of Bravo's reunions. However, he took a seat as a guest in John Hill's sold-out show The Feels Live at Feinstein's/54 Below in New York City on Wednesday, March 11.
John brought his high energy hilarity fans know and love him for as the co-host of Andy Cohen Live and The Feels on SiriusXM to the stage, opening the show with a soulful rendition of Carley Rae Jepsen's "Store."
After lamenting the fact that his ex-boyfriend Andy declined to publish his memoir on his Henry Holt book imprint and sassily commenting on all of the past and present Bravolebs whose own tomes have hit shelves, John invited fellow SiriusXM radio host Michelle Collins up to the stage. The two had some witty banter about their coronavirus prevention efforts, which included red lobster claw gloves Michelle picked up on Amazon. Michelle then delivered a rousing ballad about her period coming "one day late" set to the tune of "One Day More" from Les Misérables.
John invited Andy up to the stage where the two played a round of The Exlywed Game. Michelle tested the exes' knowledge of each other à la The Newlywed Game with a series of scandalous questions, from what the other person would say is his worst quality to the plastic surgery procedure they would suggest for each other to how they get on each other's nerves.
Along the way, we found out some very tantalizing tidbits about Andy from his ex-boyfriend, including the WWHL host's freak number (9), his currently celebrity crush (Joel Kim Booster, who John said, "I feel like they'd do well together because I think he's also like a 9."), and that Andy once asked John to do a three-way, which he declined. Andy also admitted of his past time in the bedroom with John, "There is a sex tape of us floating around somewhere."
One person in the audience asked why Andy and John broke up. "It was just time," John said, before Andy replied, "We were in different places in our lives."
John is currently in a new relationship, and his boyfriend has Andy's seal of approval. "I think he's great. I'm very into it. I love what he brings out in John," Andy said of his longtime friend's new man. "My life is easier when John has love."
John closed the show how he began it, with another unforgettable musical performance, this time joined by Natalie Joy Johnson. The duo received a standing ovation from the crowd.
Check out John's appearance as the guest bartender on WWHL on March 9, below.
The Daily Dish is your source for all things Bravo, from behind-the-scenes scoop to breaking news, exclusive interviews, photos, original videos, and, oh, so much more. Subscribe to The Daily Dish podcast, join our Facebook group, and follow us on Instagram for the latest news hot off the presses. Sign up to become a Bravo Insider and be the first to get exclusive extras.